Press "Enter" to skip to content

Take Back Your Plate | Jenni Calihan | TEDxYouth@Shadyside


14 years ago I was at home with four

little kids and the youngest was a

serial vomiter that serialism ass isn’t

over and over again and Syria with the

sea because there’s definitely Cheerios

in the mix multiple times now his name

is Jack and he threw up so often and

then he would just go right back to

eating as if nothing had happened so we

started calling him yak and come back

now my fancy MBA didn’t offer any

particular insights into how to solve

this daily vomit osis thing that we had

going on so I spent the better part of a

year cleaning up after jock as all the

mothers in this room can imagine this

was a not a very glamorous era for me

you know Plato and the hair vomit

smeared in the jeans but I was managing

the problem in that I sort of knew how

to do I bought a carpet shampooer did

you know of course lots of disgusting

laundry but it wasn’t until Jack

provided this particularly dramatic

display essentially booting all over the

table at a restaurant when a stranger

asked a question might that kid be

allergic to milk hadn’t even occurred to

me all that time cleaning up after jock

I hadn’t once step back and asked is

what I’m feeding him making him throw up

well of course the next day I pulled

milk and a bunch of other common

allergens out of Jack’s diet and he

stopped throwing up that day this was

awesome but it was also cringe worthy

because I felt so ashamed that I had let

this go on for so long like poor little

guy but it was a real awakening for me

to just the starkest of evidence that

the food we put into our bodies really

matters and I don’t mean just with like

food sensitivities and food allergies

but in general so I got really

interested in that connection between

what we eat and wellness

now as parents we spent a lot of time

energy money feeding our kids I don’t

know about you guys my kids it’s like

they expect dinner every single night

they are relentless so much work so you

know if you’re going to spend all the

time and all that energy you might as

well get it right and in my house

getting it right has been about making

changes I’m happy to report that Jack is

back to milk and all those food

sensitivities are a distant memory but

we still don’t eat the way most

Americans eat we’re part of a global

food revolution lower carb higher fat

let me explain more most of you know

we’re in the midst of an obesity

epidemic but I’m not sure that you’ve

all seen it displayed this way the red

line on the graph is obesity ramping up

beginning about 1980 essentially

tripling and the green bars show

diabetes rates rising even faster now

diabetes is one of those chronic

diseases that travels with obesity and

there are several others heart disease

stroke fatty liver some kinds of cancer

even dementia and Alzheimer’s all

tightly linked to obesity what we’re

eating and they’re all on the rise our

health care system is managing this

problem and they’re doing a decent job

of that but in terms of reflecting on

cause and prevention not so much so that

they’re kind of like knee on the floor

cleaning up after yak and come back

cleaning up our mess so today I’d like

to step back and really talk about what

could possibly be driving this now

obesity experts you’ve probably seen

them on CNN they will talk about a

obesogenic environment or how we become

victims of our own prosperity and the

idea is like too many cheap and easy

calories 24/7 food on every corner it’s

just too hard to resist and then not

enough reason to move so the idea is too

many calories in not enough calories out

and of course the cure for this is to

eat less and to exercise more I’m sure

you’ve all heard this advice

unfortunately eating less and exercising

more only work for most people in the

short term the science is actually

pretty clear on this for long term

weight loss neither eating less nor

exercising more works terribly well for

most people so we have a broken theory

of obesity and the solutions that come

out of that theory are of course broken

to what can we learn by looking back to

the 1970s and 60s before obesity took

off well I grew up in the 60s and 70s so

I can give you a little I witness report

of what it was like and a lot of things

were really the very similar there was a

lot of soda in my house certainly tons

of driving around in cars plenty of

screen time lots of cookies from the

grocery store and crappy food there was

some fast food not as much I admit but

one of the things that was distinctly

different in my house was my mother’s

attitude about food she believed that

carbohydrates were uniquely fattening

she kind of came of age in the 40s and

most women from that era believed this

so when she was on a diet she would keep

eating her bacon and eggs at breakfast

but she would give up all the starches

at lunch no dessert no bread that sort

of thing and this worked pretty well for

whole generations of women she also had

interesting ideas about exercise she

would say things like sweating is for

horses gee I can’t believe she would say

that but she did and she would she also

would no more consider regular exercise

and she would consider giving up her

regular gin martini right and

interestingly there were no gyms no yoga

pants but a fairly sedentary suburban

population maintained their weight

eating this way and living this way but

since the 70s the skirts have gotten

shorter I don’t want to do that but you

know the tops tighter and shorter too

there’s nowhere to hide

we all have incredible in

centas to maintain our way yet look at

that graph 25% of adults move from lean

to obese in just four decades not many

people would make that journey without a

fight we didn’t just sort of drift

towards obesity because of the awesome

smells coming out from the golden arches

everywhere we were pushed a big shove in

fact from our friends at the USDA so the

USDA recommended a low-fat diet around

1980

you probably remember it it was that

food pyramid which came about 10 years

later but the same thing all those

starches and grains on the bottom and

the tiny triangle of fat on the top so

we were supposed to eat less of the fat

and more of the carbohydrates and we did

just that in America this becomes an

even more processed diet too because

suddenly we have to invite the food

manufacturers in to take the natural fat

out of our food and also to process all

those grains because most people aren’t

eating like boiled wheat berries or a

boiled potato they’re eating a cracker

which is a very processed piece of food

the USDA didn’t seem to understand that

carbohydrates make most people hangry

you guys know hangry right that edgy

crabby oh my god I have to be very now

feeling it all comes together this is

the feeling you get when your blood

sugar is crashing down after a meal that

has been kind of a low-fat high-carb

meal

if you think of anything made out of

flour pretzels cookies crackers bread

all of those things turn to sugar in

your body almost immediately after you

eat them so you get a bigger blood sugar

spike than you would get from eating

table sugar in fact everyone’s a little

different I’m going to show you what my

blood sugar looks like after eating

break nuts skim milk and a banana that’s

the red line my wild grape nuts

adventure right

and then the green line is my blood

sugar after eating an omelet so very

different same amount of calories very

different experience and I have to tell

you when you come crashing down from

your wild ride

you often have to grab that Banana Nut

muffin at 11 o’clock because you just

can’t make it to lunch

you’re hangry or God forbid you go for

that Snickers bar in your desk right

this eating pattern has made us a nation

of snackers which our food manufacturers

love because it drives their revenues

and part of why this is happening is

because carbs put you into fat storing

mode and by that I mean they drive up a

hormone called insulin really important

how long does several things but one of

the things it does is tells your fat

cells hang on to your fat don’t let the

fat out of your fat cells so you can’t

access your fat for energy so that

there’s no excess that pantry within as

I like to call it so you have to reach

into your external pantry when you get

hangry and you reach for the Wheat Thins

or the granola bar or the energy drink

more carbs it’s a vicious cycle so

hundreds of scientist thousands of

doctors millions of people have figured

this out and have abandoned the low-fat

dietary advice and are going back to

real full fat food they love how cutting

way back on sugars and starches makes

them feel this is the grassroots

revolution that I’m talking about here

today sometimes when I criticize the

Dietary Guidelines which I so often do a

skinny person will sit and even you

can’t blame the Dietary Guidelines

people aren’t even following them really

hot off the presses the USDA just

dropped this report comparing what we’re

eating now to what we ate in 1970 and

it’s a per-person comparison as you can

see on the slide we’re eating more skim

milk more chicken more vegetable oil

more

fresh fruit more fish and shellfish more

flour and more vegetables we’re eating

less whole milk red meat animal fat and

eggs sound familiar

it should because this is what our

federal government is telling us to eat

right we have achieved the MyPlate

paradigm it’s just that we’re eating too

much and we’re kind of eating too much

sugar too we’re cheating a bit why then

are we eating too much I’ll say it again

because carbs make us hangry and the

food manufacturers shove sugar into

everything you can see this for yourself

swap out whatever you eat for breakfast

whether it’s granola or maybe a bagel or

low-fat yogurt swap it out for three

eggs fried and butter if you’re a big

strapping guy maybe you need six eggs to

feel full and you just go for it but see

how you feel three or four hours later

for most people this is a game-changer

self included getting rid of that carb

festive breakfast and eating food that

has a lot of fat and protein in it just

gives you this beautiful steady energy

you get all the way to lunch without

hangry it’s awesome try it trust me and

you know unfortunately most Americans

are afraid to eat this way they’re

afraid of the saturated fat and the

cholesterol in the bacon and eggs and

butter for breakfast I have four things

to tell you about heart disease and

saturated fat number one the nation’s

perhaps most prominent cardiologist dr.

Stephen this and out of the Cleveland

Clinic came out last year and called the

Dietary Guidelines an evidence free zone

and particularly called out the

relationship between saturated fat and

heart disease questioning that there was

any science to back it up number two we

have several very large meta-analysis

where they roll up hundreds of thousands

of subjects and studies showing us that

there’s no association between dietary

fat consumption and deaths due to heart

events number three journalists have

done some interesting investigative

reporting

last year and letting us know that oh by

the way the sugar industry played a

little dirty back in the 60s and 70s and

actually pay made some payments to

scientists that kind of put the thumb on

the scale a little bit as they were

deliberating whether to blame heart

disease on sugar or saturated fat and

obviously the sugar industry was trying

to push the blame away from sugar toward

saturated fat and then the fourth thing

is just that researchers have done some

investigative science and found a study

that was buried it was a well done study

in the late sixties and 70s and it

showed that as people switched from

butter to polyunsaturated corn oil they

actually had more heart disease and more

depth than the people that stayed with

the butter the idea that saturated fat

causes heart disease is based on really

thin science that keeps getting thinner

but unfortunately it’s an idea that

refuses to die I believe that it will go

down probably is the biggest public

health mistake in human history and the

faster we can forget about that idea

probably the better because it’s just

shifted our attention away from sugar

now entire countries are experimenting

fortunately with this way of eating

Sweden it’s called lchf low carb high

fat about a quarter of the population is

going rogue ignoring their dietary

guidelines and eating this way they’ve

had some butter shortages in Stockholm a

little smuggling of butter which I find

very amusing the interesting bottom line

though is that over the last ten years

is butter consumption has soared in

Sweden heart disease rates have fallen

one of the great things about cooking

this way as you can see it’s all real

normal food you can do it really quickly

vintage both fat eating is the original

fast food you can fry a pork chop saute

some onions melts and better on your

frozen peas done in 15 minutes it’s

faster than going to McDonald’s and not

only does it

tastes better and make you more

satisfied than a low-fat meal adding fat

to your meals makes them can make them

simple to this is great for parents who

have to make dinner night after night

after night I’ve been speaking about

this for a couple years and I get some

nice reports back some people have told

me about meaningful weight loss which is

great the most common comment probably

is how great it is to live life without

that hangry feeling coming up all the

time but my favorite story is a mom that

I actually know she had seen me speak a

few months ago and went home and made a

bunch of changes this mom’s a really

good cook but like most American mothers

she was skimping on the butter and was

actually cooking broccoli for her family

using Pam cooking spray well

she swapped it out for butter and served

it up for her family and her teenage

daughter took one bite and said oh my

god mom this is the best broccoli you’ve

ever made what did you do to it I love

that story I mean getting your little

kids to eat their veggies with butter is

awesome but pleasing a teenager with

butter priceless

imagine with me that the United States

is a huge cruise ship and we’ve got

millions of people of course in tons of

food the USDA is doing the cooking

excellent plenty of processed carbs and

vegetable oil on all the ample buffets

now the ship is headed straight for an

iceberg of chronic disease and it’s

really hard to turn such a big heavy

ship but fortunately they’re just

lifeboats all around the ship and

they’re serving up a different kind of

food it’s all whole real food and it’s

all full fat but the thing is you got to

jump off the ship and get in that

lifeboat to eat at those alternative

tables now there are millions of

Americans in the lifeboats already see

all those guys who aren’t wearing shirts

they’re the paleo dudes they’re showing

off their six-packs just so you’ll know

how great it is to be down there but

the average mother unfortunately she’s

back on the ship she’s pouring skim milk

on her cornflakes maybe putting

margarine on a piece of whole-wheat

toast

chasing it down with a glass of orange

juice wondering why she’s hangry all the

time

or worse wondering why she has type 2

diabetes mothers are risk averse were

afraid to grab our families break the

rules and get into those lifeboats so

much for women and children first right

but anyway what I’m asking all of you

eaters in this room to reconsider is

could go back and eating the way your

great grandmother ate minus the margin

in the Crisco could that really be

riskier than the obvious health public

health disaster we have going on right

now I mean there’s something seriously

wrong with our food paradigm and I hate

to tell you but quinoa and kale alone

will not solve this problem you’ve got

to protect your family from these modern

epidemics by going back to something

that we know works real full-fat food so

join the revolution

take back your plate I’ll see you on the lifeboats

Please follow and like us: