Press "Enter" to skip to content

Who owns your online content? | Miloš Novović | TEDxOslo


hi standing here today makes me feel

really really nervous not just because

of the stage that I’m standing on but

because I have a growing suspicion that

you will think that I literally have the

most boring job on earth I am a lawyer

and if that weren’t enough I spend my

time reading digital user agreements so

those long pieces of text that you can

see when you start using Instagram

Facebook Google and online services of

any kind really and why do I do that and

the answer is seemingly simple because I

want to find out what these companies

can really do with things that we post

online to give you an example when I

post a picture to Facebook I hope that

my friends will see that picture maybe

like it maybe share it engage with it in

some way of course I’m hoping to convey

some message when I upload that picture

as well that message might be oh look

I’m having a fabulous time with my

friends or it might be oh look how

fortunate I am I went to the beach in

any case when I post that picture on

Facebook I understand what my

expectations are but what is Facebook

allowed to do with that photo are they

allowed to for example use it in an ad

which says that I use the dating app

called single losers in 2009 and if I

recommend my friends to do the same or

are they allowed to print out copies of

these photos are they allowed to write

songs based on my status updates and see

to answer these questions I really had

to read stuff that’s in these user

agreements what I found there is utterly

terrifying and that’s a word that I

probably should not use being legally

trained but that’s the only adjective I

can come up with so let me give you a

few examples if you have ever used

Spotify for example you give them a

non-exclusive transferable sub

licensable royalty free perpetual fully

paid irrevocable worldwide license –

which will say right to use reproduce

make available to the public

publish translate modify create

derivative

works from distribute any of your

content in connection with the service

through any medium whether alone or in

combination with any other materials in

any manner and by any means method or

technology whether now known or

hereafter created and just made Spotify

is not the only one that asks you to

give up all these rights if you have

ever uploaded a video to YouTube for

example or written a comment there you

can see that you have given YouTube a

right to well keep your video even after

you have deleted it and also that all

the rights that you give them in

comments or perpetual meaning that for

example they can still own your contents

and use your use your comments in say

2070 what about Facebook most of us are

I guess interested to hear what Facebook

asks of us and here I believe that the

forum is as important as the substance

of the rights that Facebook’s wants to

get so let’s take a look at Facebook’s

User Agreement I purposefully chose its

mobile form so if you want to start

using Facebook on your cell phone this

is what you have to scroll through and

power point actually crashed when I

imported this okay that’s about it so if

you look at that agreement at the very

top it says that you give them the right

to use content that you upload on

Facebook which well makes sense but then

at the very bottom it says by use we

mean use run copy publicly perform or

display distribute modify translate

create derivative works off and that by

Facebook they don’t necessarily mean

Facebook and someplace in the middle it

also says that you permit businesses to

pay Facebook to use your content without

any compensation paid to you so if this

is not scary enough I don’t know what it

is but you know we can’t just read

agreements and think this is the entire

picture what about the laws don’t we

have some laws which can protect us from

you know once again Facebook printing

out all of your photos and selling them

on the street well first thing that

comes to many people’s mind our laws on

privacy and yes indeed laws on privacy

can offer some kind of protection but I

want you to think about content that you

upload online in a broader perspective

think of all things that don’t

necessarily contain sensitive personal

information or personal information of

any kind think of all food pictures that

you have taken pictures of airplanes

pictures of nature pictures of your pets

they don’t necessarily contain any

personal information does this mean that

Facebook can use picture of my pets to

promote pet food also I want you to

think about pictures for example or

other kind of material pertaining to

people who are no longer alive old

family photos these things are not

protected on the most privacy laws and

it would be very difficult for you to

get any meaningful compensation from

these companies if they decide to use

your content but of course even within

the scope of content that has some

personal information bear in mind that

you have already shared this content

with certain circle of friends the whole

point of using Facebook or Instagram or

Twitter or Google or anything is this

ability to communicate so when I post my

profile picture bear in mind that I have

already shared it with Republican law at

large as well as with my friends

so if Facebook then uses that to promote

single losers I can’t claim that my

privacy interests have been violated now

there is a legitimate question to be

asked here and that’s why on earth would

Facebook use my face to promote the

dating app why don’t they use you know a

photo model they will get more clicks

clicks for certain the answer to that

question lies in this number 300 percent

according to Facebook’s own research

this is how much more you’re likely to

purchase something if it’s recommended

by your friend instead of you know it

being a generic ad Facebook’s own CEO

said that this is the elusive goal we’ve

been searching for a long long time

making your customers your marketers in

other words making you sell products to

your friends Facebook’s Mark Zuckerberg

put it more succinctly he called this

the holy grail of advertising this is

why you see more and more increasingly

for example that some of your friends

like and recommend coca-cola BMW and

other things once again note that

privacy laws don’t necessarily come into

play so that’s part of the picture these

companies want to use our content and

what’s really missing in these laws I

think that the real thing that’s missing

is balance on one hand we have our

desire to protect the integrity of

message we’re one willing to communicate

if I take a photo of my family out in a

restaurant eating a pizza I don’t

necessarily want to promote that

restaurant I just want to share with my

friends that I’ve had a good time and I

as users should have a reasonable

expectation in protecting that interest

on the other hand platform providers

have some interests of their own they

want to make as much money as possible

and through that they might even assure

in some innovation they might find new

ways to use our content ways from which

all of us can benefit what the lawn

needs to do is treat these diverging

interests as an equation find a way to

balance them this is of course easier

said than done so how can we go about

finding the balance between our right to

control the integrity of our message and

platform providers right to well earn

some money and I have a couple of sir

first we need to make sure that when we

give a copyright license when we give a

permission for our creative content to

get used in some way that this

permission is made way more explicit

that it doesn’t stay at the level of a

right but that it treat is individual

uses so if I give Facebook the right to

use my content commercially or give them

the right to have businesses pay them to

use my content I want to approve each

and every ad that Facebook uses so for

example here I would get a pop-up window

that says do you agree to be the

promoting face of single losers where I

can agree or disagree you might say that

you know this will just lead us to more

clicking clicking clicking clicking I

agree yes I agree but that’s precisely

the point if we make these companies ask

for explicit permission each and every

time that places some kind of control on

them we have to stop treating them like

benign public utilities we have to have

some checks and balances and there is no

better check and balances mechanism than

transparency and how do we ensure this

transparency which is my second point

well simply by making it legally by

obliging these companies to provide us

with full insight into the ways that

they use our content so for example

Facebook or Google or Twitter should be

obliged to maintain a database that we

can access at any time where we could

see how our content actually ended up

being used so if I upload the profile

picture I get to see all the instances

of where that picture was used was it

used commercially non-commercially was

it modified how was it modified and

perhaps most controversially I think

that we should oblige these companies to

share some of the profit when you think

about it with each piece of content that

we upload online with each status update

with each short point which with each

video clip with each photo we tell the

story of our lives we explain who we are

we explain what we like to do we say

whom we love we say what we hope to

become and if somebody uses that to make

money if somebody uses that in a

commercial way it’s only fair that we

get something back either individually

or that something is given back to the

society

large so that innovation can be further

promoted now of course it’s difficult to

think and to stand here and very

idealistic Elysees you know these

companies should not have all the rights

over our content that should be some

balancing mechanisms and to hope that

the world will change overnight and that

is not what I hope for nor do I want to

say that any of big online businesses

are inherently evil and that they don’t

have users best interest at heart I use

these platforms myself but what I want

to do here today is start a dialogue why

do these companies need all of these

broad rights why should it be legally

possible for Facebook to print out

billboards with my pictures without

paying a single cent for me and that’s

what I asked a few here today don’t stop

using these services but spread the

information around if you can just for

one moment have the patience to go

through these user agreements find one

ridiculous clause find something that

says you know iTunes User Agreement says

that you cannot use this software to

operate nuclear facilities find

something that doesn’t make sense and

just share it with your friends and that

way we can move the conversation forward

because right now there is this

stalemate all that happens whenever

users say wait we are authors we make

this content it belongs to us you can’t

use it in any ways online companies have

the same phrase this is not a problem

because you still own your content I

want you to think about this for a

moment and the easiest way to think

about why this is perhaps not a

satisfying justification is if you

imagine your house and you imagine your

best friend coming over one night and

then your best friend says you know

could I stay at your place for a while

and you say okay how long are we talking

about exactly here and then your friend

pulls out this 50 pages long contract

that says well I was thinking it could

be forever irrevocably and I was also

thinking in a while we were already

talking why don’t you give me the right

to redecorate the place and also I want

to let anybody else that I you know deem

fit move in

and I really have this cool idea of

opening a zoo inside this place so a

small signature will do what would you

have said and if you’re if you raised an

objection and your friend said but

what’s the problem you still own the

then would you have said yes to your

best friend and if you would have said

no to your friend then why say yes to

Facebook every single day thank you [Applause]

Please follow and like us: