
[Music]
Imagine a lush valley valley
It is in his day in their half furrowed by
a rushing river and this valley and these
forests are the place where he was born a
young man who since childhood has played in
torrents and it has also been in
every tree in the forest
this young man now works in the
River is fortunate to work where
He was born and has been upheld by the
universe of nature that he
comforts identifies this young man has
basically an idea that can
go there and that unlike
other young contiguous towns
he may be working to form a
family there does accompany
adventurous tourists who go down well in
dugout or on rubber rafts
down the river to enjoy or
have strong experiences that the city
comforted them
Well in this experience it is
worried is concerned that there
a threat in this valley
the government wants to build a dam
that would end the valley not only
would end part of the forest and with that
torrent of water down the river
also end those
activities based on that enjoyment
of the nature
Well this reality
we’re seeing who also for
a threat he has a feeling
important is that his grandmother has
He lived like their ancestors
in the same town every afternoon or many
evenings of the week approaches the
cemetery and the cemetery sits
on the stones and tells her
husband who died
what happened during
Day tells that how it is
her granddaughter behaving also tells
that is what has happened in the world or
Today he has seen on television or
has in the market is accumulating
for years he has accumulated these
feeling those emotions
s that accumulated in memory
stones and for him that she there and
that environment and voice are you very
rewarding feels tied to his
past all the people with whom
he lived in his childhood but now
who knows the threat that knows the
Reservoir flooding that will end
cemetery is worried and increasingly
which goes to the cemetery is crestfallen
it seems not but what you feel
more importantly this young
because not only is concerned that
end its work and an end to
a portion of that nature is already
form a very strong feeling that your
story of his family history
the story of her mother and her
grandmother are involved in this
the territory many times we are not
aware of the role played
us and only when we need when
we lack that reference a landscape
It is when we notice that it has a lot
importance to us
If you are always and if you do not have a
they usually live without threat
we figure out
This maybe yes to feeling the
emotion is more important to him
I’ll tell you
this is not only something imagined this
It occurs and is inspired by a real case
which is the reservoir is a biscarrués
reservoir that takes 30 years by
government trying to do and there
social and intellectual resistance very
important so that there is no such
reservoir
Well this circumstance is that
somehow motivated the birth of
the foundation new water culture them
explained how they organized the
biscarrués neighbors and attended the
University and coincided with two
teachers who had an involvement
social very strong
Pedro Rojo and Javier economist
gil Martínez is hydrogeologist
Certainly the creator of the phrase
new water culture that we
it means something new but
It is a form a different perspective
find water the river as a way
which not only sees it as an input
economic as an element
produce something good for these two
teachers perform one with a
van trips to the towns where they
They have been asked to tell because it is not
necessary that the reservoir is made and
destroy
the link between nature and
people who live it as something
identitario they called van
the conference
before a little comic is true but
the birth of a symbiosis between
social movements need
They have an intuition and need
the reason for the argument that intuition
and on the other hand experts or teachers
Technical committed to society
who they believe that their role does not end
publish in journals of impact or
do great research
but international
they also have to bring something to the
society in which they live
Well this symbiosis is that of
Somehow it focused on these
in one conference approaches
an old to them and told them you do not
You know how important you are
doing so far
I knew this was unfair but
now I know I’m right
this is the key
the important thing is that it gives arguments
for something that you know intuitively
but finds it difficult to express
in reasoning and do not have
scientific knowledge to
discuss with the government trying them
a work that clearly is
arbitrary
This is the birth of this community
critical knowledge because I say
because community because it is a
network in which there are experts or teachers
in economics in hydrogeology
sociology ecology geography
even jurists ye
on the other hand it is critical because it has
a social commitment to those
movements need that
argument to answer
This is an arbitrary decisions
critical knowledge and community
What is the fate
what we intend to
fundamentally society
Deliberative deliberative democracy
in which eliminate and
the voter does not just depositing a vote
and thereby ends its legitimacy
intervention has no legitimacy
to be continuous and must be
continuous so that the government does
to be involved in decisions and
society is able to
intervene to respond to give his
opinion and receive a different way
decision in a participatory manner
Well this is a community
critical knowledge and what
happens or arises in that idea but when
ceases to be something local to become
something which national something is what
we are all involved because when
the challenge is also national because
there is no consciousness without problem
my experience or experience
we have the foundation is that if
there is a problem that moves us
there is also no awareness desire
to know and this is what happens to the
national hydrological plan plan
2001 National Water intended
a transfer to Barcelona and other
part towards Murcia and Almeria
ALMERIA reached even with very little
amount but reached almería
hypothetically because in reality
according to scientific studies
They made in this group of knowledge
only every eight years come something
ALMERIA but also
the costs will be incredible were
totally disproportionate
but all this was forming a
very interesting so happened that
each of us contributed
information knowledge but with a
challenge not only we were giving me
as a lawyer was not giving a
information that was exclusively
for lawyers , judges or
notaries or other
we were giving professional
information that had to converge
with other geographical knowledge
ecological and happened that
professional ecology
I was also giving that information
for me to understand
This meant that we had a job
inward forming us between
We then also facilitáramos
thus the possibility through
conferences and through reports
spread in society but not
Society in general terms that
It was open but obviously
movements that had a
interest in knowing what were the
attending them reasons this is what
somehow blew this this
movement and make the whole community
Spanish science had a
knowledge unanimity which is
water experts on the transfer
ebro
It was nonsense said in a nutshell
It is completely one but it happened
because how could one go wrong
government with a project many thousands
EUR million
Very simple powers
Typical of the construction of the
oligarchies of irrigators
hydropower were impressive and
actually winning were those
powers and the government was caught
by those powers was a self
and it made clear that solutions
They were adopted from the beginning
our debate was you have a
As we have problems we
but that problem have not seen the
possibilities to fix
then it happens have not done a study
alternatives
we did a study of
alternatives and present it to the
European Commission European Commission
He made an international technical discussion
for Commission officials
so they had certainty about what
position had to have and we were
by scientists of all
Spain from different universities
connected via conference and
and researchers across states
States argued that this was
sustainable in the debate was very
interesting because I revealed the
insufficient grounding of
government criteria especially
the issue of environmental flows of
ebro because someone has of you have
that surely heard that
Water is lost at sea
completely false false water when
It reaches the sea serves many functions
ecosystem of the things we serve us
for example because the beaches
erodes hour
Because the waters do not carry
follow and that does not feed the sand
beaches but it is also there
other elements such as the
fisheries fisheries live
mainly nutrients
carry water
and moreover in places like
ebro delta where there is a mixture
between salt water and fresh water that
produce only very delicate system
because they have the problem that the
Insufficient force water is exhausted
ecosystem
then how come the water has its
role in the discourse around the
It river and sea is such
issues was what was the subject of that
debate and that debate got the
Commission delayed because he was in
against which financed 35
percent to 7 billion euros
that this work was important because
there were many demonstrations
manifestations and even 300 or 400
thousand people and it led to a delay
important process and moreover
that political parties
in the end they entered in their programs
if you plan to repeal ebro
As you know there were elections 2003 2004
and in 2004 the transfer of the repealed
ebro out the possibility there
continue working for the foundation of
follow that critical knowledge continue
fulfilling a social function
no no because what matters is not the
success
think is success is
overrated because it is misleading
Note that even think
the history
Think for a moment what the
Christian paradigm that we
crucifixion
That is a success because the same thing happens in
Kafka literature or
Gandín policy in the 30s
success is not important what
important is that we
building a knowledge network
critical and critical that knowledge
whatever it strengthens citizenship
to achieve deliberative democracy
a democracy where they can discuss
all elements can contrast
arguments and we can decide about it
not a paternalistic society in which
decide for us
This is the key by which we are
trying to create that society
thank you very much
[Applause]
Imagine a lush valley valley
It is in his day in their half furrowed by
a rushing river and this valley and these
forests are the place where he was born a
young man who since childhood has played in
torrents and it has also been in
every tree in the forest
this young man now works in the
River is fortunate to work where
He was born and has been upheld by the
universe of nature that he
comforts identifies this young man has
basically an idea that can
go there and that unlike
other young contiguous towns
he may be working to form a
family there does accompany
adventurous tourists who go down well in
dugout or on rubber rafts
down the river to enjoy or
have strong experiences that the city
comforted them
Well in this experience it is
worried is concerned that there
a threat in this valley
the government wants to build a dam
that would end the valley not only
would end part of the forest and with that
torrent of water down the river
also end those
activities based on that enjoyment
of the nature
Well this reality
we’re seeing who also for
a threat he has a feeling
important is that his grandmother has
He lived like their ancestors
in the same town every afternoon or many
evenings of the week approaches the
cemetery and the cemetery sits
on the stones and tells her
husband who died
what happened during
Day tells that how it is
her granddaughter behaving also tells
that is what has happened in the world or
Today he has seen on television or
has in the market is accumulating
for years he has accumulated these
feeling those emotions
s that accumulated in memory
stones and for him that she there and
that environment and voice are you very
rewarding feels tied to his
past all the people with whom
he lived in his childhood but now
who knows the threat that knows the
Reservoir flooding that will end
cemetery is worried and increasingly
which goes to the cemetery is crestfallen
it seems not but what you feel
more importantly this young
because not only is concerned that
end its work and an end to
a portion of that nature is already
form a very strong feeling that your
story of his family history
the story of her mother and her
grandmother are involved in this
the territory many times we are not
aware of the role played
us and only when we need when
we lack that reference a landscape
It is when we notice that it has a lot
importance to us
If you are always and if you do not have a
they usually live without threat
we figure out
This maybe yes to feeling the
emotion is more important to him
I’ll tell you
this is not only something imagined this
It occurs and is inspired by a real case
which is the reservoir is a biscarrués
reservoir that takes 30 years by
government trying to do and there
social and intellectual resistance very
important so that there is no such
reservoir
Well this circumstance is that
somehow motivated the birth of
the foundation new water culture them
explained how they organized the
biscarrués neighbors and attended the
University and coincided with two
teachers who had an involvement
social very strong
Pedro Rojo and Javier economist
gil Martínez is hydrogeologist
Certainly the creator of the phrase
new water culture that we
it means something new but
It is a form a different perspective
find water the river as a way
which not only sees it as an input
economic as an element
produce something good for these two
teachers perform one with a
van trips to the towns where they
They have been asked to tell because it is not
necessary that the reservoir is made and
destroy
the link between nature and
people who live it as something
identitario they called van
the conference
before a little comic is true but
the birth of a symbiosis between
social movements need
They have an intuition and need
the reason for the argument that intuition
and on the other hand experts or teachers
Technical committed to society
who they believe that their role does not end
publish in journals of impact or
do great research
but international
they also have to bring something to the
society in which they live
Well this symbiosis is that of
Somehow it focused on these
in one conference approaches
an old to them and told them you do not
You know how important you are
doing so far
I knew this was unfair but
now I know I’m right
this is the key
the important thing is that it gives arguments
for something that you know intuitively
but finds it difficult to express
in reasoning and do not have
scientific knowledge to
discuss with the government trying them
a work that clearly is
arbitrary
This is the birth of this community
critical knowledge because I say
because community because it is a
network in which there are experts or teachers
in economics in hydrogeology
sociology ecology geography
even jurists ye
on the other hand it is critical because it has
a social commitment to those
movements need that
argument to answer
This is an arbitrary decisions
critical knowledge and community
What is the fate
what we intend to
fundamentally society
Deliberative deliberative democracy
in which eliminate and
the voter does not just depositing a vote
and thereby ends its legitimacy
intervention has no legitimacy
to be continuous and must be
continuous so that the government does
to be involved in decisions and
society is able to
intervene to respond to give his
opinion and receive a different way
decision in a participatory manner
Well this is a community
critical knowledge and what
happens or arises in that idea but when
ceases to be something local to become
something which national something is what
we are all involved because when
the challenge is also national because
there is no consciousness without problem
my experience or experience
we have the foundation is that if
there is a problem that moves us
there is also no awareness desire
to know and this is what happens to the
national hydrological plan plan
2001 National Water intended
a transfer to Barcelona and other
part towards Murcia and Almeria
ALMERIA reached even with very little
amount but reached almería
hypothetically because in reality
according to scientific studies
They made in this group of knowledge
only every eight years come something
ALMERIA but also
the costs will be incredible were
totally disproportionate
but all this was forming a
very interesting so happened that
each of us contributed
information knowledge but with a
challenge not only we were giving me
as a lawyer was not giving a
information that was exclusively
for lawyers , judges or
notaries or other
we were giving professional
information that had to converge
with other geographical knowledge
ecological and happened that
professional ecology
I was also giving that information
for me to understand
This meant that we had a job
inward forming us between
We then also facilitáramos
thus the possibility through
conferences and through reports
spread in society but not
Society in general terms that
It was open but obviously
movements that had a
interest in knowing what were the
attending them reasons this is what
somehow blew this this
movement and make the whole community
Spanish science had a
knowledge unanimity which is
water experts on the transfer
ebro
It was nonsense said in a nutshell
It is completely one but it happened
because how could one go wrong
government with a project many thousands
EUR million
Very simple powers
Typical of the construction of the
oligarchies of irrigators
hydropower were impressive and
actually winning were those
powers and the government was caught
by those powers was a self
and it made clear that solutions
They were adopted from the beginning
our debate was you have a
As we have problems we
but that problem have not seen the
possibilities to fix
then it happens have not done a study
alternatives
we did a study of
alternatives and present it to the
European Commission European Commission
He made an international technical discussion
for Commission officials
so they had certainty about what
position had to have and we were
by scientists of all
Spain from different universities
connected via conference and
and researchers across states
States argued that this was
sustainable in the debate was very
interesting because I revealed the
insufficient grounding of
government criteria especially
the issue of environmental flows of
ebro because someone has of you have
that surely heard that
Water is lost at sea
completely false false water when
It reaches the sea serves many functions
ecosystem of the things we serve us
for example because the beaches
erodes hour
Because the waters do not carry
follow and that does not feed the sand
beaches but it is also there
other elements such as the
fisheries fisheries live
mainly nutrients
carry water
and moreover in places like
ebro delta where there is a mixture
between salt water and fresh water that
produce only very delicate system
because they have the problem that the
Insufficient force water is exhausted
ecosystem
then how come the water has its
role in the discourse around the
It river and sea is such
issues was what was the subject of that
debate and that debate got the
Commission delayed because he was in
against which financed 35
percent to 7 billion euros
that this work was important because
there were many demonstrations
manifestations and even 300 or 400
thousand people and it led to a delay
important process and moreover
that political parties
in the end they entered in their programs
if you plan to repeal ebro
As you know there were elections 2003 2004
and in 2004 the transfer of the repealed
ebro out the possibility there
continue working for the foundation of
follow that critical knowledge continue
fulfilling a social function
no no because what matters is not the
success
think is success is
overrated because it is misleading
Note that even think
the history
Think for a moment what the
Christian paradigm that we
crucifixion
That is a success because the same thing happens in
Kafka literature or
Gandín policy in the 30s
success is not important what
important is that we
building a knowledge network
critical and critical that knowledge
whatever it strengthens citizenship
to achieve deliberative democracy
a democracy where they can discuss
all elements can contrast
arguments and we can decide about it
not a paternalistic society in which
decide for us
This is the key by which we are
trying to create that society
thank you very much
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: