Press "Enter" to skip to content

Detecting Deception: Non-Verbal Cues or a Product of Trauma? | Sarah MacDonald | TEDxUAlberta


[Music]
when my husband meets new friends and
colleagues for the first time and they
ask about me and what I do he will often
tell them that I do research and
detecting lies and that I train the
police how to interrogate people now
over the last five or six years no
matter how many times I say it’s not
interrogation it’s called investigative
interviewing the word interrogation
still sticks now the response from these
new friends and colleagues is almost
always something along the lines of well
you must not be able to get away with
anything now I don’t want to drag down
the festive and the upbeat spirit of
TEDx especially right off the bat but
I’m afraid to tell you that this whole
room is full of a bunch of liars we all
lie at least once or twice a day in fact
research has shown that 60% of adults
cannot have one conversation without
lying at least once this means that in
one day you could be lied to up to 200
times we lie most frequently about our
thoughts our feelings our attitudes and
our preferences sometimes we lie to
influence how other people perceive us
to save face or to just avoid hurting
someone’s feelings
lies even oil the wheels of social
interaction now not to pick on my
husband again but tomorrow he might tell
me that my talk today was the most
interesting most engaging speech he’s
ever heard but if this is untrue and he
was actually bored to tears I might not
really want to know that but people lie
for much more serious reasons as well
such as to hide transgressions these
lies like denying involvement in
criminal activity can have very serious
consequence
is for the liar if they’re discovered
now as psychologists we call these
high-stakes lies and we’ve been
interested in detecting this kind of
insidious deception for decades there’s
this underlying assumption that the act
of being deceptive produces this
physiological change compared with
telling the truth the theoretical
argument is that lying is more difficult
so it’s very cognitively demanding it
produces arousal meaning that the liar
experiences feelings like guilt fear and
excitement and the liar may attempt to
control his or her behavior in order to
appear credible so it’s these three
factors that are argued to lead to the
differences in the way that we speak and
the way in which we behave when we’re
telling a lie now I bet you all think
you have a pretty good idea of what a
liar looks like right fidgety avoiding
eye contact maybe nervously tapping a
pen or shaking one’s foot what about
when someone is nodding their head yes
but saying something along the lines of
well I didn’t have a sexual relationship
with that person
are these behaviors indicators of
deception well if you think that they
are and I can see some heads nodding
then you’re certainly not alone
seventy-two percent of people worldwide
think that avoiding eye contact is the
most presumed sign of lying but it turns
out that there are actually very few
behavioral cues associated with lying
research tells us that there’s really
only three nodding foot in leg movements
and illustrator use so just using our
hands to supplement whatever it is that
we’re saying the most reliable verbal
cue is voiced pitch
studies tell us that Liars tend to speak
in a higher pitched voice compared to
truth tellers but despite what the
research tells us that there’s few
behavioral cues related to deception
professionals all over the world truly
believe that nonverbal behavior and
emotional expressions are directly
related to someone’s truthfulness now
let’s take an extremely consequential
situation where lie detection gets
played out in a very high stakes context
so part of my job is to conduct forensic
interviews with victims of sexual
assault so police detectives will ask me
to conduct an interview for their file
for a variety of different reasons my
goal is to obtain as much accurate
information as possible and to find out
the truth of what happened so that the
investigation has the best chance of
success so when a victim tells me about
being horrifically assaulted but she’s
doing so with a smile on her face does
that mean that she’s lying what about
when a victim is telling me about being
assaulted by someone that she knows and
trusts but she can’t recall certain
details details that I think are really
important and ones that maybe anybody
would remember but she can’t does that
mean that she’s making it up and that
she’s lying
what about when someone is recalling a
gruesome crime but showing no mo
expression so they’re recalling the
event with a completely flat effect are
they lying the answer to all of the
above is no people who have gone through
a traumatic event often do not react the
same way that they would in a normal
situation the problem is that this can
often appear to be deceitful trauma
changes the way that our brain works the
part of our brain that is responsible
for decision-making judgment and
executive functioning known as the
prefrontal cortex is often completely
impaired the part of our brain
responsible for language production
known as the Broca’s area is also often
impaired the hippocampus which is
responsible for transferring short-term
memories into long-term memory is also
not working properly so to me and my law
enforcement colleagues who really
understand memory many of the seemingly
deceptive behaviors actually make sense
and we understand them as a product of
trauma but to others who maybe don’t
have a comprehensive knowledge of how
trauma affects the brain these behaviors
might look like lying a victim who
laughs while telling me about her his or
her assault well this can be explained
by using what we know about neuroscience
I understand why a victim might be able
to recall every single detail about a
particular smell or being able to tell
me that there were exactly 17 tiles in
the ceiling but at the same time can’t
give me any information about what the
perpetrator looked like during trauma
your brain has zero ability to control
what it pays attention to our memory
does not work like a video recorder
there’s no rhyme or reason to what gets
encoded into our memory and what doesn’t
traumatic events are often able to be
recalled
a very sensory level meaning that things
like tastes smells and sounds might be
able to be recalled in amazing detail
but perhaps information like visual
details well that could be a struggle
trauma and memory are complex and the
behavioral outputs often present much
like behaviors that are thought to be
associated with lying the problem though
is that at many different stages at the
criminal justice system all over the
world
victims credibility is being assessed
based on behaviors that are not
supported by science and what does this
mean well at the end of the day it could
mean that once a case goes to trial a
judge and our jury relies on behaviors
to determine the victims credibility and
decides that they’re not believable and
then in turn the perpetrator is never
convicted even if he or she is actually
guilty so please be very cautious in
your endeavors to detect lies do not
believe what you see on TV
critically question the glossy
commercialized articles that you see all
over the internet promising you top tips
on how to become a human lie detector
verbal and nonverbal behavior should not
be used in isolation to determine
someone’s credibility but perhaps could
be used as a tool to identify topics
that need to be probed and investigated
further there is indeed no Pinocchio’s
nose thank you
[Applause]
[Music]
Please follow and like us: