
close friend were going out for dinner
to the Taj at about 8:30 and they were
all sort of set to go out my 13 year old
son grabbed his mother and said mama
you cannot go you stay home with me for
dinner and he was very persistent so she
called the Taj and canceled the
reservation and it was just as well
because it turned out to be a
life-saving decision because it was the
evening of 26/11 when terror descended
onto Mumbai including at the hotel where
my wife were having dinner and as I was
watching the television that evening I
started to think why is it that this can
occur so easily in our country why is
there a failure of the process on so
many occasions and in fact you might
remember that those few days across
Mumbai and across the country Factory
there was a lot of protests there were
people marching protesting against the
poor governance against poor
accountability against poor public
administration and I think the the
feeling I got is that yes I do have the
right to complain and protest but I also
felt that I had an obligation as a
citizen to try to do something to
improve the governance process I was not
sure what a few days later a close
friend of mine was in a flight with me
to go up he had escaped from the Taj
early that morning the night after
terrorist attacks unhurt Pereira
harrowing experience so when I asked him
now that you’ve sort of survived that
incident how does it change your life
and he said a very interesting thing is
that I want to understand
what can I do as the ordinary citizen to
improve accountability in our country
and with that question he launched me
unknowingly onto a three and a half year
journey to understand governance and
accountability in our country being a
biologist by training I knew nothing
about political science but I felt if I
can’t characterize what accountability
was at least I should feel that I’ve
done something as an ordinary citizen to
help improve the public understanding of
accountability so here’s what I found in
my journey industry half years and by
accident the research ultimately became
a book but during that process many more
incidences of poor governance were
visible you all remember the
Commonwealth Games scam you may also
remember the coal scam the telecom scan
and I started to think that India is now
probably at its most critical juncture
in its post-independence history because
it was not the Taj under siege but I
thought it was accountability which was
under siege and through that process I
could see that well there were people I
talked to did not have a clear
understanding of what accountability
meant and so my journey was to try to
increase that understanding what I
learned is that governance is the heart
of any country but accountability is its
heartbeat without accountability you
cannot have good governance and if you
explore governance and you try to study
it
it’s qualitatively and quantitatively
measurable you can measure governance
it’s much more difficult to measure
accountability you can only measure it
through intangible understanding of the
mechanisms of accountability and I then
started looking at the system using my
biology background from a systems
perspective and I realized that this is
very complex
[Music]
governments as a system interacts with
the political system with the social
system with the economic system so if
you change something in one of those
systems there could be a positive or
negative in fact on the other system so
it’s systems dynamics at play and that’s
important because obviously governance
will then have an impact on many other
areas in the wage which country operates
so I ask the question is India too young
a democracy to really expect good
governance we’ve been around democracy
for maybe 65 years around that time now
it’s 70 years and when I did an analysis
of a large number of countries looking
at on one axis at the age of the
democracy on the x-axis and the quality
of governance and the y-axis I found an
interesting shape if you look at the
graph you will see that somewhere where
India is around 65 70 years you find
that India is way below other countries
of similar democratic age
India’s governance level is not as good
as other countries which are around 65
70 years old so there’s a lot of
catch-up that we need to do then I asked
the question how does governance impact
the competitiveness of a country and
when I did the correlation between a
global competitiveness index and
governance
I found the correlation to be 0.8 3
which means it’s extremely high
essentially good governance and being
competitive as a country move in exactly
the same direction we don’t know what
causes what but they move in the same
direction so if you are a country which
has good governance there is a good
chance to be very competitive if you
have poor governance you will not be
competitive what impact does governance
have on the human condition so I looked
at the Human Development Index and I
actually found the correlation once
again to be extremely high those
countries that have good governance tend
to have tend to have very good
human development indicators the social
condition the human condition is in good
shape
in those countries where governance is
weak the human condition is also weak so
therefore it impacts with social systems
also I also was wondering how does the
social hierarchy that exists in India
impact governance now social hierarchy
is the inequity in power and wealth
between individuals India as you know
has a very high social hierarchy which
means if I’m at the bottom of the pool
in terms of equity how can I ever
extract accountability or expect good
governance from a public official who is
supposedly at a higher level in power
and wealth and that correlation really
worried me because it’s inversely
correlated the greater your social
hierarchy the worse your governance will
be in India is those countries where
hierarchies is extremely high and that’s
developed over 2,000 years there’s a lot
of discussion today about the shadow
economy India is about maybe 25 percent
of its economy is shadowkhan maybe more
but the correlation again is very strong
if you have a large shadow economy you
are likely to have poor governance so
any attempt to reduce the shadow economy
is actually going to help improve
it is also discussion about digital
evolution now if you look at this graph
it shows you that those countries that
are digitally evolved you compare them
to the quality of governance the
correlation is almost point-9 which
means those countries that employ a
large number of digital transactions are
quite likely to have much better
governance so there is something to be
said for pushing you know digital usage
across the country so that’s definite so
if you look at accountability like I
said accountability is the heartbeat of
good governance accountability is more
measured on the basis of mechanisms or
continuity there are two kinds one which
concerns everybody in this room which is
what we call external accountability
it’s the pressure that citizens civil
society and media exerts on the
government institutions the other is the
internal countability which government
organizations have within from our
research I concluded that the most
important thing to shift any system or
any country from its equilibrium is
external pressure from outside
[Music]
implement internal changes from within
the government are much more difficult
they’re their own political
considerations it takes much more time
so the external pressure the people like
us apply which we also applied during
those years when there was an
anti-corruption movement in India to
remember and I think that has a dramatic
impact on the country’s decision to push
its accountability up and to push its
governance up from my work I found that
there are six broad things that any
country can do to improve its
accountability and therefore improve its
governance and for India for example
information which you provide which the
government provides in terms of being
transparent is very critical being
impartial that is impartial in terms of
selection of public officials focus on
implementation not just on how much
money are you allocating to your scheme
but really what was the outcome of the
allocation infrastructure so improving
essentially the infrastructure of the
courts the judiciary is absolutely
critical and independence even public
officials within the government need to
give be given freedom to make sure
they’re independent of interference from
the political executive but I think the
most important thing really is the last
one that is involvement that is
involvement of people like you and me in
the political process not only when we
would but also in the intervening period
and so if there is if there are ordinary
citizen if you’re a student if you’re a
working in a corporation what can you do
to improve accountability that was the
question that my friend who escaped from
the Taj asked me
so there are six things you can do so
first of all three five things first we
can provide your time spend a few hours
a week a few hours on weekends helping
civil society organizations who are very
well organized and already doing their
bit to improve governance in the country
you could provide your media support
which is if your access to media through
social media or regular media you can
provide that support to them we can also
provide your intellectual capability so
if you are a company if you’re a college
you have great intellectual resources
available to you and civil society
organizations don’t have access to that
so if you increase their institutional
capacity to push the governance
initiative that makes a big difference
infrastructure college like this or if
you’re working in a company classrooms
on weekends or you know in the evenings
or office space on weekends and if you
give that to a civil society
organization to simply come in and work
that helps them tremendously to fight
their battle and lastly of course can
provide monetary support but these are
the five things which which you as
ordinary citizens can do to help improve
accountability in our country so let me
walk you through the journey of
accountability over the last ten years
since 2008 we actually felt that
accountability was dropping because why
was that the case because the external
accountability pressured the citizens
were putting on the government
resolutions were enormous
so coupled with the media coupled with
civil society we were putting a lot of
pressure on the government and therefore
more scam grouping is exposed if we had
not put that pressure those scams would
not have been exposed as a result our
perception was that accountability is is
dropping continuously corruption and
governance India is becoming worse and
worse but that pressure resulted frankly
in 2014 in a complete change of
administration in a country and if I
remember the platform in which the new
government came in was claimed to be
that of providing great governance it
was the pressure that we put that
actually caused that over the last few
years I believe that accountable ease
began to improve there is much greater
pressure much greater transparency an
accomplice has become to include I think
that today we’re a much better position
than we were way back in 2008 and I feel
that in the next five or seven years
accountability continue to improve but
it can only improve if people like you
and me do orbit is no point complaining
we have an obligation as citizens of
India to do something to try and improve
the quality of governance I think is
important to remember the words of the
father of the nation if you want to make
some change you’ve got to be part of
that change process there’s no point
just saying that things should improve
it’s not going to improve unless you are
actively involved and I think that if we
all do that as ordinary citizens whether
you’re a student whether you’re in a
company I think we will ultimately make
sure that India meets its tryst with
destiny thank you you