Press "Enter" to skip to content

Small is Beautiful: Lessons from Highly Innovative Smaller Countries | Jen Rae | TEDxStPeterPort


hello thank you for inviting me to

guaranty and thanks to to mark for

organizing my name is Jen and I work for

an organization called Nesta and and I’m

going to talk to you today about some

research that I’ve done in the past on

smaller countries and how they’ve used

innovation to build a future so I’m

going to start with and a little bit

about me and my job and why I do it a

little bit about Nesta and then some

case studies and examples of countries

that I’ve looked at that I think are

interesting and try and tell you a bit

of a story about them and then finish

with why I think it matters now

so Nesta is an innovation foundation

we’re based in the UK but we work

globally and we’re interested in an

innovation and when we say innovation we

don’t just mean research or science or

tech viewing new ideas I mean those

ideas can come from anywhere and that

they can achieve anything so it can be

through the public sector businesses and

individuals themselves and we’re

interested in how we can support people

to take on those new ideas and bring

benefit both the economy and to society

in doing them my particular interest in

Nesta is about innovation at an economic

growth and but really I’m interested in

the benefit so who actually is

benefiting from that growth and working

at Nesta allows me to look in more

detail at that and in particular I don’t

think that innovation is intrinsically

good but I do think that we as a society

are able to shape that if we want to and

at its best it’s going to provide the

jobs that we want to do and the jobs

that our children want to do and also

solve some of the problems that we

develop along the way so the challenges

that will that we will reach that we

will come across new solutions

MRR a way of getting over those and and

I started to look at small countries and

across the world and because partly

because I come from one so I am raised

in Scotland and and there’s been a huge

debate there about independence

um over the last few years and then

partly because I am spent most of my

career in the northeast of England which

is a particularly deprived part m of of

the you

case earlier some of the most deprived

areas within it and I was really

interested in the sense of place and so

there’s a current of trendy government

policy placed based policy that talks

about actually what what is how do you

get things working in a place and I

think that for me as a policy maker in

the northeast of England and I was

interested and in my role within it me

as a citizen of the place and how I am

involved in it and I think that the the

divide between policy makers and people

who live there is pretty artificial and

and I think that that’s something that

we should explore more as a society

actually how do the people who are

involved in making decisions interact

with the people and who are recipients

of the decisions surely it’s in the best

interest of everybody to get this right

and so working at Nesta has allowed me

to explore some of those to move from a

policy maker role to actually looking at

the wider questions that we might want

to answer and so small Nations and the

first thing I’d like you to consider is

when you think of a country that’s good

of innovation which ones do you think of

automatically and so you may think of

the US and which is some of the best

universities in the world and some of

the most some of the greatest and

biggest businesses have come i’ve been

started to start up there particularly

in the in the tech world it’s got a

really strong and investment markets

lots of venture capital and so really

successful particularly through

investing in tech and you might also

think of a country like Japan and when

you think of technology a lot of our and

particularly electronics have come out

of out of Japan and so that might be one

of the other ones that you might think

of and or you might think of a country

like Germany and with this really strong

manufacturing base and this really

embraced advanced manufacturing

techniques and rebuilt their economy on

it and all these countries at least in

terms of population are pretty big and

they’ve got a large domestic market that

they can sell to and they’ve got strong

investment

at internal investment and they also

have a huge population by which they

could draw ideas from so I wanted to

look at if you were a smaller country

where do you stand em in the world em on

this and so we looked at em countries

across the world and small countries can

be just as innovative according to the

measures by which we look at innovation

and so I picked some of those and I

looked at countries with a population of

less than 10 million and particular

about how they use their size so what is

unique about them and and how that helps

them be more innovative and so I’d like

to talk you through a couple of those

examples and try and tell you a bit of a

story about those countries so the first

one that I looked at was Finland and so

Finland in the mid 90s was in a bit of

trouble so the Soviet Union collapsed

was main trading partner and and and the

their main industries which were wood

and paper and had gone down as well and

but since then they’ve turned their

economy around and that’s mostly through

investing in innovation and in quite a

unique way so I’ve got a few bullet

points about how they did that but I’ll

talk you through and so they prioritize

an investment and research and

developments to the government what it

was cutting pretty much everything else

increased the amount of spending on R&D

and supporting businesses to invest in

R&D and part of the reason they can do

that is they took a commitment to go

towards innovation leg growth and put it

at the heart of government policy and

and and they also looked at how

innovation could be used in public

services and I think one of the most

important things that they did was hold

a national conversation and so in 2012

and they took an exercise called Finland

foresight where a really local level

they asked citizens what do you see as

the future of the country what do you

think the government should do and then

built that up to a national picture and

I think that that to me gets people

invested in it and it gets people vest

in the future of the country and allows

everybody to move for

word together and the second one I

looked at was Estonia now this is a

country that is the go-to example and

for a country that’s really heavily

invested in technology and so in 91 and

only half the country at a full nine and

after a story of split from the Soviet

Union and the country then decided to

invest really heavily in tech m and M it

took a real strong cross government

commitment of fact that it was a prime

ministerial level commitment that this

is that this is what they were going to

do and they did this and by ruling out

mmm early infrastructure into Wi-Fi and

so in 2000 store near M enshrined in law

the right to the Internet so him a basic

human right to access it and and then

they also tackle the education system so

they put in place a program that was

specifically about making sure that at

very early age children were learning to

deal with em the technology around and

the internet so they particularly

chording em and then they used their

cross government commitment to integrate

some really quite complex government

projects using the size of the country

to be able to do it and so their online

public services and platform is called

Estonia and it became the first slowly

became the first country in 2008 where a

general election was held online and so

you can vote via at the platform you can

start a business you can pay your taxes

all in the one place and which at the

time and I think even now is considered

pretty innovative and they also looked

at an electric cars network so ahead of

the technology and they put in place the

infrastructure so that electric cars

could be ruled out across the country

and then finally Singapore and Singapore

is a classic example of a country that’s

really embraced openness and and it’s

seen as having quite effective

government policy and it’s regulate the

top of the league tables for innovation

and they’ve done this because it

I am particularly open policies around

attracting people into the country and

so they’ve focused on talent and

including sides and researchers who

bring knowledge into the country and

also foreign companies and so they set

up systems by which they can quickly

active a em if our company would

like to invest turn around a package

that involves support for that companies

coming in land access to the workforce

and so that makes sure that company will

be able to respond really quickly and

get them before anybody else does and

they’ve also looked at clustering policy

and where they’ve put research

facilities and businesses together and

particularly row in sectors and lots of

other countries doing this as now as a

result of some of the advances that

Singapore have made and then finally

they looked at their tax system and so

when they’re looking at taxing companies

and they’ve weighed in the definition of

innovation so it’s not just about

research and development but actually

about all the things around innovation

so training their staff marketing design

product development and it means that

actually companies are encouraged to do

more of the wider set sets of activities

that allow innovation to flourish in a

country so I think that from these and

we put I pulled out some lessons that I

think are relevant for small countries

around the world and when I say small

countries I actually think they’re

relevant for local areas for any area

and when you think about actually

place-based development and then these

are the types of things I think are

unique about the way that you develop

what’s happening in one place so a lot

what most of these countries were in

some way open to the world so using the

mitigating the fact that they smaller

domestic market with the fact that with

an ability to be able to look across the

world and see which bits do we want to

borrow so in particular people and

knowledge and but also ideas so what’s

happening abroad in other countries and

how could we replicate that here how do

we tweak it so that works for us and

then obviously markets and trade

the second M lesson that I think that

that these smaller countries and could

give is around getting the whole of

government involved using their size to

get the bits of government that larger

companies can’t make work together to be

able to do that and so innovation isn’t

just the responsibility of the business

department but it actually involves the

Education Department because you need to

scale people up to be able to do the

jobs innovation might be creating

probably involves the transport

department as well because you need to

make sure the roads go to the businesses

and the housing department where are the

people who are going to live and that

are going to do the jobs that you’re

creating and a real sense of planning

for the future and the third area is

around the institutions that they

creates these are public institutions

using public money and they might work

with businesses and they might be public

private and but their ability to be able

to create agile institutions ones that

can make quick decisions that can take

risks that in a larger country can be

quite hard if there’s a bureaucratic

system around that’s developed around

administering a larger country and so

the ability to take risks and the

ability to be able to take more of an

entrepreneurial approach let’s try

something and see if it works and that’s

my fourth point as well one of the key

things that the more innovative

countries we’re doing we’re

experimenting and testing new ideas and

so using their size say actually we can

do this in our country and we can do it

faster and if it doesn’t work we’ll stop

we’ll do something else instead

and then the fifth area that I think is

really important is about developing a

sense of national mission so using those

size to have a conversation with their

citizens and agreeing what is the way

forward and and who’s going to do it and

getting people lined up to be able to

take that forward and so I’d like to

finish and with a few reflections on why

this is important now so I originally

did this work in 2014 which was the head

of the Scottish referendum for

independence and which was a once in a

generation opportunity for Scotland the

world is they moved on a little now

and and but I still think that there’s

lots of interesting reflections for

countries that are do have a smaller

population

so when larger countries are becoming

potentially more protectionist and

thinking about actually their own

development and and politicians are

talking about metaphorical and physical

walls between countries it would be

really easy to think that a small

country is disadvantaged by that and but

actually there is an opportunity and

there were characteristics that smaller

places have that they can use to be able

to move forward under that environment

so things like it’s going to be really

important to consider how you are open

to the world which which bets that the

open and which bits would you want to

keep in which bits do actually you want

to think about how you take it forward

and then actually what’s within the

small country itself and how can you

promote those so is it more about

thinking about local businesses and how

to support those and can the public

sector help more with that and think

about local procurement and supply

chains and developing those and then

finally and an ability to be able to

talk to citizens and think of people who

are making decisions is not just

separate from the rest of of office of

society but actually they are part of it

and that we actually that you can make

it way forward and do it together and so

I think those are the types of

interesting questions and what I’d like

to do for the rest of the day is talk to

you about what you think some of this

means for guarantee thank you [Applause]

Please follow and like us: