
so first off thank you so much for
having me this is an incredible
opportunity and thanks again to all the
students who put this so education you
know if all of the issues you’re gonna
hear about today I would argue that
education is the worst and not the worst
that like physically harms us the most
it’s just the worst you know we’ve all
we all grew up went through the same
education system and it makes us feel
tired it makes us feel despair it makes
us feel frustrated you know even Brock
Obama can’t get through a class without
you know ball and svet head back and
saying is this really the best way and
every month it’s like we hear another
study came out Oh a new international
test in America’s last or America fell
you know American students they’re
really confident but you know not that
bright and so education is this
seemingly intractable issue but it’s
unique in that we’ve all experienced it
and so what’s strange is why is this why
is the system so terrible because when
you think about the idea of learning
which is this act that the education
system is meant to facilitate that
actually produces completely different
feelings in our mind yeah I bet even
hearing that word is this idea of
unleashing our minds becoming better
versions of ourselves exploring our
curiosity you’re feeling motivated
feeling empowered even today in today’s
world with digital connectivity I would
argue learning something new and the
idea of that even is you know dare I say
cool and this is me if you’re curious
ninth grade
and yes that is a real go T it took me
about 18 months to grow this this was
the only time in my life where I was
cool it’s my license to cool phase but
you know going through college that’s
when my intellectual curiosity really
took off and like many of us I feel like
we shared that experience and so I
started asked myself why is this why is
the education experience and system so
intractable and so boring and at the end
of my emery experience I graduated back
in 2012 I was a philosophy major so my
career path wasn’t exactly carved out
and Teach for America actually provided
me with the opportunity to jump into the
classroom and find out what exactly was
up in in education so I became a high
school teacher I taught ninth and tenth
grade social studies here in
Lana and it was almost a cliche where I
taught at this point I taught at
Banneker high school so it’s a great
school here in Atlanta but at the time
it was struggling 42 percent graduation
rate you know 97 percent of the students
qualify for free and reduced lunch which
means they’re at or below the poverty
line and you know just historically in
the last 10-15 years Banneker was not
having a lot of success and in my first
year I ran into a lot of the same
problems you’d expect oh we need more
teachers or the the standards are
outdated the books are outdated now we
just we just need more culture we need a
better energy but none of those really
felt like the fundamental issue because
something wasn’t right something wasn’t
hidden for me so my second year I
actually figured out I think I had a
moment and it’s when I met Natasha my
second year I was teaching world history
10th grade class and in Georgia like in
many states world history is actually a
required course in order to graduate and
so was second semester and every
semester you get a you know new set of
kids Natasha was in my fourth period
class on my bday 38 kids in the
classroom it was it was really a show I
must say but Natasha was not like every
other student in the class she wasn’t a
tenth grader
she was actually a twelfth grader she
was 18 year old and she had failed world
history the first time around and so it
was spring time her last semester and
she needed to pass my class in order to
graduate so here she is start of the
semester really motivated I’m motivated
we start off well she’s doing okay but
it was quickly became clear to me that
Natasha like a lot of her peers and
anybody who’s taught in underserved
schools know this is actually a
widespread issue that she was well
behind academically you know her reading
and writing were probably actually
closer to her fifth or a sixth grade
level her math is probably in that area
as well and my course is a lot based on
writing and reading and all that kind of
stuff that she do in world history and
so over the course of the semester
Natasha’s Breanna struggle
fast-forward we’re a week away from when
I have to submit grades and I look up
and at my grade book in the Tosh’s
grades at a 55 now in Georgia or in
Fulton County I should say you need a
70% in order to pass a class at that
moment I knew there was no statistical
way than Natasha could pass this class
and I offered her tutorial I’d offer
extra credit recovery packets extra
tests these are all things that in
underserved schools were oftentimes
almost forced to do by our principals
because our students are struggling
being so behind and yet here Natasha is
at 18 and she’s got a 55 so this is
where I was put into a dilemma that also
sparked some inspiration I was sitting
there and I was deciding do I pass a
Natasha or do I fail her now I bet
everybody’s sitting here and your gut
reaction was the same exact as mine
Natasha earned a 55 it’s unfortunate
she could have made better choices she
could have taken advantage of extra
credit of recovery of tutorial and so
Natasha
earned a 55 and I need to stand on the
integrity of the class stand on the
principle of the class and all the
students who actually put in a lot of
work and got passing grades and so
Natasha should earn her failing grade I
think viscerally that just feels like
the right thing because she she’s you
know facing the consequences of her
actions however at this point in time I
decided to take a step back and I said
to myself okay well let’s look at the
other side of the coin what happens if I
fail natasha natashas 18 she comes from
a school where a lot of kids drop out
most don’t actually finish and so if I
fail Natasha she’s not going to graduate
yeah maybe she’ll come back in the
summer or in the fall to get that one
credit back up but the likelihood of
that actually happening is really slim
and so to me was is Natasha responsible
completely let me definitely bear some
responsibility but it all her fault
but she ended up in world history again
spring semester senior year and her life
trajectory could be altered because of
the fact that she couldn’t master my
world history class where we’re talking
about stuff that happened 5,000 years
ago that honestly is not that relevant
to her not that relevant to me but here
we are and so if I fail her I’m gonna
drastically alter her life prospects
without a high school diploma in our
country and in our world right now it’s
really really challenging you really do
not have a ton of options and so I asked
what would you do you know do you pass
her and you know you know honestly save
her trajectory save her prospects
or do you fail her and stand on
principle because if you stand on
principle you’re not actually gonna fix
the system in that moment and that’s
when it hit me why am I in this scenario
why is a teacher am i sitting there
having to face this ethical dilemma that
you know in all truthfulness came up
many times for me and many other
teachers I knew that’s kind of beauty of
teaching America’s you get to know a lot
of teachers at different schools and we
all face very similar problems and I was
seeing myself why why is this happening
I feel like I’m in the dark I feel like
there’s no guiding principle I don’t
know what the education system is meant
to be doing and so I don’t know how to
make this decision for Natasha and
that’s where the question came to me
what is the goal of Education after all
can anybody agree upon it dude does
anybody have an agreed-upon definition
of education why we do it in the first
place what’s the vision where are we
going with this and now that I’ve worked
in education and policy and the
nonprofit sector and in the classroom I
realized nobody really knows if you
asked everybody in this room and
everybody in education you would get
tons of different answers some people
today say the point of Education is to
make everybody college and career-ready
you know other people say it’s to
develop a love of learning or a globally
competitive workforce or to earn a
college degree you go to college or to
get a job even you know all these things
depend on who you ask so if we think
about Natasha you know in that scenario
if it’s college and career-ready well
what does that mean I mean she’s
definitely not college ready from a
skill standpoint she could be career
ready depending on what’s career talking
about but we don’t really know because
no one’s told us no one’s decided no
one’s define what that means if it’s
develop a love of learning how do you
measure that how do you teach that you
know globally competitive workforce that
could be something completely different
and so as teachers and as educators
there is no North Star there is no
guiding light there is no purpose
there’s no clearly defined goal and
that’s the problem so why is it so
difficult why is this question and this
system so intractable at this point I
think it comes down to two things the
first one’s fairly obvious the education
system as we know it was started in the
Industrial Revolution and it was not
meant for what it is today
it was originally meant for routine to
teach people basic skills they can
work in factories or in the
administrative State and it’s just been
growing and growing and growing for the
last hundred years and we’ve just been
trying to fix it and force everything
that’s a new into it the second is
actually a deeper question education is
how we prepare ourselves it’s how we
prepare our children and so another
reason why it’s so challenging for us to
agree on the goal is because deciding
what education is about is actually
deciding what our purpose of our lives
should be you know the purpose of our
lives is to be productive then yeah
education should probably be about
routine and rigidity and and you know
just doing the same thing over and over
and so you produce as much as you
possibly can
if it’s about personal exploration then
it should be about discovery it should
be about challenging ourselves you know
exploring each other and collaborating
and all of that if it’s about sitting in
front of screens and phones and TVs all
day then maybe it should just be that
maybe we should start earlier as you can
see some people think we’re headed in
that direction already and since we have
no agreed-upon goal we’ve ended up in a
credential driven system so here’s a
short graph from the Georgia Public
Policy Institute it’s a research study
done a few years ago that honestly tells
us a lot that we already know by 2020 65
percent of all jobs will require a cop
some college or more and then 88 percent
of all jobs will require at least a high
school diploma so if Natasha doesn’t
gather diploma she’s pretty much out of
luck I mean there’s very very few job
prospects and honestly they’re probably
jobs that aren’t going to lead to
sustained abilities to stability to a
feeling of prosperity and so we’re in
this credential driven society where a
lot of times it doesn’t even matter what
you studied for any seniors in the room
you probably look at the jobs right now
and it just says bachelor’s degree
required and maybe it lists 10 majors
but they don’t really care what you
studied they just care can you learn are
you capable are you resourceful but we
have what now has turned into a really
elaborate filtering system you know if
Natasha gets that high school diploma it
does not reflect her skillset by any
means as I told you she’s on a fifth or
sixth grade reading and writing level
but she’s got the piece of paper so does
it really matter now I’d ask people to
imagine if we’re in a credential driven
system what does success look like what
the ideal credential different system
look like is it really everybody has a
high school diploma and a bachelor’s
degree I think it takes everybody in
this room probably less than five
seconds to realize that that reality
would be horrific it wouldn’t work
everybody would be overqualified for all
the jobs that the majority of our
economy is based off of and nobody would
want to do them we’re honestly not far
from that right now and so this can’t be
the way this should be when people look
at the education system from the highest
level and that’s what we really need to
start thinking about because we need to
find solutions that scale
a lot of people in the state and federal
policy levels honestly they look at it
like it’s a factory now when you hear
that you probably think it’s very
negative and most of times when people
talk about factories and education they
mean it in a very negative way but I
would argue that a factory isn’t a bad
analogy because when you think of a
massive you know the national scale we
need it to be as consistent as efficient
as a factory we need it to be repeatable
and consistent where everybody we turn
out competent after competent after
competent person who can really push our
society forward the problem with this
analogy is that we are so far from being
a factory we are nowhere close to this
efficiency and this takes the humanity
out of learning what we’re actually a
lot closer to is something like this if
you guys are familiar with like the Rube
Goldberg concept it’s basically you just
put a bunch of random stuff together and
they all do something that essentially
pushes out something really simple so in
this one we’ve got a clock that you know
sets off a firework that hits a bird or
something and then eventually it just
wipes the guy’s face with a napkin like
that’s the goal of it that’s what
education is right now every year it’s
something different
oh this year it’s standards or its class
sizes or its stem or its you know the
the size of the school or we need you
know more of this type of school it’s
all these little tweaks that we think
are getting at the fundamental problem
and it’s just oh it’s just this one
tweak and once we do that then then
we’re good it’ll start turning out more
kids who are ready I’m not here to argue
that that is so far from the truth and
that in reality we’re much more like a
ship we’re a ship in the dead of night
drifting in the dark there’s no compass
there’s no destination there’s no stars
to guide us
and every year we’re just making these
slight course corrections thinking that
we’re going in the right direction but
we’re really just drifting and we have
no direction and so what I want to do is
lay out a few fundamental truths about
education so that we can stop talking
about them and start getting past that
and think differently about the
educational experience because we spend
most of our time in the education policy
world argue about the same things so the
first truth that I’ve recognized and
everybody needs to come to grips with is
we will never have an excellent teacher
in every single classroom it’s a fact
it’s a physical reality there is no
possible way to have an excellent
teacher in every classroom there are 3.1
million teachers in America there has
never been a 3.1 million person
workforce where everybody is excellent
so we need to just accept that fact and
move on number two things like charter
schools and school choice should be
looked at as iterations not as
innovations and I’m not against charter
schools at all I think we need R&D and
education you know education is unique
in that are our users or us or our
products and so we need to be thinking
about new ways to do this experience and
charter schools can do that but the vast
majority of them and there are a few
that really pushed the boundaries and
challenged the status quo but the vast
majority are really just changing and
tweaking little things oh this charter
school has tiny classes or this school
has a longer school day where this
school only serves this type of student
again those are tweaks on the existing
failing model in my opinion and things
like school choice the idea where
students can opt into the lottery for
any school in their city that relies on
a lot of middle class assumptions that
students have the wherewithal the
internet access to get into a lottery
and that they have the transportation
actually consistently take advantage of
that school choice and that’s why you
see a lot of cities who have school
choice they show clear gains in the in
the short term but then when you dig
deeper into the data the safe students
are still struggling
lastly beyond the fundamentals of
reading writing math critical thinking a
hard skills approach to education will
never keep up so whether it’s cursive or
CAD or coding these skills always become
obsolete just at the time where we get
almost okay at doing them take coding
for example that’s like the big skill
today everybody needs to learn coding
but as you guys probably are
we have these coding boot camps out
there right 12 to 14 week programs to
teach anybody how to code as long as you
have a high school diploma so you’re
telling me we can teach anybody with a
high school diploma how to code in 12
weeks why would we spend four to eight
years in the k-12 system teaching them
that why not make that part of corporate
responsibility to train their own
workers they do that anyways the
majority of and for the students the
room majority of what you’re gonna do in
your job you learn on the job I never
trained to be an executive director or a
teacher really even most of my
colleagues and my friends didn’t train
to be the position they’re doing today
they’re just resourceful capable
collaborative critical thinkers so
focusing on hard skills and trying to
force them into the educational
experience will will never keep up okay
so what can we do because I think in our
guts we all know that education can be
so much more it can be a place where
intellectual curiosity is fostered every
single day because we’ve all experienced
that moment right now we think about
engineering the environment we focused
on the school building we focus on the
teacher the technology how many kids are
in the classroom and this is engineering
the environment and these are all
factors that influence education but
they’re not fundamental to the success
and I know that because I had different
teachers than you I wasn’t a different
school building you I had different
standards into our different technology
than you my classes were a different
size than you and yet we’re all here
we’re all in this room achieving some
level of success so it can’t be these
things that are fundamental what we need
to do is intent instead get into the
mind of a student really think about the
student experience how are they
experiencing these different concepts
how are they relating them how can we
get kids inspired instead of keeping
them in line how can we instead of
probably promoting compliance promote
creativity and collaboration how can we
get students in focus and in flow
instead of in routine we need to start
thinking about how students experience
this so we develop their skills and
their individuality together and we need
to start thinking about it at scale
because until we do more and more
students and educators like myself my
colleagues Natasha will be in these
terrible scenarios where we have no
guiding light we have no idea where
we’re going and we make these decisions
that end up just crippling our society
year after year after you
and will continue to be teaching in the
dark thank you
you
having me this is an incredible
opportunity and thanks again to all the
students who put this so education you
know if all of the issues you’re gonna
hear about today I would argue that
education is the worst and not the worst
that like physically harms us the most
it’s just the worst you know we’ve all
we all grew up went through the same
education system and it makes us feel
tired it makes us feel despair it makes
us feel frustrated you know even Brock
Obama can’t get through a class without
you know ball and svet head back and
saying is this really the best way and
every month it’s like we hear another
study came out Oh a new international
test in America’s last or America fell
you know American students they’re
really confident but you know not that
bright and so education is this
seemingly intractable issue but it’s
unique in that we’ve all experienced it
and so what’s strange is why is this why
is the system so terrible because when
you think about the idea of learning
which is this act that the education
system is meant to facilitate that
actually produces completely different
feelings in our mind yeah I bet even
hearing that word is this idea of
unleashing our minds becoming better
versions of ourselves exploring our
curiosity you’re feeling motivated
feeling empowered even today in today’s
world with digital connectivity I would
argue learning something new and the
idea of that even is you know dare I say
cool and this is me if you’re curious
ninth grade
and yes that is a real go T it took me
about 18 months to grow this this was
the only time in my life where I was
cool it’s my license to cool phase but
you know going through college that’s
when my intellectual curiosity really
took off and like many of us I feel like
we shared that experience and so I
started asked myself why is this why is
the education experience and system so
intractable and so boring and at the end
of my emery experience I graduated back
in 2012 I was a philosophy major so my
career path wasn’t exactly carved out
and Teach for America actually provided
me with the opportunity to jump into the
classroom and find out what exactly was
up in in education so I became a high
school teacher I taught ninth and tenth
grade social studies here in
Lana and it was almost a cliche where I
taught at this point I taught at
Banneker high school so it’s a great
school here in Atlanta but at the time
it was struggling 42 percent graduation
rate you know 97 percent of the students
qualify for free and reduced lunch which
means they’re at or below the poverty
line and you know just historically in
the last 10-15 years Banneker was not
having a lot of success and in my first
year I ran into a lot of the same
problems you’d expect oh we need more
teachers or the the standards are
outdated the books are outdated now we
just we just need more culture we need a
better energy but none of those really
felt like the fundamental issue because
something wasn’t right something wasn’t
hidden for me so my second year I
actually figured out I think I had a
moment and it’s when I met Natasha my
second year I was teaching world history
10th grade class and in Georgia like in
many states world history is actually a
required course in order to graduate and
so was second semester and every
semester you get a you know new set of
kids Natasha was in my fourth period
class on my bday 38 kids in the
classroom it was it was really a show I
must say but Natasha was not like every
other student in the class she wasn’t a
tenth grader
she was actually a twelfth grader she
was 18 year old and she had failed world
history the first time around and so it
was spring time her last semester and
she needed to pass my class in order to
graduate so here she is start of the
semester really motivated I’m motivated
we start off well she’s doing okay but
it was quickly became clear to me that
Natasha like a lot of her peers and
anybody who’s taught in underserved
schools know this is actually a
widespread issue that she was well
behind academically you know her reading
and writing were probably actually
closer to her fifth or a sixth grade
level her math is probably in that area
as well and my course is a lot based on
writing and reading and all that kind of
stuff that she do in world history and
so over the course of the semester
Natasha’s Breanna struggle
fast-forward we’re a week away from when
I have to submit grades and I look up
and at my grade book in the Tosh’s
grades at a 55 now in Georgia or in
Fulton County I should say you need a
70% in order to pass a class at that
moment I knew there was no statistical
way than Natasha could pass this class
and I offered her tutorial I’d offer
extra credit recovery packets extra
tests these are all things that in
underserved schools were oftentimes
almost forced to do by our principals
because our students are struggling
being so behind and yet here Natasha is
at 18 and she’s got a 55 so this is
where I was put into a dilemma that also
sparked some inspiration I was sitting
there and I was deciding do I pass a
Natasha or do I fail her now I bet
everybody’s sitting here and your gut
reaction was the same exact as mine
Natasha earned a 55 it’s unfortunate
she could have made better choices she
could have taken advantage of extra
credit of recovery of tutorial and so
Natasha
earned a 55 and I need to stand on the
integrity of the class stand on the
principle of the class and all the
students who actually put in a lot of
work and got passing grades and so
Natasha should earn her failing grade I
think viscerally that just feels like
the right thing because she she’s you
know facing the consequences of her
actions however at this point in time I
decided to take a step back and I said
to myself okay well let’s look at the
other side of the coin what happens if I
fail natasha natashas 18 she comes from
a school where a lot of kids drop out
most don’t actually finish and so if I
fail Natasha she’s not going to graduate
yeah maybe she’ll come back in the
summer or in the fall to get that one
credit back up but the likelihood of
that actually happening is really slim
and so to me was is Natasha responsible
completely let me definitely bear some
responsibility but it all her fault
but she ended up in world history again
spring semester senior year and her life
trajectory could be altered because of
the fact that she couldn’t master my
world history class where we’re talking
about stuff that happened 5,000 years
ago that honestly is not that relevant
to her not that relevant to me but here
we are and so if I fail her I’m gonna
drastically alter her life prospects
without a high school diploma in our
country and in our world right now it’s
really really challenging you really do
not have a ton of options and so I asked
what would you do you know do you pass
her and you know you know honestly save
her trajectory save her prospects
or do you fail her and stand on
principle because if you stand on
principle you’re not actually gonna fix
the system in that moment and that’s
when it hit me why am I in this scenario
why is a teacher am i sitting there
having to face this ethical dilemma that
you know in all truthfulness came up
many times for me and many other
teachers I knew that’s kind of beauty of
teaching America’s you get to know a lot
of teachers at different schools and we
all face very similar problems and I was
seeing myself why why is this happening
I feel like I’m in the dark I feel like
there’s no guiding principle I don’t
know what the education system is meant
to be doing and so I don’t know how to
make this decision for Natasha and
that’s where the question came to me
what is the goal of Education after all
can anybody agree upon it dude does
anybody have an agreed-upon definition
of education why we do it in the first
place what’s the vision where are we
going with this and now that I’ve worked
in education and policy and the
nonprofit sector and in the classroom I
realized nobody really knows if you
asked everybody in this room and
everybody in education you would get
tons of different answers some people
today say the point of Education is to
make everybody college and career-ready
you know other people say it’s to
develop a love of learning or a globally
competitive workforce or to earn a
college degree you go to college or to
get a job even you know all these things
depend on who you ask so if we think
about Natasha you know in that scenario
if it’s college and career-ready well
what does that mean I mean she’s
definitely not college ready from a
skill standpoint she could be career
ready depending on what’s career talking
about but we don’t really know because
no one’s told us no one’s decided no
one’s define what that means if it’s
develop a love of learning how do you
measure that how do you teach that you
know globally competitive workforce that
could be something completely different
and so as teachers and as educators
there is no North Star there is no
guiding light there is no purpose
there’s no clearly defined goal and
that’s the problem so why is it so
difficult why is this question and this
system so intractable at this point I
think it comes down to two things the
first one’s fairly obvious the education
system as we know it was started in the
Industrial Revolution and it was not
meant for what it is today
it was originally meant for routine to
teach people basic skills they can
work in factories or in the
administrative State and it’s just been
growing and growing and growing for the
last hundred years and we’ve just been
trying to fix it and force everything
that’s a new into it the second is
actually a deeper question education is
how we prepare ourselves it’s how we
prepare our children and so another
reason why it’s so challenging for us to
agree on the goal is because deciding
what education is about is actually
deciding what our purpose of our lives
should be you know the purpose of our
lives is to be productive then yeah
education should probably be about
routine and rigidity and and you know
just doing the same thing over and over
and so you produce as much as you
possibly can
if it’s about personal exploration then
it should be about discovery it should
be about challenging ourselves you know
exploring each other and collaborating
and all of that if it’s about sitting in
front of screens and phones and TVs all
day then maybe it should just be that
maybe we should start earlier as you can
see some people think we’re headed in
that direction already and since we have
no agreed-upon goal we’ve ended up in a
credential driven system so here’s a
short graph from the Georgia Public
Policy Institute it’s a research study
done a few years ago that honestly tells
us a lot that we already know by 2020 65
percent of all jobs will require a cop
some college or more and then 88 percent
of all jobs will require at least a high
school diploma so if Natasha doesn’t
gather diploma she’s pretty much out of
luck I mean there’s very very few job
prospects and honestly they’re probably
jobs that aren’t going to lead to
sustained abilities to stability to a
feeling of prosperity and so we’re in
this credential driven society where a
lot of times it doesn’t even matter what
you studied for any seniors in the room
you probably look at the jobs right now
and it just says bachelor’s degree
required and maybe it lists 10 majors
but they don’t really care what you
studied they just care can you learn are
you capable are you resourceful but we
have what now has turned into a really
elaborate filtering system you know if
Natasha gets that high school diploma it
does not reflect her skillset by any
means as I told you she’s on a fifth or
sixth grade reading and writing level
but she’s got the piece of paper so does
it really matter now I’d ask people to
imagine if we’re in a credential driven
system what does success look like what
the ideal credential different system
look like is it really everybody has a
high school diploma and a bachelor’s
degree I think it takes everybody in
this room probably less than five
seconds to realize that that reality
would be horrific it wouldn’t work
everybody would be overqualified for all
the jobs that the majority of our
economy is based off of and nobody would
want to do them we’re honestly not far
from that right now and so this can’t be
the way this should be when people look
at the education system from the highest
level and that’s what we really need to
start thinking about because we need to
find solutions that scale
a lot of people in the state and federal
policy levels honestly they look at it
like it’s a factory now when you hear
that you probably think it’s very
negative and most of times when people
talk about factories and education they
mean it in a very negative way but I
would argue that a factory isn’t a bad
analogy because when you think of a
massive you know the national scale we
need it to be as consistent as efficient
as a factory we need it to be repeatable
and consistent where everybody we turn
out competent after competent after
competent person who can really push our
society forward the problem with this
analogy is that we are so far from being
a factory we are nowhere close to this
efficiency and this takes the humanity
out of learning what we’re actually a
lot closer to is something like this if
you guys are familiar with like the Rube
Goldberg concept it’s basically you just
put a bunch of random stuff together and
they all do something that essentially
pushes out something really simple so in
this one we’ve got a clock that you know
sets off a firework that hits a bird or
something and then eventually it just
wipes the guy’s face with a napkin like
that’s the goal of it that’s what
education is right now every year it’s
something different
oh this year it’s standards or its class
sizes or its stem or its you know the
the size of the school or we need you
know more of this type of school it’s
all these little tweaks that we think
are getting at the fundamental problem
and it’s just oh it’s just this one
tweak and once we do that then then
we’re good it’ll start turning out more
kids who are ready I’m not here to argue
that that is so far from the truth and
that in reality we’re much more like a
ship we’re a ship in the dead of night
drifting in the dark there’s no compass
there’s no destination there’s no stars
to guide us
and every year we’re just making these
slight course corrections thinking that
we’re going in the right direction but
we’re really just drifting and we have
no direction and so what I want to do is
lay out a few fundamental truths about
education so that we can stop talking
about them and start getting past that
and think differently about the
educational experience because we spend
most of our time in the education policy
world argue about the same things so the
first truth that I’ve recognized and
everybody needs to come to grips with is
we will never have an excellent teacher
in every single classroom it’s a fact
it’s a physical reality there is no
possible way to have an excellent
teacher in every classroom there are 3.1
million teachers in America there has
never been a 3.1 million person
workforce where everybody is excellent
so we need to just accept that fact and
move on number two things like charter
schools and school choice should be
looked at as iterations not as
innovations and I’m not against charter
schools at all I think we need R&D and
education you know education is unique
in that are our users or us or our
products and so we need to be thinking
about new ways to do this experience and
charter schools can do that but the vast
majority of them and there are a few
that really pushed the boundaries and
challenged the status quo but the vast
majority are really just changing and
tweaking little things oh this charter
school has tiny classes or this school
has a longer school day where this
school only serves this type of student
again those are tweaks on the existing
failing model in my opinion and things
like school choice the idea where
students can opt into the lottery for
any school in their city that relies on
a lot of middle class assumptions that
students have the wherewithal the
internet access to get into a lottery
and that they have the transportation
actually consistently take advantage of
that school choice and that’s why you
see a lot of cities who have school
choice they show clear gains in the in
the short term but then when you dig
deeper into the data the safe students
are still struggling
lastly beyond the fundamentals of
reading writing math critical thinking a
hard skills approach to education will
never keep up so whether it’s cursive or
CAD or coding these skills always become
obsolete just at the time where we get
almost okay at doing them take coding
for example that’s like the big skill
today everybody needs to learn coding
but as you guys probably are
we have these coding boot camps out
there right 12 to 14 week programs to
teach anybody how to code as long as you
have a high school diploma so you’re
telling me we can teach anybody with a
high school diploma how to code in 12
weeks why would we spend four to eight
years in the k-12 system teaching them
that why not make that part of corporate
responsibility to train their own
workers they do that anyways the
majority of and for the students the
room majority of what you’re gonna do in
your job you learn on the job I never
trained to be an executive director or a
teacher really even most of my
colleagues and my friends didn’t train
to be the position they’re doing today
they’re just resourceful capable
collaborative critical thinkers so
focusing on hard skills and trying to
force them into the educational
experience will will never keep up okay
so what can we do because I think in our
guts we all know that education can be
so much more it can be a place where
intellectual curiosity is fostered every
single day because we’ve all experienced
that moment right now we think about
engineering the environment we focused
on the school building we focus on the
teacher the technology how many kids are
in the classroom and this is engineering
the environment and these are all
factors that influence education but
they’re not fundamental to the success
and I know that because I had different
teachers than you I wasn’t a different
school building you I had different
standards into our different technology
than you my classes were a different
size than you and yet we’re all here
we’re all in this room achieving some
level of success so it can’t be these
things that are fundamental what we need
to do is intent instead get into the
mind of a student really think about the
student experience how are they
experiencing these different concepts
how are they relating them how can we
get kids inspired instead of keeping
them in line how can we instead of
probably promoting compliance promote
creativity and collaboration how can we
get students in focus and in flow
instead of in routine we need to start
thinking about how students experience
this so we develop their skills and
their individuality together and we need
to start thinking about it at scale
because until we do more and more
students and educators like myself my
colleagues Natasha will be in these
terrible scenarios where we have no
guiding light we have no idea where
we’re going and we make these decisions
that end up just crippling our society
year after year after you
and will continue to be teaching in the
dark thank you
you
Please follow and like us: