Press "Enter" to skip to content

A New Theory of Human Intelligence | Scott Barry Kaufman | TEDxZumbroRiver


I would like to offer you today a
broader definition of human intelligence
one that I think takes into account the
whole person both our deepest challenges
as well as our most profound strengths
I believe our standard model of
intelligence is systematically letting
far too many kids fall between the
cracks in an educational system that has
such limited notions of human potential
let me share with you two school
evaluations that I think do a nice job
illustrating this point so this one is a
middle school assessment about a quiet
but friendly and hardworking young man
who’s enrolled in a small private
Academy depending on the subject he
works at a variety of different grade
levels
his teachers report he’s a willing
participant in every facet of school and
comes fervent even obsessive about
activities of particular interest
showing superior grasp of academic
concepts in his homework class
discussions and projects he occasionally
suggest alternatives to teacher directed
assignments so that he can demonstrate
his comprehension and skill as a result
his relationships with peers older
students with mutual interests and
adults continue to improve okay now I
want to show you another school
evaluation about an eight year old boy
who was referred to a neurologist
according to this neurologist
information provided by mother and
observations in the office setting
indicate that difficulties displayed
have a multifactorial basis including
attention deficit hyperactive disorder
mild oppositional defiant disorder
generalized anxiety disorder and mild
unevenness in skill development now when
I ask you all a question raise your hand
if you thought I was talking about two
completely different children so I see
some hands here I mean would it surprise
anyone in this room to know that this
was actually the same kid Blane at
different points in this kid’s life one
when he was eight years old and one in
middle school do you think just looking
at this report by the way these are the
recommendations of this kid we have a
whole bunch of things including
counseling medication social
interventions behavioral management is
there anything in this evaluation that
would have allowed you to predict
this kid I want you to think about that
for a second in recent years a number of
very thoughtful educators clinicians
psychologists and parents have
identified the unique needs and learning
styles of a particular classification of
students called the twice exceptional
student so I want to tell you today
about this twice exceptional these twice
exceptional students well you find is
that twice exceptional students
simultaneously have exemplary strengths
as well as extraordinary challenges so
you may see the child could have
difficulty with written expression high
anxiety could become easily frustrated
difficulty with social interactions
uneven academic performance while also
having a rich vocabulary being
resourceful being curious imaginative
creative having a special talent or
interest all in a single package now
it’s estimated there are about 300,000
of these kids in this country but I
think that’s a gross underestimate for a
number of reasons for one I don’t think
we fully realized that a lot of these
challenges can be strengths in the right
context but I also think we have a
really narrow notion of strengths to
begin with so I think in order to really
find out how many these kids are form
through the cracks and really get the
best out of these students I think we
need to take an account of four see
model so when you take it into account
capacity competence commitment and
creativity importantly they’re not all
the same thing you often you do
sometimes see them all in the same
package but I think it’s really
important to differentiate them from
each other so first of all what is the
difference between capacity and
competence well here’s a chart of so
called of one of our biggest metrics of
potential IQ the IQ test most of you
heard of the IQ test it’s supposed to
forecast your ability to achieve
academically on actual competent tests
of standardized achievement and what you
see here is yeah it’s true IQ does
correlate with standardized achievement
I’m not saying that IQ is a useless
measure of human of potential and
academics but what you see here is that
about 50% of individuals are
underperforming based on their predicted
measure of potential and often
recognized 50
percent are over-performing based on
their predicted measure of human
potential that often is not made nearly
as much we need to leave much more room
in our models in school for children to
surprise us something is clearly not
complete here in our understanding of
human intelligence but if we just stop
there there’s obviously more to getting
out of seeing possibility and children
than just their academic performance
they’re kept their capacity or even
their competence we also have
commitments you see kids in special
education have so many commitments so
much values they have so many values and
passions for special interest areas for
things that they’re for making the world
a better place I think something is
deeply fought with an education system
where if a child comes to you and says
look I’d really like resources to end
violence or end bullying or to develop
my musical talents etc etc that we say
hold on we have to measure your IQ or
measure your see look at your
standardized test to see whether you’re
not each score above a certain threshold
in order to make the world a better
place I think something is deeply
followed with a system where we don’t
just immediately say great how can we
help you get there and in addition to
commitment I also see creativity as
extraordinarily important you find the
creativity often comes the most
unexpected packages so you see that you
see these kids right here these happy
engaged group of kids well these are
kids on the autism spectrum now
according to a lot of popular notions of
autism they’re not they’re not capable
of deep social interactions and bonding
but what do you find when you actually
work with kids in autism spectrum is
that they they are they crave connection
they deeply crave connection and my
colleague Matt Lerner has been designing
these improv exercises that puts them in
this kind of situation where they can be
funny with each other where they can
really bond with each other neat fun
ways and finds the instead of the social
awkwardness that you the that a lot of
people a lot of what may be referred as
neurotypical people would call social
awkwardness among people in the autism
spectrum actually it’s completely
reframed as social creativity in this
context and they are genuinely creative
in this context I don’t know about you
but I would much rather be
socially creative than socially awkward
and least have that framing so I really
do believe we need a new theory of human
intelligence one that is more holistic
and takes to account a child’s passions
personal goals as well as their ability
level because the more that we engage
and are motivated to achieve the more
that increases our actual ability and
the more the ability achieves it’s then
becomes an upward spiral more than our
engagement is greater as well and the
most important once it’s connected to a
personal passion or a dream then we can
start to realize real possible
possibility we have now I’d be remiss if
I didn’t tell you that I this is deeply
personal for me when I was a child I was
diagnosed with a learning disability
called central auditory processing
disorder and made it very difficult for
me to process information in real-time
and I was held back in third grade as a
result a lot of the kids and teachers
thought I was they took my slowness as
an indicator of being stupid and I was
kept in special education until ninth
grade when a teacher took me aside and
she said you know I see you I see your
frustration why are you still here and
she inspired me I realized I had no good
answer that question and she inspired me
to see what I was possibly what was it
was i capable of could my capability
exceed my capacity that everyone was
telling me and so I took myself out of
special education I signed up for lots
of classes I joined the school orchestra
I joined the choir by my senior year
most of my friends were in gifted
education and I wanted to be in gifted
education I went to the school
psychologist I said you know I would
love to my senior year being gifted
education and he he said well you you
look gifted you know that’s good good
start
you get your guy told him I’m getting
straight A’s I’m getting straight A’s
and all my class he said that sounds
gifted as well but I have to see if
you’re actually gifted I need a look at
your IQ score when you’re age 11 so he
pulled out my test my score at age 11
which turned out that my measured IQ at
age 11
I’ve never revealed this in a talk was
borderline mentally
intellectually impaired and he said he
took out a bell-curve and he said to
look up here on the right these are the
kids who are in your gifted class these
are all your friends basically you know
to the left here about in the center is
about average and he moved to the left
of the bell curve and said this is you
I’m sorry you don’t qualify for gifted
education I was so upset and shy at that
moment and I just remember thinking to
myself gosh at what point can my as my
achievement allowed to trump my
potential when I’m actually doing it at
what point can that Trump what was
measured as my potential I knew at that
moment that I wanted to do something to
change the system and I applied at
Carnegie Mellon University and put in a
personal statement I said look I really
want to change our metrics of human
potential and and I think far too many
people are falling between the cracks in
terms of our standard models and they
rejected me to Carnegie Mellon they said
sorry your SAT scores are not high
enough to redefine intelligence
again again I was rejected because they
were looking at my city scores potential
over what I was trying to show them
right in front of their face so I looked
at the different departments at Carnegie
Mellon to see which ones don’t look at
SAT scores and I found the Opera
Department I went in the following week
did not tell the Opera Department I was
already rejected by their University and
I said hi I just loved opera and I’d
like to audition and I sang stars from
lame as Rob sang my heart out and they
accepted me on a partial scholarship to
Carnegie Mellon University for my
singing ability apparently the
department’s don’t talk to each other
very much
I was just rejected once I got to car
you melon I I should say it’s a lovely
department no disrespect by endured a
full semester of dance classes and
ballet and acting classes I’m a terrible
actor singing class is not a bad not a
terrible singer and and I went in second
semester of freshman year to the
psychology department at Carnegie Mellon
my heart beating so fast trying to
pretend that hadn’t planning this my
whole life and I walked in to the
department and the Secretary was there
eating a bologna sandwich and I said hey
I just took a course in psychology I
loved it do you think maybe I could be a
minor in psychology it’s called foot in
the door technique you start small and
work up and she’s like whatever like no
one’s ever been this excited to be a
minor in psychology a car you know
I think she’s like just sign this paper
I remember as I was skipping back to my
door in my tights because I just come
from dance class that day I was remember
thinking to myself with this paper in my
hand my gosh this is all came down to in
life was finding a way to sign the paper
to get to that space where there was
high expectations for everyone where
everyone just saw a different aspect of
me and there was no question she all she
wanted to do was finish her bologna
sandwich she didn’t ask to say well I’m
sorry let me see what are your SAT
scores or sit down and let me have you
taken IQ tests no I was there I had
figured a strategy through my commitment
and creativity to get there and once I
was there it didn’t matter anymore what
my potential was so following semester I
went back to the same secretary I think
somehow she was still eating the same
bull and you sandwich I don’t know how
that’s possible but I said look I would
like to be a major in psychology I took
another course and it was just even
better than the first
this is the part who knew this
department would have such a good
psychology department and she said I’m
just saying these two pieces of paper
you could have whatever you want so I
changed my major to psychology and then
working my way up I graduated Phi Beta
Kappa straight A’s Carnegie Mellon got
accepted to Yale University for a ph.d
program oh thank you thank you
in 2009 I actually did graduate from
Yale with a PhD and my dissertation was
a new theory of human intelligence so
now I’ve seen through personal
experience as well as lots and lots of
research just how many kids really are
falling between the cracks I think that
if we’re ever going to get the best out
of students we need to really understand
this coexistence of ability and
disability not treat them as opposites
not have gifted education here and
special education here instead of this
false dichotomy in our school system
that we only have these two binary
characters these two binary categories I
think in order to really see the true
possibilities in all students we need to
have a theory of intelligence that is
holistic and really takes into account
appreciates the whole person thank you
so much
you
Please follow and like us: