Press "Enter" to skip to content

Shaping laws in India | Rajesh Chakrabarti | TEDxRGNUL


let’s start with this question about who
shapes laws the so obviously our first
point is first thing is legislature
legislators are supposed to make laws
sure they sign that law they debate that
law in Parliament and then it gets done
but the legislature cannot is not the
only force that makes laws so you have
got the legislature the bureaucracy
which implements the law but which is
also something that probably produces
the first draft of the law suggests the
law the cabinet obviously the final
authority of government to take the law
to its stage obviously as a major role
but what do you think of media NGOs
corporates international organisations
not to not to get away from the
political party structures which are not
necessarily either the cabinet or the
legislature themselves but probably more
politically forceful than the than the
other parts and of course judiciary so
when you look at the nine laws that we
look at and I’m going to give you a list
in a couple of minutes you’ll find that
in many of these cases the real filip
for the lawmaking came from certain
landmark judgments and it’s the
judiciary that has played a very
important role in pushing forth the
agenda of lawmaking in a particular in a
particular area so let me start off with
giving you the list of nine laws that we
were we are looking at so we looked at
the Competition Act we looked at RTI RTE
right to information and right to
education the child labour bill which as
I mentioned subsequently passed but it
was not passed at that point the
microfinance bill which came to the
table prime did not get passed at least
during that window food security act
local act Land Acquisition Act and the
criminal laws act seminal Laws Amendment
Act which is in the in the in the wake
of the nearby er episode so we looked at
these nine cases and we try to follow
the entire evolution and trajectory of
the legislation over
several years several decades you know
when you think of making a law it is a
continuing story just like history it
doesn’t necessarily have a very clear
point from which you say okay on such
and such date the journey for this law
started it’s difficult to say that
there’s not a clear break most laws that
you talked about at intense they’re
there in the in the minds of some people
going back probably to the independence
or earlier and then they slowly shape
into whatever you see coming out of the
legislature several decades down the
road so we have to make a judgment call
and say well this is what we consider is
the starting point of this movement
which ultimately led to this law subject
to that arbitrariness it is interesting
to take a look at the variability of
time that it took for some laws to come
into existence and the quickness with
which certain laws came into be so for
all of you who remember the neighbor
happy sod I would like to point out then
that the criminal laws act post that
horrendous crime that got got that took
place in less than four months
government constituted a committee went
through the entire discussion engaged
with several several women’s groups took
their feedback process the information
put it in parliament and actually in
four months time the amendment was done
now compare that to anything in this
list let’s a food security act which is
a pretty young movement I would say
right now that’s about twenty-one years
old right before it actually saw the 21
years in the pre legislative and 1.9 so
that’s two years there 23 years takes to
get there the low pal act depends on
when you want to time it from the latest
movement was about to about five years
to get to the act stage but if you go
back to the original local issue that
was some
early 70s and that period so that can
you can even call that a three decade
long four decade-long movement so
depends on what you want to call the
birth so the point of this slide is that
the range of social movements or
activism or advocacy producing actual
legislative effect can be hugely varied
it can be as short as three months it
can be as long as 25 years court
essentially and you don’t produce the
desired action desired result so the
question therefore begs is why is it
that some laws get done quickly and why
is it that some laws seem to take
forever to go anywhere it’s obviously a
very long story and there can be many
alternative ways of looking at this it’s
a it’s a it’s a multi stakeholder
multi-dimensional story so there’s no
one right way of saying okay this is the
way do you think about this this is the
prism through which you should be
looking at the question but the approach
that we take and after having run
through the standard existing political
questions political theories which did
not seem to do the job for us what we
found is we just did a very simple two
by two matrix and try to see the nature
of activism so when do activists
collaborate with government when do
activists conflict with government what
is the tune of advocacy that you follow
do you work with the government that’s
what we are calling collaborative here
and do you go straight on the warpath
and take government head-on to push your
point that’s what we are calling
conflictual so they’re red marks there
are conflictual moments what we consider
conflictual in the nature of the
movement that took place and the blue
ones are collaborative on the government
side also the reaction the openness to
engage with non elected participants
differ from case to case
so there are times when government is
more cooperative and more listening more
open to
engage in a conversation with
non-elected participants and there are
times when government is completely
closed for whatever reasons political
reasons the mood of the nation the whole
perceived legitimacy or lack thereof of
non elected people to talk on issues as
as representing a general voice whatever
may be the reason sometimes government
also becomes confrontational I wouldn’t
call it conflictual it doesn’t get into
a conflict because it is in the winners
seat anyway it’s holding the power so it
becomes confrontational and sometimes
government is cooperative now this
combination of advocacy activism styles
by the champion of the laws between
collaborative and conflict and conflict
well and the government’s attitude
cooperative with confrontational or
confrontational may actually have an
impact on the amount of time it takes
which is there in the third column here
to get the legislative agenda to include
this particular legislation that that we
are that is in question however even
there you don’t find a very clear
pattern it’s not to say that well let’s
say the microfinance bill the means of
active is almost collaborative
microfinance organizations didn’t take
to streets didn’t burn effigies didn’t
do major marches didn’t shout for
resignations of government people or
anything like that and government was by
and large cooperative even then it has
not gotten done in about 20 years of
talks so it’s not like cooperative
attitudes always produce results and
there are times when you can get the
government to capitulate let’s say the
low pal Act for example conflictual
confrontational and yet something got
done in a short period of time this is
not to try to say that this was right
and that was wrong or this is good or
this is bad I’m just trying to put down
the resulting time that it took to as a
result of the in relation to the Styles
adopted by both parties in the in the
process this puts the same story in a
in a slightly in a graphical manner the
difference and if I may go back to the
previous slide for a second
those those bullet holes that you see in
this picture that’s what what that
refers to are these external triggers as
you can see the criminal laws act and
Lokpal act had external triggers now
what do we mean by external triggers
well the near Bahia incident was an
external trigger something happens in
the environment which just produces an
effect which simply would not have taken
place through the gradual advocacy that
the call that the that the owners of
that cause pushed with the government it
just changes the rules of the game and
produces a law as quickly as in four
months time so external triggers play a
massive role in hastening accelerating
the legislative agenda but so when you
when you talk about the styles of the
two parties that and you have to be seen
in light of the external triggers so the
last thing that I’m going to stop with
here is a sense that if you are trying
to make a sense of the legislative
process of this collaborative structure
where different stakeholders come
together to make laws well it is it is
something that I called a complex
process this picture and I would ask you
to go and take a look at it later is a
famous Stacey diagram which shows that
most of the action in lawmaking happens
when the right thing to do is uncertain
and the degree of agreement between
different players is not not too much
and that’s where most of the real
politics behind lawmaking takes place
thank you very much
you
you
Please follow and like us: