Press "Enter" to skip to content

“Being Religious in a Post-Truth World” | Jonathan L. Best | TEDxStThomasAquinasHS


good morning thinking about this talk I

was thinking about the concept of post

truth now if you remember the year 2016

not so long ago 2016 was remarkable in

several ways but one of these being the

idea of post truth now this got a lot of

traction when Oxford dictionary’s named

post truth the word of the year and this

hurt a lot of people caused a lot of

confusion and such what do you mean by

post truth

well post truth as defined by oxford

dictionaries is where objective facts

have less relevance than in swaying

public opinion or influencing public

opinion than say personal beliefs or

convictions we solve this phenomenon of

post truth especially during the

election cycle and especially during

during the idea of fake news fake news

became hugely popular among Facebook and

Twitter where people were sharing

articles that had no basis in reality

essentially instead n fake news actually

outpaced news in terms of what was being

shared across social media now this is

not just the only thing that was

happening with post truth but also among

our politicians among both sides there

seems to be a lack of clarity in terms

of information we are continually

bombarded with all sorts of types of

information from a variety of different

sources especially across social media

it can be really hard to filter out this

information to understand what is truth

what is opinion and how do you discern

how do you make the right choices for

picking news for understanding news for

hiring information so that we can better

become more educated men and women as I

was thinking about this from both

perspectives of a librarian that’s my

day job and a theologian I kept thinking

about what does it mean to be religious

and post truth me being as a theologian

a religious person and I also was

thinking about this in terms of being a

librarian because this is what I deal

with on a daily basis students come to

me looking to find articles looking to

find information so they can write

better papers and often we think that

hey I just go to the Internet whatever I

find is valid and true and what I find

is most often is that students to have

trouble discerning what is truth and

what is not truth now this can affect us

on many ways the amount of information

that we’re exposed to is completely

remarkable you can just think about 30

years ago the idea that I could have a

device like my cell phone type in a

search term and have virtual access to

information past and present across a

wide variety of topics millions and

millions of articles this really seems

still like stuff of science fiction I’m

totally astonished by the things that I

can do and that we can all do in finding

information we should be living in a

golden age of information in many ways

we are but how does post truth exist in

an age where we have information on

anything anything we want now part of

this is the way that we’re bombarded

with information I can go on Facebook

and I can be reading about new solar

technologies and new green technology

and things about our solar system in

universe and then 30 seconds later be

watching a cat video which there’s

nothing wrong with that but

we are bombarded with all types of

information and sometimes hard to filter

what is relevant what’s not relevant and

what I can use to further and better

myself as a human being now I was

thinking about this as also a theologian

and I was reminded of an article that

call rauner prominent Catholic 20th

century theologian produced about in the

mid 20th century called runner passed

away in the early 1980s before the

internet call runner was looking at the

ways that the spirit information that

were encountered and all the types of

various sources and it’s really hard to

take all the information that we’re

exposed to and put it into some sort of

system or so you put it organize it in

some way sometimes just feels like an

unfiltered mess some of it true some of

it not true

and often what we encounter is that

there we counter to choices when we have

this information one is to escape from

it and to escape in the triviality some

of the ways that we escape is celebrity

news and my favorite way again cat

videos and the trivial of trivial nature

because sometimes information is hard it

makes us uncomfortable it makes us hard

to figure out what is what is relevant

was not was true and some of it is very

hard to read frankly or to be a watch

especially when we’re looking at news

and information about world hunger

suffering the wars terrorism so that

makes it very difficult for us the other

way to make sense of all this

information call Ron ‘red talked about

is to escape into an oasis where

information is almost like this desert

this unfathomable desert of unsisterly

ties information and so in the way in

our attempts to make sense of it we

escaped in this desert from Oasis to

Oasis trying to find a place where we

can feel comfortable one of the most

problematic things with information is

that it sometimes makes us feel on edge

especially when that information is

contrary to what we believe now

sometimes people do this they escape

from Oasis to Oasis in the desert to

find people that think the same way that

believe the same things and that I can

feel comfortable sharing information

that I believe everyone else in my

little oasis beliefs and we get really

comfortable here it’s also we can come

think of it this is our comfort zone

where I don’t want any sort of

information that is that questions the

things that I hold to be true we do this

all the time especially when we look

back at 2016 in the ways we think about

politics we want to be right when we

look at information we want to make we

want to be we want to make sense of the

information give it purpose give it a

clarity and most of all as human beings

we don’t want to be wrong now this is

not the greatest way of dealing with

this information because what happens is

that eventually the Oasis at least in

Rogers terminology almost becomes a sort

of a mirage that what we think is this

oasis of information a place where post

truth kind of merges in it and and we

feel that we’re getting nourished and

fed by this but what since happens is

that post truth gives us when we’re just

out searching for information that

confirms our own biases while post truth

gives us leaves us malnourished in the

desert we end up eventually dying of

thirst because the information that we

thought was important turned out to be a

mirage now Rahner presents a third

option might be seemed to be crazy but

his option was that we should plunge

into the desert into the sea of the

unfathomable information not to just

remain comfortable in our oasis but to

go out Rahner

talks about this for a variety of

reasons one of these being is that to be

religious and if we want to understand

what it means to be religious is that we

have to encounter the infallible the

uneasiness the unsystematic and because

this is where religion thrives if its

rise into questions and answers it

thrives and searching and questioning

truth that truth is something that it’s

not just on the surface level that truth

is not something that is easily people

can say I have the truth but rather

truth is something that is deeper more

mysterious more life-giving than just

what we find on 24-hour news cycles what

we find on social media enter and

BuzzFeed and Twitter runners pointing to

something they think we can especially

when we think about when Jesus describes

himself as I am the way the truth and

the light in the Gospel of John and I

thought about that in particular what

does Jesus mean by saying I am the truth

and what does it hat what does it mean

in a post truth age have any meaning at

all if we’re looking at the Greek word

for truth Alethea

it means to uncover to reveal to

disclose to be to remove that veil above

that that separates us from truth Jesus

is the one who unveils and so for honor

what Rahner is talking about here

plunging ourselves into the infallible

desert the abyss is that if we really

want truth truth is hard truth means

sorting and going through this infirm

questioning looking at one piece of

information and asking how do you back

there’s another bit of important

information I think is for being

religious in a post truth age and also

being an informed person in post truth

age it’s the idea of doing the truth the

Gospel of John also talks about in

chapter three about that one should do

the truth to do good if we live in a

post truth age it makes it that much

more harder to do truth if I’m

comfortable in my oasis of information

or if I shut myself away in the

triviality of social media I’m less

capable of doing the truth in my

community I’m less capable of being

actively involved in my nation in my

world I’m less able to help those to do

good in the world because it’s not just

a matter of theory truth is not just a

matter of knowledge it is also a matter

of action post truth stifles us by

saying I believe what I believe doesn’t

matter if it’s true or not but is why I

believe and it eliminates that human

spirit to question to ask to ask really

the hard questions about a world and

it’s easy it’s easy to be with people

who think the same way who act the same

way and who believe the same things that

I do that’s easy

anyone can do that those hard thing is

to plunge into the desert the infallible

information and to encounter those that

think differently than for me those that

look differently from me and those that

challenge what I believe and make me

think further about what are the things

that I hold to be true and were they

really true or just a mirage doing the

truth is just as important as knowing

the truth and I feel that if we’re going

to survive and this PO

truth age if it really is something

that’s got that it is happening if we

are going to survive we have to return

to this idea of also doing the truth and

that means calling out social injustice

that means calling out for equality and

that means doing the hard work that it

takes to be religious men and women to

be informed men and women and our inner

culture in our society truth is met

truth is not easy it’s meant to be hard

what I think for there the post truth

age does present for us is an

opportunity to do more and to really

think about truth itself it gives us the

opportunity to reflect and ask ourselves

have I really been living the truth have

I been doing the truth or have I decided

or am I really living in oasis and not

really challenging my own core

convictions and not really seeking the

hard questions do the truth and I feel

that this is the way to most better

effectively counter a post truth age thank you

Please follow and like us: