Press "Enter" to skip to content

The flaws in our democracy | Petter Hallqvist | TEDxUWCRCN


[Music]
[Applause]
what if I told you that anarchy
the lack of laws chaos is the closest
thing you can find to democracy
democracy stems from the Greek words
demos and clatters meaning power to the
people and anarchy the complete absence
of rules and regulations gives freedom
independence and self empowerment to the
people which is the exact same however
democracy as we know today has been
infected freedom destroyed rather than
the public electing politicians
elections now determined by media and
other external factors independence gone
the ruling power in the hands of lying
corrupt politicians self-empowerment
eradicated stupid people determining how
you live your life we do not want our
rulers to be determined by corruption
and thirst for hunger with no one to be
governed by manipulation and dirty
campaigning we do not want foolish
ignorant and unintelligent people to
rule no we want to be empowered we want
to have control over our own lives now
what did you think about that
realistically taking away all systems
and safeness of society would not solve
any other issues the whole link I made
between Anarchy and democracy was built
on the definitions of the words and
nothing more I mean democracy has been
working while Anarchy would destroy
society as we know it create problem
problems rather than solving them
but this comparison brings up one very
important question the actual
questioning of democracy as we know it
today what if it is more floor than we
think having grown up mostly in Sweden I
have been told for my entire life how
great democracy is it has been portrayed
to me as the Utopia a perfect state
where everybody gets heard no one is
left out and everyone is happy it seems
almost as if democracy has no negative
sides to it that it is purely good the
reason for including this first
outrageous part was to make you think I
wanted you to question what I was saying
I also wanted to show how wrong you can
be if you only choose to look at one
part one aspect of something like we are
doing with democracy today if you do not
think and criticize then you agree to
ignorant by believing all the
information that is thrown at you you do
not have control over yourself and what
about what I mean by this is that every
time you receive some kind of
information like this talk you just
think well this might not be true just
because somebody else or science says
that this is no guarantee it never is
no matter what you need to question and
not once but repeatedly and of course
there’s a limit to what’s actually worth
spending time on but be rational if it
is important you must question it and
this especially goes for things we
assume are good and take for granted
like democracy it is really important
that we dare to question even what you
might think what you might be afraid to
prove wrong and the reason for this is
very simple if we do not question
there cannot be any improvement
criticising something is the only way we
can both
find the problems and their solutions
and this means that if we’re able to
think critically then we are also able
to improve society improve the lives of
people by criticizing I’m thinking
rationally we are able to keep evolving
to raise people’s standard of living to
improve people’s quality of quality of
life and ultimately to make people happy
the whole aim of criticizing is to make
as many people as possible as happy as
possible and that is why it is so
important so when questioning something
when looking at objectively the views of
other people are invaluable because they
provide you with new perspectives things
you haven’t thought of before but if we
choose to rely on the opinions of others
then we’re not thinking critically then
we’re just accepting someone else’s view
as our own and not questioning it and I
want you to keep this in mind when I now
present some of the floors to democracy
in my opinion and even though I will do
so and do it in a critical manner it is
up to you to think critically it is up
to you to actually make an effort
accountability looking at the system I
see huge flaws in the accountability of
politicians I mean the whole point of
electing them is because we trust them
we trust them to represent us to
represent our beliefs so I think it is
unacceptable how they are able to make
statements that they then never act on
because that means that they have been
violating the trust in essence they’ve
been lying to us the entire time and I
think the rainy main reason why they do
so is populism they are trying to get
attention and support rather than
actually fighting for a course and
because they have no willingness to
follow up on this and no obligation to
do so in the end nothing happens
so what about having an accountability
law forcing politicians to act on their
statements if they do not they would be
impeached removed from their post and if
even more disincentive is needed we
could add that they would be replaced by
someone from another party
however this law is not really realistic
it would be too hard to determine what
Satan should be binding and it would
also limit politicians in what they
could say and even their ability to
change their minds right the system the
representative political system in most
Western societies is built on electoral
cycles now this means that every four or
five years we elect politicians to sit
so every cycle there could be a new
party with a new ideology in power reach
changing back the laws passed last cycle
and this causes a lot of instability and
reduces the only slow rate of decisions
often reversing progress made by one
ideology to favor another furthermore
these electoral cycles are accompanied
by the campaigning of parties this means
that instead of actually making
decisions politicians spend a lot of
their time on trying to seem in a
certain way and trying to appealing to
people interestingly enough there is a
very effective way of increasing the
rate of decisions and making sure that
they build on each other and this would
in turn increase economic growth and the
way to do so is to have dictatorship
then we wouldn’t even need the
campaigning of parties but there are
also viable solutions if we were to
extend the electoral cycles make them
longer then there would be less
instability in decisions and would
create more time for actually making
them on the other hand what if we
realize that the party we chose is not
suitable and then we’re stuck with them
for another maybe eight years
an extended electoral time would need
more informed decisions by the public
that’s because this much greater if we
fail to make good ones this brings me to
my third area knowledge and
understanding what we the general public
do not realize is that we do not have
enough knowledge about society in order
to make decisions on how it should be
the range of questions and in-depth
knowledge required in each question
makes it virtually impossible for anyone
to gather all the information needed and
they make and then take a stance based
on purely in your own belief this forces
us to rely on the information that is
provided by authorities and media and
since this information is biased we need
some kind of background knowledge
otherwise there’s no way we can
interpret it in an in and at least
somewhat objective manner without
knowledge and understanding we cannot
have any form of critical thinking if
I’m listening to somebody speaking I
have no idea what they’re talking about
there’s no way I can determine if it is
true or false and there’s no way you can
criticize a system if you know nothing
about it
and the problem is that we are blind to
our lack of knowledge we cannot see or
fail to admit so now how little we
actually know and the same goes for
politicians who are given huge amounts
of power it is not only the people
electing the leaders this should be
better educated but also the leaders
themselves we could solve this problem
by letting acknowledged experts make
decisions for us a system known as
technocracy I mean then we would have a
much larger chance of actually having
informed decisions but again it’s a form
of elitist rule which does not include
everyone an alternate solution would be
to change the way the voters think right
now if you want to vote you need two
things one you need to be of a certain
age which is usually eighteen and two
you need to set in ship and what if we
would make a third point we would need
an actual amount of knowledge what if we
would say that a certain amount of
education was needed and you had to pass
her at a test in order to vote this
would increase the amount of informed
decisions again but it is a very
controversial topic and it has been
discussed for a very long time
historically and it has been used to
exclude groups of people to vote and one
example is in the u.s. between 1860s and
the 1960s where african-americans now
the minority group were completely
excluded by an extremely hard literacy
test so this is why my proposal comes
with the requirement of equal education
if we do not have equal education then
the rich and highly educated can easily
exploit the poorly educated but again it
is a very controversial debate because
equal education in itself is just a
theoretical concept there will always be
differences no matter how you organize
it the bottom line is that both the
people and the leaders need more
education right participation this is by
far the most important part of democracy
if people want control over their lives
they need to take that control and then
election it’s an opportunity served on a
silver platter to do so the only thing
you need to do is take a box that’s it
yet we see a downward trend of voter
participation around the globe an
extremely good example is the European
Union which in lots last elections of
2014 had a voter participation of 43
percent
this is a terrible result decisions are
based on only on the fraction on a
fraction of the population and the
decisions still influence all but there
is one country which still managed to
keep a very high election turnout Russia
we need to really be asking ourselves
how did they manage to get a hundred and
forty six percent of their population to
vote you see one coming from with this
critical thinking thing right on a more
serious note the whole point of
democracy is that the people decide what
should be done because their decisions
affect the people so if all people
didn’t vote the systems does become
undemocratic and since people obviously
are too lazy to do so
the most effective way would be to make
not voting legal Australia’s had this
law since 1924 and now they are the
world’s highest voting turnout with 91
percent in the last elections the fine
for not voting is only 20 dollars and
that’s such a small disincentive can
cause such a high turnout makes it seem
like a completely natural thing to have
this extremely simple solution shows
were actually thinking critically about
something can do it can be applied to
every part in life the only reason why I
chose democracy was because it’s so
obvious how little we actually question
it but what we have to realize is that
even this democratic system did not come
from acceptance of the situation but
from critical thinking critical thinking
does not only find the problem more
importantly critical thinking find
solutions to problems if we are able to
expose issues completely then we can
visibly see the solutions in the problem
itself if we get our minds together if
we start thinking critically
collectively then I believe that we can
solve the problems of the world and
that is what will keep us evolving and
moving forward to summarize I would like
to quote Winston Churchill who once said
democracy is the worst form of
government except for all the others we
have tried thank you
Please follow and like us: