Press "Enter" to skip to content

Communicating Science in the Post-Truth Era | Claire Sale | TEDxKAUST


[Music]
ladies and gentlemen I am here to sell
you a fantastic new product which will
change your life forever this amber
teething necklace is guaranteed to make
your baby more comfortable while
teething and it’s all due to the
succinyl acid which has proven
anti-inflammatory properties and it’s
all yours for the low low price of $20 a
pop the only problem it’s a lie it’s
deceit there is no scientific
peer-reviewed evidence to support the
claim that amber necklaces can reduce
teething pain but people believe it and
they’re buying the necklaces I’m a mom
and it’s a claim I’ve heard over and
over by my friends on internet mommy
groups and on blog posts written by
people who are selling them but I’ve
also spent the last 10 years working in
communication with academic and
technology groups and this overlap
between my work and my home life made me
realize how academia should be
responding to the new ways that people
are sharing scientific information it
also reminds me about this concept we’ve
been hearing about in the news the post
truth era the idea of post truth rose to
significance during the political
conversations around the truthiness
and last year’s brexit campaign in the
United Kingdom and the presidential
election in the United States it was
widely reported that the voting public
didn’t really care if the points the
politicians were making were possible or
even true
just like with the amber necklaces
people cared more about how that story
made them feel and about how that
picture fit into their worldview host
truth became such an important concept
in 2016 that the Oxford Dictionary named
it word of the year today truth feels
less relevant than ever before and I
blame the Internet
don’t get me wrong the Internet’s a
beautiful place where we can create
community and friendship and access the
entirety of human knowledge in the palm
of a hand but it’s not always serving in
our best interest where there’s a buck
to be made people will make it
especially in the case of the internet
where anonymity is obtainable whether
it’s fake news websites shared on
Facebook or marketers trying to sell us
their products or lobbyists vying for
attention for their causes there are big
powerful groups telling really
compelling stories and some are very
good at misleading us for their own
benefit say for example I believe that
there are little green men flying around
our planet in UFOs I can find all kinds
of sources to back up that claim I can
find blog posts or YouTube videos meetup
groups and all sorts of pseudoscience to
confirm my belief in the existence of
little green men and flying saucers
I might even believe that there’s a
government conspiracy to cover up the
existence of little green men and tell
myself that’s why there’s no supporting
body of peer-reviewed information on the
topic this assertion may seem ridiculous
to you and me but this is truth to a
fair number of people to combat this
kind of nonsense fact-checking website
started popping
on the internet fact-checking was
supposed to be the definitive source to
discern truth from less reliable sources
like chain mail or urban folklore ads or
ambitious politicians it was supposed to
solve the problem of people who lie in
public forums but even the credibility
of supposedly credible sources is
questioned when opinion is stronger than
truth people have been taught to
question their sources but what
constitutes a trusted source seems also
to be different from person to person
based on their culture or their
political leanings or their life
experiences the scientific method too
was designed to overcome these biases
but unfortunately it seems that some
people are valuing opinion over
scientific evidence even when the
evidence shared in peer-reviewed
journals is overwhelming let’s take for
example something more practical than
UFOs let’s talk about the public
conversation in America around climate
science the validity of human-caused
climate change has been backed by both
peer review study and a near unanimous
consensus in the scientific community a
2013 review published in ERL showed that
97% of climate scientists agree there is
a human-caused global warming trend that
kind of consensus is unheard of but
incredibly a 2015 study from Yale showed
that 30% of Americans believe something
different so if there’s near consensus
in the scientific community why is there
still a debate in the public about the
validity of climate change this is post
truth I think most of us are willing to
admit that
scientific community as a whole has been
slow to respond to the changing media
landscape by the way that’s why
fact-checking web sites became the
default on the internet rather than
peer-reviewed journal articles but the
scientific community can’t ignore the
post truth mentality if enough people
believe that climate change is a hoax
and they’re influential enough they
might be able to stop government
industry and nonprofit players from
allocating funds to climate research and
funding is what drives science to remain
relevant academia must adapt and respond
to the problems that the internet
revolution and the post truth era are
raising fundamentally the way that
scientists communicate hasn’t changed
much since the 1600s scientists are
taught to publish precise and detailed
papers in peer-reviewed journals and the
articles are aimed at informing other
scientists compounding the issue papers
published in journals are hard for non
scientists understand and they’re
generally only available to people
working at institutions which are rich
enough to afford subscriptions put
simply scientists talk to other
scientists and they leave the public out
of the loop but the Internet has
disrupted traditional media and it’s
disrupted traditional communication now
it’s time for academia to capitalize on
this disruption to combat a culture of
misinformation it is the responsibility
of universities today to rethink the
incentive structure for communication
and academia we need to create
incentives for scientists that place
more emphasis on public communication I
get it
demands
scientists time are already daunting
most of their effort is devoted to
discovery and publishing in traditional
journals and acquiring funding but
emphasizing public communication in
addition to the traditional
peer-reviewed methods when it comes to
the hiring and promoting of scientists
could have a major impact for
universities especially with regards to
improving reputation and increasing
overall funding of course the peer
review process will continue to be an
essential part of the equation but by
incentivizing scientists to share their
findings with a general public we might
just find that the impact is as great or
perhaps even greater than the
communication revolution that is already
occurring in other industries today so
assuming scientists see the opportunity
they feel the responsibility and they’re
appropriately incentivized how can we
support them as they begin their
communication with the public to bridge
the gap between scientists and the
relatively new ways that people are
getting information via the internet
universities are employing professional
communicators like me universities most
universities have communication
departments that are aimed at least in
part at translating science to the
masses but I’ll never be able to tell
your story better than you can tell it
yourself as a professional
I can help you by shaping messaging or
building communities or making beautiful
visuals to help you tell your story
better but the gist and the power will
always come directly from the source of
the message there is no better
spokesperson for your work than you I
like to remind scientists three things
as they begin communicating with the
public first the excess
Cybil if you’re serious about your
research making a real world impact
communicating about your work beyond
your network of potential collaborators
is essential traditionally this is meant
getting your work covered in the news
but you could also start by using social
media write a blog or talk about your
work on Twitter or do and ask me
anything on reddit how you choose to do
this will be deeply personal but by
making your research accessible to a
general public you’re taking the first
step it takes your conclusions out of
the scientific echo chamber and empowers
the general public to have access to
your work second be clear as scientists
you’re trained to focus on small details
but it’s your ability to explain the
overarching story of your work and your
field of science that will help you the
most so begin with the big picture the
implications of your research rather
than trying to explain your hypothesis
with conclusion or die’s our precision
the goal is to get people to buy into
you as an expert and the kind of work
that your impact can have with this in
mind you’ll want to share your message
in a way that your audience can
understand use plain English and frame
your messages in a way that is both real
and personal to your audience think
about who you’re speaking to and use
language and concepts and analogies that
they can understand and most importantly
relate it back to why your work will
benefit them I’m not suggesting you
dumbed down your science the public is
full of really smart people but remember
the goal isn’t simply to get more people
to understand what you do the goal is
also to get people to recognize the
implications of your research for
themselves and for society third
be honest don’t succumb to post truth
the post truth error will be hard on
academia but that doesn’t mean we should
abandon the scientific method it is an
enduring foundation but just because
you’re right doesn’t mean anyone will
listen a scientist you’ll get something
out of all this – communicating outside
of your scientific area will enable you
will give you perspective that enables
you to understand where your research
fits into the wider world being a
thought leader on your topic well guy
will help you guide the public
conversation of your field and for my
family
financial perspective this will support
a more favorable funding environment for
your wider research area remember
funders give money to fix issues that
they understand and funders give money
to fix issues that people are talking
about there are quite a few scientists
today who have already put these pieces
together and are pushing their research
forward through public communication let
me share with you two of them locally I
enjoy following scientists here at
couched on social media one of them
Susanne Dirk’s
is a young up-and-coming scientist who
goes by the name scientific diver on
Instagram there she shares lots of
pictures of her field work collecting
giant clams in the Red Sea
her goal is to figure out how important
the clams are to over all coral reef
health she shares beautiful pictures
relating to the process of her work and
also information of general interest
about plants and animals in the sea her
communication efforts are accessible and
clear and honest and they’re digestible
to a general public while still
maintaining scientific credibility
what’s more her social media posts
enable her to connect with people all
around
the world and her efforts are increasing
attention for her work both within her
field and for the general public sharing
the stories behind her research makes
her more credible and makes it more
likely for people to discover her
findings and want to support her work
globally climate scientist Katharine
Hayhoe is also using these principles to
make significant impact for climate
research
she’s aggregating her findings and
research findings from others in her
industry and sharing them at
high-profile events and with high-impact
media she’s found a balance between
conducting her research and
communicating about climate science with
the big picture in mind the impact is
that she’s been able to use data and
information to dispel myths circulating
with the public around climate change
she’s been covered in the New York Times
she’s met with Barack Obama and Leonardo
DiCaprio on the White House South Lawn
and she has got one heck of an online
presence and all of these efforts are
raising the profile for climate science
for the better the best part is anyone
can do what Kathryn and Suzanne are
doing this is the future of scientific
communication the democratization of
media has enabled us to communicate to
wide audiences on narrow topics but in
too many cases it’s enabling harmful
untruths to be perceived as facts today
there are more voices and communication
channels than ever before and as we saw
with the amber necklace many are really
good at distorting the truth for their
own benefit it is the responsibility of
academia today to seriously consider the
opportunities associated with a two-way
flow of information with the public and
use proven communication techniques to
get the public to believe in real
science
cynical peddlers of pseudoscience have
effectively packaged their messages in
neat believable bite-sized formats that
the public is hungry for if real science
is to prevail we must adapt
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: