
this way here okay your anything right
so let’s say that you and I are both on
business it’s honor let’s say we’re both
on businesses at down south of Louisiana
and we will produce the same product I
seem to be very loud we don’t produce
the same product for it will produce the
same product using the same equipment
etc okay the only difference is that
you’re willing to hire anybody who can
do the job if man who isn’t any racial
ethnic group you’re willing to hire
anybody who can do the job
whereas I will only hire people look
like me my question for you is which one
of us is going to have to have which one
of us will end up with lower cost of
labor lower wages yes absolutely to put
numbers on your hiring from a much
larger pool and you might be able to
hire workers for 6 bucks an hour we’re
in Louisiana after all whereas I finally
hire people look like see I might have
to pay $7 now so if you have lower wage
costs which of which firm is going to be
more profit is your company or my column
yes I agree your company lower wages
German be more problem this is what the
market does the market punishes
discrimination punishes bigotry if you
are prejudiced towards workers or your
employees to your customers to your
shareholders then the market is going to
punish you back ok now consider the role
of a minimum wage or not consider well
the minimum wage will submit any wage
right now seven dollars and a quarter so
let’s say a minimum wage law is passed
you use to be able to get workers for
six dollars I had to pay seven this gave
you an advantage because you were not
prejudiced but now
Harmon is and everybody paid southern a
quarter for ages what happens to your
competitive advantage it’s gone it’s
gone you’re no longer I’m no longer
punished for being prejudiced you’re no
longer rewarded for being willing to
hire anybody who can do the job so nice
Theory nice theory but is it true well
consider going back to 1928 1948 the
minimum wage in the United States was 40
cents now 40 cents Valley now who works
at the minimum wage
well it’s people generally going for
their first job they may not have
experience they may not have a lot of
education teenagers usually teenagers
their first job is going to be a
minimum-wage job well if you look at
1940 the unemployment rate among black
teenagers the unemployment rate among
white teenagers was almost exactly the
same
but the minimum wage keeps increasing
it’s increased 23 times since 1940 if
you go to the Great Recession in 1982
the worst downturn we’ve had since Great
Depression you will see that the
unemployment rate among black teenagers
was twice as high as that of white
teenagers in in 1982 and in fact if you
look at last month
October 2016 the unemployment rate among
black teenagers is still twice as high
as that among white teenagers so here we
had this very desirable outcome we want
to have a minimum wage to allow people
to be able to support their family even
if they’re starting off in their first
job and yet this very desirable outcome
made another problem worse the minimum
wage desirable in itself reducing racial
discrimination desirable in itself but
the minimum wage has made the racial
discrimination problem worse so what
went wrong what went wrong well I’m not
just said who won the Nobel Prize
anything he put the following talk like
this he said okay they give yourself you
have a job to do and the job is the
nature of the job
that can only be done by one person and
it’s a 500 dollar job so you’re going to
hire one person in your village to do
this job and you do a little research to
discover that there’s three people in
your village you can do the job to new
with Chantal and Regina so they can all
do the job you don’t have enough money
to hire two up it’s a one-person job
you’re not rich so what should you do
you should flip a three-sided coin and
whether wins gets the job see if what
your three sided coin and up comes
Regina see you star walk you over to
repeat at a knock on our door and tell
her the good news
and on your way there you run into a
friend of yours and the friend you tell
him what you’re doing your friend says
well you’re right the three of them can
do the job but did you know that the new
was definitely the poorest of the three
not only has he poured that his family’s
been poor for generations much poorer
than Machado much more than Regina my
question for you is you were going to
give the job to Regina because you
flipped the coin but now you know that
the new is by far the poorest you change
your mind
do you give the job to do or sleep right
here we need a decision yes okay all
right so I turn around and I walk across
the village I promise not to persecute
you anymore I walk across the village on
our children to do to give him the
Dubnyk good news he has a job but I run
into another friend of mine my friend
says you know what you heard was
absolutely right do do is the ports of
these three but his family’s been poor
for generations
he’s become reconciled to his poverty
Machado
until you so he was middle-class his
poverty is recent he’s not as far as
dennou but he can’t cope with in fact
many of the songs
friends believe that he doesn’t get a
job soon he’s going to commit suicide
now I don’t want to answer but should
you give the job that to do the poorest
or should you give the job to Bassano
who is desperate and may commit suicide
or Regina after all among the toss well
you decide I’ll give it the Bashan so
you’re walking over to the shun oh you
almost got into his house and you run
into your friend now fortunately you
only have three friends so the story is
going to come to an end you run into a
friend and the friend says yes the news
the poorest and Visayas desperate may
commit suicide but did you know that
Regina
suffers from a medical condition and if
she gets this job for $500 she’ll be
able to get a cure for a medical
condition that will not only make her
more prosperous but will open up a whole
life for you don’t show a better family
show a better career that her whole life
the capabilities will expand domestic to
do the poorest vashanoo the desperate or
do you give it Regina where she can get
a one-time fix for medical problems and
the rest of her life could be much
better at this point you might think
ignorance is bliss it would be better if
I didn’t run into my friends if I just
flip a coin and and go to everyone but
your knowledge now has a responsibility
you have to act on that knowledge so the
point of August 7 was trying to make is
two points first of all decisions that
we make whether we’re in favor of
minimum wage whether it in favor of
reducing racial discrimination or any of
the other choices are based first of all
information some information is easy to
gather people’s income relatively easy
to gather some information is difficult
to gather whether a person is desperate
other information might be difficult to
gather and
most impossible to interpret whether an
operation is actually going to make a
change in a person’s life okay so the
first problem we faced is that the
information the information that’s
easiest to obtain might not be the
information which is relative
the second issue that said may the
second challenge said may is people’s
preferences are different people’s
preferences are different you might
decide to give the job to do you might
decide of Machado you might decide
Regina you might prefer to raise the
minimum wage even if that’s going to
lead to increased racial discrimination
you might say that reducing racial
discrimination is more important than
providing a living wage for those at the
minimum wage so is this the only
challenge we face no you can actually
you can actually get worse challenges
more challenges absolute worse
okay consider licensing consider
licensing so the idea behind licensing
is that none of us want to go to a
doctor that doesn’t know math if we
don’t want to be picked up by an
ambulance if the emergency medical
technician doesn’t know how to take care
of we want to take our dog to a
veterinarian or veterinary or with our
dog sick route as well alright so we as
a people we as a people want to have
some kind of control we don’t have a
licensing system well what has happened
what’s happened in the United States is
a dramatic growth in the number of
professions and require licensing from
less than 5% of the professions in the
1950s to over a third of all professions
now and this is just as and doctors this
is people holding up ordinary jobs the
some of these professions the requires
may by law our strike me as being
incredibly irrational
let’s consider to the average if you’re
going to get a license as an emergency
medical technician you’re going to be
working with people without
medical emergency the average amount of
education required is 33 days of
training if you are going to become an
interior designer the requirement by law
is if you have 2160 days worth of
training excuse me sir how many people
have died from bad interior design I
think you’re overly pessimistic I think
nobody has ever died remotely from
adverse effects of interior design not
only not only are the education
requirements the financial requirements
well now why is this a bad thing well
think about who it impacts think about
who it impacts it we’re not talking
about professions that are helped by
people with college degrees the ratios
are the numbers I’m giving you here are
the hundred and two professions that are
most likely to be held by people low and
middle income not high income low and
middle income so by putting these
licensing requirements by requiring the
education or the payment in some case
you have to pay a five thousand two
hundred dollar fee to get a license so
you’ve just graduated from high school
you want to go into something maybe you
want to become a barber in Washington DC
you have to have 350 days of training to
legally become a barber and that you
have to pay several thousand dollars
worth of license fees it blocks the
young people to be able to get their
first job it blocks people from able to
establish their business and you might
say wait a second that wasn’t our
intention that wasn’t our purpose we
just wanted to make sure that the guy in
the end
new item tree no heart attack and how
did this happen well the problem is this
is that if we don’t do something
ourselves we create institutions and
when we create institutions we create
incentives and this brings us to or
maybe does yes this brings us to another
requiring James Buchanan and the pointy
mates the point makes is that
institutions create their own incentives
ok 2004 2004 you had that terrible
tsunami that hit South Asian okay 167
thousand people died in Thailand
Indonesia and so I went out there to
help coordinate the rescue every one of
the things I did not realize about
tsunami is it earthquakes earthquakes
kill a lot of people and they leave a
lot of people injured broken arms broken
legs crushed chest a lot of injuries
tsunamis are not like that
tsunamis they either kill you or you’re
probably okay
you weren’t either drowned or swept away
or you probably alright the number of
broken legs broken arms crushed chest
very very low
okay so Banda Aceh was in the Northland
on the western part of Indonesia and it
was wiped out by the tsunami within two
weeks two weeks six international
charities had established hospitals in
Banda Aceh
and these hospitals were incredible
standing outside the tent the the air is
bad the water is bad electricity doesn’t
work there’s rats you can step inside
the tent and the air is clean the water
is often clean the doctors and the
nurses or first class it’s like stepping
into what Johns Hopkins are like
stepping into the Mayo Clinic the
problem was
tsunamis they either kill you or you’re
alright those six hospitals didn’t have
enough patients in fact at the end of
week one directly
versus getting more water discretes of
baan taad chain trying to find people
and drag them back to the hospital
hey I noticed you’re walking with a limp
come with me okay so I’m in the office
one day and the gentleman walks in I
think he was belted right in the Dutch
gentleman walks in and he says on the
director of the advance party of a
hospital that’s coming from bellman and
we were told to check in here before we
set up our Hospital at Bondi chain and
my boss comes in and he surprised me but
Goss comes in and says look he says
there are six hospitals in Banda Aceh
and there’s not enough patients he said
up in the hills of the hills there
people who have never seen a doctor
never
he said I’ll do this for you you’re
coming into the International Airport
with all your doctors and nurses and
equipment my boss said is I will give
you the helicopters we will transport
you up in the mountainside I will
transport generators so you have
electricity
I will provide fuel every day for your
your generators I’ll provide food to
feed your people you stay up there as
long as you want to and when you decide
to leave I’ll provide that all countries
bring you back to the International
Airport and the guide for the Belgian
hospital group said wow I never involved
this this is fantastic said let me call
the home office and I’ll get back to you
tomorrow so the next day he came in and
he said well I talked to the Home Office
I told about your offer
and they said set up the hospital in
Baja GA anybody want to tell me why why
because how do charities raise money
they raised money by being seen doing
good not by doing good but my Ducey’s
doing good all the world’s media was
filming banda aceh and so the management
back in Belgium said look if you said
Hospital banda aceh and we get on
evening television television in in
Belgium then 62,000 people donate would
you give us the money that we can use to
respond to the next disaster you go up
into the hills where there’s no cameras
where there’s no media we won’t be able
to raise money for the next disaster so
a seventh Hospital was established in
Banda Aceh
let me create institutions when we
create institutions institutions have
their own incentives and their
incentives may diverge from the
incentives for the people who
established them I think if we could
have called those 62,000 people that
donated to that charity and asked each
one of them should we put the hospital
off of the hills I think all would have
said yes
take the hospital where its most needed
but we didn’t have that option we didn’t
have that after a rather me charity
didn’t have that option so we ended up
with the seventh hospital the bonod
shape so what harm is done by the our
rather how does this how does this occur
then to say good I was insuring it well
you don’t directly provide licensing you
rely on the state of Pennsylvania rely
on the national government you rely on
regulatory authorities and their
incentives are different from yours who
is in favor of licensing who’s in favor
of regulation it is existing businesses
I’ve run a funeral home for 40 years I
would like to make it more difficult for
somebody else to establish a parallel I
run an interior design from I have a
strong incentive to make it more
difficult for somebody else to open an
interior design firm and the politicians
listen to them of course they do they
support them they vote for they donate
money to their campaigns
how about the Regulatory Authority in
Harrisburg if you’re regulating one
industry
Selenia public to staff to you for how
much do you get paid $60,000 a year but
what if you’re regulating a hundred
industries in Pennsylvania ah now your
staff will be a hundred and you can page
six figures plus so we create
institutions institutions have
incentives and that’s the end of my time
okay we’ve created an institution and
the institution has incentives which
disagree okay so what can be done I’d
like to say three things three things
first of all humility there’s a lot we
do not know they talk about States as
being the laboratory of democracy you’ve
got a great idea that’s going to make
the country better good try it out in
one or two states let’s see if it works
there and then expand it let’s not say I
understand the way the world works and
expanding second one’s subsidiarity have
things work as long as possible level if
possible if you’re thinking of feeding
hungry people the best way of doing that
is go to work at the soup kitchen in
Allentown think about that you will be
there to judge the quantity of food the
quality of food you will be there to
make sure that the people who come to
the soup kitchen are treated with the
respect that you would expect them to be
treated okay if you think well I’ll
create an institution to provide meals
in San Francisco then you have the
problem with the incentives in the
institution the incentives of your salt
by different and finally reversibility
each generation has the responsibility
of making sure that they haven’t closed
the doors for future generation that you
haven’t followed a policy which sounds
like a great idea now but if it turns
out to be a mistake in 30 or 60 years
they won’t build reverse I guess what
I’m asking for is is for humility is the
is it ignorance good now ignorance is
painful ignorance is painting but I
think the greatest harm in this world is
done by those who
no doubt the greatest harm in this world
is done by those people who who have no
sense that they’re ignorant any study
thank you [Applause]