Press "Enter" to skip to content

The Trump-Putin “Bromance” | Michael McFaul | TEDxStanford


[Music]
[Applause]
[Music]
yeah this is what I want to talk about
if if you work on foreign policy or
national security as I do this has been
a rather and I’m a former diplomat so
let me use a diplomatic adjective
challenging time because one of our
candidates candidate Trump and now our
president has said some incredibly
unorthodox things about how we should
conduct ourselves across the globe about
China about Mexico about our allies in
Europe about our allies in Asia and he
pretty much says them on a repeated
basis through Twitter or other places
but nothing is more mysterious than this
odd relationship between Trump and Putin
it cuts against the grain of if you’re a
Republican
everything that Trump has said as a
campaign as a candidate and most
certainly still as a president is
against everything or Republicans have
believed let alone Democrats so I think
it demands some explanation so I want to
answer before lunch three big questions
first
why does Putin like Trump second why
does Trump like Putin and third will it
change our policy between these two
countries so first why does Putin like
Trump it’s pretty simple
it’s actually pretty simple uh trunk
supports Putin and his policies so why
wouldn’t vitamin Putin support candidate
Trump and now President Trump on the
campaign trail candidate Trump has said
that he would lift sanctions on Russia
these were sanctions put in place after
Russia annexed territory in Ukraine
Crimea and then doubled down and invaded
eastern Ukraine they were put in for a
reason in my view and they should only
be lifted if Russia changes its behavior
and yet candidate Trump has said he
would look into doing that second he
said when asked as a candidate that he
would look into recognizing Crimea
territory that was annexed by Russia
first time that territory has been
annexed in Europe since 1945 uh he would
look into that music to Putin’s ears
third he said NATO is obsolete what
could be better if you’re Vladimir Putin
than to hear an American say that NATO
is obsolete fourth check it out maybe
I’m wrong about this follow me on
Twitter at McFarland and and text me
today but I’ve never heard the president
talk about democracy or human rights and
advocating for it
music – Vladimir Putin’s ears he hates
it when Americans talk about that and
for me most offensively was won on
Morning Joe in December 2015 you know
it’s a kind of chatty show I’m on from
time to time I work for NBC and so you
can get your guard can get down for a
while maybe maybe didn’t really mean
what you said by Joe Scarborough asked
him about Putin and about the killing of
some of the people that have been killed
Joe kind of exaggerated by the way but
instead of saying that’s bad Vladimir a
candidate Trump said well we do a lot of
killing people we do a lot of killing to
somehow equated what we do abroad what
our soldiers do abroad with what
Vladimir Putin does so if you’re sitting
in the Kremlin why these are all very
obvious reasons why you would like
candidate Trump and president Trump you
don’t need a PhD in international
relations to figure that out
he goes on and on this is now after he
was elected he still praises a lad
American that’s that’s nice because
Vladimir Putin doesn’t get a lot of
praise from American presidents this
support for Putin the support for Trump
excuse me is within society as well
societal elements support them civil
society people support them and I just
want to remind you that these positions
from Donald Trump are antithetical to
traditions in the Republican Party
that’s why Putin likes Trump it goes
further than that so I’m going to just
tell you about it which is he didn’t
just like a Trump he helped Trump get
elected the Russian government and their
entities stole data from Americans
publish that data in a way to try to
help Trump win and Clinton lose they
also ran ads they also were on the
Internet
they also sponsored BOTS these are
machine BOTS that that had played a role
in influence the way that we talked
about our election and I want to make
sure you understand this we were
attacked last year our sovereignty was
violated when we were trying to do one
of our most sacred things that we do
choose our own leaders so not only did
Putin support Trump and his ideas he
also tried to do something about it
there’s a second reason why Putin like
strum he’s the opposite of my former
boss Secretary Clinton all of those
things I just described for you are
things that she did not support she
doesn’t support the recognition of
Crimea she doesn’t support the lifting
of sanctions she talks about democracy
and in particular she talked about
democracy at a time when it really upset
Vladimir Putin
there was an election in December 2011
in Russia parliamentary election by our
views in the US government I was working
at the White House at the time I was
falsified that kind of the normal rates
normal rates kind of a weird word to use
for pulse’ fication but Russian
elections four or five percent no big
deal at least in our view but when we
saw it
Secretary Clinton criticized it that’s
what we do that was our policy we talked
about these things and in Putin’s view
she sent a signal to spark the
demonstrators to protest against him and
that’s what they did not because of
Clinton let’s be clear of that but they
went out first five thousand then ten
thousand and fifty thousand then two
hundred thousand people were out on the
streets of Moscow protesting against
Vladimir Putin and he blamed us for it
he said these people were taking their
orders from Americans they were taking
their orders from the White House they
were taking their orders from the
Secretary of State and they were taking
their orders from us to foment
revolution against his regime and
eventually they said they were taking
orders from me personally as the
Ambassador this this green man up here
you is his name’s Alexei Navalny he is
the mastermind of these protests he was
a leader of these protests in 2011 this
just happened to him out in Siberia when
he was campaigning a bunch of people
threw some green stuff on him and he
just decided to wear it for the rest of
the day but this became a tension in
fact this was when things got really
tense between the United States and
Russia the end of the reset that we had
tried to do before and they started to
blame us in fact I became the poster
child for this campaign as ambassador
where I was blamed I was the one that
was responsible sent by Barack Obama to
foment revolution against Vladimir Putin
he didn’t so he took it very seriously
so one he likes Trump because of his
policies and two he didn’t like
Secretary Clinton
but there’s a third reason why I likes
Trump and why they supported Trump and
why they intervened in our elections
last year because they believe that
Donald Trump president Trump will make
us divided will be polarized we’ll be
fighting against each other guess what
they’re exactly right
that’s exactly what’s happening and that
means we’re not talking about Crimea
we’re not talking about democracy and
human rights in Russia we’re not even
talking that much about Syria and what
Russia is doing there we’re pulling back
and fighting amongst ourselves
that is exactly what Vladimir Putin
wants why does Trump like Putin second
question three different theories are
kind of kicking around there let me go
through them in turn let me take the
middle on first blackmail so there’s an
argument out there that the Russians
have compromising material on our
president from visits he made there I’m
sure you’ve read about it and that
business associates including some in
the family also have done some deals
with the Russians and therefore they had
they have leverage on the Trump
administration they can blackmail them
to do things now let me be clear I don’t
know exactly what Donald Trump did in
Russia in the year 2013 I was the
ambassador when he came we thought about
hosting him and we decided that was not
a good idea given why he was there but
let me just tell you without talking
about things I’m not allowed to if you
go to Russia and you stay in a fancy
hotel built in the last 15 years you
should assume that every phone call you
make every email you send every motion
you do and every conversation you have
can be monitored by the Russian if
tremendous capacity tremendous capacity
to monitor what you do moreover I’m sure
that there is more to the story about
business deals between the Trump
associates and and Russians and maybe
some of that might even lead to charges
of money laundering but I don’t think
that’s the explanation for why Trump
likes Putin so much because I can’t
figure out where that deal happens right
that they may happen on house of
cards or you know another television
show where you know I will send I’ll
expose this information about you unless
you recognize Crimea and then somebody
says ok you got me I got to do that but
that’s not how diplomacy really works I
don’t know where that deal happens so I
don’t think that’s a explanation second
support during the campaign obviously
there was that support not yet obviously
there may have been collusion between
some people that were close to Trump and
not and that’s why we needed to be
investigated I myself support a
bipartisan independent commission like
we had after September 11th but we most
certainly have to keep the pressure on
our members of Congress and on the
executive branch to get to the bottom of
we still don’t know the whole story my
own guess is that there were some people
that said things that they probably
shouldn’t have said and they most
certainly had not did not have the
authority to deliver in terms of these
quid pro quo but again I don’t think
it’s the explanation for the simple fact
for two reasons one Trump was saying all
these positive things well before the
Russians intervene in our election and
two I’m just not sure that some of these
people that were saying these things had
that kind of relationship with the
president but I want to know more and
you should want to know more we can’t
just move on and say well let’s just
forget about the elections over the
election is over but we have to know
what the Russians did and what the
Americans who may have colluded with
them what they may have done for one
simple reason like we got it we don’t
want to do this again folks we don’t
want to have that same plot replay of
what happened in terms of the violations
of our sovereignty so far the executive
branch and the US Congress has not done
one thing to better protect your vote
today than what happened in the last
election that is a shame and it won’t
change unless you keep the pressure on
them okay all right third one
ideological alliance it is most
certainly true that those that think
about ideology people like Steve Bannon
I have an affinity and share some
ideological
forms with people like Putin and Lipan
and the populist nationalist anti
internationalist anti liberal movement
that is now sweeping Europe and most
certainly is part of what happened in
our country with the election of Donald
Trump and I think of the three that this
one is probably the best explainer for
why Trump likes Putin because they’re
they’re alike ideologically however I’m
not so sure that that President Trump
thinks that much about ideology thinks
that much about grand scale grand
strategy in the world and that leads me
to the fourth one is that Putin likes
Trump period it’s your crazy uncle at
Thanksgiving explanation for a lot of
the things that he does he just likes
him he thinks he’s a strong leader no
ulterior motives he just thinks he’s a
good leader he wants to be like him and
it’s just that simple what does that
mean for our foreign policy will that
mean a new rapprochement a new
relationship with Russia as a result of
this nice things that these two people
have said about each other there are
some factors in favor and summing
against without question the central
driver of conflict between the United
States and Russia when I was in the
government was our disagreement about
revolutions in Egypt in Syria in Ukraine
and eventually in Russia were they
blamed us for people going out onto the
streets and we tried to tell them Barack
Obama tried to tell Putin directly yes I
was there many times and I listened to
it that’s not us people actually do
things on their own they don’t need the
CIA to tell them what to do they
actually go out and protest we were
reacting to them just like you were and
we could never come to an agreement on
that Putin always thought that it was a
hidden hand behind it and that was us
with your taxpayer money and people like
me doing it not true but that dramas
however we’re not we’re not arguing
about that anymore and so that creates
an opportunity we’re not arguing about
it anymore in the Middle East Ukraine or
even Russia all those democratic
movements are weaker today than they
were back when I was in the
government and so the central conflict
is gone that creates a permissive
condition for breakthrough second I
already talked about Trump’s worldview
that he thinks if we could just get
along with Russia we could you know
fight terrorism that creates an
opportunity for Putin and most certainly
Putin has things on his agenda that he
wants delivered from president Trump
today he wants those sanctions lifted he
wants to see NATO in disarray and in his
dream of dreams he would love if the
president of the United States would
recognize Crimea as part of Russia
so um he’s going to hang in there for a
while to try to make that happen I think
it would be a mistake and I want to
leave you with some good news about the
factors that are against it first the
common agenda between our countries
right now tragically in my view is small
back in the beginning of the Obama
administration we had out we actually
did some really big deals right you know
like the president likes to talk about
we did some big things we we signed a
treaty to reduce nuclear weapons in the
world by 30% that’s what I did in 2010
what did you do ah that’s a big deal
we had sanctions on Iran we built supply
routes to Afghanistan through Russia we
were allies in the fight against Taliban
back in 2009-2010 all of that a common
agenda is now gone the one that
president Trump likes to talk about a
lot is fighting terrorism
I’m all for fighting terrorism with
anybody that we can do it with but I’ll
just remind you with the Russians that’s
a little difficult one they define
terrorism in a lot bigger way a broader
way than we do they call people
terrorists that we call freedom fighters
that’s a problem – they fight terrorists
in a different way we try to not bomb
and kill civilians they wiped out Aleppo
smashed it to smithereens that’s how
they fight terrorism do we really want
to be a part of that by the way allied
with Hezbollah and mr. Assad and Iran
and doing so I don’t think that’s a very
good deal for America and then third
with respect to Isis just so you know
we’re fighting
Isis it’s called Operation inherent
resolve we’ve been fighting them since
2014 and Putin loves to just watch sit
back and watch us do the fighting why
get involved in it when the Americans
and their allies are already doing it so
I actually think the common agenda is
pretty small – I’m not a big fan of
Donald Trump you may figure that out by
now
I try to be respectful and I try to
engage when I can I am impressed with
some of the people that he’s hired in
his team including the secretary of
defense including the national security
adviser people that I know well and I
think they’re having a moderating
positive influence on Trump across the
board and most certainly with respect to
Russia 3 because of the Russian
investigations and the president’s
current domestic failures he’s got to
make a decision does he really want to
invest his diminishing capital political
capital on a breakthrough with Russia my
answer that is probably not he’s got
other bigger agenda items that he’s not
succeeded doing when everybody is
against him including most of the people
in his party about some new date hunt
with Russia do you really want to waste
what you have left on that my guess is
not and then the final one second here
is I’m not sure Putin wants it he wanted
Trump to get elected he’s got is he’s
got his laundry list of things he wants
to get from the president but at the end
of the day Putin called us the enemy as
a way to justify his breakdown on all
those people protesting wrote that I
showed you earlier he needs us as an
enemy to keep that that story alive so I
don’t think it’s likely except for one
wild card Donald Trump if you don’t have
a view about the world if you didn’t you
know you haven’t you haven’t take the
international relations 101 here at
Stanford you haven’t learned about the
way of the world that means the the
switch can go on and off in a very quick
way and therefore that makes me unable
to predict for you where us-russian
relations are going because of their
erratic nature of our president thank
you
you
Please follow and like us: