Press "Enter" to skip to content

What if the patient knows best? | Christina Farr | TEDxOslo


imagine that you’re at a restaurant

you’ve been really excited about this

booking because you made it months ago

but when you show up they ask you to sit

in a room and fill out pages of

paperwork about yourself and when you

finally get seated at your table the

server comes over and tells you that

they’re too busy to take your order and

instead they’ll bring you whatever

happens to be available that they think

you’ll like and that’s where all well

and good but when the final bill comes

it turns out they ordered you the most

expensive thing on the menu oh yeah and

this whole meal it only lasts eight

minutes before they ask you to leave to

make room for the next a set of guests

open your eyes you wouldn’t go to this

restaurant more than once would you

maybe some of you would I certainly

wouldn’t but how about this hospital or

this doctor’s office so as you might

have guessed and this isn’t a real

restaurant I modeled it on the

experience of health care faced by

patients in America every single day and

if you’re wondering why I made this

analogy between the hospital and the

restaurant because they’re clearly very

different I find it useful because at a

restaurant we know that there is so much

more to an experience than just being

fed but in the hospital the priority has

been in fixing the person rather than on

engagement and satisfaction so what

happens when we put the patient

experience first well we’ve been finding

that when we do that we can get people

healthier faster and keep them healthier

for longer I’m a journalist with CNBC in

Silicon Valley and I write about how the

big tech companies like Apple and Google

are moving into health care for the

first time with a focus on the patient

experience

but by far the favorite part that I have

of my job is in talking to the

entrepreneurs and the innovators that

are trying to fix this because they all

have one thing in common and that is a

personal brush with a broken system

whether it’s them or it’s in more often

it’s with a loved one like a mother a

brother a sister or a friend so

entrepreneurs want to disrupt everything

but healthcare is one of the hardest

sectors to change and there are many

many complicated reasons for this but a

simple one is tradition for a very long

time we’ve had a system of medicine

called paternalism in which the doctor

knows best and the patient is assumed to

know very little back in the 1960s

not that long ago it was very common for

doctors to think it was in the best

interest of their patient to not tell

them that they had a diagnosis of cancer

and go ahead and treat them accordingly

take a moment to imagine not knowing

that you had a potentially fatal disease

now we’ve made some really huge strides

since then with the rise of ideas around

informed consent and patients rights

movements we still have a long way to go

and the system of paternalism has

manifested in a lot of different ways

and some of them you’ll you’ll recognize

from your own experiences of healthcare

would you believe that the average time

that doctors spend with their patients

during a typical visit is between 8 and

15 minutes now that might seem like a

decent amount of time but it’s far less

than I’m talking with you today and in

eight minutes think about everything

that you’d want to cover in that visit

for some of us it’s only once a year you

might want to talk about how you’ve been

feeling recently

whether you need a medication or some

kind of treatment whether or not you

should even be taking a medication in

the first place how about some of the

stresses that you’ve been experiencing

at life in life

at work maybe you’ve recently lost your

job or been through a breakup you might

want to touch on that too because it has

an impact on your health and how about

coming up with some shared goals and

some simple ways that you can hack your

health to feel better in the future

typically all we have time for though is

a quick checklist of your symptoms and a

set of instructions go home take this

pill and continue taking it until the

bottle is empty so consider the

absurdity of this fact more people have

had their medical records hacked than

have ever seen them hackers have an

easier time in you and I and looking at

our own health information and the

reason for that is because these IT

systems were not set up for the purpose

of making it easy for doctors and

patients to communicate with each other

or for patients to view their

information that they should have a

right to have instead they make it

easier for hospital administrators to

bill you and in many countries even ones

that are as progressive as a country

like Norway it’s only been very recently

that we’ve started to make it possible

for people to view their medical records

online but rather than continue to focus

on these problems I wanted to shift to

the solutions and to do that

here I wanted to introduce you to

someone that I’ve met during my job as a

journalist who is confronting these

realities every day and it’s a doctor

his name is Tom Delbanco and he had this

really crazy radical idea back in the

70s that you and the patient should be

able to view your doctors notes right

now we have no idea what the hell are

doctors are scribbling and those paper

notebooks are on the computer he thought

that you should have a right to view

this and when he initially proposed the

idea he was met with a lot of resistance

many of his peers thought that if

patients were to read these notes they

would become crazy and

anxious and maybe even offended you know

what would happen if a patient read that

their doctor thought that they were

obese or how about some medical

terminology like s OB which means one

thing to you and I and shortness of

breath in medical terminology but it’s

now been 40 years and guess what pretty

much nothing has happened it’s it’s been

a huge success this movement called open

notes is now being used by 12 million

people in the US alone

and almost a hundred percent of them

have reported wanting to see their notes

again in the future there have been very

few cases of anyone being anxious and

yelling at their doctor and in recent in

recent years Tom has been reporting that

a lot of patients are finding mistakes

in their notes and fixing them and this

is really important because these these

mistakes could have been potentially

life-threatening in the future and Tom

wanted me to tell you one thing which is

that the slogan that underpins this

movement nothing about me without me was

coined by a Norwegian nurse so he says

thank you for that and so what tom is

doing and so many others in this field

are looking towards is the future of

medicine and it’s now spread to even the

traditional healthcare system I

regularly hear from hospitals and

insurance companies and governments that

talk about patient empowerment and

patient engagement and I like to think

of it more as a patient and doctor

partnership model because I think both

have an equally important role to play

and this shift is embodied by this idea

that we need to start thinking rather

than what is the matter with the patient

that we should shift to you what matters

to the patient

and speaking of empowered patients and

the guy in the baseball cap that is

Blake and he interviewed him for

National Public Radio and he lives in

California he has type 1 diabetes and

and Blake was one of the most like on

top of it patients that I’ve met in my

where when I met him he had just

enrolled in a pilot program at Stanford

University and the idea is that he would

take all the data that he was collecting

from his glucometer about his blood

sugar and compare that with what his

Fitbit activity bracelet and other

store-bought devices could tell him

about his sleep his steps what he’s been

eating and so on and that data together

would be read by his iPhone which he

would carry with him all the time and

with his consent he could share that

with his mom if it wasn’t too

embarrassing or potentially his doctor

and Blake told me that after a few

months and being involved in this pilot

that it changed everything for him even

though this might seem like such a

simple solution because we when he went

to see his doctor who’s a featured in

the blue tie the two of them could have

an informed conversation about his

health there was much more than educated

guesswork if there was a time that he

was feeling lethargic or tired they

could look back in that log of data and

see what was wrong and together as a

team make a decision about how Blake

so when it works and technology

especially the personal health

technology that we’re all using can be a

catalyst for the shift towards patient

empowerment and in Silicon Valley

there’s an assumption that all of this

stuff these gadgets are just being used

by rich healthy curious people with too

much time on their hands but I’m finding

that it’s patients like Blake who have

chronic conditions like heart disease

and diabetes that are finding a lot of

use for these tools they can self manage

their care outside of the doctor’s

office now so I think that the future of

medicine isn’t just patient driven and

it’s not just evidence-based it’s also

distributed it’s happening everywhere

it’s happening all the time and patients

are also driving these changes when they

do this very scary thing which is to

research medical

online it is in many ways dangerous I’m

sure many of us in the audience and

certainly myself have been guilty of

having a headache and spending too many

hours in the middle of the night on

WebMD convincing yourself by the morning

that you have an incurable brain tumor

but in many cases I’m meeting with

doctors who say that the favorite kind

of patient is one that has done their

homework and is willing to walk into the

doctor’s office with some realistic

ideas about how they can improve their

own health and this is especially true

among the younger generation and as we

move to all of these new technologies

more patients than ever a reporting that

they feel a responsibility for their own

health and this is not something that

they just want to leave to their doctor

to make decisions for them this is a lot

to digest and but if there’s one thing

that I hope you take away from this talk

that you have way more power than you

think

thank you [Applause]

Please follow and like us: