Press "Enter" to skip to content

What I’ve learned from Kindergarten to M.D. | Anthony Longo | TEDxMorristown


I know that I look young but in a little
over a month I will become a medical
doctor and I think at the end of my
journey in medical school my final year
in medical school is the perfect time to
look back at the education system that I
spent so long in if you were to count
which grade I’m in I would be in
something like the 20th grade so it’s a
long time but this was me on my first
ever day of kindergarten and I loved it
I went from K to 12 with no problems
graduated valedictorian of my high
school went to Cornell and subsequently
entered medical school now I tell you
this not to impress you but rather to
impress upon you that by all means I
succeeded in the system I should love it
right it’s a system that I did very well
and I flourished but you’ll see that on
the exception and not the rule if I did
so well why would I want to change the
system so I started to ask questions and
I realized there was a big need for
change and so this is observation number
one 21st century students are using 20th
century systems to learn 19th century
ideas what do I mean by this well modern
kids are using an old outdated system to
learn from a selection of courses that
have no connection to their interests so
how could you be spending six and a half
hours a day in school and for almost
your entire childhood and young adult
life and not be exploring your interest
in your classes aren’t even connected to
each other so this is a problem that
keep in mind throughout the talk another
observation high school is less
satisfying according to students
themselves it’s less engaging do we have
any evidence of this yes and it comes
from none other than a Gallup poll which
was conducted with students and what it
showed was that an elementary school
seventy-four percent of students were
involved and engaged but by the
time you got to high school you’re at
44% so what so we know that students are
disengaged but why you can’t say oh well
school is boring and kids don’t like
school because you had them in
elementary school you had them 74%
of kids were involved and engaged so
what happened and even so in high school
you get to choose your classes so in
theory you at least have some choice
over it but so this is another problem
to keep in mind the structure of school
lends to this problem so this is what
high school looks like it’s a tier and
we all know that tiers and hierarchies
really work well you know among people
among young students and they don’t so
at the top of it and this is not the
skill but at the top of the tier you
have honors students who take honors AP
IB courses they’re usually the same kids
that are taken lots of the same courses
and then you have everyone else the vast
majority of the students the so called
non honours students who don’t have that
fancy label of honors so keep in mind
this structure so another observation if
you do the math we are wasting a lot of
time and you’ll see how it works out so
you’re going to begin to see a math
problem emerge and it’s going to solve
itself at the bottoms you don’t need to
know any math but what’s interesting
about this is it’s just to give you a
sense of scale it’s not exact math it’s
just to give you just to show you how
much time we may or may not be wasting
so we know that there’s 8 courses per
day and high school on average and
you’ll see four high schools that don’t
follow this format it’ll still work out
the math will still work out in the end
and we know let’s say that 4 and a half
of those courses students are feeling
disengaged in where do we get that from
well we know 44% are engaged so 100%
minus 44 is 56% times 4.5 so we start
with 4.5 we know that courses last
approximately 45 minutes each we know
that the school year last 180 days and
there are fourteen point nine million
students enrolled in high school so when
you do the math and all that math it
comes to one a modest one million years
of collective disengaged
now to put that number in perspective
we’re disengaging students 200 times the
recorded length of history imagine if we
just use a small percentage of that time
to do something good let kids feel good
about themselves let them work on some
real-world projects but we don’t and
I’ll let you stick to the imagination
and I’ll stick to the numbers but what
if we just used one percent of that time
that would be a period of ten thousand
years we went from the first written
word for the supercomputer and
collectively in half that amount of time
so you see a lot of time is being wasted
and you may say oh well I’m not in high
school I’m having been in high school
for many years
you might not know somebody with a kid
in high school but you could see how
this could affect you because your tax
money is paying for this so we’ve
identified the high school is to a large
extent dissatisfying it’s disconnected
and it’s disproportionately unproductive
so let’s get rid of this this is the
Academy style school it allows you to
take eight disjointed classes and curate
them towards your interests or skills
and we’re not advocating a particular
type of Academy or a particular one but
rather as long as kids are being
encouraged to explore their interests
and explore career options then it stops
becoming a school and starts becoming an
academy now one of the worst things
about high school and if you think about
it is or in people in general really is
hierarchies you know gangs exclusive
clubs social cliques and if I were to
ask you right now to imagine a bad
memory that you had in high school or
some problem you had in high school
chances are your minds would go to a
problem created by one of these
hierarchies but what if we took people’s
love of being part of a team and put it
towards something good so what kind of
teams are we talking about well we
created and we like the acronym schema
science humanities Expo
raishin mathematics arts and what that
does is it allows you to at least choose
something that you’re interested in now
can you switch between academies if you
decide halfway to it you don’t like it
yes in fact it’s encouraged if you do
that because that means you ruled out an
entire field by the time you get to
college so it’s actually a good thing
and you drop into the explorations
Academy which just signifies you’ve
explored multiple interests and in that
way the traditional high school liberal
arts curriculum is preserved so both
systems went in this now you may be
saying well how do you meet state
requirements how does the school like
this meet state requirements for the
core classes
well you spin a class into the
corresponding Academy so a kid again
who’s interested in science in their
English class they’ll still learn the
core principles of English but there’ll
be a theme of reading about great
scientific passages about learning how
to write a scientific abstract which I
don’t even learn how to write until
college and how to glean results quickly
from a scientific paper so you now see
how their English class can apply to
their science interests so the Academy
style schools they sound really good but
do they work so we’re in New Jersey
today so this is the list of the top 10
high schools in New Jersey according to
the US News and World Report most recent
one now let’s see how many of these
schools are Academy style schools which
will now show up in red so nine out of
ten of the top 10 high schools in New
Jersey are by our definition at least
Academy style schools so they’re doing
well they’re doing really well and if
you look at other surveys and other top
10 lists they also continue to do well
this is another example the city of
Paterson is a city that’s had been
notoriously having trouble with this
education system
it’s a state-run district it’s been run
for 25-30 years by the state and it
faces a different problem than probably
many of the top ten schools would face
it’s an inner city and gang violence is
prominent so what the city decided to do
was to around a 2009 era create a
district plan which involved the
creation of Academy
from their public high schools and
around that time is also when you start
to see the graduation rate start to
climb 46 percent up to 78 percent now
it’s dangerous to assume that Academy
style schools were the direct cause of
this or that just because kids are
graduating at higher rates means that
they’re going on and it’s having any
impact but the graduation rate in fact
has gone up and with it has gone up the
attendance of two to four-year college
programs and although we can’t solely
pin the success on an Academy style
school that was the biggest change that
was implemented in that 2009 era and
continues to be implemented so the
results are encouraging to say the least
now there’s no point of a movement and
less than an educational movement really
unless the students want it and there is
almost no data and believe me I’ve
checked that evaluates student opinions
on these types of schools and partially
because they don’t have a unified
definition whether or not that’s the
reason whether it’s because the data is
not out there it’s difficult to find and
it’s probably outdated so we decided to
collect some to all the students to Mars
town high school asking are you in favor
of an Academy style school like this and
first respondent only poll we got a
pretty pretty high turnout which was 150
students who responded the following 87
percent almost 87 percent were in favor
of this style of school so again
although this was respondent only and
its preliminary results they’re
encouraging and we like to collect more
all good studies face criticism all good
ideas face criticism and this is a
sampling of some of the criticism
Academy style schools have faced so
we’ll go through them and see why
they’re really inaccurate so first thing
you might hear while academies make
students think about careers far too
early and this one I hear it a lot and
it really kills me because well how
could you like I said how could you have
kids in school for six hours a day most
of their young childhood and young adult
life and they’re not supposed to even
put a thought about their careers and
even so which what is worse being too
early or being too late this idea of
well it
itself out in the end and and put it off
till later it’s really a problematic way
of thinking and not a pragmatic way of
thinking in high school college and
medical school one thing I learned that
being too early is never a bad thing and
being too late is always a bad thing
and in Japan which is a comparable
wealthy country with high education
standards kids have to decide their
career essentially they have to decide
their career by 18 because their
colleges and their training programs are
intertwined so you basically would have
had to know before you you go to college
and so really why can’t we do that here
and hint
there’s no reason why we can let’s
replace that so it’s never too early but
you can certainly be too late another
one well you have time to explore these
interests in college and this
misconception is also related to the
first problem
you certainly have time to explore
interest in college but why would you
not explore them earlier are the academy
program has nothing to do with the
college in fact a student in a science
academy to continue an example can
continue on and do an English major in
college so what did the kid in the
science academy accomplish what’s
different about him well he was able to
rule out an entire field of careers
before he got to college would you know
which is the reason why he presumably he
chose them doing an English major and
because of that he’s now maybe two to
three years ahead and for parents who
are listening we’re talking about
tuition money time and money this has
real-world consequences so no more
wasted time in college now another one
while academies are a new idea and they
have been put to the test well this may
be your first time hearing about Academy
style schools and they go by many
different names but depending on your
definition of them there is old as I am
about 26 and if you were to look at when
these programs begin to emerge there’s
no set date but you generally start to
see them in the early 1990s and by 2016
2017 they’re dominating all of the
college right at the high school ranking
list so they do well and more
importantly the kids are going on to do
right things so economies have been
tried and proven now the last one how
could you possibly support an overhaul
like this even just from a financial
standpoint and this is what you might be
thinking to yourself well Anthony you’re
young you’re idealistic you’re
well-intentioned but you’re naive to the
problems of the world everything runs on
money and in the end everything needs a
budget especially the school system well
let’s talk about money then the
government and various third party
organizations have been giving out money
like candy to schools that are willing
to take it so why would you not accept
the money and modernize your school at
the same time it’s really a good idea
and you could imagine why not if you’re
an administrator you’ve been comfortably
in your school for a long time doing the
way things you have been done well you
could see why schools haven’t done it
the government believes we need a change
as well so we created real world Academy
which is trying to create advocacy for
Academy style schools one of the
problems is that Academy schools like I
said don’t have a great little you know
there’s academies pathways tracks mini
academies stem programs themed folk you
see how they go by different names and
it’s hard to find the concrete
definition for them so that’s just one
problem but then how do you take an
existing school and create an academy
from it how do you figure out which
academies are appropriate for each
school how do you train teachers to
teach in these environments how do you
create a grassroots movement how do you
have advocacy nobody’s been able to do
it so far at least to the scale that it
needs to be done and what we think is
interesting is that if you sit back and
you start connecting people and
collecting data you can do a lot and so
how can a school that has no experience
and Academy systems adopt one out of the
blue they can’t we’ve tried we’ve went
to them it’s almost impossible so again
we’re just starting by collecting data
and connecting people but we think we’re
off to a good start now how can people
help be involved in advocacy well if
you’re a high school student you could
try to help create some of that data
how high-school students whether or not
they want academies and collect polls
like the pie chart I showed earlier if
you’re a teacher or a counselor and you
feel constrained in what or how you
teach you are not alone there are so
many others like you and if you’re a
college student or somebody fresh out of
college or somebody looking in between
careers you could volunteer to help
create real world style classrooms and
you could potentially affect thousands
of people’s lives and for mentoring
programs medical students and law
students are in a great position to do
that so there’s a lot that can be done
and we need your help I leave you again
with this help us change the world thank
you
[Applause]
[Music]
Please follow and like us: