
[Applause]
in 1800 and 74 leo tolstoy the famous
russian author experienced the severe
existential crisis on the surface he
seemed to have everything in life he had
a wife he had family he had wealth and
he sucks it in here carrier having just
written to war and peace but still there
was something missing in his life and he
was asking himself why should I live
what real indestructible essence will
come out from this phantasmal
destructible life especially after his
brother’s death he started to realize
that we are all going to be dying sooner
or later so what’s the point of
struggling what’s the point of doing
anything and his talk was and he was
unable to find it he could answer to a
question which meant that when he
described his period later on in his
diary he said that as long as he was
unable to find an answer to the question
of why my life stopped and I wanted to
destroy myself and his question of
meaning of life is as relevant today as
it was 200 years ago in fact it could be
even more relevant today because of a
certain paradox as regards this meaning
of life and this paradox like I guess
many of you have seen this kind of craft
before the DP measure the cross domestic
production of a country and then we
measure the life satisfaction levels
average life satisfaction of the country
they usually correlate so more wealthy
countries usually experience more life
satisfaction which makes sense because
it’s easier to be satisfied with your
life with them when you have food on the
table but recently oshi and dinner keys
to researchers they went out and looked
at 132 countries and how much
meaningfulness people experience in
these countries and interesting they
found exactly the opposite pattern the
more they’re worth meaning in a country
or the more diverse wealth in a country
the less people were experiencing
meaningfulness which is rather a
surprising result and something that
needs to be explained but in order to
explain this fact we need to know more
about the question what do we ask we
actually ask when we ask about the
meaning of life and when we look at the
question itself we quite soon realize
that there’s actually two separate
questions about this meaningfulness
there’s first there’s this universal
question about meaning of life which is
the question about why does life exist
why do you human beings exist why does
errors exist I’m a but that’s one
question but then there’s a separate
question which is more about this
personal sense of meaningfulness what
makes my life feel meaningful for me
what makes my life feel significant and
as regards these two questions
I forgot the universal question I’m
afraid I have to say that I do have any
good answer to that question because
whatever answer we try to give to that
question there always seems to be one
more why question okay Big Bang like
universe started in a Big Bang but why
did the Big Bang come from already it
come from or God created to heaven and
the urge but where did God come from so
however we try to answer the question
there’s always this like further
question about and it all boils down to
the question of why is there something
instead of nothing and I said I believe
that we can never find a good answer to
this question we just have to be lucky
that there seems to be somebody here and
there simply somebody able to ask these
questions and that that brings us to
this more personal question about
meaning in my life what makes one in my
life meaningful and as regards this
question there’s also like separate ways
to understand this question as well in
fact there seems to be like three
separate ways to understand it firstly
we can think about it as the sense of
coherence sense of life making sense
someone that we understand what is
happening in our life and it’s not
chaotic and unstructured the second way
of understanding this question about
meaning in life
about the sense of purpose having some
goals in the future that give meaning to
my present-day activities having some
like future-oriented
future-oriented ness in my life and then
the third way of understanding what we
mean by meaning in life is about the
sense of significance sense of life life
having some inherent value sense of
feeling that my life is worth living and
of these three I will say that this
third one the significance is the most
most important most fundamental and most
burning question because like the sense
of coherence it’s nice to like life
makes sense that we understand what is
happening but when we ask about meaning
we also want to like evaluate our life
find some positive value in our life so
coherence by itself is not enough and
same goes for purpose it might be a
strong way of get a feeling that my life
is significant but at the same time many
of our lives most meaningful moments are
moments when we are present or present
in the present moment and not think
about any future or in that goals so the
significance is the most fundamental
question we can ask about meaning in
life it’s also the most fundamental
question of philosophy at least if we
are asked the existentialists like
Albert Camus who said that searching
whether life is or is not worth living
amongst to answering the most
fundamental question of philosophy the
he was saying that like unless we can
find a good answer to that question why
should we ask any other question
shouldn’t be first trying to find a
figure out to answer to this question
and all the after that we should move on
to this more trivial other questions so
now we know more about the question
itself but in order to end answer this
paradox we have to look also at the
history of the question because quite
often when we think about this question
of meaning of life we think about it as
some kind of eternal question that has
bothered mankind since the beginning of
humankind but actually to phrase itself
meaning of life was invented quite
recently all in a
hundred and thirty-four thomas carlyle
was the first month who mentioned it in
the literature his British author and
quite soon after were after him they
were sir and Kierkegaard the day in his
philosopher who was also to speak about
meaning of life and then there was
Arthur Schopenhauer – chairman
philosopher who was writing a German
language and using the phrase they are
seen des lebens which also translates
into meaning of life so there seemed to
be something happening in the 19th
century that really made this question
very burning and relevant and what was
then happening there of course in the
19th century there were many important
developments there was the Industrial
Revolution urbanization people traveling
more but I would argue that the most
significant change that happened in the
19th century was the rise of the
scientific worldview that the scientific
worldview became more and more relevant
it and it started to replace this like
religious worldview in many people’s
minds and this is actually what happened
that is Thomas Carlyle to serve in
Kierkegaard to are to show up an hour
and to Tolstoy all of them abandoned
prediction or tenth they struggled with
their faith and after this struggle with
their faith they came this question of
meaning of life became very salient and
burning for them and this is actually
the same result that is oily and inner
found I said that they they look at the
132 countries and found this negative
correlation between meaningfulness and
wealth and when they tried to look for
explanation for that correlation they
realized that actually the more they
looked at several factors and the most
important factor that they found was
exactly religiosity that the more
wealthy countries at least really chose
it various religious countries and
because of that they also seem to
experience less meaning in life and what
they found out also was that meaning
life itself was connected to the suicide
rate of the country that the countries
that experience where people experience
less meaning in life where countries
where people had higher suicide rates
which really goes to show that this
question is about whether or not life is
worth living
so now we won’t know more about the
question but I guess what quite many
people want to know at this point is
what will be then the answer to this
question especially like where to find
the answer to this question if one is
not able to find it from religion
anymore that many people in today’s
world they are not able to find it from
the religious religious authorities
anymore and they are looking for an
answer
and where can they find this answer then
and I would argue that the best bet that
we can have in this situation is to look
at human psychology look at what are the
factors that humans the human beings
across the world universally seem to
value seem to be very motivated to
pursue and then identify those factors
and those should be the factors that
might be what gives significance and the
sense of worth to our lives and I could
tell long stories about the empirical
research on the topic both by myself and
by others but instead I will give you a
one sentence answer and the one Center’s
answer to the question of meaning of
life that I came up with already several
years ago was this meaning in life is
about making yourself meaningful to
other people so the way that my life
becomes meaningful is when I feel in
that I’m able to somehow be meaningful
to other people and there’s basically
two different ways that I can be
meaningful to other people and I can
connect to other people but firstly I
can connect to other people through the
sense of relatedness that when I have
some like deep relationships in my life
these are usually very meaningful when
I’m with my loved ones when I with my
family when I with my friends they are
there what like usually gives my life
meaning and also because of our deep
relationship I can be meaningful to them
by just by being there but at the same
time there’s another dimension that is
connecting to other people which is more
about the sense of contribution being
able to have some kind of positive
impact in the life of the other people
being able to help other people and if
you think about this
typical examples of meaningful living
like Nelson Mandela or Abraham Lincoln
or Martin Luther King what unites them
all is that all of them have made a huge
contribution towards the mankind that in
one way or other they had liked had this
huge contribution and that’s why their
life is regarded so meaningful
so this contribution is another strong
way of finding my life meaningful if
unable to make some contribution towards
other people but then later on at some
point I realized that this is only half
to answer to the question of what makes
life meaningful and I realized this when
William Damon this professor of
psychology at Stanford he was telling
the story about the surgeon that he met
at the church and happened to be one of
the like primary expert experts on
certain heart surgery which meant that
he was saving human lives on a regular
basis he went to work he came back home
and he could again say that again I
saved one human life so in this sense
there’s hard to find out an occupation
that would be more meaningful but at the
same time the same guy had a hard time
getting out of bed in the morning and
getting to work because he really
started to hate his work and the reason
he started to hate his work was because
he thought that it’s actually not his
thing that he can he had become a
surgeon because his parents were doctors
so after high school it was natural to
go to medical school in medical school
he was good so it was natural to become
a searcher so he when I had gone through
this pipeline without never stopping to
think what he really wants to do in life
and when he finally stopped to think
about what he wants to do in life
he realized that he wants to do
something completely different than be a
surgery so that’s what he did he quit
his carrier and went to another field
and the point of the story is that in
order to experience meaning in life it’s
not enough that you connect to other
people you also have to connect to
yourself as some wise person has said
it’s better to be yourself because
everybody else is already taken
so based on that I have like three bytes
my answer to the question of what it
where does this meaning in life come
from so in addition to the sense of
connecting to other people we know so
need to have the sense of self
realization that we’re able to realize
ourselves somehow to our lives and
there’s also two dimensions to the self
realization firstly there’s the sense of
autonomy being able to do things that I
myself find interesting that I might
have find valuable feeling that I’m able
to do like things that Express who I
really am as a person so this is an
important part of self-realization but
it it alone is not enough because we
also need to feel the sense of
competence in this in our activities but
if you’re not able to accomplish
anything it doesn’t matter how much we
are interested in the thing but if you
all all the time fail in the activity it
doesn’t like bring the sense of
self-realization
so only when we find things that we find
interesting that we find felt valuable
and then we are able to feel the sense
of competence that we are able to be
effective in our work workings
accomplish something did we have the
sense of self-realization and
accordingly
nowadays like the best possible answer
that I’m able to give to you about what
makes life meaningful is that it’s about
these two things it’s about the sense of
self-realization and the sense of
connecting to other people that we need
both of them in order to feel sense of
meaningfulness and accordingly the one
sentence answer the question of meaning
in life that I’m going to leave you with
is this meaning in life is about doing
things meaningful to you in a way that
makes yourself meaningful to other
people thank you
you
in 1800 and 74 leo tolstoy the famous
russian author experienced the severe
existential crisis on the surface he
seemed to have everything in life he had
a wife he had family he had wealth and
he sucks it in here carrier having just
written to war and peace but still there
was something missing in his life and he
was asking himself why should I live
what real indestructible essence will
come out from this phantasmal
destructible life especially after his
brother’s death he started to realize
that we are all going to be dying sooner
or later so what’s the point of
struggling what’s the point of doing
anything and his talk was and he was
unable to find it he could answer to a
question which meant that when he
described his period later on in his
diary he said that as long as he was
unable to find an answer to the question
of why my life stopped and I wanted to
destroy myself and his question of
meaning of life is as relevant today as
it was 200 years ago in fact it could be
even more relevant today because of a
certain paradox as regards this meaning
of life and this paradox like I guess
many of you have seen this kind of craft
before the DP measure the cross domestic
production of a country and then we
measure the life satisfaction levels
average life satisfaction of the country
they usually correlate so more wealthy
countries usually experience more life
satisfaction which makes sense because
it’s easier to be satisfied with your
life with them when you have food on the
table but recently oshi and dinner keys
to researchers they went out and looked
at 132 countries and how much
meaningfulness people experience in
these countries and interesting they
found exactly the opposite pattern the
more they’re worth meaning in a country
or the more diverse wealth in a country
the less people were experiencing
meaningfulness which is rather a
surprising result and something that
needs to be explained but in order to
explain this fact we need to know more
about the question what do we ask we
actually ask when we ask about the
meaning of life and when we look at the
question itself we quite soon realize
that there’s actually two separate
questions about this meaningfulness
there’s first there’s this universal
question about meaning of life which is
the question about why does life exist
why do you human beings exist why does
errors exist I’m a but that’s one
question but then there’s a separate
question which is more about this
personal sense of meaningfulness what
makes my life feel meaningful for me
what makes my life feel significant and
as regards these two questions
I forgot the universal question I’m
afraid I have to say that I do have any
good answer to that question because
whatever answer we try to give to that
question there always seems to be one
more why question okay Big Bang like
universe started in a Big Bang but why
did the Big Bang come from already it
come from or God created to heaven and
the urge but where did God come from so
however we try to answer the question
there’s always this like further
question about and it all boils down to
the question of why is there something
instead of nothing and I said I believe
that we can never find a good answer to
this question we just have to be lucky
that there seems to be somebody here and
there simply somebody able to ask these
questions and that that brings us to
this more personal question about
meaning in my life what makes one in my
life meaningful and as regards this
question there’s also like separate ways
to understand this question as well in
fact there seems to be like three
separate ways to understand it firstly
we can think about it as the sense of
coherence sense of life making sense
someone that we understand what is
happening in our life and it’s not
chaotic and unstructured the second way
of understanding this question about
meaning in life
about the sense of purpose having some
goals in the future that give meaning to
my present-day activities having some
like future-oriented
future-oriented ness in my life and then
the third way of understanding what we
mean by meaning in life is about the
sense of significance sense of life life
having some inherent value sense of
feeling that my life is worth living and
of these three I will say that this
third one the significance is the most
most important most fundamental and most
burning question because like the sense
of coherence it’s nice to like life
makes sense that we understand what is
happening but when we ask about meaning
we also want to like evaluate our life
find some positive value in our life so
coherence by itself is not enough and
same goes for purpose it might be a
strong way of get a feeling that my life
is significant but at the same time many
of our lives most meaningful moments are
moments when we are present or present
in the present moment and not think
about any future or in that goals so the
significance is the most fundamental
question we can ask about meaning in
life it’s also the most fundamental
question of philosophy at least if we
are asked the existentialists like
Albert Camus who said that searching
whether life is or is not worth living
amongst to answering the most
fundamental question of philosophy the
he was saying that like unless we can
find a good answer to that question why
should we ask any other question
shouldn’t be first trying to find a
figure out to answer to this question
and all the after that we should move on
to this more trivial other questions so
now we know more about the question
itself but in order to end answer this
paradox we have to look also at the
history of the question because quite
often when we think about this question
of meaning of life we think about it as
some kind of eternal question that has
bothered mankind since the beginning of
humankind but actually to phrase itself
meaning of life was invented quite
recently all in a
hundred and thirty-four thomas carlyle
was the first month who mentioned it in
the literature his British author and
quite soon after were after him they
were sir and Kierkegaard the day in his
philosopher who was also to speak about
meaning of life and then there was
Arthur Schopenhauer – chairman
philosopher who was writing a German
language and using the phrase they are
seen des lebens which also translates
into meaning of life so there seemed to
be something happening in the 19th
century that really made this question
very burning and relevant and what was
then happening there of course in the
19th century there were many important
developments there was the Industrial
Revolution urbanization people traveling
more but I would argue that the most
significant change that happened in the
19th century was the rise of the
scientific worldview that the scientific
worldview became more and more relevant
it and it started to replace this like
religious worldview in many people’s
minds and this is actually what happened
that is Thomas Carlyle to serve in
Kierkegaard to are to show up an hour
and to Tolstoy all of them abandoned
prediction or tenth they struggled with
their faith and after this struggle with
their faith they came this question of
meaning of life became very salient and
burning for them and this is actually
the same result that is oily and inner
found I said that they they look at the
132 countries and found this negative
correlation between meaningfulness and
wealth and when they tried to look for
explanation for that correlation they
realized that actually the more they
looked at several factors and the most
important factor that they found was
exactly religiosity that the more
wealthy countries at least really chose
it various religious countries and
because of that they also seem to
experience less meaning in life and what
they found out also was that meaning
life itself was connected to the suicide
rate of the country that the countries
that experience where people experience
less meaning in life where countries
where people had higher suicide rates
which really goes to show that this
question is about whether or not life is
worth living
so now we won’t know more about the
question but I guess what quite many
people want to know at this point is
what will be then the answer to this
question especially like where to find
the answer to this question if one is
not able to find it from religion
anymore that many people in today’s
world they are not able to find it from
the religious religious authorities
anymore and they are looking for an
answer
and where can they find this answer then
and I would argue that the best bet that
we can have in this situation is to look
at human psychology look at what are the
factors that humans the human beings
across the world universally seem to
value seem to be very motivated to
pursue and then identify those factors
and those should be the factors that
might be what gives significance and the
sense of worth to our lives and I could
tell long stories about the empirical
research on the topic both by myself and
by others but instead I will give you a
one sentence answer and the one Center’s
answer to the question of meaning of
life that I came up with already several
years ago was this meaning in life is
about making yourself meaningful to
other people so the way that my life
becomes meaningful is when I feel in
that I’m able to somehow be meaningful
to other people and there’s basically
two different ways that I can be
meaningful to other people and I can
connect to other people but firstly I
can connect to other people through the
sense of relatedness that when I have
some like deep relationships in my life
these are usually very meaningful when
I’m with my loved ones when I with my
family when I with my friends they are
there what like usually gives my life
meaning and also because of our deep
relationship I can be meaningful to them
by just by being there but at the same
time there’s another dimension that is
connecting to other people which is more
about the sense of contribution being
able to have some kind of positive
impact in the life of the other people
being able to help other people and if
you think about this
typical examples of meaningful living
like Nelson Mandela or Abraham Lincoln
or Martin Luther King what unites them
all is that all of them have made a huge
contribution towards the mankind that in
one way or other they had liked had this
huge contribution and that’s why their
life is regarded so meaningful
so this contribution is another strong
way of finding my life meaningful if
unable to make some contribution towards
other people but then later on at some
point I realized that this is only half
to answer to the question of what makes
life meaningful and I realized this when
William Damon this professor of
psychology at Stanford he was telling
the story about the surgeon that he met
at the church and happened to be one of
the like primary expert experts on
certain heart surgery which meant that
he was saving human lives on a regular
basis he went to work he came back home
and he could again say that again I
saved one human life so in this sense
there’s hard to find out an occupation
that would be more meaningful but at the
same time the same guy had a hard time
getting out of bed in the morning and
getting to work because he really
started to hate his work and the reason
he started to hate his work was because
he thought that it’s actually not his
thing that he can he had become a
surgeon because his parents were doctors
so after high school it was natural to
go to medical school in medical school
he was good so it was natural to become
a searcher so he when I had gone through
this pipeline without never stopping to
think what he really wants to do in life
and when he finally stopped to think
about what he wants to do in life
he realized that he wants to do
something completely different than be a
surgery so that’s what he did he quit
his carrier and went to another field
and the point of the story is that in
order to experience meaning in life it’s
not enough that you connect to other
people you also have to connect to
yourself as some wise person has said
it’s better to be yourself because
everybody else is already taken
so based on that I have like three bytes
my answer to the question of what it
where does this meaning in life come
from so in addition to the sense of
connecting to other people we know so
need to have the sense of self
realization that we’re able to realize
ourselves somehow to our lives and
there’s also two dimensions to the self
realization firstly there’s the sense of
autonomy being able to do things that I
myself find interesting that I might
have find valuable feeling that I’m able
to do like things that Express who I
really am as a person so this is an
important part of self-realization but
it it alone is not enough because we
also need to feel the sense of
competence in this in our activities but
if you’re not able to accomplish
anything it doesn’t matter how much we
are interested in the thing but if you
all all the time fail in the activity it
doesn’t like bring the sense of
self-realization
so only when we find things that we find
interesting that we find felt valuable
and then we are able to feel the sense
of competence that we are able to be
effective in our work workings
accomplish something did we have the
sense of self-realization and
accordingly
nowadays like the best possible answer
that I’m able to give to you about what
makes life meaningful is that it’s about
these two things it’s about the sense of
self-realization and the sense of
connecting to other people that we need
both of them in order to feel sense of
meaningfulness and accordingly the one
sentence answer the question of meaning
in life that I’m going to leave you with
is this meaning in life is about doing
things meaningful to you in a way that
makes yourself meaningful to other
people thank you
you
Please follow and like us: