
I feel very welcome and very supported
here today and I feel a little bit
guilty about delivering such a horrid
speech because this is not gonna make
very Li’s easy-listening so my apologies
in advance this July an elderly man was
tasered in his nursing home in Rotterdam
he was a 73 year old dementia patient
who was described by his son as a frail
old man his confusion had caused him to
become agitated which is a very common
symptom in dementia patients and it was
in this agitated state that he became
uncooperative and he broke a plant pot
and a TV set and he was trying to smash
a window the staff didn’t know what to
do although it was a nursing home with a
psychiatric wing they seemed to have no
resources skills training or support
that would help them to cope with the
patient exhibiting what are really not
uncommon symptoms of dementia so they
called for help not from the on-call
doctor not from the senior nurse not
from the patient’s family they decided
to call the police three police officers
came they didn’t know what to do either
they’re used to dealing with criminals
not patients and they too seemed not to
have the right resources skills training
or support to deal with this patient so
they did what they do to criminals they
fired a taser at a 73 year old patient
in the nursing home where he lives near
Rotterdam in the Netherlands in 2018 now
being tasered hurts it hurts a lot
two high-voltage electric probes are
shot from a gun and they attached
themselves to the victim who then
receives one or more electric shocks of
around 1,800 volts now even the toughest
bad guy is screaming
when they’re tasered and this is one of
the reasons why it’s against the law to
fire tasers at patients the action by
the police was condemned by Amnesty
International who pointed out that
firing a Taser can kill elderly and
vulnerable people and the Dutch justice
minister Ferdinand Harper House he
appealed for understanding for the
police officer when I read this story in
the newspaper it made me think of our
neighbor Alex who’s about the same ages
as this man and it reminded me of our
friend moths who’s also 73 and reminded
me of my father who suffered from
dementia before he died in his 70s and
lastly it made me think think of my
husband Peter who was just 12 years
younger than the patient they tasered
and who won’t have me to look out for
him when he’s an old man in need of the
human touch and that toll thought undoes
me now in in fairness I I really should
point out at this point
that that such events are mercifully
rare and that the majority of nurses and
doctors who care for patients do a good
job and they are good and kind people
but not everybody is good and kind are
not all the time anyway there’s a seam
of hardened indifference running through
many health care institutions in many
countries from the leadership and
regulatory bodies to frontline staff
this lack of compassion is an everyday
occurrence and it de-stresses every
patient who experiences it it’s the big
taboo of our modern health care it’s
what every patient is experiencing but
no one dares to talk about it it’s the
absence of compassion and the absence of
the human touch in the place where we
now it’s it’s it was very interesting to
me right from the very beginning that
these TED talks today on the team of the
human touch have been organized not by a
hospital not by the health Inspectorate
not by a patient support group the event
here today has been organized by the
hotel school what is it that a college
of catering and hospitality can see
instinctively
that the whole health care system is
missing well most obviously the
hospitality industry knows that the
human touch is an essential part of the
friendliness the warmth and
consideration that their guests expect
to find or put boldly people know that
if they’re not nice to guests they’ll go
and stay in someone else’s hotel or
they’ll go and eat in someone else’s
restaurant and so the commercial
imperative makes hotel bosses actively
recruit staff who have good people
skills who are good communicators who
like their fellow folk and who are
genuinely eager to help the health care
system has no such imperative and they
don’t actively seek out good
communicators or test candidates for
empathy they also don’t set out to
attract patients there’s a steady supply
of us and so they put us on lists to
wait until they can get around to
dealing with us so you can see there is
quite a different mindset right from the
start
communication skills are not taught to
young doctors they’re not shown how to
conduct a consultation with the patient
or how to handle it if dialogue becomes
difficult or breaks down after all
hospitals are places of medical
excellence research and scientific
breakthrough soft skills such as empathy
openness identifying with the patient
and compassion the human touch are not
valued
as part of a doctor’s training if
they’re considered at all it’s only as
some sort of optional garnish like a
sprig of parsley on the pie it’s really
only there for the optics but yet we as
patients confidently expect to be
treated with compassion when were ill
and were frequently shocked to find
sometimes a total absence of the human
touch now of course I didn’t know about
any of this until I became a patient who
was seriously harmed by her Hospital UMC
Utrecht in 2011 a laboratory test that
indicated I had cancer lay on scene in
my file for two years while the tent the
tumor continued to grow untreated inside
me my own doctor who was devastated by
what happened was kind when he told me
the news but the hospital was not even
though the damage caused was calamitous
Peter and I were left to get on with
things on our own no more was said about
any errors being made every day when
Peter and I went in to UMC Utrecht we
expected someone representing the
hospital to approach us and say
something like we heard what happened to
you and we just like to say how sorry we
are and to reassure you that we will do
everything in our power to find out what
went wrong we expected someone to say
how are you coping is there anything you
need how can we make this easier tell us
how we can best support you but no one
said any of those things
UMC attracted absolutely nothing
whatsoever to say to their patient who
now at a potentially terminal cancer as
a result of their negligence at that
time we were both in desperate need of
the human touch in the form of a team of
caring professionals who were trained to
deal with the victims of serious harm we
needed someone who was trained to handle
such situations and would be able to
the practical emotional psychological
career medical and legal guidance that
we so desperately needed
for the first couple of weeks we naively
believe that such a person our team
existed and would reach out to us soon
but like most of the hospitals here in
2013 no such person our team existed in
UMC Utrecht no discipline aimed at
supporting patients traumatized by
medical error existed in the Netherlands
so we were told Peter and I tried to
explain what we felt should be happening
we knew instinctively what was missing
and we sought expertise from abroad to
support our views we went back to the
hospital and we told them there should
be an admission that something had gone
badly wrong in my case an apology from
the hospital board a discussion with all
of the parties involved a root cause
analysis an investigation that would
find out what had gone wrong a reports
drawn up that explained what happened so
that lessons could be learned and other
patients protected a special specialist
support for for both of us and for my
doctor and for just a touch of human
but our ideas were met with blank looks
shakes of the head genuine in
comprehension they had never heard of
such a program so what was on offer
instead was no support for the patient
no discussion about what had happened no
apology from the hospital no
investigation no report no informing the
health Inspectorate no answers and no
official record that anything at all had
ever happened and harmed Adrian Collin
at UMC attract the message we were
receiving loud and clear was at the
hospital had no further interest in my
case had no plans to talk to me to meet
me to provide any help or to take any
action what
mattered so much to Peter and me was a
little consequence to them compassion
and the human touch were totally absent
in the relationship between UMC Utrecht
and their patient I’m going to if you
don’t mind I’m gonna sit down just for a
second um since I started telling the
story of what happened to me at UMC
Utrecht of the medical negligence it’s
costing me my life of the crew away the
hospital dealt with us at every stage
and of the healthcare system in general
people have been getting in touch we’ve
had emails phone calls Twitter
whatsup conversations people coming to
see us and the stories have come
flooding out and often they’re stories
that have never been told to anybody
before neighbors colleagues friends
chance acquaintances and sometimes total
strangers young and old Dutch and
experts have been telling me what
happened to them and to their family and
friends at this stage I have enough
stories to fill a book it seems that a
lot of the people are feeling let down
by their hospitals in all parts of the
country and have been missing the human
touch that they too expected to find
when they were vulnerable and most
needed it just a few examples of the
stories I’ve been hearing a friend in
her 30s was given a breast implant in
light a hospital there was inexplicably
a size too big causing much pain and
discomfort when her own skin was
stretched over it
the surgeon never spoke to her about how
this had happened in his theater an
emergency department also enlightened
tried to send a patient home with
laxatives and enemas for constipation
even though her husband and daughter
told them that they were sure she’d had
a stroke and MRI carried out much too
late showed that she’d in fact had two
strokes a patient on the ward in The
Hague who had been confined to bed for a
week
ask the nurses to help her wash her long
hair she was handed a pair of scissors
I’m told to cut it off a breast cancer
patient who had been disease-free for
almost five years was told over the
phone on Christmas Eve that she had
metastasis on her liver she was at home
alone in Amsterdam at the time she’s
died since an ex-navy veteran needed a
knee operation but the surgeons in the
hague operated on the wrong one
leaving him permanently in a wheelchair
no one even said sorry an elderly woman
who developed an infection at the site
of her IV was cruelly accused of causing
it herself all of these stories and many
more came from my Dutch neighbors
colleagues and friends they’re not urban
myths and experts like me well we get
our own special treatment on top more
than 20 times in the past five and a
half years staff treating me in several
different hospitals as an outpatient in
the wards and even when I was in the
operating theatre have had some cutting
remark to make about that I live here
and I don’t speak Dutch I’ve been
shouted at have had the phone hung up on
me cruel mark remarks have been made and
one occasion I was ridiculed for not
understanding and laughed at out loud
other act expats tell me that they’ve
been given the same treatment orphanage
was lips pursed in disapproval when they
asked to speak English are a comment
along the lines of I’m a Dutchman and in
this country we speak Dutch other times
it was more serious a friend who needed
a sperm count tried his best to manage
in Dutch while on the phone to a clinic
in Amsterdam but the vocabulary around a
sperm count gets quite complicated so
after a while he started a struggle and
he asked if he could speak in English
immediately the phone went dead an
English friend was taken to hospital in
Rotterdam with an acute asthma
he’d forgotten his insurance card and
the hospital refused to treat him
because he couldn’t prove he was
entitled to be in the Netherlands they
simply left him at reception struggling
to breathe another expert was an English
colleague in a very young man he was he
needed sirak he needed a major surgery
and while he was in the ward waiting to
be taken down to theatres a nurse asked
him did they not have hospitals in his
country
unfortunately these and all the other
stories I have are the tip of the
iceberg and they’re uncomfortable to
listen to the behavior described is a
betrayal of the patients whose health is
solemnly entrusted to doctors nurses and
hospitals it’s also a betrayal of the
staff the many staff who performed their
jobs with compassion and professionalism
but in a strange way I take hope from
these stories I take them as an
indication that at last we’re beginning
to talk openly about a very distressing
problem that the human touch and the
human heart that guides it are not
always present in the places where we
most expect to find them and where we
most need them what we as patients need
to do is probably among the hardest
things that we’ll ever be asked of us we
need to call it out we need to challenge
it when it happens we need to talk back
politely but insistently and demand that
those looking after the most vulnerable
members of our society treat us with
respect and dignity and acknowledge that
we are equal partners in our own
healthcare and what are the hospital’s
need to do they need to listen to their
patients they also need to ensure that
their staff always have the resources
skills training and support that will
allow them to choose the human touch and
most of all they need to set down red
lines for behavior in hospitals lines
that must not be crossed ever
and the tasering of dementia patients
can be the first red line to be drawn
this isn’t Amnesty International’s job
this is our job thank you [Applause]
here today and I feel a little bit
guilty about delivering such a horrid
speech because this is not gonna make
very Li’s easy-listening so my apologies
in advance this July an elderly man was
tasered in his nursing home in Rotterdam
he was a 73 year old dementia patient
who was described by his son as a frail
old man his confusion had caused him to
become agitated which is a very common
symptom in dementia patients and it was
in this agitated state that he became
uncooperative and he broke a plant pot
and a TV set and he was trying to smash
a window the staff didn’t know what to
do although it was a nursing home with a
psychiatric wing they seemed to have no
resources skills training or support
that would help them to cope with the
patient exhibiting what are really not
uncommon symptoms of dementia so they
called for help not from the on-call
doctor not from the senior nurse not
from the patient’s family they decided
to call the police three police officers
came they didn’t know what to do either
they’re used to dealing with criminals
not patients and they too seemed not to
have the right resources skills training
or support to deal with this patient so
they did what they do to criminals they
fired a taser at a 73 year old patient
in the nursing home where he lives near
Rotterdam in the Netherlands in 2018 now
being tasered hurts it hurts a lot
two high-voltage electric probes are
shot from a gun and they attached
themselves to the victim who then
receives one or more electric shocks of
around 1,800 volts now even the toughest
bad guy is screaming
when they’re tasered and this is one of
the reasons why it’s against the law to
fire tasers at patients the action by
the police was condemned by Amnesty
International who pointed out that
firing a Taser can kill elderly and
vulnerable people and the Dutch justice
minister Ferdinand Harper House he
appealed for understanding for the
police officer when I read this story in
the newspaper it made me think of our
neighbor Alex who’s about the same ages
as this man and it reminded me of our
friend moths who’s also 73 and reminded
me of my father who suffered from
dementia before he died in his 70s and
lastly it made me think think of my
husband Peter who was just 12 years
younger than the patient they tasered
and who won’t have me to look out for
him when he’s an old man in need of the
human touch and that toll thought undoes
me now in in fairness I I really should
point out at this point
that that such events are mercifully
rare and that the majority of nurses and
doctors who care for patients do a good
job and they are good and kind people
but not everybody is good and kind are
not all the time anyway there’s a seam
of hardened indifference running through
many health care institutions in many
countries from the leadership and
regulatory bodies to frontline staff
this lack of compassion is an everyday
occurrence and it de-stresses every
patient who experiences it it’s the big
taboo of our modern health care it’s
what every patient is experiencing but
no one dares to talk about it it’s the
absence of compassion and the absence of
the human touch in the place where we
now it’s it’s it was very interesting to
me right from the very beginning that
these TED talks today on the team of the
human touch have been organized not by a
hospital not by the health Inspectorate
not by a patient support group the event
here today has been organized by the
hotel school what is it that a college
of catering and hospitality can see
instinctively
that the whole health care system is
missing well most obviously the
hospitality industry knows that the
human touch is an essential part of the
friendliness the warmth and
consideration that their guests expect
to find or put boldly people know that
if they’re not nice to guests they’ll go
and stay in someone else’s hotel or
they’ll go and eat in someone else’s
restaurant and so the commercial
imperative makes hotel bosses actively
recruit staff who have good people
skills who are good communicators who
like their fellow folk and who are
genuinely eager to help the health care
system has no such imperative and they
don’t actively seek out good
communicators or test candidates for
empathy they also don’t set out to
attract patients there’s a steady supply
of us and so they put us on lists to
wait until they can get around to
dealing with us so you can see there is
quite a different mindset right from the
start
communication skills are not taught to
young doctors they’re not shown how to
conduct a consultation with the patient
or how to handle it if dialogue becomes
difficult or breaks down after all
hospitals are places of medical
excellence research and scientific
breakthrough soft skills such as empathy
openness identifying with the patient
and compassion the human touch are not
valued
as part of a doctor’s training if
they’re considered at all it’s only as
some sort of optional garnish like a
sprig of parsley on the pie it’s really
only there for the optics but yet we as
patients confidently expect to be
treated with compassion when were ill
and were frequently shocked to find
sometimes a total absence of the human
touch now of course I didn’t know about
any of this until I became a patient who
was seriously harmed by her Hospital UMC
Utrecht in 2011 a laboratory test that
indicated I had cancer lay on scene in
my file for two years while the tent the
tumor continued to grow untreated inside
me my own doctor who was devastated by
what happened was kind when he told me
the news but the hospital was not even
though the damage caused was calamitous
Peter and I were left to get on with
things on our own no more was said about
any errors being made every day when
Peter and I went in to UMC Utrecht we
expected someone representing the
hospital to approach us and say
something like we heard what happened to
you and we just like to say how sorry we
are and to reassure you that we will do
everything in our power to find out what
went wrong we expected someone to say
how are you coping is there anything you
need how can we make this easier tell us
how we can best support you but no one
said any of those things
UMC attracted absolutely nothing
whatsoever to say to their patient who
now at a potentially terminal cancer as
a result of their negligence at that
time we were both in desperate need of
the human touch in the form of a team of
caring professionals who were trained to
deal with the victims of serious harm we
needed someone who was trained to handle
such situations and would be able to
the practical emotional psychological
career medical and legal guidance that
we so desperately needed
for the first couple of weeks we naively
believe that such a person our team
existed and would reach out to us soon
but like most of the hospitals here in
2013 no such person our team existed in
UMC Utrecht no discipline aimed at
supporting patients traumatized by
medical error existed in the Netherlands
so we were told Peter and I tried to
explain what we felt should be happening
we knew instinctively what was missing
and we sought expertise from abroad to
support our views we went back to the
hospital and we told them there should
be an admission that something had gone
badly wrong in my case an apology from
the hospital board a discussion with all
of the parties involved a root cause
analysis an investigation that would
find out what had gone wrong a reports
drawn up that explained what happened so
that lessons could be learned and other
patients protected a special specialist
support for for both of us and for my
doctor and for just a touch of human
but our ideas were met with blank looks
shakes of the head genuine in
comprehension they had never heard of
such a program so what was on offer
instead was no support for the patient
no discussion about what had happened no
apology from the hospital no
investigation no report no informing the
health Inspectorate no answers and no
official record that anything at all had
ever happened and harmed Adrian Collin
at UMC attract the message we were
receiving loud and clear was at the
hospital had no further interest in my
case had no plans to talk to me to meet
me to provide any help or to take any
action what
mattered so much to Peter and me was a
little consequence to them compassion
and the human touch were totally absent
in the relationship between UMC Utrecht
and their patient I’m going to if you
don’t mind I’m gonna sit down just for a
second um since I started telling the
story of what happened to me at UMC
Utrecht of the medical negligence it’s
costing me my life of the crew away the
hospital dealt with us at every stage
and of the healthcare system in general
people have been getting in touch we’ve
had emails phone calls Twitter
whatsup conversations people coming to
see us and the stories have come
flooding out and often they’re stories
that have never been told to anybody
before neighbors colleagues friends
chance acquaintances and sometimes total
strangers young and old Dutch and
experts have been telling me what
happened to them and to their family and
friends at this stage I have enough
stories to fill a book it seems that a
lot of the people are feeling let down
by their hospitals in all parts of the
country and have been missing the human
touch that they too expected to find
when they were vulnerable and most
needed it just a few examples of the
stories I’ve been hearing a friend in
her 30s was given a breast implant in
light a hospital there was inexplicably
a size too big causing much pain and
discomfort when her own skin was
stretched over it
the surgeon never spoke to her about how
this had happened in his theater an
emergency department also enlightened
tried to send a patient home with
laxatives and enemas for constipation
even though her husband and daughter
told them that they were sure she’d had
a stroke and MRI carried out much too
late showed that she’d in fact had two
strokes a patient on the ward in The
Hague who had been confined to bed for a
week
ask the nurses to help her wash her long
hair she was handed a pair of scissors
I’m told to cut it off a breast cancer
patient who had been disease-free for
almost five years was told over the
phone on Christmas Eve that she had
metastasis on her liver she was at home
alone in Amsterdam at the time she’s
died since an ex-navy veteran needed a
knee operation but the surgeons in the
hague operated on the wrong one
leaving him permanently in a wheelchair
no one even said sorry an elderly woman
who developed an infection at the site
of her IV was cruelly accused of causing
it herself all of these stories and many
more came from my Dutch neighbors
colleagues and friends they’re not urban
myths and experts like me well we get
our own special treatment on top more
than 20 times in the past five and a
half years staff treating me in several
different hospitals as an outpatient in
the wards and even when I was in the
operating theatre have had some cutting
remark to make about that I live here
and I don’t speak Dutch I’ve been
shouted at have had the phone hung up on
me cruel mark remarks have been made and
one occasion I was ridiculed for not
understanding and laughed at out loud
other act expats tell me that they’ve
been given the same treatment orphanage
was lips pursed in disapproval when they
asked to speak English are a comment
along the lines of I’m a Dutchman and in
this country we speak Dutch other times
it was more serious a friend who needed
a sperm count tried his best to manage
in Dutch while on the phone to a clinic
in Amsterdam but the vocabulary around a
sperm count gets quite complicated so
after a while he started a struggle and
he asked if he could speak in English
immediately the phone went dead an
English friend was taken to hospital in
Rotterdam with an acute asthma
he’d forgotten his insurance card and
the hospital refused to treat him
because he couldn’t prove he was
entitled to be in the Netherlands they
simply left him at reception struggling
to breathe another expert was an English
colleague in a very young man he was he
needed sirak he needed a major surgery
and while he was in the ward waiting to
be taken down to theatres a nurse asked
him did they not have hospitals in his
country
unfortunately these and all the other
stories I have are the tip of the
iceberg and they’re uncomfortable to
listen to the behavior described is a
betrayal of the patients whose health is
solemnly entrusted to doctors nurses and
hospitals it’s also a betrayal of the
staff the many staff who performed their
jobs with compassion and professionalism
but in a strange way I take hope from
these stories I take them as an
indication that at last we’re beginning
to talk openly about a very distressing
problem that the human touch and the
human heart that guides it are not
always present in the places where we
most expect to find them and where we
most need them what we as patients need
to do is probably among the hardest
things that we’ll ever be asked of us we
need to call it out we need to challenge
it when it happens we need to talk back
politely but insistently and demand that
those looking after the most vulnerable
members of our society treat us with
respect and dignity and acknowledge that
we are equal partners in our own
healthcare and what are the hospital’s
need to do they need to listen to their
patients they also need to ensure that
their staff always have the resources
skills training and support that will
allow them to choose the human touch and
most of all they need to set down red
lines for behavior in hospitals lines
that must not be crossed ever
and the tasering of dementia patients
can be the first red line to be drawn
this isn’t Amnesty International’s job
this is our job thank you [Applause]
Please follow and like us: