Press "Enter" to skip to content

What is the future of American manhood? | Brendan Stermer | TEDxGullLake


[Music]
[Music]
you
a couple of years ago I moved away from
rural western Minnesota for the first
time to study Eastern philosophy for a
year in Seoul South Korea Seoul is a
fast-moving futuristic neon tinged mega
city everything that my hometown is not
and yet what surprised and challenged me
the most was not the language or the
food or the noise it was the behavior of
my new male friends they gave each other
massages scrubbed each other’s backs in
the bathhouse bought expensive facial
moisturizers and fashionable clothes
texted cute emojis and were dramatic and
sentimental in their displays of
affection towards lovers growing up in
rural Minnesota I always assumed that
manliness meant more or less the same
thing all around the world but involves
some combination of emotional stoicism
physical strength and an interest in
professional sports I identify as a man
but I never under these criteria
considered myself particularly manly to
be honest I never knew quite what to
make of myself I still doubt as a
teenager I played sports but I also
played the clarinet these days I write
poetry but I also love watching two guys
beat each other to a pulp in a UFC fight
the move to Korea a culture with
different expectations for male behavior
gave me permission to explore the less
conventional aspects of my masculinity
but just as I was starting to see
results from my expensive new male
skincare regimen it was time to head
home and within a few weeks of my return
I was employed at a warehouse growing a
scruffy beard and greeting my coworkers
not with a bow but a slight upward
inclination of the neck the flexibility
of manliness across cultures within
cultures and within myself was all at
once thrown into sharp relief so I did
what any philosophy major would do I
began to ruminate obsessively about
ridiculous questions that I had no idea
how to answer like for example what is
the meaning of modern
manhood how has that changed and where
is it going and is there enough room in
that concept to fit someone like me
eventually I had the idea for an online
video series called manhood and rural
America I would interview local men of
differing ages sexualities and
socioeconomic backgrounds ask them all
the same five questions about modern
manhood then juxtapose the footage last
summer I teamed up at the local public
TV station to make it happen and I want
to share a short clip from that series
with you now in this episode men
responded to the question is there
anything about yourself that some people
might consider unmanly being a single
father I think you know some some people
might consider unmanly as I’m willing to
go and play dolls with my kids we play
tea cups I mean edia parties they let
him put makeup on me they paint my
fingernails I read a lot of books and
liked it I tried to refuse fighting
wouldn’t possible I mean people do make
fun of me about that to stuff I don’t
care I guess you can say pretty much
everything about me is almost unmanly
just on the fact that I don’t have the
quote-unquote man’s body but I guess
even personalized people want me to fit
into the girl box and so they look at my
territory stiix and they try to push
them more like oh that’s more girly like
I can say that I like rom-coms like
those are funny and they’re romantic and
keeper like oh man don’t like that so
you can’t be a man
so those are just a few of the men that
I interviewed and many others responded
similarly they acknowledged that yes
there’s some part of them that might be
considered unmanly that they like me
don’t fit perfectly into the
conventional American manhood
box I did all my interviews for this
series in groups of three whenever I
would ask that question about unmanned
leanness the energy of the group would
change at first third be awkwardness and
apprehension but as the men began to
share the secret unmanly parts of
themselves their to merge this new sense
of relaxation and humor our relationship
to each other would begin to feel more
human and thankfully I found this also
holds true outside the context of an
experimental video project I’ve noticed
that when I bring the full range of my
identity to my interactions with other
men when I don’t hide my obsession with
skincare for instance or my fondness for
romantic poetry this gives other men
permission to do the same I believe that
many men conform to hyper masculine
norms not because they like them or feel
most comfortable with them but because
they’ve never been given permission to
act otherwise and so I would argue that
one of the most effective ways to bring
about a more flexible understanding of
manhood and our culture is for men to
have the courage to be themselves in the
company of other men easier said than
done I know and before I move on I want
to address a few caveats first it’s
important to acknowledge that some men
queer and transgender men in particular
may not feel safe simply being
themselves and conventionally masculine
spaces and that’s valid and secondly I
want to clarify that I do think hyper
masculinity is a legitimate gender
identity it would be mistaken to assume
that all hyper masculine men are acting
or hiding something rather my point is
that hyper masculinity should be a
choice not a social obligation a gender
identity should be a home not a prison
so where does this leave us with respect
to my central questions what is the
meaning
modern manhood how has it changed and
where is it going another way I like to
frame and explore this question is by
asking what is the role of modern men in
family and community life here’s what a
few of them and I interviewed had to say
the man role is in the families they
have to decide what they what needs to
be done in the family but as we say
right now it’s kind of a blend our
culture his ladies became more powerful
I hate to say this but we are looking
out for that so we try to stay on top
weeds so that we don’t want to let our
culture to disappear same as everyone
else I guess yeah yeah I don’t think it
matters a distinction hi there’s like no
distinction for anyone I mean like it’s
the same for everyone all of us have the
same role it does not matter at all if
you’re a man and almost any sense of
reward I think we’re getting closer to
figuring that out we’re definitely not
there but I think there are more people
who who seem to understand that but it
matters less and less
so I share that clip not because I want
to analyze these men like a sociologist
or a gender theorist but because
together they illustrate a few of the
most common ways that I have approached
this question of modern manhood in my
own life that is when I ask myself what
my role is as a man in this society I
usually respond in one of two ways
either I harken back to what manhood
used to mean or I shrug it off and
conclude that the whole idea is now
completely meaningless lately I’ve come
to see the problems with both of these
common approaches to the question of
modern manhood on the one hand I don’t
think we should just abandon the idea of
manhood or render it some sort of
cultural joke I think most humans
including men have a psychological and
emotional need for cultural traditions
that provide them with clear roles and
their society on the other hand I
acknowledge that in the past such roles
have often been narrow oppressive and
dehumanizing is there any way to
reconcile these two truths I don’t know
yet what I do know is that modern women
have begun the work of imagining and
embodying a femininity not defined by
subordination to men I believe it is our
job now as men not to leave manhood
behind but to imagine a new more
flexible modern manhood not defined by
dominance and control over women or for
that matter over any human other men
included thank you
[Applause]
you
Please follow and like us: