Press "Enter" to skip to content

What creativity isn’t | Björn Olafsson | TEDxUChicago


there’s this moment from Sponge Bob
Squarepants that I’ve always found to be
extraordinarily interesting there with
me so it’s from season 2 episode 15
Squidward is teaching all the residents
of Bikini Bottom how to be in a marching
band you know reading music and playing
instruments and all that jazz and it’s
going great until one of them well one
of them has a question so patrick stars
one Tom’s best friend he puts his hand
in the air he puts his hand to the air
and then he very enthusiastically asks
is mayonnaise an instrument well is it
the time I had no idea but I wanted to
so me being the young annoying little
scientist that I was I decided to
investigate so I grabbed a spoon and a
jar of mayo from the fridge and I
started banging it out literally I made
at the time what I believe to be
beautiful music but was probably more of
a cacophony the point is then as a
psychologist then as a child and now as
a psychologist I understood that that
moment that question was always more
than just a joke from a cartoon or an
internet meme no that question is also
the most profound example of creativity
that I’ve ever seen now you all know
what creativity is right I mean you
might not be able to define it in words
but you have a general idea of what it
means to be creative well you’re wrong I
hate to break it to you but you’re wrong
now don’t worry I’m wrong too
I’ve been collecting data about how
people come up with ideas for almost a
year now and the more and more I look at
the more and more I realize just how
wrong I am creativity is so much less
than what we think it’s so much simpler
so much
I’m getting ahead of myself I have moved
away from the question what is
creativity no the far more interesting
question the far more potent question is
actually what isn’t creativity and the
first thing creativity isn’t is
associative at least in the traditional
way this is something called an
associative semantic network it was
first proposed by Elizabeth Loftus and
Alan Collins in the 70s and it’s
basically a way of understanding how we
store our ideas and more importantly how
we retrieve our ideas because
information actually spreads along this
web through their research we are able
to understand that for example if I were
to say the word mayonnaise you are
instantly more able to think of the word
egg or white or creamy or jar or mustard
or whatever you happen to associate with
mayonnaise for me it’s inedible
gelatinous goo but maybe that’s just me
so when a normal person would come up
with a new musical instrument they might
stay within this network they might
modify an existing instrument like
taking a tuba and making it smaller into
a baritone which incidentally is the
instrument I happen to play in high
school band class or you might combine
aspects of instruments together like an
electric guitar which is the instrument
I could have played in high school band
class but when people think they usually
don’t go beyond this network but that’s
exactly what Patrick does is mayonnaise
an instrument thoughts of mayonnaise
don’t trigger thoughts of music and
thoughts of music don’t trigger thoughts
of mayonnaise but nevertheless he still
asked that question and that question is
itself a rebellion against this way of
thinking against this semantic network
it’s a rejection of thoughts that we
have preconceived notions and
traditional Association
that’s why it’s bold that’s why it’s
creative but now there’s a reason that
such a simple question just four little
words are able to be so creative and
that’s because number two creativity
isn’t complicated this very University
demonstrates the exact same thing we’re
known for our unique se prompts the ones
we give to prospective students here’s
one for example what does Plato have to
do with Plato
well for starters one of them is a
children’s toy and the other is the most
ancient philosopher that we know of and
it’s the same thing as with Patrick’s
question Plato Plato music mayonnaise
same connection but it has one more
commonality that connection is simple it
doesn’t ask you to reinvent a children’s
toy doesn’t ask you to make a profound
claim about the origins of philosophy
Patrick doesn’t hand you a blueprint for
an instrument he doesn’t tell you what
it would look like or sound like or how
he played no they just make that
connection creativity doesn’t need many
moving parts in order to function well
it doesn’t need complexity at all
creativity’s existence it’s predicated
on its own existence that brings us to
number three creativity isn’t practical
what are the most common ways the
psychologists test for creativity is
called the alternative uses tasks
basically we get people an everyday
object a pencil a paperclip a towel
whatever and then we ask them to come up
with as many ideas as they can for that
object here is it an anonymous person’s
answers for a brick and yeah you can see
that some of these are practical
you know using as a weight or a weapon
or whatever but then you look at some of
the more interesting ideas using a brick
as a piece of Modern Art a croquet ball
a teddy bear as a Barbie’s coffin let me
ask you this how many of you have gone
up to a six year old child handed them a
brick and told them that it was the
coffin of their doll I’m guessing not
many when people trying to think of
ideas when they really dig down into it
they ignore practicality they ignore
whether or not it could or could not
exist in the real world and
psychologists do too when researchers
like myself look at data like these we
don’t code it for practicality or
realism we look at the originality yes
we look at the number of ideas yes but
we don’t care about the practicality
that’s because practicality and
creativity have nothing to do with each
other now we’re on to number four
creativity isn’t communal although a
brainstorming is right you know a bunch
of creative types huddled in a room with
a whiteboard mark with a white board and
the expo marker and they’re all
scribbling out their ideas as fast as
they can
shouting them out interrupting each
other well that’s great but it’s not
creative it’s a different thing it’s
brainstorming a 1991 meta-analysis by
Brian bullen and Craig Johnson shows
that as the number of people in a group
goes up the number of ideas goes down
and the people who have the best ideas
the people who have the most creative
ideas the ones that impress researchers
the most well they actually worked alone
the researchers go as far to say that
the long live popularity of
brainstorming techniques is
unequivocally and substantially
misguided well why then do we do it why
do we work in groups well the answer is
very simple
it’s fun people really enjoy being
collaborative and talking to other
people but you have to keep in mind that
when other people around you your
creative output is diminished when you
have an idea in your brain and you know
that it’s going to be judged implicitly
or explicitly you’re less likely to
voice it my favorite example of this is
actually Tycho Brahe hey he’s this
Danish astronomer who used stellar
parallax without the aid of a telescope
essentially he looked into the heavens
and measured the distances between stars
in the sky and a 1572 supernova and he
correctly concluded that the Stars and
the heavens are actually further away
from us than the moon I know it sounds
obvious but at the time this was
revolutionary that the universe could
exist beyond our solar system famously
he came to this creative idea alone he
holed himself up inside a city outside
of his castle event he ignored the
advice and research of other scientists
including his own fever pupil Johannes
Kepler his creativity sprung in part due
to his isolation now I want to make one
thing clear I’m not trying to say that
we should all be Hermits I’m not trying
to say we should holo cells up inside
castles or literally or figuratively
live under a rock that’s not what I’m
saying I am advocating for a step back
if you’re in a group you know with your
co-workers or teammates or whatever you
need to acknowledge the fact that their
presence changes what you’re going to
say maybe that involves writing down on
a piece of paper all that you have to
offer really thinking about what ideas
are yours and what ideas are others
because creativity is a personal process
not a collective one finally
we’re on to number five creativity isn’t
abnormal it’s not this mythical concept
only employed by artists and scientists
and tortured geniuses no everyone has it
it’s a process not a product and it’s a
process that we all have in the words of
Francis Picabia an artist known for
switching styles constantly our heads
are round so our thoughts can change
direction we all have the ability to
change the channel it’s just a matter of
doing it so for all that creativity
isn’t here’s what it is it’s a
connection between concept a and concept
B it’s this thin imaginary line drawn
between two disparate ideas that’s it
it’s unburdened by practicality and
realism and what could or could not
exist it is unburdened by traditional
associations and what other people think
and complexity it just is no here’s what
this means that means that the vast
majority of creative ideas aren’t going
to cause paradigm shifts they’re not
going to cause revolutions and they’re
not going to invent new gadgets no the
vast vast majority of creative ideas
that flit across your brain so quickly
are going to be tossed aside they are
utterly and completely meaningless but
don’t think for a second that doesn’t
mean they’re not worthwhile don’t think
for a second that questions like
Patrick’s shouldn’t be asked or
questions like you Chicago’s should it
be answered
because creativity is not a painting
hidden in a gallery no it’s the artist
standing in front of a blank canvas
paint brush in hand
simultaneously imagining the every
single brush stroke she could possibly
paint creativity is not the moment
you’re giving a presentation to your
co-workers or to your teammates it’s the
night before when you’re in the shower
shampooing your hair and you just let
what could or could not work but people
might or might not think just wash away
and let your ideas amalgamate I will and
creativity is an anthropomorphic pink
starfish who not so jokingly asked an
impossible question and creativity is
the child at home watching and thinking
thinking of a possible answer thank you
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: