Press "Enter" to skip to content

Community Design for Affordability | Ryan Kilpatrick | TEDxHarveyStreet


[Music]
so most of the time when you buy things
anywhere in the marketplace you have a
lot of choices to make right when you
buy a soda when you buy a cheeseburger
you can choose all kinds of things about
what you’re gonna buy one of the things
we’re great at is altering choices based
on size there’s the family size there’s
the compact size there’s the perfect
size for whatever it is that you want to
do one of we’re not very good at is
providing a lot of choice in the
marketplace when it comes to housing and
a lack of choice very often leads to a
lack of affordability today that’s
dealing with a lack of affordability in
your local housing market as we are very
often in West Michigan a big reason for
that is because there’s a lack of choice
in the marketplace so what you’re seeing
right now is an example of a local
zoning ordinance zoning is often adopted
by a local municipality city or Township
and very often what they do is they
regulate things based on size they
regulate homes based on where they can
be placed how big the lot is how big the
unit can be how big the bedrooms have to
be in some instances how many closets
you have very often these regulations
are imposed by benevolent planning
commissioners who are trying to do the
right thing for the community based on
community input based on preservation of
property values based on the character
of the existing surroundings but what we
don’t understand is that all of those
little decisions add up to big costs so
over time the cost of sticks
two-by-fours and drywall and roofing
materials every time you add a closet or
you add a bedroom or you add an extra
150 square feet you’re adding cost for
the end consumer and you’re eliminating
choice from the equation so the result
is we get a lot of neighborhoods that
look like this and I’ve been really I
the number of conversations we’ve had
today about the importance of connection
and I want you to think about this
neighborhood relative to maybe your own
neighborhood and the fact that in this
site plan the drawing shows an
individual swimming pool and
backyard right what happened to
community connection what happened to
the public swimming pool right we’re
designing our communities in a way that
eliminates that connectivity in ways
that allow us not to look our neighbors
in the eye and in a lot of instances
this kind of community is important
there there’s an important place for
this community in the marketplace
an important place for this type of
housing in the marketplace but we’ve got
to have alternative choices and very
often not doing is building those
choices into our environment so think
about this kind of a housing unit today
typically costs about a hundred and
sixty-five to two hundred dollars a
square foot to build and so if the local
zoning ordinance says that that housing
unit has to be at least 1500 square feet
in order for it to be legal in your
municipality you’re creating a minimum
cost of two hundred and fifty to two
hundred and eighty thousand dollars to
build that unit then you add on the cost
of acquisition for the land plus the
hookup for utilities plus all of the
other amenities that need to go into the
unit and you’re looking at minimum
housing prices in our market today of
two hundred and eighty-five to three
hundred and twenty five thousand dollars
which is great for a segment of the
marketplace but it’s not great for a
much bigger segment in the marketplace
so here’s an example of what local
zoning does very often we establish
minimum lot size minimum lot coverage
minimum setbacks and it creates a very
small box within which we can put things
and that lack of choice results in a
lack of affordability and results in a
lack of opportunity for the two biggest
generations in our society today so
Millennials and baby boomers are the
biggest generations we’ve ever seen in
the United States of America
and one-third of baby boomers right now
demand a walkable urban environment and
they prioritize place over size two
thirds of Millennials prioritized place
over size they would much rather have a
walkable in urban environment when all
other things are equal then have a
suburban drivable Empire
so this is a graph of wage distribution
in Ottawa County the numbers aren’t
important what’s important is low-end is
$10,000 a year salaries and at the far
right is $200,000 a year salaries the
vast majority of incomes are on that
left hand bactrim more than 60% of our
population is earning incomes below what
it requires to be able for a two hundred
and fifty two thousand dollar a year
home so this housing type is actually
significantly in demand in the
marketplace but we don’t allow for it in
most of our municipalities we don’t
allow for it in most of our townships in
most of our cities in many of our urban
corridors part of the reason for that is
because those unit types tend to have
smaller square footages they tend to
have small more in footprints and the
problem with that is local zoning
outlaws that they say it’s not big
enough our standards in our local
municipality here’s an example of a kid
64 square feet very often we were to be
something more like a hundred and fifty
or two hundred and fifty square feet the
sprawling open floor plan the OSC and
Better Homes and Gardens that you see on
HGTV is great if you can afford it it’s
not so great if you can here’s a forty
five square foot dining room it’s great
if you can have a big sprawling dining
room but if you can’t afford it why
should we mandate it here’s a cottage
cluster of houses these houses don’t sit
on individual Lots they share a central
courtyard these counted somewhere
between 700 and 900 square feet but for
the most part these are not legal in
most of West Michigan because they’re
too small this townhouse has a 900
square foot footprint it’s not legal in
most of West Michigan because it’s too
small this is a carriage house with an
apartment above a garage this is a great
opportunity not only to build
affordability to an existing
neighborhood but also to build in
opportunities for existing homeowners to
add wealth and equity so it’s a source
of income for maybe an aging single
adult because they’re able to rent out
the apartment above their garage and
it’s also an inexpensive
for a young millennial just out of
cottage college to rent someplace where
they don’t have to have a roommate where
they know they’re in a safe neighborhood
and they’ve got access to local news but
again it’s not legal in most of the West
Michigan so here’s an example of how
we’re prioritizing things for the most
part on the right you’ve got an example
of the amount of space that parking
often takes up in our zoning codes and
therefore in our built environment
typically 1 to 2 parking spaces is the
equivalent of a 650 square foot
apartment very often we’re mandating
that any use that gets built has a
minimum two parking spaces per dwelling
unit or one parking space for every 300
square feet of retail space and so very
often we get a lot more parking than we
do housing units and more parking than
there is housing we get a shortage of
housing and a plethora of parking and so
what happens in the marketplace is we
all expect to have free and convenient
parking everywhere we go but we expect
to have affordable housing everywhere we
go we’ve accepted the fact that housing
gets too expensive what if we flipped
that right what if we expected that
there was affordable housing in every
community not that it was luxurious or
huge or that you had all the amenities
you could ever want but there was a safe
dry warm place to live in any community
well this is an example of the city of
Hudsonville plan there are people in
your community today that are doing
great things to plan for these types of
communities the just outside the window
this building today are those beginning
seeds of this kind of a community but
what’s important is for you all to stay
connected to that process whether you’re
local or regional or you’ve got a
community at home elsewhere it’s
important to be invested in these
processes because people are making
things about what can get built they’re
making decisions about how big it has to
be about how it’s going to be staged
about how it connects with other things
in the community and if you’re not
invested in those choices import
participating in the conversation very
often you get the kind of product that
we’ve gotten over the last 40 years
which is great for a slice of the market
but not great for the entire market
so what we’re advocating for is building
places where connection is not only
possible but almost require is building
places where you can go hang out at the
local coffee shop where you can come to
a TEDx event and it’s in walking
distance to your apartment where you can
get food you can go to the library you
can go to school and work and you’re
able to make all of those choices
because those choices were built into
the urban environment based on decisions
that will the local unit of government
made I hope you’ll all stay connected to
your local unit of government
you’ll stay connected to the process and
you’ll you’ll become more invested in
your local community thank you
[Applause] [Music]
Please follow and like us: