Press "Enter" to skip to content

Rethinking Smart Cities | Nigel Jacob | TEDxBermuda


for the last several years the world I
think has really begun to realize that
if you want to take on the big
challenges that we face as a
civilization cities are the place to do
that cities are the place where you can
get leverage on these big problems and
really bring them down to size problems
like multi-generational poverty
crumbling infrastructure that no one
really knows how to pay for and
increasingly climate change affects
these are all big challenges that cities
are now seen as part of the potential
range of solutions that we have to bring
to bear on it and local government has
to figure out a way to deal with that so
one of the ideas that’s been put forward
in recent years it’s kind of a corporate
idea to to take cities to this next next
level is the idea of smart cities there
is no good best single definition of a
smart city it’s really the application
of technology sensors data analytics to
sort of vertical areas of concern in
cities a smart retail those kinds of
things the question with a lot of those
applications with those ideas as far as
using technology in cities is what do
you Mize for is it cost is it crime rate
so interestingly my old bus so this is
Tom Menino the former mayor of Boston
although he was considered famously to
be a Luddite I think he actually came up
with a really interesting way to answer
the question of what you optimize for
Mayor Menino got his nickname the urban
mechanic because of his really fanatical
approach to creating a people centered
approach to government and I think
that’s really the secret sauce here and
so he traded a team to implement this
idea I hope does my team it’s called the
mayor’s office of new urban mechanics
and our job is very big our job is to
invent the future of the city the good
news is since we launched new mechanics
back in 2010 this has really become a
wave a global trend of using of trainees
public oriented labs to drive innovation
in cities and what’s different about
this approach is that it’s driven by a
sense of experimentation rather than
presuming that we know the answer before
we do something let’s test it first
let’s see if it works in a kind of
scaled-down version in approach
and then scale it up once we have
success or shut it down if it doesn’t
work and there we are neutered mechanics
so the good news is my new boss our new
boss Marty Walsh our new mayor of Boston
has the same vision the same idea that
cities are great when they can do
everything they can to make its people
great so we’ve been doing this work for
a bunch of years now we’ve learned a lot
of things we’ve learned what not to do
and I want to share some of these
lessons with a few examples to give you
a sense as to how the actual will
actually play out in the world briefly
stated number one how you build is just
as important as what you build this is
really an acknowledgement of the
importance of process especially as it
relates to trying to develop new kinds
of solutions especially technological
ones in communities it’s important how
you are inclusive when you’re rolling
these things out it’s important how you
consult the public without with the
kinds of solutions that you’re that
you’re building so I’ll talk a bit about
that number to build things that people
actually want or need so this may seem
obvious to you but having worked in
government for a few years now I can
tell you that’s not what we always do we
often end up building the things that we
know how to build and so the idea here
is to let’s rethink that let’s actually
focus on what you want need and build
that for you number three using
technology to build compassion this
might seem kind of counterintuitive but
and obviously when we think of
technology usually we think about it
making things faster better cheaper more
efficient those kinds of things and
those are all good things and we need
more of that in the world but when I
think about the the real opportunity
here with technology and cities it is to
build connections between people between
different neighborhoods between
government but those the governed and
the governing so compassionate because
it really complete an important key here
when you think about technology and then
lastly it’s important that you be
prepared to challenge people’s instincts
so what this is really about is that if
we’re going to try to make the city
better we can’t only appeal to people’s
rationality in how we think about where
we should be tomorrow we also need to be
understanding and appealing to their to
the emotional side so we’ll talk about
that so number one how you build is just
as important as what you build this is
for those of you that have
you know read books on innovation or you
know go to those kinds of websites
you’ve seen this kind of thing before
this double-ended funnel thing this is
an innovation pipeline many of them out
there I do has one but because this is
ours this is the best one essentially it
is three simple stages right so it’s a
simple mental model explore experiment
and evaluate theirs although it’s simply
stated there’s actually some magic here
right when I think about it the real
value add that my team has brought to
local government into our city is the
capacity for experimentation all
innovation requires some kind of
experimentation and which means that
there might be some potential for for
failure and that’s part of part of our
team sometimes recalled that the
Department of failure I prefer the
Department of of yes so explore
experiment evaluate on the front end
this means that we spend a lot of our
time looking for good ideas challenging
problems interesting collaborators new
kinds of projects and what we’re looking
for when we talk to these startups
researchers community groups we’re
looking for three things the first is
we’re looking for the potential of
impact right we don’t want to be doing
things just for the sake of doing them
we want to be doing these kinds of
innovation products because they have
the potential we think they will have
the potential for making the city better
or people’s lives better number two
we’re looking for the capacity for these
ideas to be turned into a prototype at
all I mean there’s lots of great ideas
out in the world but they’re either many
of them rather very expensive or can
only only be done at scale so we’re
looking for things that we can test and
experiment with and then lastly we’re
looking for the potential for the the
for scaling these things up just do
these things have the potential even a
principle to go from the experimental
stage into a scale-up fits scale-up
stage so if you can find projects that
have those three criteria we move into
the experimental phase and these are
literally experiments right we’ve got
some kind of a hypothesis a guess as to
what we think will happen and then we’ll
we will run it and that often means that
if we’re trying to do something in
schools for example we might test it at
three schools before we were and see if
that works and if it does work we’ll
then scale up to whatever the next
logical step maybe a hundred schools
what have you and then ridiculous to
this to this last stage
evaluate and possibly expand phase and
here we’re looking at what did we just
learn through the experimental phase
does this thing work does it not if it
does work it becomes our job to help
those things spread if it does not work
that’s an important thing right failure
is really when I think about one of the
the inhibitors to innovation in
government and in most institutions I
would say it is that there’s just
traditionally never been the capacity to
manage failure failure is a bad thing we
didn’t govern but I think by bringing a
team that can manage that and sort of
provide protection from the negative
aspects of failure we can drive you can
create a culture of innovation which is
really what this is all about number two
build things that people want or need so
I’m always glad when you can’t read the
slide because it reinforces the point
right so this is what you had to read up
until 2014 this is the document that you
had to read if you wanted to rate to
register your school your child in the
Boston Public School System right this
is actually two pages of four right so
this is a bad experience right this is a
scary experience and what we found in
talking you know as part of that explore
phase and talking to parents in the
community the the challenge of having to
read this often encouraged or
disincentivized parents from going
through the registration process because
this is the sort of thing you look at
and you say no thank you I’ll do that
next weekend next weekend in next
weekend and then for a lot of people
they actually didn’t register at the
time their kids on time at all the
challenge with that Boston is a very
complicated school system basically as I
sort of grew up as a system to deal with
issues of inequality which are still
very much there in the city and so you
have to get your selected schools in on
time and what we found was that those
parents that had three three jobs that
were often sort of least educated were
those that were not registering that
their children for school on time so
this was an equity problem so there was
obviously something we could do about
this we changed the mental model right
this is essentially the this is a
platform that we developed a few years
ago this is sort of like the hotel’s
calm or the Expedia of schools it allows
you to you know explore different
schooling options for your
and then you know hopefully a more
elegant way what’s interesting to me
about this so the approach that we took
here is that under the covers is this
right the same system that supports this
supports this so in a lot of ways this
is just a skin deep redesign but when we
talk to the parents what he told us was
what was painful they told us that with
the pain of the experience that they
were most worried about and so he
realized what if he just dealt with the
the experiential part of it and leave
the the sort of dealing with the heavy
weight mechanics till later and so
that’s what we did we just changed the
interface and what we found after we
released this in beta back in the day we
saw a big jump in how parents were able
to register their their kids for school
so this is an important consideration
that when you’re going to try to work on
changing systems sometimes it’s enough
to just focus on the initial experience
number three
you use technology to build compassion
so back in 2009
Boston was one of the first cities to
create an app that allows you to
automatically report things into into
City Hall all right so the idea here is
called citizens connect and the idea is
that you see as it shows there some
graffiti or a pothole you took out your
phone with the app snap a photo of it
you click send it goes to City Hall City
Hall has a system there that sends you a
ticket so you can track it and when we
fix it you get a notification with that
as well but as I said the idea was about
building compassion and so we really
thought about this as an experimental
platform right so we started in 2009 and
we tried a whole bunch of different
ideas most of those that came from our
users from from the public actually we
used QR codes Americans don’t love Q
don’t don’t use QR because I don’t
understand what this why this is but not
that I love them but we tried automated
systems and there you can see citizens
connect was rebranded as Boston and one
a couple years ago but what we wanted to
try was you know does this technology
actually improve the way that the public
works with the public sector so what we
started doing by waving a new an
experiment a new experiment was for some
of the requests that came in we would
include the photo of the team that did
the fixing so you wouldn’t only get a
photo of the fixed thing whatever
happened
but you also get a picture of Mike and
Steve right the theory being that if you
as a resident if we could give you this
that the the sense that your issue is
fixed not by the faceless bureaucracy of
government or robots but by people you
know Mike and Steve or whoever they are
that it would change the way that you
thought about the experience that you
would you would think of it as an
interpersonal exchange and it turns out
that it works it does so we’ve been
studying this question with with some
research friends of ours and we found
some interesting results whenever we
included the photo of the teams the
total number of requests that people
responded with went up by 60 percent
we found the the range of things that
they were reporting potholes street
lights graffiti went up by thirty five
percent and the behavior change lasted
for quite a while so I wouldn’t complain
I wouldn’t claim rather that this is
necessarily compassion but I do claim
that this is somewhere on the continuum
of redesigning or redeveloping the
relationship between the public in the
public sector this is another moment for
for building compassion civic meetings
town halls what have you can be anything
but civil unfortunately sometimes this
is you know you often see lots of
grandstanding people standing up and
shouting and sometimes at each other so
this is this is and this stands in the
way of democracy I would say so we have
to do something about this and it’s
worth noting that this is 400 year old
technology if not older all right we can
do better so one of the things that we
began to to consider when you look at
these public meetings frequently the
people that yell the loudest know the
least about what they’re talking about
not always but often so we thought what
if and part of that issue is that people
there’s there’s a lot of there’s a lack
of knowledge frequently that’s that’s
that’s there in the room that people
don’t know what’s going on
so we had this idea that what if we
could take the the learning component
out of the room and not expect people
who have read all these you know
pamphlets beforehand but make it fun
make the learning about the civic issue
fun so the idea was to turn it into a
game right so we worked with a a group
in in Boston it’s called the engagement
game lab and they build that’s what this
is what they do they build games for
civic engagement and so we turned it
into a non laying experience where
people would go through these missions
they would get badges and points the
whole everything you expect from a game
and then the idea was to have those same
people come back together in person to
deliberate and what you see obviously we
changed the physical layout a little bit
right so we turn it into circles of
chairs as opposed to you know Stadium
seating kind of like what we have here
and what you see is a completely
different kind of behavior right people
were talking there’s no one standing up
and just stick you lating or what have
you is it’s civil behavior that we’re
seeing there what’s interesting also is
that not only in general you know that
civil behavior but we see different
groups of people being involved in the
process this is a 16 year old talking to
a table full of adults and as you can
see they’re listening our ABC knows what
he’s talking about he’s been through the
game he’s making solid points and so I
think that’s an important consideration
we’re redesigning these moments of the
civil deliberation the last one
be prepared to challenge people’s
instincts Boston in Boston density is a
is a bad word it really is which means
so Boston is a fairly small City source
forty nine square miles it’s bounded for
the most part by other cities and towns
in water so but at the same time we’re
also growing right so we’re we have
around 600 30,000 people you know in a
few years we’ll have 700,000 people
we’re not gonna give the grow out so
we’re not gonna take annex anybody and
thanks to the Boston Brahmins back in
the blue the Blue Bloods back in the day
you can’t build above a certain height
either so we’re not going out we’re not
gonna grow up so the only way the future
bustle is about
how do we use our space more
intelligently the challenge is your
average person your average residents
winner in our neighborhoods equates
density to a lower quality of life they
think of tenements that kind of thing so
that stands in our way of the future of
Boston in many ways so we decided what
if we did something about that so let’s
let’s try to find a way to give people
different sense as to what density can
be so this is what we did we built a
curb in housing unit and essentially it
is a my tiny home right so if you go
online or watch TV tiny homes small
houses these are like it’s a trend and
to build things smaller and so this is
345 square feet and the idea was that we
you take this tiny home as a
demonstration literally to kind of
change people’s assumptions their
instincts about what density means and
we drove it around the city so there we
are in come rain or come shine right
there’s some snow that wasn’t fun and we
bring people into the space as you can
see it’s elegant I think it looks pretty
nice I wouldn’t mind living there and we
as we were having people in we were
talking about what this means and the
quality of life that they could have I
don’t have numbers on this yet but I
would say that qualitatively the the
discussion were able to have indents
around density and many of our
neighborhoods has completely changed
right because people are now using this
experience as a reference point when
they’re when they’re having a dialogue
which has been credible the last thing I
want to talk about I did I did start out
the talk referring to smart cities I
will say I’m a skeptic in many ways even
though I’m often called the smart city
guy so what we started doing was
compiling what we like least in these
big companies that come to us in Boston
to try to sell us their stuff and so
we’ve come up with I think some
interesting and maybe even snarky pieces
of feedback for them I’ll let you read
those I’m not going to read all of them
for you I really wanted to highlight
number two they’re solving real people
real problems for real people you know I
think you know we referring back to the
problems they I mentioned in the very
beginning I think that we’ll only as a
society as a species will only be able
to get at those things until we are
actually solving real problems and not
theoretical problems that
can throw theoretical solutions at I
think we really need to kind of roll up
our sleeves and really understand how
changes in the built environment affects
people’s lives and focus on those things
first thanks very much
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: