Press "Enter" to skip to content

How schools can stop teaching and start learning. | Anju Musafir | TEDxEicherSchool


her name is Virginie panchal resident of

Ahmedabad dreaming of being a doctor

only she never lived to fulfill her

dreams because in March 2016 she

committed suicide due to academic

pressure every 90 minutes there’s a

teenager in India who commits suicide

the latest Lancet Commission report

tells us that suicide is a growing

phenomenon amongst the adolescents and

the youth in India but you know

statistics don’t always tell you the

full story the impact of this on

families three months ago the shiny’s

mother puja been she also hung herself

in the same room on the same ceiling fan

with two of her children and her husband

outside she couldn’t bear the grief in

despair I know what it’s like to lose a

child because I also lost my child meet

Tara I lost her two years ago methought

I left you to a sudden illness she was a

very happy child loved her school she

studied in math magani international

school that i created and i think

somehow that has given me the strength

to carry on because you see at least she

had a happy childhood 12 years of bliss

and she blessed us so what’s really

wrong with our education system several

things but you know it some models it is

built on one of the models is of course

the behaviorist model which is kind of

tabula rasa you know the empty slate

speaking of empty slates if I asked you

to put your finger in the air and draw a

scenery that comes to your mind

immediately what would you draw

mountains River setting sunbirds well

that’s my rendition of that image I’ve

asked this question

two Indians across the country across

generations all school-going Indians and

they all tell me this is the first image

that comes to mind so schools don’t

really educate us

they actually conditioned us and that’s

really a major problem so I was pretty

too satisfied with my education I

studied in very elite schools and most

of what I learned wasn’t useful to me at

all one of the things I learned was the

digestive system of a frog I’m going to

be nearly 50 years old I have yet to

meet a frog with digestive problems whom

I can help I couldn’t change the car

tire I could draw circuits but didn’t

know how to change a fuse and most

importantly at best

I was bored in school at worst I was

petrified of my teachers so in the year

1999 with my husband Pascal Shah so his

French we decided to create a different

school a school where children are happy

a school where they enjoy the learning

experience you know why should education

be a bitter pill to be swallowed

why is it kind of an injection that you

need and sort of you become immune to it

so we wanted a school where there are no

uniforms where there is no fixed

timetable where knowledge isn’t

fragmented into subjects there no stress

there’s no homework and no teaching just

learning because you see the school

system we have you know we have a

colonial past

it comes from two models either the

factory system or the prison system and

Michel Foucault

a French philosopher and writer made a

comparison between schools asylums army

and prisons and guess what’s similar

between prisons and schools the uniforms

come from the prison system the

timetable the roll call the assembly and

the cellular structure of sitting so

that the jailers don’t interact with

each other and the children don’t

interact with each other and create

chaos I know

why children run out of schools when the

bell rings I’m talking about your

traditional schools so we decided to

create a school where learning was fun

and with that we created a

public-private partnership model with

the Ahmedabad Municipal Corporation we

wanted the poorest of the poor to study

in an international school with the

elite because we wanted an education

that is accessible to all sections of

society so we said different castes

different religions different abilities

what children will study together so you

know when you try to make a change in an

experimental school international school

now everybody tells you be the change

nobody really tells you what’s going to

happen if you try to change something

and we were in for riots blood signature

campaigns burning of buses really fast

mobs that surrounded us and wanted to

lynch us public interest litigation in

the High Court it went up to the Supreme

Court and I was just 30 years old that

time and I was stunned I didn’t know

what hit me and every night has to go to

bed crying I just didn’t know what to do

but in the morning when I would wake up

I tell myself in my life I don’t want to

look back and think I didn’t even try

maybe I won’t succeed in this project

because different sections of society

were against this project for different

reasons thanks to a lot of help from

wonderful people we succeeded in the

project so you can see a lot of police

posted outside because of the rights

like situation and the rights was

spreading from city to city so we really

went past a very strong system exchange

and my husband I remember told me you

know the fact that this such a big

reaction to this project makes me

convinced that we are on the right path

so later on of course we got the

building it is a old municipal school

building in the heart of the city of

Ahmedabad you can see what it was in

1998 and what it became later that’s

also the before and after the toilets

and I think it’s important to show that

what’s the state of public school

toilets in our country

a lot of parents will ask me if you

can’t give admission to our children

which board do you recommend us to go to

and I tell them I don’t know about

boards just go and check the toilets of

the school

if the toilets are clean there’s a fair

chance is some good education and the

toilets are dirty you children really

deserve better so a lot of our children

come from very poor sections of society

because diversity as a tool in the

learning process was very important to

us what did we do really in our school

we created a three-tier system a

research Action Centre a teacher

training centre and a school of

application and the methodology that we

developed was called generated resources

learning because we said there enough

resources around us always and your

biggest resource is your body the body

has been put into exile in education for

very very long finger on your lip sit on

the bench

don’t ask questions etc etc so we said

we use a body and we use the senses to

learn so here is an example of sex

education module going on in our school

you can see these children who have

written they’ve created color colored

sheets where they have colored the parts

of the body where they feel comfortable

if somebody touches them and parts of

the body where they don’t like to be

touched

they’re playing lots of games you know

the sense of touch is hardly ever used

in education we use the visual and the

auditory because children sit and learn

or listen to speeches or whatever so

here lots of icebreaker activities a

sense of touch is encouraged a lot in

our school they become familiar with

each other friendly to each other here

you can see them drawing outlines of

their body the silhouettes now this is

important because when I was a kid and

we were learning about the reproductive

system there was some sort of a alien

looking creature kind of a half figure

with our nose in a mouth with lots of

squiggles inside and I just didn’t

understand what was the digestive what

was a reproductive system and what did

it have to do with my body

so here when children are drawing

silhouettes this is their own silhouette

this is their body they fill in the

details

and that’s how you bridge the gap

between the subject the learner the self

and the object of learning it’s one in

the same then of course they play lots

of visual games they do artwork they’re

you know

exploring different things then again

they do kind of silhouettes again on

cloth stitching it up stuffing it

putting paint on it and then doing a

role play of the sexual education so you

have other projects – there’s a

cafeteria project which has been running

since 1999 and through the ninja

Disciplinary project children learn

about science and mathematics and

languages you know through advertising

organizational skills etc and then of

course from inside to the outside of the

classroom experience learning means

making films you know that that’s one

project we do every year and children

make films on social issues they connect

with communities for indigenous

knowledge they made films for the state

government of Gujarat for cleanliness

and then they also made films for the

Election Commission of India so we went

from the school and slowly we progressed

to making nearly professional films and

there this was a pilot project to create

water awareness they made lots of firm’s

contents and different posters this is a

pledge that they made motives pledge

which went out to 7.5 million voters

across the country 25 children reached

out to 7.5 million voters and 7.1

million voters signed the pledge and

gave it back and this got is also an

award from the Election Commission of

India because acknowledged the work done

by the children what’s really important

for this kind of a learning a democratic

school is very important children make

their own rules and they follow their

own rules the mapping of projects

interdisciplinary projects is really

important that the teachers do and

children can outwork the teacher on

projects they can vote for the projects

that they want to learn and they work

with the teacher to map the projects

that they want to they want to do the

seating arrangement must foster equity

inequality so it’s a very flexible

seating arrangement that cluster groups

children can sit where they want work

with different groups and of course we

are aware

group a small school so we have very

limited resources so the floor is also

used as a space and you can see your

children have made the maps and they’re

using the floor as a major board now if

learning is fun then of course

examinations must or must be fun but we

don’t use a word examination because

somehow that is a very authoritarian

view to it evaluation is a better word

but you give value to what the child

knows so here there is a political party

that the students have made and here

he’s talking about his own manifesto and

that is being voted by the students the

whole community gives qualitative

feedback we never give marks because

that’s very normative and children tell

me once I’ve graduated from school the

fact that you never gave us marks meant

there was no hierarchy in the class

there was no 60 percent or 50 percent or

90 percent student everybody was special

because everybody was good at something

or the other so what’s the impact of

this small school of 300 children it led

to the Right to Education Act in 2010

everything that we did in 1999 including

the 20% children that we gave admissions

to became 25 percent qualitative

feedback etc but the other thing that we

did was also we brought the Ministry of

External Affairs under the RTI Act in

2007 and children did this Archer our

teachers were denied visas teachers

coming from France and Germany so the

children resorted to RTI Act and we went

to Central Information Commission and we

won the battle of course youth water

festival became a general resolution and

teacher trainings now are expanding to

other schools and with her we said you

know children have fun teachers must

have fun they must enjoy the learning

experience too and Gandhiji said this

you know if all our teachers who will be

the learners

let’s all be learners so in our

experience your learning processes

teachers have a lot of fun so the

purpose of learning why should we learn

learning must connect to the child’s

life it must be meaningful purposeful

and useful to me I did must create

citizenship it must make a real

difference in the world they it must

bring in confidence I’m using words the

children said that they actually learned

it’ll lead to innovators one of our you

know grade 11 students he’s traded a

Oh a system that can run on a PC the

only kid in the world to do that we’ve

got children in heaven standard who are

running their own startups today so the

purpose of learning is really to create

a meaningful education and I can just

give you one example of this young girl

Chandrika who has come who joined us

from a municipal school in grade one she

finished her IB education went to st.

Xavier’s went to UK to Dudley College

learnt film editing and she’s back in

our school teaching film editing and

many of our students come back to a

school and their teachers so you know

learning must make sense and I’d like to

end the presentation by saying by giving

you a little coat for my daughter Tara

the world we say the world we said the

world is a big place and I’m small but I

matter because I am matter ladies and

gentlemen

every child matters every child is

special and an education system that

pushes young children to commit suicide

is an education system that needs to be

radically changed so what now are

radical change in education system thank you

Please follow and like us: