Press "Enter" to skip to content

Why Do We Fail to Innovate? | Umberto Callegari | TEDxBocconiU


okay let me start it off by asking y’all
question I know it will sound strange
but I promise it all makes sense by the
end of this talk so how many of you have
been a list once in a lifetime being
labeled as troublemakers or unreasonable
man or woman please raise your hands
okay thank you very much hold it it will
all make sense in a minute so ever since
our society has started relying heavily
on information communication technology
and particularly digital witness
incredible overthrown across industries
we’re seeing companies rising from out
of nowhere to reshape entire industries
and some others the word very successful
at that time failing to recognize the
needed change and falling spectacularly
and disappear now digital revolution is
a cyclical process it’s based on fixed
rules and principles and it should be
fairly simple it’s not easy for at least
those of us worse in that domain to
understand the impact that a new
evolutionary cycle will have on our
companies and ultimately on ourselves
but yet there’s rising and falling goes
on and on and on so after more than
eleven years spent working with hundreds
of company in that precise moment of the
needed change I started asking myself
why do we fail to innovate is that a
common pattern to successful innovation
and what are did I mention of innovation
typically when we talk about lack of
innovation we tend to label it as lack
of creativity but is that true
and even better is creativity you really
consider an asset in our society and
among our companies despite what we
might think practically every study on
education from 1948 to basically
yesterday give us a very precise and
possibly different picture creativity
might not only be not rewarded but
actively punished teacher seems to
prefer other qualities such as
conformity and unquestioning acceptance
of authority and they tend consistently
to discriminate highly crafted students
labeling them as troublemakers
now I’m not saying our teachers
educators professors are trying to
sabotaging our society I’m saying that
all in all our culture is far more
centered on success in terms of money
power status reachable through
conformity and consensus rather than on
unique innovation that ultimately make
our life much better what happens is
that the more we value that kind of
success the more we are afraid and most
of the time terrified particularly in
Italy in Europe of failing and we are
afraid of and when we are afraid of
failing two things happen we stop
believing it’s possible and we don’t
even try and this obviously has an
impact on our companies in our society
because 85% of professional over more
than 40,000 professional interviewed
confessed then whenever they have a new
idea regarding their business they tend
to keep it to themselves
natsu you know be labelled ice travel
maker or rocking the boat but maybe you
know those ideas weren’t great Mary
we’re not losing that much wrong again
and out of study on thousands and
thousands of ideas on new products
services and ventures reinvented by the
same professional tell us that 87
percent of them were completely unique
and worth interest so we can start doing
the math if 87 percent of the of the
ideas are unique but 85 percent of
people don’t speak up we can start
seeing where the bottleneck of
innovation might be the problem doesn’t
seem to be idea generation but rather
ideas selection and this is fairly
natural let me explain innovation is the
process of corrective disruption that
often requires always requires to let go
and exist in paradigm for as successful
as they might have been in the past to
embrace the new one that still has to be
proven successful and obviously these
rates and barriers and when it’s time to
decided to embrace the new innovation
particularly certain very successful
companies instead of opening up they
closed himself in there
relying on that existing paradigm that
they give us that gave up fortune and
fame in the first place and they create
consensus on consensus on it and they
generate what is known to be called
groupthink which is the worst enemy of
innovation in other words companies they
tend to evaluate innovation through the
lens of an existing paradigm and that’s
as you can all understand is a
contradiction in terms
let me give you two example in this
ideas selection process that went wrong
the first one regards Edwin lang
it was Steve Jobs one of Steve Jobs
personal hero it was an innovator he
invented among out of things the iStent
cameras and the polarized filter for
light that we use today in billions of
product if you want he was like the
great grandfather of selfie it changed
our culture forever with that instant
camera soul and found that Polaroid in
1948 he brought the company from short 7
million revenues to a 950 million
revenues in 1978 and he dusted him six
and he dominated an industry that he
created for 28 years but that’s
something happened digital happen and it
was about the time to let go film as the
epicenter of photography to embrace
digital but instead of opening up you
relied on is known paradigm the one that
it brought him to be so successful so he
generated consensus over it and create
groupthink and when in 1980 he was
approached by Akio Morita Sony founder
and chairman to work together on a
project of for a digital camera he
refused and dismissed the idea saying
people will always be willing to wear
the photo printed instead of opening up
each try to reapply the same paradigm on
a different domain you try to work on an
instant cameras for movies which right
now sons sounds you know scaring Leah
like a great-grandfather of snapchat a
physical one
but back then was pretty
counterintuitive you burn 600 million
the product was a bust
and unfortunately in 82 we was removed
as a CEO of the company that he created
by his board
but even after LAN was gone
groupthink remained and five years
afterwards the new CEO said film will
always be the epicenter of photography
and we know better because we invented
this thing and when a young collie and
Koski you might know into being the
later inventor of Sony Playstation
desperately tried to pitch him the idea
of transitioning the company into its
digital phase the CEO replied and I’m
quoting I don’t know if I should fire
you or punch you in the nose so I’m not
gonna lie to you I love this slide and
really represented that innovation most
of the time is an uphill run it’s really
tough this is the first example and he
created a false negative so a company
like Polaroid or a Nokia or Motorola
many other that didn’t recognize an
opportunity but group a group thing and
ideas selection also generate false
positive and this is the second example
regarding these two gentlemen Steve Jobs
and Jeff Bezos
to the brightest mind of our generation
or of any generation for that matter to
great lateral thinkers innovators and
interpreters that fail spectacularly in
predicting the future of a product they
define the second biggest thing after
Internet and a product so cool they
would have had CDs build around it the
product was this one the Segway it was
released in 2001 it was supposed to be
selling at 30,000 pieces a month but
after twenty one month and on even 6,000
pieces sold the company decided to cut
recall their product for engineering
problem
so why jobs and bases despite being so
brilliant God is so wrong with the
Segway it turns out that there are three
fundamental dimension of innovation and
they all need to play together the first
one is with the second one is debt and
the third one is volume with regards
lateral thinking and how broad and
diverse our mindset could get when
approaching a fact a problem or an
opportunity how different we might think
right and this is not just philosophy
Albert Einstein discovered relativity
not by running experiment that were
never attempted before but by rereading
and rerunning existing experience
experiment with a different mindset it
was thinking of imagining of chasing a
beam of light and the good news is we
don’t need to be Albert Einstein to
great be great lateral thinkers it turns
out that we can ignite our ability a
trigger our ability to innovate and
through lateral thinking by doing
concrete things like emerging ourselves
in different domains like living abroad
for a few years or even better by
nurturing our love for art and I know it
sounds too cool to be true but another
study on every Nobel Prize winner for
science from 1901 to 2005 showed clearly
that the biggest and basically only
difference between those great
accomplished scientists who won the
Nobel Prize and those who never did was
not the knowledge of the domain but was
indeed there how active they were in art
so I’m telling you if you’re a scientist
and a magician or some sort of performer
rock in the stage you have 22 times more
chances of winning a Nobel price and the
same result was shown when every great
entrepreneur in Silicon Valley was
assessed art really seemed to be at the
beginning of lateral thinking and
innovation but the interpreters the
scientists and and Einstein tell us a
story also of the second dimension which
is depth how well you know your domain
meaning in order to make the most out of
your lateral thinking you better be sure
that you know what you’re trying to
innovate otherwise you will get it wrong
and this was probably the main problem
with job and vases regarding the Segway
they might have been and be great
interpreters and lateral thinker but
begged and didn’t know enough about the
domain that we’re trying to innovate
which was traveling transportation third
dimension perhaps the most important of
them all volume the amount of action
that we take towards innovation now we
all know that there’s a trade-off
between quantity and quality that in
order to achieve extreme quality we need
to quit fool around and focus on that
one thing again and again and again to
accomplishment perfection right wrong
when it comes about idea generation
quantity is the only predictable path
words quality Thomas Edison in order to
create a handful of innovation that
should change a life forever
he filed two thousand three hundred and
thirty two patents worldwide and more
than 1900 in US alone including this the
creepiest talking doll
ever conceived and luckily for mr.
Edison or for any one of us history
doesn’t judge you for your failure or
for your lows you judge you for your
highest and I’m not just saying the
least you know goes on and on and on
look at land 533 still the second in in
history of us for two great inventions
and what I’m saying is not that
innovation it’s the number games so the
more you try it the more chances you
have it to get it right one but that is
exist a positive correlation between the
quantity of your action and the average
quality of your output in other words
you will reach your highest quality in
the period in which you are more active
if you want to know that that point on
the left is Vagner and it pulled it off
because of propaganda and regime that’s
pretty obvious and this is so important
because when you were terrified of
failure as we were saying basically you
kill innovation and this is so perverse
if you don’t try there’s no chance in
hell you can get to a great result why
am I telling you this
and why now it goes right now and I and
we’ve said before evolution is cyclical
and digital evolution especially and we
are on a verge of a new change of a new
paradigm and this is going to reshape
what we know about digital is gonna be a
Renaissance much more closer to what he
was these original promises internet and
digital will cease to be a centralized
game for you and will become a much much
more distributed participated and
interpret aerial game for anyone who
wants to join this is gonna this is
called blockchain and IOC we don’t have
time to go into details but I’ll be
pleased if you want to if you want to
reach out please do but what I want to
tell you
is that right now we really in this
moment on we really have an opportunity
to make a mark towards a better world
not to work just for wealth but for
prosperity for a bigger good a greater
good and now like never before our
ability of innovate and to innovate will
draw the line between those rise and
those who fall and only need to do is to
debunk some dysfunctional belief the
first one being that innovation it’s not
a stroke of genius
it’s the process it’s something that you
can trigger nurture and make part of
your culture and even share and look
there are thousands of thousands of
thousands of way in which this can be
done and thousands of program classes
books but luckily they all rely on few
very simple values in principle question
the default emerge yourself in different
domains find new paradigm and point of
view welcome criticism because it’s only
through criticism and radical
collaboration that we can kill
groupthink for the companies don’t hire
based on cultural fit you will you will
listen you will you will hear it so much
from now on like cultural fit higher
based on cultural contribution because
repetition might make a perfect process
but it never makes new and most of all
try stuff try stuff and try stuff you
know I’ve I’ve talked about design
thinking earlier on and in this
presentation I’ve baked a few principle
of them and the most important principle
of a design thinker is designers that
don’t think the way forward they build
their way forward and they fail the way
forward in other words if you don’t act
it doesn’t matter how good you get it in
the first place there’s no chance in
which you can reach anything and I know
it’s tough I know it’s gonna be an
uphill run and that’s why I want to
share in a conclusion one of the
triggers that really helped me make that
decision and this goes back on the
unreasonable man or women that I’ve
asked before and these four
George Barna Shaw he says that the
reasonable man is the one that adapts
himself to the world and the
unreasonable man is the one that
persists in China adapting the world’s
to himself and therefore all progress
depends on the unreasonable man thank
you very much
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: