
I want you to imagine I want you to
imagine you are Keith a 23 year old
homeless patient of mine
your right leg is swollen from your
groin to your foot I your doctor I’m
telling you there is a clot in your leg
and at any moment it could fire off
explode your pulmonary blood vessels
causing instant death would you not go
to hazel t he wouldn’t he said he was
too busy now let’s say instead you were
Kelly a 32 year old homeless patients of
mine you are coughing a vivid green
sputum with blood ernest your oxygen
sacs are in your boots you are
desperately short for breath I say llamo
Nia off to hospital would you not go she
wouldn’t she didn’t think she was that
sick and she thought she take her
chances if you were to provide a health
service for one group of people it would
be homeless people their life expectancy
is terrible 44 years for rough sleepers
one in 20 of hepatitis B one in 20 of
hepatitis have HIV
one in one entry of hepatitis C one in
two of depression and one in three of
attempted suicide at some stage in their
lives and yet they don’t think they need
to take care of the health I wanted to
find out why and so decided to conduct
ethnographic research and it tried to
answer this question I honor that a
deeper question is it that homes people
are feckless and irresponsible
individuals not bothered to take care of
their health or is it that we society
are effectively responsible not bother
to create a health service fit for use
for homeless people so what did I find
out firstly I found out homeless people
didn’t use health services the way they
should they rarely attended family
doctors and other primary care
professionals they avoided psychiatrists
they didn’t keep their hospital
outpatient appointments in the last
three months I referred
forty people for new life-saving
hepatitis C treatment and twenty-six of
the mr. appointment they tend not to
take their medication and the usually
way to their symptoms are so full
menacing and overpowering that they have
no choice but to go to casualty and
being so sick when in casualty they
usually require admission in my two
local hospitals despite comprising less
than a half percent of the population
homeless people account for 7% of
emergency attendances and several 10% of
hospital bed days and then so
frustratingly when in hospital they
often leave before their treatment is
finished and so require readmission
three weeks later
no wonder doctors tear their hair out at
such ingratiates I also found out that
there is no stereotypical homeless
person and while I identified a number
of reasons why there behaved this way
not all reasons apply to every single
homeless person it explains why they as
a group behave this way firstly they
face external barriers here are some of
those barriers physical barriers
distance is a barrier if you don’t have
a car and if you can’t afford the bus
fare administrative barriers forms if
you want to keep homeless people away
from your health service get them to
fill in a form if you really don’t want
them to tend your health service make
that form as complex as possible in
Ireland to get free primary health care
you have to fill in a complex
administrative form appointments as an
administrative barrier homeless people
believe bleed chaotic lives they don’t
have Diaries they don’t they change
their phones they don’t have homeless
addresses for decades we have been
sending them appointments and for
decades they have been missing most of
those appointments and we lack the
imagination to stop sending them
appointments the never ending queue as
an administrative barrier
in casualty of to wait a long time if
you leave the cube if when you go
outside and come back in you have to go
back to the end of the cube one in two
homeless people have an addiction so if
they start getting the shakes and sweats
of withdrawal when they go out to take a
shot of heroin or a negative vodka to
get get cured there with their symptoms
when they come back in they go back to
the end of the neverending catch-22 q
rigid rules rigidly applied many
homeless people were born into spawn of
families where where rules were enforced
with stick and fist rent rigid rules
rigidly apply are like the proverbial
red rag to a bull causing them to kick
off and get and get evicted from the
service we justify these rules as
promote inappropriate behavior in effect
they exclude some of the sickest people
from our health services we need to be
more imaginative and manage challenging
behaviors in a way that produces the
appropriate behavior without breaking
down the patient relationship so these
are some of the external barriers we
have our health services created but we
have done much much worse
we have stripped homeless people of the
desire and belief to have a healthy and
fulfilling life and by doing this we
have created a series of internalized
barriers which are thoughts and feelings
that result in homeless people ignoring
their poor health here are some of those
thoughts fatalistic thoughts if you
think you’re going to die young why
bother taking care of your health if you
think you’ve reached a stage in your
life where you don’t that you have a
chance of getting a home a job a partner
children a family why seek to extend
that life and why would homeless people
think they’re going to die young because
the statistics showed they will die
young denial thoughts take Diane a
homeless patients of mine she said she
is HIV and like many patients of mine
with will who have chronic diseases
don’t
hadn’t attended four months for her met
refer to the hospital hadn’t taken her
medication for months she said I’m not
going to let that bleed and disease beat
me every time I think about are those
sugars in the back of my head I need to
survive thoughts health is very low down
in homeless people’s priorities it for
them they have to spend time begging to
get money for food for shelter and to go
get drugs and alcohol so in that
environment taking care of your health
is an actual luxury the self-blame
thoughts if enough people blame you you
start thinking it’s your own fault
takes you on your street drinker it’s
all I’m only to blame myself I know by
the way they look at me he said didn’t
go to casualty because to quote I’d only
be wasting their time he didn’t think he
was worthless the presumption of
discrimination thoughts Kevin and Anna
to page two people homeless people one
Sunday last winter were out in the
pouring rain
it was lashing rain they couldn’t keep
they couldn’t find anywhere to go so
they ended up going to casualty because
Kevin was actually getting sleepy as he
lay down there and the doctor was caught
in office closed he was semi-conscious
due to hypothermia the doctor turned to
Anna and said isn’t it disgusting the
condition he has got himself into this
stigma is continuously faced by homeless
people and because of that they tend to
avoid going to the hospital because
would you go back to service you felt
humiliated in the presumption of poor
treatment thoughts those people in that
never-ending queue they soon learned
there’s no point going back to the queue
wait till you’re so sick that you’re
brought at the head of the queue right
into the emergency room here are some of
the feelings fear fear of violence and
aggression in homelessness violence both
physical and sexual is endemic many
people avoid services where they think
there were people who are aggressive or
whoever vendetta against them fear of
authority figures and institutions
as I said before many homeless people
come from dysfunctional families one in
three homeless people were in care as
children for them parental figures don’t
offer security and safety they offer
fear and danger they fear authority
figures and institutions doctors and
hospitals shame some homeless people
feel ashamed of being homeless some feel
embarrassed by their physical appearance
or their personal hygiene and so waned
won’t wait in queues with a family
doctor at their Hospital hopelessness
and low self-esteem as you go down the
socio-economic gradient the slope gets
steeper as you approach poverty at the
edge of poverty there’s a cliff over
which Alastor story says homeless people
fall most most homeless people were born
into poverty that’s why they were so
close to the edge of that cliff and
hopelessness is inextricably linked with
poverty you don’t have to face continual
disappointment if you don’t have any
expectations and that hopelessness
contributes to the these the low
self-esteem and the fatalism the cause
of people to homeless people to ignore
their poor health so in summary we have
created a health service for you and I
the housed those of us who’ve got order
in our lives
you’ve got phones you’ve got cards
you’ve got money we’ve got time to
prioritize our health we didn’t design a
whole service that was fit for use by
homeless people who have been left
without the desire to help a healthy
life struggling for existence so what
can we do the secret to providing health
care to homeless people is to bring the
services to where they are this is
happing globally in terms of sometimes
funded by national health services
sometimes funded by charities however
though it is global it is sporadic and
it is not institutionalized as routine
health care policy in the vast majority
of countries in Ireland we have worked
with our health care
Health Service executive to provide
services to homeless people
we found a safety net in 2005 which is
responsible for developing 26 clinics
for homeless people in 19 different food
halls hostels and drop-in centers in
Dublin while supporting others in
Limerick cork and Galway safety net
founded a mobile health unit that goes
out at night time to rough sleepers
safety net worth with deduct to provide
an out of our service for homeless
people safety net responded to addiction
in homelessness by developing a
methadone treatment service and the
community benzodiazepine in alcohol
treatment service Benz a safety net
developed a mobile health screening unit
for homeless people including chest
x-ray screening because safety net had
developed such a good reputation who
work with marginalised groups safety net
was asked develop other services since
for migrants Roma and drug users as we
need service we run these services we
need doctors so in 2009 we found at the
North Dublin city GP training scheme
this is the first of its kind
internationally it is a GP training
scheme the trains GPS to work in areas
of deprivation
these young doctors are educated in
hospitals and general practices in areas
of deprivation and in their fourth year
they spend time working in homeless
services drug services migrant services
and in prison services and when I say we
I am talking about the huge amount of
people who have contributed to
development of all these services
because of their passion and desire to
provide health care to homeless people
and we know it’s working
we know safety net provides health care
to over six and a half thousand people
from marginalized populations every year
we know that homeless people have better
access to primary health care we know
homeless people stand longer time in
hospital we have developed services with
Arthur Keenan Akali called social
inclusion in hospital where she has
tried to make Hospital more welcoming so
they’re more likely to stay and we know
it’s working
we know of the 500 people we started on
methadone 80%
of them have seen their accommodation
staffers improve which included going
from streets to hostels and hostels to
accommodation and we safety net brought
those Hospital services outpatient
appointments to the hostels including
those ones for hepatitis C and of those
26 people I told you who didn’t go for
her appointments without life-saving
treatments 20 are due to start in the
next two weeks and we’re chasing down
the other six we know that the graduates
of the GP training scheme are all
working in areas of Mars of deprivation
and also with Mars and those groups and
most of the doctors working in safety
net now are graduates of that scheme so
let’s return to that question who are
the ones that are feckless and
irresponsible we all have chance at the
question of some stage in their lives do
you believe the people on the margins of
our society are there because of bad
genes are bad circumstances if you’re a
bad gene theorist of a negative
disposition then you won’t believe in
wasting your money on those degenerates
if you’re a bad gene theorist of a
positive disposition then you will give
to charity to help those less fortunate
than you if you are a bad circumstances
theorist you have to believe that the
only way to rectify this injustice is
through political action to enforce
every person’s right to have a home and
to have help it is through rights not
charity that the answer is the existence
and extent of homelessness in our
society today is our political choice we
have chosen to place our fellow citizens
in peril of losing their lives and of
their health so I have something I want
to ask of you next time a politician
calls and starts talking about the
economy I want you to take Bill
Clinton’s quote and reverse it and say
it’s not about the economy stupid it’s
about the society we live in stupid I
want a society where health is more
equitably distributed so that gradience
to poverty is now
so steep that people roll off into
homelessness I want a society that you
build a wall along their cliff to
prevent people falling into homelessness
and I want a society that if I were
waiting for that wall to be built that
we instituted health policy that
everyone has access to high-quality
health care irrespective of their
background and including those in the
margins not as a charity but as a rice
thank you very much
imagine you are Keith a 23 year old
homeless patient of mine
your right leg is swollen from your
groin to your foot I your doctor I’m
telling you there is a clot in your leg
and at any moment it could fire off
explode your pulmonary blood vessels
causing instant death would you not go
to hazel t he wouldn’t he said he was
too busy now let’s say instead you were
Kelly a 32 year old homeless patients of
mine you are coughing a vivid green
sputum with blood ernest your oxygen
sacs are in your boots you are
desperately short for breath I say llamo
Nia off to hospital would you not go she
wouldn’t she didn’t think she was that
sick and she thought she take her
chances if you were to provide a health
service for one group of people it would
be homeless people their life expectancy
is terrible 44 years for rough sleepers
one in 20 of hepatitis B one in 20 of
hepatitis have HIV
one in one entry of hepatitis C one in
two of depression and one in three of
attempted suicide at some stage in their
lives and yet they don’t think they need
to take care of the health I wanted to
find out why and so decided to conduct
ethnographic research and it tried to
answer this question I honor that a
deeper question is it that homes people
are feckless and irresponsible
individuals not bothered to take care of
their health or is it that we society
are effectively responsible not bother
to create a health service fit for use
for homeless people so what did I find
out firstly I found out homeless people
didn’t use health services the way they
should they rarely attended family
doctors and other primary care
professionals they avoided psychiatrists
they didn’t keep their hospital
outpatient appointments in the last
three months I referred
forty people for new life-saving
hepatitis C treatment and twenty-six of
the mr. appointment they tend not to
take their medication and the usually
way to their symptoms are so full
menacing and overpowering that they have
no choice but to go to casualty and
being so sick when in casualty they
usually require admission in my two
local hospitals despite comprising less
than a half percent of the population
homeless people account for 7% of
emergency attendances and several 10% of
hospital bed days and then so
frustratingly when in hospital they
often leave before their treatment is
finished and so require readmission
three weeks later
no wonder doctors tear their hair out at
such ingratiates I also found out that
there is no stereotypical homeless
person and while I identified a number
of reasons why there behaved this way
not all reasons apply to every single
homeless person it explains why they as
a group behave this way firstly they
face external barriers here are some of
those barriers physical barriers
distance is a barrier if you don’t have
a car and if you can’t afford the bus
fare administrative barriers forms if
you want to keep homeless people away
from your health service get them to
fill in a form if you really don’t want
them to tend your health service make
that form as complex as possible in
Ireland to get free primary health care
you have to fill in a complex
administrative form appointments as an
administrative barrier homeless people
believe bleed chaotic lives they don’t
have Diaries they don’t they change
their phones they don’t have homeless
addresses for decades we have been
sending them appointments and for
decades they have been missing most of
those appointments and we lack the
imagination to stop sending them
appointments the never ending queue as
an administrative barrier
in casualty of to wait a long time if
you leave the cube if when you go
outside and come back in you have to go
back to the end of the cube one in two
homeless people have an addiction so if
they start getting the shakes and sweats
of withdrawal when they go out to take a
shot of heroin or a negative vodka to
get get cured there with their symptoms
when they come back in they go back to
the end of the neverending catch-22 q
rigid rules rigidly applied many
homeless people were born into spawn of
families where where rules were enforced
with stick and fist rent rigid rules
rigidly apply are like the proverbial
red rag to a bull causing them to kick
off and get and get evicted from the
service we justify these rules as
promote inappropriate behavior in effect
they exclude some of the sickest people
from our health services we need to be
more imaginative and manage challenging
behaviors in a way that produces the
appropriate behavior without breaking
down the patient relationship so these
are some of the external barriers we
have our health services created but we
have done much much worse
we have stripped homeless people of the
desire and belief to have a healthy and
fulfilling life and by doing this we
have created a series of internalized
barriers which are thoughts and feelings
that result in homeless people ignoring
their poor health here are some of those
thoughts fatalistic thoughts if you
think you’re going to die young why
bother taking care of your health if you
think you’ve reached a stage in your
life where you don’t that you have a
chance of getting a home a job a partner
children a family why seek to extend
that life and why would homeless people
think they’re going to die young because
the statistics showed they will die
young denial thoughts take Diane a
homeless patients of mine she said she
is HIV and like many patients of mine
with will who have chronic diseases
don’t
hadn’t attended four months for her met
refer to the hospital hadn’t taken her
medication for months she said I’m not
going to let that bleed and disease beat
me every time I think about are those
sugars in the back of my head I need to
survive thoughts health is very low down
in homeless people’s priorities it for
them they have to spend time begging to
get money for food for shelter and to go
get drugs and alcohol so in that
environment taking care of your health
is an actual luxury the self-blame
thoughts if enough people blame you you
start thinking it’s your own fault
takes you on your street drinker it’s
all I’m only to blame myself I know by
the way they look at me he said didn’t
go to casualty because to quote I’d only
be wasting their time he didn’t think he
was worthless the presumption of
discrimination thoughts Kevin and Anna
to page two people homeless people one
Sunday last winter were out in the
pouring rain
it was lashing rain they couldn’t keep
they couldn’t find anywhere to go so
they ended up going to casualty because
Kevin was actually getting sleepy as he
lay down there and the doctor was caught
in office closed he was semi-conscious
due to hypothermia the doctor turned to
Anna and said isn’t it disgusting the
condition he has got himself into this
stigma is continuously faced by homeless
people and because of that they tend to
avoid going to the hospital because
would you go back to service you felt
humiliated in the presumption of poor
treatment thoughts those people in that
never-ending queue they soon learned
there’s no point going back to the queue
wait till you’re so sick that you’re
brought at the head of the queue right
into the emergency room here are some of
the feelings fear fear of violence and
aggression in homelessness violence both
physical and sexual is endemic many
people avoid services where they think
there were people who are aggressive or
whoever vendetta against them fear of
authority figures and institutions
as I said before many homeless people
come from dysfunctional families one in
three homeless people were in care as
children for them parental figures don’t
offer security and safety they offer
fear and danger they fear authority
figures and institutions doctors and
hospitals shame some homeless people
feel ashamed of being homeless some feel
embarrassed by their physical appearance
or their personal hygiene and so waned
won’t wait in queues with a family
doctor at their Hospital hopelessness
and low self-esteem as you go down the
socio-economic gradient the slope gets
steeper as you approach poverty at the
edge of poverty there’s a cliff over
which Alastor story says homeless people
fall most most homeless people were born
into poverty that’s why they were so
close to the edge of that cliff and
hopelessness is inextricably linked with
poverty you don’t have to face continual
disappointment if you don’t have any
expectations and that hopelessness
contributes to the these the low
self-esteem and the fatalism the cause
of people to homeless people to ignore
their poor health so in summary we have
created a health service for you and I
the housed those of us who’ve got order
in our lives
you’ve got phones you’ve got cards
you’ve got money we’ve got time to
prioritize our health we didn’t design a
whole service that was fit for use by
homeless people who have been left
without the desire to help a healthy
life struggling for existence so what
can we do the secret to providing health
care to homeless people is to bring the
services to where they are this is
happing globally in terms of sometimes
funded by national health services
sometimes funded by charities however
though it is global it is sporadic and
it is not institutionalized as routine
health care policy in the vast majority
of countries in Ireland we have worked
with our health care
Health Service executive to provide
services to homeless people
we found a safety net in 2005 which is
responsible for developing 26 clinics
for homeless people in 19 different food
halls hostels and drop-in centers in
Dublin while supporting others in
Limerick cork and Galway safety net
founded a mobile health unit that goes
out at night time to rough sleepers
safety net worth with deduct to provide
an out of our service for homeless
people safety net responded to addiction
in homelessness by developing a
methadone treatment service and the
community benzodiazepine in alcohol
treatment service Benz a safety net
developed a mobile health screening unit
for homeless people including chest
x-ray screening because safety net had
developed such a good reputation who
work with marginalised groups safety net
was asked develop other services since
for migrants Roma and drug users as we
need service we run these services we
need doctors so in 2009 we found at the
North Dublin city GP training scheme
this is the first of its kind
internationally it is a GP training
scheme the trains GPS to work in areas
of deprivation
these young doctors are educated in
hospitals and general practices in areas
of deprivation and in their fourth year
they spend time working in homeless
services drug services migrant services
and in prison services and when I say we
I am talking about the huge amount of
people who have contributed to
development of all these services
because of their passion and desire to
provide health care to homeless people
and we know it’s working
we know safety net provides health care
to over six and a half thousand people
from marginalized populations every year
we know that homeless people have better
access to primary health care we know
homeless people stand longer time in
hospital we have developed services with
Arthur Keenan Akali called social
inclusion in hospital where she has
tried to make Hospital more welcoming so
they’re more likely to stay and we know
it’s working
we know of the 500 people we started on
methadone 80%
of them have seen their accommodation
staffers improve which included going
from streets to hostels and hostels to
accommodation and we safety net brought
those Hospital services outpatient
appointments to the hostels including
those ones for hepatitis C and of those
26 people I told you who didn’t go for
her appointments without life-saving
treatments 20 are due to start in the
next two weeks and we’re chasing down
the other six we know that the graduates
of the GP training scheme are all
working in areas of Mars of deprivation
and also with Mars and those groups and
most of the doctors working in safety
net now are graduates of that scheme so
let’s return to that question who are
the ones that are feckless and
irresponsible we all have chance at the
question of some stage in their lives do
you believe the people on the margins of
our society are there because of bad
genes are bad circumstances if you’re a
bad gene theorist of a negative
disposition then you won’t believe in
wasting your money on those degenerates
if you’re a bad gene theorist of a
positive disposition then you will give
to charity to help those less fortunate
than you if you are a bad circumstances
theorist you have to believe that the
only way to rectify this injustice is
through political action to enforce
every person’s right to have a home and
to have help it is through rights not
charity that the answer is the existence
and extent of homelessness in our
society today is our political choice we
have chosen to place our fellow citizens
in peril of losing their lives and of
their health so I have something I want
to ask of you next time a politician
calls and starts talking about the
economy I want you to take Bill
Clinton’s quote and reverse it and say
it’s not about the economy stupid it’s
about the society we live in stupid I
want a society where health is more
equitably distributed so that gradience
to poverty is now
so steep that people roll off into
homelessness I want a society that you
build a wall along their cliff to
prevent people falling into homelessness
and I want a society that if I were
waiting for that wall to be built that
we instituted health policy that
everyone has access to high-quality
health care irrespective of their
background and including those in the
margins not as a charity but as a rice
thank you very much
Please follow and like us: