Press "Enter" to skip to content

Disrupting education | Sarah Pashley | TEDxHull


education is failing the UK economy how
do we know this well I think we know
this because employers are constantly
telling us that schools are not
producing young people with the skills
that they need they don’t have
leadership skills they can’t work
effectively in teams their verbal
communication skills are underdeveloped
they cannot project manage they’re not
able to work independently lots and lots
of things that you’d think that schools
would actually be doing really
effectively well I’m a head teacher and
if I look at who’s responsible for this
you have to say well surely it’s the
school’s surely the schools are to blame
well we we are to a certain extent but
you need to understand the context that
schools are operating in before you have
portion all the blame to the schools and
to the head teachers the key thing for
me is that the UK education system has
become totally obsessed with exams
schools are judged the on the
examination results that our students
achieve and it’s a really public
judgement because the Department for
Education in the UK
produces league tables which rank our
performance every year our performance
our examination performance against that
of every single school in the country
and parents look at the league tables
and judges and the media looks at a
league table and judges us and really
importantly for us the gods that is
Ofsted the schools looks at the league
tables and judge eaters as well and the
Ofsted judgment is absolutely key to any
school and anybody working within the
education system knows how obsessed we
are about about actually making sure
that we tick all the boxes for Ofsted
Ofsted are really funny about
examination results because what they
say is that you can’t be a good school
regardless of everything else that you
do you cannot be a good school unless
your GCSE results your a-level results
are at least good and good for Ofsted
isn’t just students coming in and making
expected progress oh no what Ofsted will
is for schools to add value so it’s all
about high aspirations high expectations
and I don’t have a problem with that
but it means that it’s really
challenging for all schools because
young people have got to come to us and
we are judged on the progress that they
make from the exams they take in primary
school aged 11 to the exams that they
take at the end of compulsory education
age 16 and students have got to make
better than expected progress in order
for the progress to be judged good so
that’s a real challenge for us a real
challenge because average is not good
enough so the other thing they say is
that the league tables the performance
tables also insist that our students
study eight GCSEs now many schools do
more than this but everybody’s got to do
eight so every single kid has got to
make better than expected progress in
eight subjects the problem for schools
is that because we’re so obsessed with
the examination results and because we
in most schools we only have a 25 hour
teaching week there is absolutely no
time for anything else other than to
teach to those exams and that
unfortunately is what we do so we do not
spend time encouraging our young people
to become leaders we do not allow them
to work in teams unless that’s actually
a part of the exam syllabus we do not
focus on verbal communications because
to be quite honest the English GCSE GCSE
English language isn’t interested in
verbal communication it’s not even
assess it’s interested in reading and
writing which i think is bonkers but you
know that’s the new exam introduced two
years ago and because that’s the exam
that’s what we do because we have become
slaves to the league tables we don’t
allow our young people to work
independently in schools because we’re
absolutely terrified if we do that then
they will not make the progress that we
have to have them make and we cannot
afford to for them to fail or for us to
fail if we come on to creativity which
is a real thing – that I am passionate
about as an art teacher
one of the performance measures that
schools are judged by is the English
Baccalaureate or ‘back it’s this
government’s preferred performance
measure for schools which means that
lots and lots of schools channel young
people into the English Baccalaureate
the ‘back consists of English maths
sciences history or geography and a
modern foreign language there is not a
single creative subject in the ‘back
there is no art there is no music there
is no dance there is no drama so what
we’re doing is we are actually forcing
schools to focus on some subjects at the
expense of all those wonderful creative
subjects that would deliver what our
employers are looking at before it would
deliver the innovation deliver the
creativity that employers need and that
young people are desperate to experience
brings me on to digital digital
technology we know is absolutely
integral to the success of our global
community yet in the UK 72% of large
businesses and 49% of small and medium
enterprises say that they cannot fill
the skills gap the tech skills gap
people are not coming to them with the
skills that they require yet again
schools should be developing young
people they are the digital generation
they are the bedroom coders they’re on
social media 24/7 yet we are not
producing young people with the skills
for digital skills that businesses need
the reason for that is because digital
is not in the English Baccalaureate
unbelievably it does not figure in the
‘back performance measure and because we
are slaves to the performance measures
we do not teach those skills
I think it’s criminal so what we get is
the performance tables the performance
measures that schools are judged by
actually steering schools into certain
curriculum pathways regardless of
whether we agree with them regardless of
whether they are right for our young
people and we all steer them down these
pathways at the expense of other really
exciting subjects that our young people
would love to study and there are
employers and our
he needs them to study one of my
favorite quotes is from Albert Einstein
now Albert Einstein said everyone is a
genius but if you judge a fish on its
ability to climb a tree it will live
it’s whole life believing it is stupid
in English schools at the moment we have
an awful lot of poor little fish
flapping around desperately trying to
climb trees and it’s really unfair on
them and it’s really unfair on the
businesses that we are supposed to be
feeding because those little fish will
be much better swimming in seas or
rivers that suit their aptitudes and
skills so coming back to the purpose of
this talk is education failing the UK
economy yes it is and the reason why
it’s failing the UK economy is because
we’ve become obsessed by exams because
their curriculum and our exam system is
not fit for purpose so what should the
21st century curriculum look like well
this is my opinion what I think we need
to do is to radically change the way we
actually structure our curriculum in
skills at the moment all students do a
core set of subjects once they get to
the later stages of secondary education
and at the moment that consists of
English and maths and Sciences and then
you have health and well-being which
fair enough or how to lead healthy
lifestyles and then you have citizenship
or fundamental British values or however
they want to package it which is all
about young people’s place in society
and developing an appropriate value set
well I think we should strip out the
English and maths because I don’t think
that English is necessarily about
communication in our schools at the
moment and I think we should replace
that with a subject which is about
communication and which place is equal
if not more emphasis on verbal
communication and social interaction
working together in teams as well as on
reading and writing and I think we
should strip maths
after the curriculum as well and I think
we should replace that with numeracy
because ultimately the core curriculum
should be about what everybody needs to
be successful in their personal lives
and in the world of work and we don’t
need a lot of the mathematics
which she’s taught as part of GCSE but
we do need very well-developed numeracy
skills the other thing I will put in
there because I think it’s just a
no-brainer is that everybody needs to
study digital because everybody uses
digital we are digital citizens and what
we have to do is make sure we handle
digital responsibly and that we’ve
developed tech-savvy young people who
can go out into the world of work and
actually deliver what employers and our
economy needs that will be my core
curriculum the thing that everybody
needs to study this for me is absolutely
key though I would then develop what
schools call the option curriculum the
subjects that kids are allowed to choose
and I would have three pathways I would
retain a sort of a Bakke looking pathway
where students can study English
language and English literature and they
do study history or geography in a
modern foreign language because those
subjects are valuable and they do
produce skills they’re just not right
for everybody I would also have a spend
pathway that kids could opt into where
you do your Sciences and yes absolutely
you do your pure maths and your
statistics and you do your digital your
technical digital and then finally my
favourite pathway would be the creative
pathway where we put back into the
curriculum all those amazing creative
subjects which switch people on and
encourage them to be creative thinkers
and express themselves creatively as
well but the key thing is that all three
pathways will be equally valued by the
performance measures and by Ofsted so
that schools are free to allow young
people to opt into the pathway which
best suits them and are not penalized by
the examination system and the league
tables which ultimately decide whether
or not we are judged a good school by
Ofsted few years ago I was head teacher
at the successful East Riding School and
at the time we thought we were amazing
and the league tables look like we were
amazing because we were the top
performing school in Yorkshire and
Humber for our examination results and
we were the xviii top performing school
in the country for our examination
results and we’d work really hard we had
to work really hard to
rise up the rankings for the league
tables and that had an opportunity to
meet Charlie Spencer who is executive
chairman Spencer group engineering hall
and I also met Finbar Dowling who was
then overseeing the development of the
new blade Factory for Siemens in Hull
and Charlie and Finbar spoke to me about
a new vision that they had for education
and they challenged my perceptions of
myself about whether I was a good head
teacher and of whether or not my school
was a good school because what they said
was that I might be churning out kids
with top-quality examination results but
did those kids have the skills that
Charlie and Finbar’s businesses needed
and I thought I haven’t got a clue
because I have never thought about what
you need because what drives me as a
head teacher is my performance in those
league tables and it made me rethink
absolutely everything I did because I
realized that I had become obsessed with
ticking the Ofsted boxes and driving my
school up the rankings and I had
forgotten about the purpose or what the
purpose of Education actually is and
that quite simply I think is to make
sure that young people are prepared for
the next steps after leaving school so
of course everything that Charlie and
Finbar said to me was true and I knew
that I had to stop doing what I was
doing and I had to join with them and
rethink how education should be
delivered so I’ve been working in
partnership with Charlie Spencer and a
big team of employers and what we’ve
been looking at is an employer engaged
model of learning and what we think
learning should look like is this
employer engagement has to start from
the perspective of the skills so you
have to involve businesses in designing
and developing the curriculum yes
students need to sit exams and yes lots
of things that we’re currently doing
needs to be incorporated into that
curriculum but really importantly we
have to consult the employers in
designing it because if it doesn’t start
from what they need we will not deliver
young people who can slot into those
businesses and have a really positive
impact on our economy secondly and this
is where we need the employers to step
up they need to stop moaning
that need to start doing because they
have to support teachers to deliver the
technical and the specialist aspects of
that curriculum where teachers some of
us may well have worked in industry but
we are not working in industry now so
our knowledge is not current so what we
need to do is join forces with people
from industry coming into school to work
with teachers to teach the specialist
and the technical skills and the
employability skills that young people
need thirdly I think we need to cut down
at the number of exams that kids do and
what we need to do is to do the subjects
in much more detail we need to do the
subjects bigger if you like and we need
to create opportunities where young
people can take the theory that they’re
learning in classrooms with teachers and
apply that theory to real projects set
by employers to contextualize the
learning to make kids think much more
deeply about what skills they have learn
and apply them to something because if
you do that you deepen their theoretical
understanding and you make the learning
real
and finally employer engagement needs to
involve the employers providing the
careers information advice and guidance
that schools are currently trying to do
now we’re teachers we haven’t got a clue
about what engineering consists of or
all the amazing opportunities there are
in digital what we need to do is we need
to to broker the the employers coming
into our schools to actually talk to the
young people about what they do what are
the career opportunities in their
industries and really importantly in the
21st century
where technology is moving at such a
rapid pace we need them to be predicting
the sorts of jobs that young people
could move into in the future we can’t
do that as teachers we’ve got some
brilliant careers advisers but what we
need is absolutely amazing
industry experts talking to our young
people so they can inform the pathways
that they take ok so coming back to the
purpose of this talk then is education
failing the UK economy absolutely it is
absolutely we can’t deny it and the
reason for that is as I’ve just said we
need the employees to be working where
the school’s students are studying too
many exam subjects the content of the
exams is not covering the skills that
the employers need the curriculum is far
too narrow and the thing that’s driving
all of this is the performance measures
for schools which prioritize some
subjects over others if we change the
performance tables we will change what
schools do because that’s what drives us
and changes the keyword because I think
at the moment we are failing young
people in schools we are quite clearly
failing businesses and we are most
definitely failing the UK economy if we
keep doing the same thing over and over
again or tinkering at the margins
changing the odds subject here and there
then we are not going to have the impact
that we need so what we’ve got to do is
actually do it completely differently so
employers must get involved with the
schools that have got to work in
partnership with educators so that the
curriculum that we put in place and the
way we deliver it is fit for purpose and
works for them we have to reduce the
number of example subjects so we can
create opportunities within the school
week to contextualize the learning we
have to incorporate employability skills
into the exam subjects themselves if you
put leadership in an exam we will teach
leadership because our kids have got to
develop those skills to get the grades
that we need them to get if you don’t
put it in the exam we will not teach it
really sad but that’s the absolute true
fact because we do not have time to do
anything else
we have to broaden the curriculum to
make sure that we have opportunities for
everybody so that all young people can
tap into there what makes them tick and
their particular aptitudes and interest
but really importantly to broaden the
skills that we are teaching young people
as well so they fit with what employers
want and then obviously to do it all we
have to change the performance measures
so all subjects and all curriculum
pathways must have equity and if we
prioritize as well within those
performance measures the destinations
that our students move on to when they
finish school which after all is the
month
the absolute purpose of what we do
if we put those into the performance
measures so that we have teachers or has
had teachers are judged aware our kids
go from us then that will make sure that
we prioritize the the careers and the
higher education opportunities that you
move onto in a way that we really don’t
think about now and the key thing for me
is that we have to do this now because
as I’ve said we are failing lots of
people and we are failing our employers
and we are failing the economy and if we
don’t do that now that little duck that
was my metaphor for the struggling UK
economy is never ever going to get its head above the water
Please follow and like us: