Press "Enter" to skip to content

The Injustice of the Justice System | Ximena Silva | TEDxColegioBolivar


[Music]
you
[Music]
On January 7 2017 I was at Fort
Lauderdale Airport in Florida and I was
absolutely terrified just the day before
esteban santiago ruiz had opened fire in
the baggage claim and killed five people
while the security in the airport was
completely amped up I still felt
insecure being there while I was waiting
for my luggage I imagined the people in
the same spot that they before me before
experiencing possibly the most traumatic
and terrifying event of their lives
I wondered what the killer must have
thought moments before opening fire on
innocent civilians and I wondered what
would come next for him the media was
going absolutely insane suggesting that
I stay on who Santiago himself was
mentally unstable it was in this moment
that I questioned how mentally ill
individuals are prosecuted in the
justice system most people tend to judge
mentally ill individuals and are quick
to one a harsh punishment however their
layer they rarely ask what led the
criminal to commit an act the first
thing that must be taken into
consideration is that those who are
considered mentally unstable do not
think like you’re I do their perception
of reality is drastically different than
ours thus their consequences should be
treated differently as well in recent
years the amount of mass shootings has
increased dramatically a study conducted
by the Central Florida intelligence
exchange has found that 79% of mass
shootings since 2011 have been
perpetrated by individuals with
demonstrated signs of continuous
behavioral health issues and mental
illness however most of these criminals
are thrown into prison and not treated
accordingly to their to their sickness
mentally ill individuals should not be
prosecuted as a normal person would be
as they are often denied the help they
need there are not enough mental
hospitals and prisons are seen as
dumping grounds for psychiatric
hospitals according to the Department of
Justice nearly 1.3 million people are
incarcerated in state and federal jails
compared to only about 70,000 people
being served in
hospitals if these people are not
getting the help they need it is
irrational to prosecute them and condemn
them for acting in ways they cannot
control one of the reasons why they are
denied this help they need is because of
the lack of mental hospitals according
to The Huffington Post there are the
same number of psychiatric hospital beds
as there were in 1850 this is a huge
issue because there are not the same
number of crimes committed by mentally
ill individuals as there were in 1850
not only are there not enough best due
to little funding they will often get
turned away at hospital doors and it
could take months to get an outpatient
appointment a stay on Santiago Ruiz does
the Fort Lauderdale Airport shooter is a
perfect example of getting turned down
at an at a hospital door according to
CNN he had gone to a mental hospital to
check himself in as he was suffering
from hallucinations and hearing voices
that said to fight for Isis however
after two days he was released and they
returned the gun to him as well this
shows the recklessness of the doctors
that were treating him considering the
recent events linked to terrorism they
should not have given such a weapon to
an ex veteran who stated he wanted to
fight for Isis now SD on Santiago faces
prison time instead of getting help in a
real institution jails are often seen as
dumping grounds for mental hospitals Jo
Paris Kayla a mentally ill man
voluntarily admitted himself into a
hospital where two days later he was
transferred to a prison cell after he
tried to escape the ward there is an
available unavailability of medication
and improves outpatient treatment but
most of the change is no more than a
switch from a mental institution to a
prison this is an issue as instead of
dealing and tackling with the real issue
behind their mental instability they
just treat the patients with medications
or send them to prison in order not to
deal with them
this unveils a huge issue with inner
society one that demonstrates that
mentally ill individuals are seeing as a
burden while many people may state that
mentally ill individuals are a danger to
society they are danger to themselves in
fact according to CNN people with
serious mental
are three times more likely to commit an
axe again compared to those who are not
mentally ill this is an area of concern
as people with mental illness are
starting to commit suicide according to
the Centers for Disease and control
prevention 61% of all firearm fatalities
in the United States were not only
suicides but were committed by mentally
ill individuals this contempt or these
people obstinate leads them to want very
serious consequences for the mentally
unstable and they do not consider the
disorders that they are dealing with
this issue is something that is a
recurrence and appropriate measures
should be taken the government’s role in
this in mental health is to facilitate a
person needs by providing services
research and protecting the rights of
every individual allowing them to
receive the support they need to achieve
their life goals and contribute to
society while it is completely
reasonable to want justice for the
victims of mass shootings it should also
be considered that the person behind the
trigger also is a victim if they act in
such ways because of their mental
illness they should be getting help and
not be punished in jails most of these
people are afraid of their own minds and
what they are capable of thank you
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: