Press "Enter" to skip to content

13 Lessons from the Past about the Future of the Internet | JONATHAN STUBBS | TEDxCIU


okay thank you

Oh so I’m a historian of the media

mainly Phil but today I’m going to talk

about the Internet and in some ways it’s

difficult for the historian to talk

about something which is so new which is

something which is happening right now

the my argument is that the best

perspective that we can get on the inter

comes from looking at the history of

other media and so I’m going to suggest

12 ways in which the past can shed light

on the present and maybe the future why

twelve well it was going to be thirteen

but one of them wasn’t very good so I

changed it okay so number one nobody

really knows anything so from the middle

of a huge social change the worlds of

later employments communication are

being reshaped in forums and people have

no idea how it’s going to end up the

people who invented the internet were

trying to change the world

but then it was a solution to

engineering problem in 1943 of the

chairman of IBM reportedly said I think

there’s a world barking four maybe five

computers and I think there are more

than five computers in the present today

but this is the state of knowledge of a

time of you were speaking Thomas Edison

who invented the phonograph the first

device for recording sounds thought that

people would use it for dictating

letters to their sacrifice Alexander

Graham Bell who invented the telephone

or the people would use it for sending

messages to their lovers they were

stupid they just work psychic they

didn’t know what they had

and we’re not cycling even so we don’t

know how things are going to end up okay

number two communication systems start

on open and end up close so Tim Wu has

suggested that there’s a cycle of

information technologies go through they

travel from open systems where many

contributors work on them to a closed

channel which is dominated by a single

company or cartel of companies in

America this has been the case with

radio newspapers cinema even television

and it’s the case where the Internet is

worth until the late 1990s the internet

was an open and free place where little

money changed hands today the Internet

has been colonized by a small number of

private corporations all based in the

same part of California and their

influence over public is absolutely

enormous so happy internet be a free and

open place again this takes me to my

third point which is that media

ownership is important people used to be

concerned about the power of people like

Rupert Murdoch who owned various

newspapers and television stations but

today that kind of monopoly power pales

into insignificance today Google

controls about 88 percent of online

search Facebook controls about 77% of

social media traffic

these are monopolies by any standards

and it means that’s two companies

control or dominates public access to

almost all media online so what can we

do

Jonathan Taplin has made

the case for breaking up companies like

Google forcing them to sell parts of the

sales off so they break up into smaller

less powerful organizations and this has

placed why would you ask a successful

company to diminish themselves but it

has happened before in the early 1980s

the American telephone system was

dominated by one company at Bell

Telephone Cystic but the government

required them to break up this number

loop so the mail system was slit up into

several smaller or local companies and

as a result telecommunication in America

became more capacitive and therefore

innovation increase okay my full points

our attention has a price and the cost

so a protection online is a commodity

companies like Facebook have a business

in in mining is attacked in extracting

this adaption and then selling it all to

appetizers for the highest price all the

media companies work like this as well

so television stations and newspapers

created audiences and then sold

advertising around their content to

advertisers who wanted to reach these

alliances but Facebook are better assets

the vendor reminding our attention and

then better and selling our personal

data to organizations and I think the

cost is to us because companies like

Facebook are so excellent as extracting

our attention it becomes very hard to

focus on other things that makes it hard

for us to avoid being distracted

internet is designed to distract us so

that our attention can be sold to

advertisers number 5 technology is

disruptive and by this I mean

economically

disrupt the number of jobs that will

soon become performed by software is

growing the rise of driverless cars is

very exciting unless you’re one of the

millions of people whose job involves

driving in some fashion there are

precedents to lace a few hundred years

ago most people around the world works

in agriculture industrialization took

these jobs away machinery meant that

fewer people needed to be employed in

agriculture the new jobs were created in

factories to replace these jobs but what

if this new industrial revolution is

something else

where will the new jobs come from in the

age of artificial intelligence and I

think the point is that capital wins

over labour which is to say that the

people who over the robots and own the

software are in a much better position

than people who they were previously

unemployed ok another six people stopped

valuing things when they have fruit so

what obvious effect of the internet has

been to reduce the value that people

place on things like films and

television music journalism we used to

get in these things for free now and as

a result they seem to be worth less to

people good quality news good quality

music is expensive to produce

but the audience to these things is less

willing to pay money for but it was

interesting is that we Instax Internet

services to be free as well how much

would we pay to use Facebook it’s

basically the cost 5 euros a month if

Google costs 10 euros a month who would

actually paid

I think that suggests that the holes

that these companies have over us is

actually quite weak if people are

completely unwilling to pay to use these

services it’s just they’re not really

valuable to people ok number seven we

live in information ghettos so hundreds

of years ago information was incredibly

scarce and therefore the people who have

access to this information became very

powerful today information is not scarce

but the information we receive is

increasingly tailored towards our

personal interests the right Eli Pariser

has called this the filter buff and it’s

the idea that social media and search

engines creates unique universes of

information for each of their users in

some ways this is good more specific

more targeted information is good but if

we live in our own information bubbles

it becomes hard to see things from the

point of view of other people doesn’t it

just quote from Mark Zuckerberg I’m sure

you regret saying this but he said a

squirrel died in front of your house may

be more relevant to you an interest

right now than people dying in Africa

we’ve seen shocking that the sad thing

is I think he’s probably right for most

people

something happening which is specific to

their location is more interesting than

famine or civil war I think most people

would prefer to read gossip online than

they would to read about the possibility

of nuclear war in

career the question is is that right

should they be more interested in

squirts them okay number eight our sense

of privacy is flexible I think we’re

getting used to the idea of being

surveilled by our own technology of

living under surveillance through the

mobile operators that we carry in our

pockets through our activities online

and people are really bought into the

idea of share sharing information online

is a social group but I think we’re now

sharing really means is allowing

companies like Facebook to sell personal

data and advertisers now people often

say that if you’ve got nothing to hide

nothing to hide you’ve done nothing

wrong about nothing too hard though it

has a fallacy I think we all happenings

are there are things that we would like

to tell her husbands or wives or I’ve

doctors that we wouldn’t like anybody

else to know that doesn’t mean they’re

wrong it just means we would like to

control who has access to private

information to thousands now on the

other hand privacy may be a relatively

recent concept before industrialization

it was common for humans to live much

closer together

and it was impossible to keep secrets

from your neighbors it was only in the

nineteenth century that people could

afford to live in private rooms and so

the modern sense the privacy developed

so people have tolerated less privacy in

the past and it’s lovely when they will

do so in the future as well

ok maama line digital information is not

permanent so I started writing my PhD

thesis way back in 2003 I kept it on a

disk like this if I still have that disk

today what could I do with it would I be

able to find a computer that could read

this is the way that we store

information and the format’s were used

and come obsolete very quickly the

number of computers that have optical CD

or DVD drives is reducing the number of

computers that have USB ports is

reducing as they replace by different

types of thoughts so information that’s

stored digitally is vulnerable to

becoming obsolete on the other hands

books going to work you have a book from

a few hundred years ago and it’s still

work this technology has not become

obsolete and I think this poses problems

for future histories if you want to

learn about the past you read documents

from the art you read letters that

people have written if all of this

information exists digitally there are

huge questions about how people are

ok now the ten but but the internet

makes it hard for us to escape the past

in a sense we are tied to the mistakes

we have made the things we’ve said

through the online presence that we’ve

created it’s harder than people to

reinvent themselves if a search of their

name bruza

photo or a common living light of many

years ago i think that the next

generation and political leaders will

have to be very boring if they’ve ever

made any mistakes that could embarrass

them in the future number eleven

technologies mainly empower the powerful

so the benefits of the internet cannot

be spread equally around the world

the main benefactors are those who are

already privileged in wealth spaces this

probe and shows us how many Internet

users there are per hundred hundred

inhabitants in the developed world and

so the other line is the developed oils

and the lower line is the developing

world we’ve had amazing what those terms

really need but I think what’s

interesting is exact between the

developed world and the developing world

is increasing more people in the

developed world are getting online that

people in developing countries so they

can’t between the haves and have-nots is

widely if you look at the most popular

people on Twitter and on Instagram it’s

people who are already famous it’s

people who have profile via common forms

of media so the loudest voices of social

media of people who already have Fame

and power and influence through other

means recently Facebook released some

data about where that money comes from

and they revealed that they receive

about $20 per user in the US and Canada

about $6 per user in Europe about $2 per

user in the asia-pacific region about $1

40 per user in the rest of the world

which i think means South America South

Asia and Africa so clearly they’re much

more interested in the marketing which

frees them up they get 10 times as much

money from the US and Canada us from the

rest of the world this is the market

that is valuable to them that finally

number 12 so the Internet is just a tool

it’s not ideological in itself it’s an

expression of power but it doesn’t

represent any specific opinions now it

does not cause revolutions the Arab

Spring was not the results of Twitter or

Facebook

the pretty grass did not create a

Reformation or lead to the scientific

record

Vasili safety these things that did not

emerge from that technology so I think

what matters even though the Internet is

a tool is how we use it and also who

uses that but also who benefits from and

if it should be us who benefits rather

than corporations ok [Applause]

Please follow and like us: