Press "Enter" to skip to content

Visually Documenting American Identity, Then and Now | Courtney McNeil | TEDxSavannah


when was the last time you really

stopped and looked at a work of

historical portraiture maybe it was

during a museum visit or perhaps it was

in a book either way these days it seems

like it’s getting increasingly harder

and harder to find time to really stop

and look it feels like a luxury but

today I’m here to make the argument

that’s stopping to look at works of

historical portraiture can bridge the

past and the present and shed light on

Universal concerns that are just as

relevant now as they were more than two

hundred years ago my argument is

illustrated by the two paintings you see

before you here both of these are in the

collection of the museum that I work for

and are currently on view side by side

just across the square on the right we

have dr. noble Wimberly Jones dr. Jones

was born in England and emigrated to

Georgia in 1733 when he was a young boy

of about ten years old he and his family

were among the very first European

colonists to settle in the Savannah area

his father was Noble Jones who

established what would become known as

wormsloe plantation part of which is

still in the hands to his descendants to

this day dr. Jones was a practicing

physician but he was really best known

for his work as a politician in the

years leading up to and encompassing the

American Revolution he was a prominent

leader of the Georgia Whig party which

was the driving force in Georgia for

independence for America from British

rule

he served after the war as a delegate to

the Continental Congress and enjoyed a

long and productive career so why are we

looking at him he was painted around

1804 near the end of his long life and

his productive career he was certainly

aware of how this painting would allow

him to be remembered looking at this

portrait we see that there’s very little

ornamentation or detail in the portrait

and that puts him in stark contrast to

the gentleman on the left he is Sir

James Wright who was the third and final

royal governor of the British colony of

Georgia

he was born in South Carolina to English

parents and to the very end remained

loyal to the British crown in fact he

was such a strong advocate for the

British crown and dr. Jones was so

strong in opposition to British rule

that the two men frequently came head to

head during dr. Jones’s service in the

colonial Georgia legislature and he was

such a formidable rival that each time

dr. Jones was elected as Speaker of the

Georgia Commons House of Assembly Sir

James would just dissolve the house

altogether

rather than going toe to toe with this

very formidable rival so the the

contrast between these two paintings is

great we can look at the very simple

attire of dr. Jones he wears a plain

black coat with that nice stiff collar

he has that white gathered collar of his

shirt at his neck but there’s no

ornamentation at all Sir James on the

other hand has a very elaborate coat

this beautifully painted laced shirt in

collar and the luxury of the scene is is

indicated even further by the luxurious

red curtain in the background Sir James

was painted during one of his many

visits to London and the style in which

he is painted has its roots in English

court portraiture of the 17th century so

to summarise that style the grander the

more opulent the more extravagant the

better in addition to the elaborate coat

and backdrop Sir James is indicating his

status and his importance with his lofty

expression he gazes into the distance he

does not deign to meet our eye and it

looks like he’s concerned with these

important ideas that we little people

couldn’t possibly understand and in case

you can’t determine from his lofty

expression beautiful opulent luxurious

setting in the background and his

expensive attire that Sir James is

somebody very important the artist has

made it even easier for us by giving him

this important looking pile of documents

and going so far as to inscribe on the

document he holds in his hand for the

governor of Georgia so in contrast to

all this pomp and circumstance mr. James

is dr. Jones as I mentioned before his

attire simple his background nan desu

ripped it doesn’t offer any overt clues

about his setting and it certainly

doesn’t make direct associations with

his wealth and status like Sir James’s

setting does what does stand out about

dr. Jones’s portrait is his forthright

gaze he meets the viewers eye with

intelligence with authenticity and with

confidence another striking attribute of

this painting is the shadow in the

background that delineates dr. Jones’s

profile now this is not an accident and

it’s not something that was limited to

this portrait alone in fact at this

point in history after the American

Revolution was very popular to

distribute profiles of our new country’s

leaders this was done to create

associations between our leaders and

those of the Roman Republic whose

profiles were very frequently featured

on ancient Roman coins and medals so the

artists were creating a history by

association between our brand-new

Republic and the oldest most

long-lasting Republic in human history

now despite these differences in style

of the two portraits they’re both

expressions of power and they’re both

indicative of who held power during the

turn of the 19th century both wealthy

land owning white men of anglo-saxon

descent but they demonstrate their power

in very different means one by tying

himself consciously to the traditions of

British and European Court portraiture

and the other by casting off the

elaborate trappings of court painting

and instead aligning himself with a

visual language of the Roman Republic

now for both of these men the images you

see right now are the best-known images

of them that exists today in fact for

sir James this is the only known

portrait of him that exists at all so

imagine that even these wealthy powerful

men only had one or two opportunities to

be visually remembered for posterity

and ordinary people at that time would

never have had the chance to have their

portrait painted by a professionally

trained artist and much would change

through the rise of Technology over the

ensuing decades and centuries we saw in

the 19th century the rise of photography

which democratized the art of port

making portrait making further and then

in the 20th century the rise of digital

photography which brings us to where we

are

today where we have this near miracle of

having a tiny device in our pockets that

can capture and share dozens of

portraits although today we call them

selfies in just a matter of seconds and

share them around the world with

limitless numbers of people you know the

world we inhabit today looks very

different in so many ways from the world

inhabited by Sir James and dr. Jones

more than two hundred years ago but I

think we can all still relate to their

impulse to control the way they were

portrayed to the world they use these

visual images to make statements about

their political leanings their beliefs

their values even the composition of

their character today these concerns

still drive us when we make decisions

about which photos of ourselves to take

which ones to share and how to share

them we’re participating in a process

that’s very similar and shows just how

universal this question is of how to

best visually portray our self-identity

so I would ask you the next time you are

sharing your own photographs or you’re

consuming photographs shared by other

people take a moment to stop and think

what are the values the attributes and

the beliefs that the image maker is

trying to express with this image like

our predecessors we continue to grapple

with the question of how to best

visually represent our American identities thank you

Please follow and like us: