
[Music]
[Music]
dusty Bibles lead to dirty lives so I
left mine behind after mama died a burnt
her aprons and I broke her jars only
thing we agreed on was that tears scar
we live in a divided world most of us
live in comfortable bubbles where our
neighbors our co-workers and our friends
are as similar to us as possible
conventional wisdom has it that
differences create these divides but
what if differences could bridge these
divides I’m a singer songwriter writer
and storyteller I was supposed to be a
lawyer I am the daughter of immigrants I
went to Yale University I have a
master’s from the London School of
Economics
I was the embodiment of the American
dream for my family so when I left
Goldman Sachs to become a full-time
musician there was only one kind of
musician I could be a rock star i
grappled with stage fright and
insecurities and i strung together gigs
in back-alley bars but i couldn’t seem
to write that hit song that would
catapult me to stardom instead i was
inspired to write songs about oddballs
in history
my journey writing and performing those
songs has let me discover something
monumental about differences and
connection I’d like to ask you to take a
moment and think about the last time you
interacted with someone really different
from yourself how did it go did you
enter into the conversation wide open or
were you already judging anticipating
what the other person did or did not
have to offer regularly I get up on the
stage and I try to connect with people I
don’t know
who are potentially very different from
me my fear is always that at the end of
the song there will be silence or maybe
a perfunctory clap or two or that people
will walk out but the reason that I keep
getting back on that stage that I keep
grappling with my own stage fright and
insecurities and facing down the
expectations of my family and peers is
that sometimes in transcendent moments I
can sense in the shadows behind the
stage lights the tender bodies of my
audience
breathing with me and that sensation is
sublime the first time I felt my
audience breathed with me was the first
time I played a song about an oddball in
history Butte is about a madam at
Montana’s Dumas brothel the
longest-running bordello in American
history and when my audience breathed
with me
I learned something I never expected
differences can create connection
took my dowry – Jessie zone strip
I rented a room with a timer and a bed
saladin pencil on peeling walls each
time my bed posts dug deeper in the
floor Butte is a song about a prostitute
most of my audiences are not prostitutes
Butte is a song about suicide most
people don’t talk openly about suicide
and Butte was never gonna be a hit
single when I wrote it I was scared to
perform it I I thought my audiences
would hate it because they’d have
nothing to relate to in it but I had
this urge to put the story out into the
world so I had to muster the courage and
take the scary leap and put myself out
there not as a potential rock star but
as me with an unusual song about an
untouchable subject and when I did my
audiences responded as with no other
song I had ever written they came up to
me after concerts to tell me how much it
meant to them they bought more of my CDs
I wasn’t getting famous but I was having
the sublime and addictive experience of
touching other human beings
I wanted more so when I was inspired by
the story of another oddball I wrote
another ordinarily unsung song this one
about a sideshow performer named Todd
Robbins who ate light bulbs
[Music]
mother Sulu and Andi revealed that her
missing lightbulb was this morning’s
meal tommix and doctors therapists and
quacks none could keep Andi from metal
or glass the same thing happened my
audience is breathe with me so I wrote
more ordinarily unsung songs and each
time I performed one each time I
performed a song about a person on the
fringes of their community and
completely different from the people in
the chairs in front of me I felt that
rush of connection but I didn’t
understand what I was experiencing the
songs my audience was responding to most
were the songs where the subjects had
the least in common with them why after
performing these songs for over a decade
I have come to believe that the answer
lies in an open secret that writers
share the universal begins in the
specific the universe old that which
makes all of us human begins in the
specific details that make us
individuals so the more specifically I
could render a story or subject the more
universally it resonates with my
audience the fascinating details of my
subjects lives as different as they are
from the experiences of the listeners in
my audience tap into something
universally human in them in the case of
the song beaut I wasn’t writing about
some woman who’d fallen in love and
gotten rejected I was writing
specifically about a woman of a certain
time who chose instead of marriage to
become a prostitute and then fell in
love with the client in the case of Andi
the light philometor I wasn’t writing
about some guy who did tricks I was
writing specifically about a born
performer who could put a light bulb in
his mouth crush its thin glass with his
teeth and swallow correct crunch feel
the fly screw twist down inside crack
crunch feel it slides through twist down
inside
there is science behind this neuro
economist Paul Zak has shown that when
people are exposed to good stories the
brain hormone oxytocin the cuddle
hormone also responsible for empathy
Rises significantly our brains are wired
for story and specifics the detail that
make us different are the building
blocks of a good story cognitive
scientist Steven Pinker has pointed out
that as literacy has increased in the
world violence has declined because the
more good stories we are exposed to the
larger and more extensive grow the
circles of people that we relate to so
the specific details of who we are our
differences can allow each of us to
resonate with one another our
differences can shrink our divides okay
you say so this works for songs and
stories what about real life well my
Eureka moment about ordinarily unsung
songs led me to try out this theory
unwittingly in my real life it was 2005
I was living in New York City my
birthplace and my home when I realized I
needed time and money to write more of
these songs about oddball so I applied
to a month-long artist residency in New
York Mills Minnesota a town of 1,000
people in rural West Central outstate
Minnesota one and a half hours from the
nearest metropolitan area of Fargo North
Dakota when I was accepted I decided to
use some of my time to go on a three-day
two-night canoe camping trip and when
everyone but the board member leading
that trip dropped out it became a
three-day two-night blind date
we fell in love and I married that board
member so one year after I first set
foot into the rural American heartland I
moved from New York City to New York
Mills all at once I was the oddball at
first I used my differences as a way to
maintain the divide between my very
different neighbors and myself it got
pretty lonely so I tried a different
approach I adopted the traits of my
neighbors I learned to knit to garden to
can jam to harvest maple syrup and that
was better but I still wasn’t really
connecting you see I was trying to be
somebody else and then trying to connect
from that false or at least incomplete
version of myself which brings me back
to my songs about oddballs so in order
to cope with my extreme culture shock I
started writing a memoir about my move
from New York City to New York Mills and
in the process I remembered the lesson I
had already learned on the stage
differences can create connection I
decided to apply that theory to my real
life and embrace my differences as a way
to connect I started by writing a column
for the local newspaper about everything
in rural Minnesota that made absolutely
no sense to me
deer hunting snowmobiling the extreme
cold snowmobiling in the extreme cold
and suddenly people were coming up to me
on the street asking if I was that New
Yorker writing for the paper when I said
yes they introduced themselves we
started talking and the next time we saw
each other we talked some more I stopped
hiding my Jewish heritage from my
church-going neighbors and I invited
them to Hanukkah parties and Passover
Seder ‘s they came and then they invited
me to talk about Judaism at school and
at church
I finally began to connect with my
neighbors
only by embracing my differences I don’t
believe that differences can create
bridges in all situations but I believe
that they can be a way to start
connecting that one by one we can use
who we are
the differences that make us individuals
as a way to connect with what makes
another person who they are through our
differences we can find our shared
humanity
maybe if we approached our differences
with the intention to honor them and
even enjoy them that could be a model
for how to bridge the widening gaps in
our world maybe instead of using our
differences as walls we could use them
as windows we could learn to be
different without being divided see the
beauty there the prettiest girls
[Music]
[Music]
so I wanted to play one full-length song
for you before I left the stage and the
one that seems most appropriate is my
song hold on about dr. Bronner the maker
of dr. Bronner’s magic soap who here is
familiar with dr. Bronner’s soap all
right okay those of you who aren’t may
have seen it these are the soaps and
bottles and bars that have labels on
them with so much writing in such small
print that you can’t believe that anyone
can have that much to say about soap and
if you were to read them you were
discover that they’re not about soap at
all they’re about dr. Bronner’s
fundamental philosophy that we are all
connected or in his words we are all one
dr. Bronner came to the United States
from Germany and he started preaching
this philosophy on street corners for
which he was committed to an insane
asylum he escaped and built a natural
soap empire with the goal of spreading
the word that we are all connected
[Music]
for rabbi dr. eh Ron her making so close
family honor till the Germans went after
the Jews he came to the states and got
himself arrested for preaching too loud
that were all connected they locked him
in asylum to change his views they said
you’re not like us we don’t want to hear
your preaching don’t try to fight us
we’ve got the might of right behind us
and deep inside himself II heard a voice
say
[Music]
Oh
[Music]
electroshocks to his third escape he
Gamble’s his last 24 fare to LA in
Tinseltown he found his groove he slept
on the roof of the YMCA he’s been days
fighting forest fires to pay and nights
mix with soap in his bathtub with a
broom we thought they won’t listen to my
preaching I have so much to teach them
how can I tell them what I know I know I
can write it all down on soap
so he made labels for his soap on which
he wrote
[Music]
[Music]
to disseminate his philosophy he built a
natural soap company capitalism the
Bronner way leopard print swimsuits at
business meetings and soap labels long
enough for bathroom reading socially
responsible business with a spiritual
safe and now that everyone has dr.
Bronner’s in their neighborhood we can
all learn how to
[Music]
[Music]
[Music]
[Applause]
I invite you I invite you to become part
of the differences connect movement step
no bursts out of your comfortable
bubbles and do something extraordinary
be someone extraordinary the someone you
already are and by doing so allow
someone else to be extraordinary with
you here’s how the next time you’re with
someone different from yourself today
this week this month take the scary leap
say something true about who you are how
you feel a somewhat revealing detail
from your past step out of judgment and
see what happens it could be the
disheartening equivalent of a
perfunctory clap or to the other person
might walk out of the room or maybe
you’ll find out that the other person is
different just like you and that
sensation will be sublime
you
[Music]
[Music]
dusty Bibles lead to dirty lives so I
left mine behind after mama died a burnt
her aprons and I broke her jars only
thing we agreed on was that tears scar
we live in a divided world most of us
live in comfortable bubbles where our
neighbors our co-workers and our friends
are as similar to us as possible
conventional wisdom has it that
differences create these divides but
what if differences could bridge these
divides I’m a singer songwriter writer
and storyteller I was supposed to be a
lawyer I am the daughter of immigrants I
went to Yale University I have a
master’s from the London School of
Economics
I was the embodiment of the American
dream for my family so when I left
Goldman Sachs to become a full-time
musician there was only one kind of
musician I could be a rock star i
grappled with stage fright and
insecurities and i strung together gigs
in back-alley bars but i couldn’t seem
to write that hit song that would
catapult me to stardom instead i was
inspired to write songs about oddballs
in history
my journey writing and performing those
songs has let me discover something
monumental about differences and
connection I’d like to ask you to take a
moment and think about the last time you
interacted with someone really different
from yourself how did it go did you
enter into the conversation wide open or
were you already judging anticipating
what the other person did or did not
have to offer regularly I get up on the
stage and I try to connect with people I
don’t know
who are potentially very different from
me my fear is always that at the end of
the song there will be silence or maybe
a perfunctory clap or two or that people
will walk out but the reason that I keep
getting back on that stage that I keep
grappling with my own stage fright and
insecurities and facing down the
expectations of my family and peers is
that sometimes in transcendent moments I
can sense in the shadows behind the
stage lights the tender bodies of my
audience
breathing with me and that sensation is
sublime the first time I felt my
audience breathed with me was the first
time I played a song about an oddball in
history Butte is about a madam at
Montana’s Dumas brothel the
longest-running bordello in American
history and when my audience breathed
with me
I learned something I never expected
differences can create connection
took my dowry – Jessie zone strip
I rented a room with a timer and a bed
saladin pencil on peeling walls each
time my bed posts dug deeper in the
floor Butte is a song about a prostitute
most of my audiences are not prostitutes
Butte is a song about suicide most
people don’t talk openly about suicide
and Butte was never gonna be a hit
single when I wrote it I was scared to
perform it I I thought my audiences
would hate it because they’d have
nothing to relate to in it but I had
this urge to put the story out into the
world so I had to muster the courage and
take the scary leap and put myself out
there not as a potential rock star but
as me with an unusual song about an
untouchable subject and when I did my
audiences responded as with no other
song I had ever written they came up to
me after concerts to tell me how much it
meant to them they bought more of my CDs
I wasn’t getting famous but I was having
the sublime and addictive experience of
touching other human beings
I wanted more so when I was inspired by
the story of another oddball I wrote
another ordinarily unsung song this one
about a sideshow performer named Todd
Robbins who ate light bulbs
[Music]
mother Sulu and Andi revealed that her
missing lightbulb was this morning’s
meal tommix and doctors therapists and
quacks none could keep Andi from metal
or glass the same thing happened my
audience is breathe with me so I wrote
more ordinarily unsung songs and each
time I performed one each time I
performed a song about a person on the
fringes of their community and
completely different from the people in
the chairs in front of me I felt that
rush of connection but I didn’t
understand what I was experiencing the
songs my audience was responding to most
were the songs where the subjects had
the least in common with them why after
performing these songs for over a decade
I have come to believe that the answer
lies in an open secret that writers
share the universal begins in the
specific the universe old that which
makes all of us human begins in the
specific details that make us
individuals so the more specifically I
could render a story or subject the more
universally it resonates with my
audience the fascinating details of my
subjects lives as different as they are
from the experiences of the listeners in
my audience tap into something
universally human in them in the case of
the song beaut I wasn’t writing about
some woman who’d fallen in love and
gotten rejected I was writing
specifically about a woman of a certain
time who chose instead of marriage to
become a prostitute and then fell in
love with the client in the case of Andi
the light philometor I wasn’t writing
about some guy who did tricks I was
writing specifically about a born
performer who could put a light bulb in
his mouth crush its thin glass with his
teeth and swallow correct crunch feel
the fly screw twist down inside crack
crunch feel it slides through twist down
inside
there is science behind this neuro
economist Paul Zak has shown that when
people are exposed to good stories the
brain hormone oxytocin the cuddle
hormone also responsible for empathy
Rises significantly our brains are wired
for story and specifics the detail that
make us different are the building
blocks of a good story cognitive
scientist Steven Pinker has pointed out
that as literacy has increased in the
world violence has declined because the
more good stories we are exposed to the
larger and more extensive grow the
circles of people that we relate to so
the specific details of who we are our
differences can allow each of us to
resonate with one another our
differences can shrink our divides okay
you say so this works for songs and
stories what about real life well my
Eureka moment about ordinarily unsung
songs led me to try out this theory
unwittingly in my real life it was 2005
I was living in New York City my
birthplace and my home when I realized I
needed time and money to write more of
these songs about oddball so I applied
to a month-long artist residency in New
York Mills Minnesota a town of 1,000
people in rural West Central outstate
Minnesota one and a half hours from the
nearest metropolitan area of Fargo North
Dakota when I was accepted I decided to
use some of my time to go on a three-day
two-night canoe camping trip and when
everyone but the board member leading
that trip dropped out it became a
three-day two-night blind date
we fell in love and I married that board
member so one year after I first set
foot into the rural American heartland I
moved from New York City to New York
Mills all at once I was the oddball at
first I used my differences as a way to
maintain the divide between my very
different neighbors and myself it got
pretty lonely so I tried a different
approach I adopted the traits of my
neighbors I learned to knit to garden to
can jam to harvest maple syrup and that
was better but I still wasn’t really
connecting you see I was trying to be
somebody else and then trying to connect
from that false or at least incomplete
version of myself which brings me back
to my songs about oddballs so in order
to cope with my extreme culture shock I
started writing a memoir about my move
from New York City to New York Mills and
in the process I remembered the lesson I
had already learned on the stage
differences can create connection I
decided to apply that theory to my real
life and embrace my differences as a way
to connect I started by writing a column
for the local newspaper about everything
in rural Minnesota that made absolutely
no sense to me
deer hunting snowmobiling the extreme
cold snowmobiling in the extreme cold
and suddenly people were coming up to me
on the street asking if I was that New
Yorker writing for the paper when I said
yes they introduced themselves we
started talking and the next time we saw
each other we talked some more I stopped
hiding my Jewish heritage from my
church-going neighbors and I invited
them to Hanukkah parties and Passover
Seder ‘s they came and then they invited
me to talk about Judaism at school and
at church
I finally began to connect with my
neighbors
only by embracing my differences I don’t
believe that differences can create
bridges in all situations but I believe
that they can be a way to start
connecting that one by one we can use
who we are
the differences that make us individuals
as a way to connect with what makes
another person who they are through our
differences we can find our shared
humanity
maybe if we approached our differences
with the intention to honor them and
even enjoy them that could be a model
for how to bridge the widening gaps in
our world maybe instead of using our
differences as walls we could use them
as windows we could learn to be
different without being divided see the
beauty there the prettiest girls
[Music]
[Music]
so I wanted to play one full-length song
for you before I left the stage and the
one that seems most appropriate is my
song hold on about dr. Bronner the maker
of dr. Bronner’s magic soap who here is
familiar with dr. Bronner’s soap all
right okay those of you who aren’t may
have seen it these are the soaps and
bottles and bars that have labels on
them with so much writing in such small
print that you can’t believe that anyone
can have that much to say about soap and
if you were to read them you were
discover that they’re not about soap at
all they’re about dr. Bronner’s
fundamental philosophy that we are all
connected or in his words we are all one
dr. Bronner came to the United States
from Germany and he started preaching
this philosophy on street corners for
which he was committed to an insane
asylum he escaped and built a natural
soap empire with the goal of spreading
the word that we are all connected
[Music]
for rabbi dr. eh Ron her making so close
family honor till the Germans went after
the Jews he came to the states and got
himself arrested for preaching too loud
that were all connected they locked him
in asylum to change his views they said
you’re not like us we don’t want to hear
your preaching don’t try to fight us
we’ve got the might of right behind us
and deep inside himself II heard a voice
say
[Music]
Oh
[Music]
electroshocks to his third escape he
Gamble’s his last 24 fare to LA in
Tinseltown he found his groove he slept
on the roof of the YMCA he’s been days
fighting forest fires to pay and nights
mix with soap in his bathtub with a
broom we thought they won’t listen to my
preaching I have so much to teach them
how can I tell them what I know I know I
can write it all down on soap
so he made labels for his soap on which
he wrote
[Music]
[Music]
to disseminate his philosophy he built a
natural soap company capitalism the
Bronner way leopard print swimsuits at
business meetings and soap labels long
enough for bathroom reading socially
responsible business with a spiritual
safe and now that everyone has dr.
Bronner’s in their neighborhood we can
all learn how to
[Music]
[Music]
[Music]
[Applause]
I invite you I invite you to become part
of the differences connect movement step
no bursts out of your comfortable
bubbles and do something extraordinary
be someone extraordinary the someone you
already are and by doing so allow
someone else to be extraordinary with
you here’s how the next time you’re with
someone different from yourself today
this week this month take the scary leap
say something true about who you are how
you feel a somewhat revealing detail
from your past step out of judgment and
see what happens it could be the
disheartening equivalent of a
perfunctory clap or to the other person
might walk out of the room or maybe
you’ll find out that the other person is
different just like you and that
sensation will be sublime
you
[Music]
Please follow and like us: