Press "Enter" to skip to content

Facing Our (Hidden) Fears | Dalbir Sehmby | TEDxUAlberta


[Music]
stereotyping can be lots of fun
especially if we actually don’t believe
in any of the stereotypes
I don’t even though I have this face
when I was a child I would look in the
mirror and frightened myself because at
grade three I began to grow facial hair
and growing up I did not always wear the
turban I had different hair styles
haircuts so when people saw me they
assumed I was Mexican African American
maybe an exotic Spanish guy
sometimes when I grew my beard little
bit longer here longer they assumed I
was from Saudi Arabia Pakistan India or
I’d simply hated all women more
surprisingly on the phone people assumed
I was white because I don’t actually
talk like this I was born in Canada’s
Northwest Territories
[Applause]
to seek Indian immigrant parents and I
grew up fascinated by human beings first
and foremost all I want to be is a human
being but I can’t I have all this
pressure on me see I’m lactose
intolerant can’t have gluten
which means my mother can’t feed me any
traditional Punjabi food is out she
keeps trying to give me a so much just
give you here take a samosa it’ll cure
your gluten I can’t have it have some
rice pudding I can’t have it there’s
milk in it lots of pressure going up but
all I wanted to be first and foremost
was a human being and socially that was
difficult especially after I grew my
hair and started to tie it up in a
turban because everywhere I went people
assumed I was the cab driver after 9/11
people assumed I was al-qaeda Taliban or
Isis now I don’t want to scare anyone
I’m not al-qaeda Taliban or Isis so long
as the university keeps hiring me back
as a sessional instructor I shouldn’t
have to get my cab driving license now
today I want us to reboot humanity
reboot our understanding of ourselves
our relationship to one another reboot
humanity and we go through four areas an
area of our primal stress response the
second area about our inner ET our ego
and our tribalism and then I’ll talk to
you about the institutionalization of
our insecurities and I will discuss the
superstition of scapegoating and then
I’ll give you a conclusion inside each
and every one of us is a marvelously
primal brain if there’s real physical
danger we can freeze flee or we can
fight if you see a lion
you can play dead you can run away
or you can kill it because there’s
nothing like walking back to the tribe
with a fresh lion skin it’s a wonderful
primal response that we have and then we
can tell other people of the tribe this
is what you need to do when you see a
line be alert carry a submachine gun
we’re not just primal we’re also social
beings we have individual egos and we
have tribes and in that there’s some
difficulty because when our primal
responses are firing out of context or
when our egos get insecure or we’re just
trying to justify our worldviews or were
blinded by our tribal worldviews then we
have trouble I’ll illustrate with an
example from our breakfast table
recently I asked my daughter why she did
poorly on a test which a note to all
parents never asked you to kids that
before they’ve eaten breakfast it just
makes them extra cranky but so that was
a factor but I asked her why she didn’t
do so well on a test and with her
wounded ego she lashed out because the
teacher never gave us the users
she projected her own vulnerability her
own inability onto the teachers teachers
not doing the job and then her brother
being a good big brother jumped right in
and formed a nice little tribe yeah that
teachers tough when it comes to tests
yeah
teachers and then I have a
three-year-old son he just ran around
the table with the forks screaming JJ
but I should add he does that like every
morning he just with a fork running
he doesn’t say teacher but he picks some
different words but the point is that
they get this they let my daughter
lashed out and and she overlooked some
basic simple elements one she didn’t
have that principle behind of common
humanity that the teachers on her side
instead she built up this narrative that
already pre-existed her a binary about
students versus teachers and then she
scapegoating the teachers and
stereotyping the teacher she’s not doing
a good job it’s her fault and that
pattern seems to persist which is why we
need to reboot now these are just kids
and even though I’m picking on my kids I
see myself in them I’ve done things like
this as well none of you have I’m sure
but I have now adults are another thing
though because adults have
institutionalized their insecurities and
what I mean by that is and I there’s
this there seems to me from my
perspective a parallel between the
primal stress response and some of the
way our historically our institutions
have behaved so for instance if we have
this response of freezing we can think
of it as a way of you know
interpersonally when you’re upset you
give someone the silent treatment right
have you ever done that by the way I
should say sorry I don’t where my wife
is sitting but I know what she looks
like but I can’t see but I’m sorry
whenever I give the silent treatment
have you given the silent treatment you
know what I’m talking about
now our institutions do this as well
when they go blind and deaf
problems within the subcultures right
institutions have gotten gone frozen
when for instance they ignore the voting
rights of women when they ignore
adequate housing for African Americans
or when they ignore putting First
Nations into textbooks institution can
can do the other step of fleeing and by
that we could think of it as like in the
old days maybe when we’re cave ancestors
if there was danger
you could run up a tree now it seems
like your institutions have implemented
a method of erecting walls real or
metaphorical or hierarchies and so we
get this with any form of segregation we
divide we forget to put humanity first
treat everyone is equal so we can do
this it’s race with a gender with any
sort of category but probably the one of
the best one is class because with class
there’s no easy visible marker that’s
why if you think about now a lot of
businesses are getting away with these
short term contract part-time type of
workers that precariat and don’t think
universities are immune universities
also foster precariat underclass so
along with institutions freezing and
fleeing they also do something else
which is the one that we most know
fighting we actually have institutions
that are geared towards fighting the
military you can go to war you can
commit genocide or sometimes that you
get a choice so Isis might say convert
or be killed
it’s not much of a choice but they give
you that choice it’s not a real choice
by the way and then there’s a polite way
to do things too you can coerce through
institutionalized violence and by that I
mean you could say come come to our
school we’ll train you for a while and
make you more civilized so these are all
patterns that we’ve seen
institutionalized
in our past and these are problematic
for many reasons
but primarily because we don’t put
humanity first so we need to reboot
humanity and instead we boot people out
hence the superstition of scapegoating I
have an equation for you and that
equation is stress plus fear equals hate
when we experience a trauma a major
traumatic event like 9/11 we experience
this major trauma that is disorienting
and that fills us up with a certain
amount of fear so we have this group of
the week so this I won’t do these quotes
all the time my kids thinks these are
bunnies but we so we have this group the
in-group that’s saying that the lives
are threatened lifestyles are threatened
values are threatened and so the world
doesn’t disarray you’re not thinking
clearly but we have the social mechanism
of superstition the superstition of
scapegoating to ease those fears so that
channel of all of our hate towards one
visible target oh I get it
it’s just that guy over there if we just
get rid of that guy then our community
will be fine our future will be fine and
within this there’s a narrative that
parallels the one I told you about my
kids at the breakfast table we have a
when we tell stories like this about one
another after major traumatic events
those stories are not necessarily
grounded in a nuanced reality but in
stereotypes so we have the binary
thinking of us versus them you need that
every drama needs a good conflict
ostracism you have stereotyping because
you have characters in your fantasy good
versus evil and then the scapegoating
functions as a solution to the narrative
because once a traumatic event happens
our present is unsafe and our future is
unsafe we’re scared and instead of
dealing with that fright that fear in a
healthy way we project onto some sort of
scapegoat
the first 911 victim as a hate crime
victim four days after 9/11 was an
individual who just donated money to the
New York Relief Fund and then was shot
dead he was a Sikh American wearing a
turban he was not a terrorist he was not
alcot al-qaeda Taliban or Isis he was
not Muslim but he looked the part and
that got me thinking about that era that
9/11 what happened and how it has is not
only a media event in that time it’s a
media event that resurrected all these
colonial fears these narratives that
layered on top of one another so if you
think of 9/11 think of what occurred
these planes fly into towers this
recalls our traumatic memory of kamikaze
pilots in World War two the center of a
city is being attacked this is the
blitzkrieg from World War two after
World War two cities were redesigned so
that won’t happen and we started getting
suburbs and also we know about Pearl
Harbor it’s a surprise attack
so all these narratives already exists
they’re floating around and when we were
fearful consciously or unconsciously
most often they come back alive so
inadvertently we get colonialism 2.0 in
a new millennium we’re now whoa we’re
scared now what do you do the alert when
you see brown guys carry submachine gun
simple solution or so we think that
simplicity simplicity is problematic of
course that’s why we need to reboot our
understanding of 9/11 we need a new
story about 9/11 how to deal with that
trauma 9/11 certainly is an American
tragedy
it is a Western tragedy but it is also a
global tragedy victims of 9/11 include
people from over 70 countries and after
9/11
there’s
terrorist attacks around the world in a
tragic irony Sikhs in Afghanistan
wearing turbans are killed by the
Taliban the very people they’re confused
with in America and these attacks that
occur around the world they occur in
Western and in non Western nations they
occur against non-muslims and against
Muslims
Isis is attacking Muslims as well so the
situation is more complicated than the
stereotyping or the scapegoating or the
popular narrative has but those
narratives have big sway because they’re
simplistic solutions well we need to
reboot this we need to look at acts as
recent as in January of 2017 the Quebec
attack on a Canadian Muslim mosque the
shooter entered this is a type of
terrorist act that needs to be included
in our discussion to move beyond this
mentality of scape ability five years
early and earlier in Milwaukee there was
a similar incident in a Sikh Gurdwara
with several turban people were shot and
in between those two events there was
another shooting in an african-american
church where nine African Americans were
killed by a shooter and that all these
events are interconnected because after
9/11 there was a general rise in hate
groups and this narrative ization is
superstition of scapegoating so
certainly brown bodies have been
affected people with turbans have been
affected but also African Americans hate
crimes have increased Jews against Jews
hate crimes have been increased
immigrants and even homosexuals
so when hate begins a superstition it is
conjured these old colonial biases and
re-implemented them and this is all very
depressing
and now I’m supposed to give you an
answer but not every TED talk can give
you all the answers what I can try to do
though is give give you a sort of
working method and by working method I
want us to become clear so the first
thing is clarity so I’ll say with me
clarity we need to get clear about what
we know and what we don’t know here’s
what we know we know we have this cycle
of hate the superstition of scapegoating
that we keep repeating over and over
again we know that we don’t put humanity
first what we don’t know we don’t know
the future the future is uncertain
so we need to just admit that we don’t
know what exists in 7.5 billion people’s
heads and when we do we’re being
delusional what I mean by that is think
about your loved ones in your life you
don’t know what’s happening in their
heads it’s weird but you don’t you know
what’s happening in the characters of
fiction more than you know the people in
your in your lives because you can’t
enter their brains but you can enter
Harry Potter’s brain so you know Harry
Potter and then sometimes we falsely
assume that we know what other people
are thinking and if you ever hit a point
really oh I know what that person over
there is thinking then you risk
stereotyping so we need to get clear
about that but we know what we don’t
know sometimes we don’t even know what
we are thinking which brings me to my
second piece of advice which is we
should try to become more aware so
clarity now awareness Thanks if I did
then it didn’t work will be just weird
it would be like dancing would be
clarity awareness we need to get aware
of our primal stress response get aware
of our inner ET when our vulnerable ego
or our tribalism our worldviews are
blinding us we need to along with
awareness move towards a greater balance
by that I mean there’s no one shot
solution this is one mistake that we I
think we have we have a mistake of
thinking if we just had one you know one
religion one nation everything will be
fine
no wouldn’t or if we had no religion no
races no name I don’t know because if
you’ve been to my broker’s breakfast
table it’s a pretty homogeneous
community and there’s still stereotyping
and scapegoating and other sorts of
fighting the most homogeneous
communities unfortunately have these
problems still so instead what we might
be able to strive for is some balance
that’s a third one so say with me
balance so clarity awareness that might
help us from teetering one way or
another if we just you know it’s kind of
balance although now I’m doing the punk
rock right so I hope one day I can stand
before you and you’ll believe me when I
say I am first and foremost a human
being and if there’s ever any trouble
remember o yaara my friend called on my
dad clarity awareness and balance
[Applause]
[Music]
Please follow and like us: