
[Music]
[Music]
the flight attendant on the long flight
from Chicago to Melbourne was hilarious
throughout the flight he beamed at my
pregnancy steadied my wobbling body and
exclaimed practically every hour oh my
god you’re having twins and when he
discovered that I was a doctor you can
only imagine his curiosity and
excitement but finally finally the
flight landed he took my hand and said
good luck your life is going to be
amazing it turns out that he was wrong
tragedy led just around the corner in
the form of a routine ultrasound with my
new obstetrician I was young fit and
poised to have twins who’s also poised
to become an oncologist life was good
the veteran obstetrician and I chatted
away and I would have missed the
expression on his face had it not been
for the sharp
prod of his probe into my abdomen I
didn’t know the doctor but I knew that
expression it was the kind of expression
I imagined I would wear when looking at
bad scans and progressive disease but
even before I had an opportunity to
frame a question he had rushed out
through the door through the closed door
I heard whispered exchanges and I knew I
was in trouble but how much trouble I
followed the obstetrician into a cramped
space obviously not set up for
unexpected encounters he gave me his
comfortable chair and took the hard one
the concern on his face now evident I
still had no idea
I’m afraid I have bad news he said for a
fleeting moment I thought that my
medical brain would kick in and I would
pummel him with sophisticated questions
to challenge his assertion that my twins
were gravely ill but of course I was
like every other patient my mind burning
with questions while my voice was numbed
by shock of course I also knew that
doctors sometimes sidestepped the truth
usually with the intent of protecting
the patient he could have asked me to
wait for tests and more doctors but I
knew that he knew and I wanted him to
tell me the truth so all the questions
that I could have asked him I asked the
only question that mattered will they
die yes he said holding my gates until
tears started streaming down his face
and he made no attempt to wipe them I
was struck then by the profound
realization that in all my years of
medical education and training I had
never seen a doctor cry in front of a
patient surely those years had produced
no end of tragedy and I had heard
remorse regret expressions of sigh but I
had never seen a doctor cry my mind
continued to burn with questions from
the extraordinary to the mundane what
happened when in nutrit winds were dying
was something awful about to happen to
me as well and how did one pay for this
life-changing encounter with credit or
cash meanwhile my doctor said nothing he
didn’t offer any brainy solutions nor
trite platitudes he didn’t tell me that
he understood
he didn’t tell me that things would be
okay
and he certainly didn’t tell me to look
on the bright side instead
my doctor said quietly and allowed me to
do the same and while it may have seemed
to him like a thousand years gone by to
me those few moments gave me the
greatest gift the gift of composure I
don’t know what to say
he finally murmured his eyes still moist
tell me you can fix it I thought instead
I asked are you sure yes he responded
his honesty stung but he had told me the
unflinching truth and in doing so almost
surgically displaced any uncertainty
with the knowledge that I needed to
prepare myself for what lay ahead
later that day I had test after test and
saw doctor after doctor but I cooked
better because the first doctor had told
me the truth it’s difficult to know what
sort of an oncologist I might have
become had it not been for the searing
experience of my personal loss but what
my loss showed me is that while
technical skills matter what matters
most of all is the art of Medicine
humanity humility compassion navigating
uncertainty telling the truth these are
the things that our patients remember us
for and I know that long after my
medical drama was over
what stayed with me was that my doctor
had shared my sorrow somehow it made my
sorrow seemed less maddening less
personal more bearable this experience
as a patient has been the guiding light
of my career as a doctor
you know the flight attendant was right
my life did turn out to be amazing I
went on to have healthy children a
fulfilling career and opportunities like
this and to be honest it’s not very
often that I dwell on the loss of the
twins but I’m only human and every now
and then I do catch myself thinking
about what they might have been like and
at times like this I like to think that
I’m saying to the twins that their loss
was not in vain if at every bedside and
at every encounter
I remember the importance of the art of
Medicine
[Applause]
[Music]
the flight attendant on the long flight
from Chicago to Melbourne was hilarious
throughout the flight he beamed at my
pregnancy steadied my wobbling body and
exclaimed practically every hour oh my
god you’re having twins and when he
discovered that I was a doctor you can
only imagine his curiosity and
excitement but finally finally the
flight landed he took my hand and said
good luck your life is going to be
amazing it turns out that he was wrong
tragedy led just around the corner in
the form of a routine ultrasound with my
new obstetrician I was young fit and
poised to have twins who’s also poised
to become an oncologist life was good
the veteran obstetrician and I chatted
away and I would have missed the
expression on his face had it not been
for the sharp
prod of his probe into my abdomen I
didn’t know the doctor but I knew that
expression it was the kind of expression
I imagined I would wear when looking at
bad scans and progressive disease but
even before I had an opportunity to
frame a question he had rushed out
through the door through the closed door
I heard whispered exchanges and I knew I
was in trouble but how much trouble I
followed the obstetrician into a cramped
space obviously not set up for
unexpected encounters he gave me his
comfortable chair and took the hard one
the concern on his face now evident I
still had no idea
I’m afraid I have bad news he said for a
fleeting moment I thought that my
medical brain would kick in and I would
pummel him with sophisticated questions
to challenge his assertion that my twins
were gravely ill but of course I was
like every other patient my mind burning
with questions while my voice was numbed
by shock of course I also knew that
doctors sometimes sidestepped the truth
usually with the intent of protecting
the patient he could have asked me to
wait for tests and more doctors but I
knew that he knew and I wanted him to
tell me the truth so all the questions
that I could have asked him I asked the
only question that mattered will they
die yes he said holding my gates until
tears started streaming down his face
and he made no attempt to wipe them I
was struck then by the profound
realization that in all my years of
medical education and training I had
never seen a doctor cry in front of a
patient surely those years had produced
no end of tragedy and I had heard
remorse regret expressions of sigh but I
had never seen a doctor cry my mind
continued to burn with questions from
the extraordinary to the mundane what
happened when in nutrit winds were dying
was something awful about to happen to
me as well and how did one pay for this
life-changing encounter with credit or
cash meanwhile my doctor said nothing he
didn’t offer any brainy solutions nor
trite platitudes he didn’t tell me that
he understood
he didn’t tell me that things would be
okay
and he certainly didn’t tell me to look
on the bright side instead
my doctor said quietly and allowed me to
do the same and while it may have seemed
to him like a thousand years gone by to
me those few moments gave me the
greatest gift the gift of composure I
don’t know what to say
he finally murmured his eyes still moist
tell me you can fix it I thought instead
I asked are you sure yes he responded
his honesty stung but he had told me the
unflinching truth and in doing so almost
surgically displaced any uncertainty
with the knowledge that I needed to
prepare myself for what lay ahead
later that day I had test after test and
saw doctor after doctor but I cooked
better because the first doctor had told
me the truth it’s difficult to know what
sort of an oncologist I might have
become had it not been for the searing
experience of my personal loss but what
my loss showed me is that while
technical skills matter what matters
most of all is the art of Medicine
humanity humility compassion navigating
uncertainty telling the truth these are
the things that our patients remember us
for and I know that long after my
medical drama was over
what stayed with me was that my doctor
had shared my sorrow somehow it made my
sorrow seemed less maddening less
personal more bearable this experience
as a patient has been the guiding light
of my career as a doctor
you know the flight attendant was right
my life did turn out to be amazing I
went on to have healthy children a
fulfilling career and opportunities like
this and to be honest it’s not very
often that I dwell on the loss of the
twins but I’m only human and every now
and then I do catch myself thinking
about what they might have been like and
at times like this I like to think that
I’m saying to the twins that their loss
was not in vain if at every bedside and
at every encounter
I remember the importance of the art of
Medicine
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: