Press "Enter" to skip to content

Graffiti of Hope | Alan Deverell | TEDxTraverseCity


[Music]
I guess we all like to be told when
we’re doing a good job whether it’s in
our work whether it’s raising our
families or just trying to get into
shape when we put out and soul into
something it’s really important to know
that we’re getting somewhere
conservation conservation organizations
are no different they invest large
amounts of time and resources into
trying to save endangered species and
threatened landscapes and they and the
people that support them people like you
and me want to know that they’re
actually making a difference but how do
you really know if you’re running a
business may just be a question of how
much profit you make by the end of the
year or if you’re training to run a
marathon how many miles you can run in
certain period of time but in the world
of conservation it’s not quite so
straightforward one of the most popular
tools that people use something called
indicators that is you take your project
goals and objectives and you measure
those things that indicate how close you
are to achieving those goals so let’s
take one of my favorite examples
elephants let’s say your project
objective is to ensure that you have a
viable population of elephants so in
year one you have twenty Elly’s in year
five you have thirty so that’s a 50%
increase sounds like you’re on the right
track
pretty simple right actually it’s not
quite that easy first start although you
wouldn’t think so given their size
elephants are actually quite difficult
to count the little beggars are really
good at hiding buying trees
but more importantly what I’ve learned
from working in conservation is it’s not
about elephants anyway
at its most basic conservation is about
people after all if you just leave
nature to its own devices it just gets
on with it just does its own thing it’s
when you throw people into the mix that
the problems begin how they interact
with the environment the choices they
make and people are a lot harder to
quantify unlike elephants it’s not so
much about numbers as it is about
attitudes and beliefs because ultimately
that’s what drives people’s behavior
conservation is struggle with these
kinds of indicators it’s one thing to
measure a change in the population of
elephants it’s another thing to measure
a change in attitudes or levels of
awareness take another example let’s say
your data it shows that in the previous
year there was actually a decrease in
poaching now the big question is is that
because of the efforts you’ve made to
educate people that they’re now more
aware of the environment is it because
your anti-poaching patrols are becoming
more effective or is it simply because
there are a lot less animals left to be
poached it’s really important that we’re
able to answer these questions because
only then can we know where to focus the
limited resources that we have at our
disposal so maybe we need to think of
some other kinds of indicators perhaps
less traditional ones that will give us
a more accurate picture of what is
really going on in 2011 I was asked to
help set up a new project in the
Democratic Republic of the
go the objective of this project was to
begin supporting the restoration of what
is in essence a Forgotten Park in the
southeastern corner of this vast and
deeply troubled country very few people
here have probably heard of a member
National Park but remember it turns out
it’s one of the oldest parks in Africa
in fact it’s one of the oldest in the
world
and at the time of its founding it was
considered to be one of the most
biodiverse places on the continent yet
what we found when we arrived there was
truly shocking a ten thousand square
mile landscape almost totally devoid of
animals
the chief ranger station the park
headquarters in Luce inga had in its
time being a prime tourist destination
now it was almost completely completely
in ruins yet the the Rangers lived there
with their families in what can only be
described as abject poverty the Ranger
force was a total mess their vehicles
were scrap metal their patrol equipment
was completely worn out or a long been
stolen and very few the Rangers were
ever paid and the few that were had a
large chunk of their salaries skimmed
off by corrupt officials long before it
ever reached them the camp itself was a
complete disaster there were no health
care facilities there were no markets no
shops nearby the women had to walk over
ten miles just by basics like cooking
oil and what went for a school was just
a derelict building with a few branches
on the floor four desks the one thing
they did have though
was children lots and lots and lots of
children so the first thing you ask
yourself when you confronted with this
kind of situation is where the hell do
you start after all it was no good
reintroducing animals as had been
originally planned or giving these guys
brand new guns after all there was a
very good reason why there was so few
animals left in the park
and when you’re not paid and your kids
are hungry who can blame them but what
we did know was unless we did something
to help the people who were running the
park there was no way we would be able
to confront the threats coming from with
outside now the only trouble was the so
called project plan didn’t really take
into account this kind of situation it’s
often much easier to focus on things
like charismatic wildlife and anti
poaching strategy than it is complex
humanitarian issues and in all fairness
a lot of organizations are now beginning
to realize that unless you work closely
with the local communities your
conservation project has very little
chance of success but still all too
often these plans that are drawn up in
office is thousands of miles away in
Europe or in North America more about
impressing donors or taking
administrative boxes than they are about
dealing with these complex issues and
the truth is it’s not until you’re
actually on the ground dealing with
those issues on a day to day basis can
you really understand where you need to
focus your efforts so we decided
that we would take the project plan and
put it to one side and focus on what we
could do to support the ranges and their
families so we opened up a tiny clinic
where people get basic treatment and
some medicines and then we open up a
food store we hired one the ranges wives
to manage it the first time any woman
from the camp had ever had an employment
contract and we did what we could to
support the school by buying some basic
equipment and paying a few teacher
salaries but most importantly we gave
the ranges some opportunities to earn
money so they could feed their own
families without some crook skimming off
the top of it before it even reached
them very simple things as it turned out
and it took a while but eventually
things began to improve for the Rangers
and their families people seemed
healthier they will seem better fed it
was a real sense of hope in the camp now
the only trouble was now we had another
problem and the problem was how were we
going to report back to our headquarters
to the people who paid our salaries
about the improvements that be made
after all none of this had been in the
original project plan and there was
nothing we could tell them about
elephants we would need to think of some
other way to demonstrate the positive
changes that had happened now one of the
things that impressed me the most when I
first arrived in the park was the amount
of graffiti it was everywhere now as any
parent knows one of our children’s first
creative acts is to grab hold of
something and start scribbling all over
the wall
the children of loosing er were no
exception every surface of every
crumbling old building had been scrawled
on by countless tiny hands clutching
their pieces of charcoal the only
trouble was there was something deeply
disturbing about these images these were
not the innocent drawings of happy
carefree children these drawings spoke
of fear and violence and suffering
images like this
but then when you saw what these
children faced every day of their lives
these images made total sense not only
were they living under the impact of
malnutrition and disease but they were
under constant threat of attack from
marauding bands of insurgents who were
fighting for control of the resources in
and around the park we hear a lot about
the violence in the north and the east
of the Congo but actually that area
around new Pemba has for many decades
been deep profoundly unsettled in fact
it was something we found out ourselves
firsthand after being attacked on two
separate occasions by heavily armed
rebels during the time we were there but
then something changed after we’d been
working in the park for a few months
doing what we could do to improve
people’s lives something amazing
happened it wasn’t obvious at first but
then we notice it the graffiti was
beginning to change so instead of the
scary heads and the knives and the guns
we started to see this and this
and this the kids were starting to draw
the kinds of drawings you expect
children to be drawing and then my wife
gave them some paper and color crayons
boy there was no holding these guys back
so then it struck us of course these are
the indicators this is how we could show
the positive progress that have been
made why don’t we put these in our
reports well as you probably know
organizations have their own traditional
way of doing things so you can imagine
the initial response you say the kids
are doing what they are drawing flowers
and animals on the walls some kind of a
joke right what about the bloody
elephants but then even the most
skeptical people came around and the
reason they came around was because
something else amazing began to happen
for the first time in years
large animals were beginning to appear
on the open savanna in the area around
the park headquarters in broad daylight
of course if the poachers if the
surrogate of three if the range is no
longer needed to poach them to feed
their families the animals were going to
come back so sometimes we need to think
about how we evaluate and measure things
we may think we’re actually moving
forward when in fact we’re standing
still and at other times we may think
we’re going nowhere but we’re actually
moving forward we need to look beyond
the numbers
and the statistics of course they tell
their own very important story we still
need to be counting elephants but we
need to make sure that we don’t miss
those other stories those other really
important stories that are being drawn
upon the walls now I know we hear a lot
of negative news coming in out of Africa
these days about loss of wildlife and
their habitats and it’s true we are now
at a major crossroads depending on how
we act over the next few years we may
well be one of the last generations to
oversee these magnificent creatures in
the wild again that’s a pretty
depressing thought but there is hope and
the hope is that the generation of young
Africans who are now growing up will not
fall victim to the self-interest and
misguided policies of their forefathers
but that is why it is so important that
we now just like the children of Lu
Singha expose them to new ideas to give
them hope and to help them discover and
explore the amazing natural world that
they live in and to watch what they’re
drawing on the walls so the next time
you walk in and you find that your
children or your grandchildren have
scribbled all over the newly painted
dining room wall before you get mad just
remember this may merely be their way of
trying to communicate to you something
about the kind of world they would like
to grow up in thank you
you
[Music]
Please follow and like us: