Press "Enter" to skip to content

Minding the Fault Lines | Claudia Horwitz | TEDxWashingtonSquare


for the last 25 years I have been
supporting people to work for social
change across boundaries boundaries like
race age class sexual identity gender
and no matter what I’m doing whether I’m
leading a workshop or running a meeting
or helping to host a large conference I
work to keep this one vow that I made 25
years ago which is basically just to
engage that group in a period of quiet
together some mindfulness meditation or
gentle yoga I believe we have barely
tapped the potential of these practices
to really transform our politics and our
future and today I want to show you how
early in the black lives matter movement
I was living in Houston and like a lot
of other cities people there were
holding town meetings organizing
protests advocating for body cams all
really vital actions there wasn’t
however a lot of opportunity for people
to come together and really connect
across racial lines I was working at a
place called the Rothko Chapel which is
a very unique singular space for art
spiritual practice in human rights and
we decided to host a community forum
called black lives matter getting beyond
the hashtag we wanted folks of course to
hear from experts of color so we invited
historian and elder young organizer
incredible voices of wisdom and we also
wanted people to have an opportunity to
actually feel their feelings in the
midst of a turbulent time and really
hear each other so I also led this very
short guided meditation just inviting
people into their heart into their
breath and I explicitly welcomed these
specific emotions I knew we were feeling
things like fear rage grief compassion
confusion motivation and then people
split up into small groups to talk
across race and age lines and pretty
soon the space filled with that buzz of
folks laughing and crying and when we
came back together we opened up the
space for people to share black parents
talked about their communal concern for
black youth a white woman discussed her
struggles with a really racist and
reactionary relative and a journalist
talked about the challenges of covering
all of these complexities in today’s
media and everybody was witnessed with
great compassion and great attention I
tell you this story because if we are
really interested in true social
transformation it’s likely we are
spending a lot of time in groups our
progress depends on how well we can hang
together and get things done
whether that’s shifting policy building
alternative institutions or stopping a
war and these groups mean that we are by
definition in today’s society crossing a
lot of boundaries in fact we’re being
asked to cross more boundaries more
often and with a lot greater skill this
is really exciting because there’s a lot
of creative energy at the boundary think
about those places where the sea meets
the shore where an open field
transitions to forest or that edge of
society where revolutionary ideas come
from differences meet at a boundary and
there’s great possibilities that abound
but these boundaries are also a real
test of our humanity these lines of
difference can really really easily
become fault lines our good behavior one
on one it doesn’t translate up so easily
the larger and more diverse groups got
the more competitive and less friendly
we tend to be we can certainly see this
today in our political climate or around
hot-button issues we know what it looks
like and even when we do agree we
stumble we fail to build on each other’s
good ideas and we’re not so great at
creating trust that would really allow
for the kind of work we need over the
long haul so just take that in a minute
what does that mean not to be able to
build these relationships of trust I
think part of it is that we are raised
to fear or reject what we don’t
understand this manifests often as what
we could call implicit bias we all have
that those are assessments that it lie
deep in the subconscious they tend to
start early on just by nature of the
society we live in and they continue to
motivate our behavior I have this you
have this we’ve seen the devastating
effects of implicit bias when it comes
to race and racism and we need to get
braver about acknowledging how it
unfolds in our daily lives as a white
woman working mostly in multiracial
settings I’ve had so much opportunity to
examine my own failings and interrogate
my own biases there’s a lot of times
where it would be much easier for me to
just freeze up in my confusion or let my
anxiety about making a mistake push me
to a safer sideline but I have been
really lucky to have places that allow
for vulnerability around this and I’ve
tried to create those kinds of spaces
for other people I’ve seen what happens
when the rough edges of racism are met
with a gentle fierceness and I know the
difference now between unhealthy shame
and healthy regret think about that what
is the difference between unhealthy
shame and healthy regret I also know
what’s possible when we meet at the
boundary with courage and that’s where
practice comes in there’s been so much
amazing research that we know so much
about the benefits of these practices
like meditation and yoga increased
attention span greater ability to
regulate emotions and cope with stress
less depression students acting out less
there’s even been one study and we need
a lot more that has shown that
meditation can reduce implicit bias
around race and age and this makes sense
intuitively think about how a little bit
of mindfulness can really begin to shift
and slow down that mental stream of
activity that seems so constant how it
like interrupts the conditioning and how
it can enable us to step back into what
the Yogi’s call witness consciousness
which is a kind of meta awareness that
allows for non-attachment and a lot more
wisdom and compassion to come through I
want to invite you just to take a look
around the room and imagine right now I
won’t do it but imagine I asked you to
get into small groups with three or four
people that you don’t know and then
imagine I asked you to share a little
bit about your own biases or your
experiences with racism notice what
arises for you maybe curiosity maybe a
little bit of discomfort I know I could
start to feel that in my belly you might
feel it in your chest or in your jaw and
of course we don’t want to live in this
place of tension so let’s take a nice
inhale and exhale little breathing room
is what allows us
to come back to wiser thinking and our
best selves taking another breath in and
another breath out and one more nice
full breath in and exhale when I get a
little breathing room
I can observe my own thoughts and other
people with less judgment and I’m Way
more open that’s the witness and it has
so much power to short-circuit these
prejudices these biases even the effects
of internalized oppression for this
reason I feel like we need to be super
planful and intentional about how we
include practice in every kind of
political and activist group experience
that were a part of I plan for it now
intentionally so that I can keep that
valley me 25 years ago it’s just like
planning what food to serve or it can be
an intervention sometimes if I notice
someone in a meeting starting to round
forward I know something’s going on that
maybe isn’t the most productive
contribution so I just invite them to
inhale open their chest and drop their
shoulders you can try that right now and
I’ve also called for practice when it’s
so clear that talking has run its course
and people need to drop down from their
head into their heart or their gut many
years ago I was working with a high
school program for students it was a
faith-based program the topic of race
came up and a lot of things started
happening at once white students were
sort of acting out of traditional
stereotypes and students of color were
very frustrated and understandably angry
so we met as a staff to try to figure
out what to do and we had a rich
conversation but it didn’t lead to a lot
of clarity so I just suggested that we
take 10 minutes together to be quiet
after 10 minutes were up and I came out
of my own meditation practice I looked
around the room and I saw my colleagues
my friend Jason a white rabbi was
standing at the window
preying my friend Liz whose Catholic and
latina was on her knees with her hands
clasped in prayer and Christian and
african-american Baptist had taken his
Bible out we regrouped and wisdom just
flew around the circle we quickly came
up with a plan to introduce a framework
of oppression Center the voices of
students of color and give everyone a
chance to speak so what I’m saying is
this I didn’t learn the skills to cross
boundaries when I was growing up you
probably didn’t either but we can learn
them now and we have to our collective
survival and our shared humanity it
depends on me and you breaking through
the fears we have and literally re
patterning our behavior so that these
fault these lines of difference don’t
become fault lines I believe that this
nation is in its early adolescence when
it comes to engaging the realities and
the consequences of racism and I believe
we all want to grow up and the good news
is that these practices that thirty
million of us are using every day can
help these are the ways that we start to
shift but we have to be willing we have
to be willing to scale up mindfulness so
that we can meet at the boundary and
build relationships of solidarity and
that means we have to be willing to be
brave to struggle even squirm it’s like
going further in a yoga pose if we’re
mindful of a stretch it is a really
fruitful place of growth and expansion
if we’re mindless we can get hurt if we
relax into the breath and the body the
mind softens and what is difficult
becomes generative this is just like
cells building a body it starts with our
daily interactions the groups you find
yourselves in difficult family
conversations meetings at work or at
school the activism you’re a part of
lunch right now
I believe that we all want with those
folks in Houston wanted what those
students wanted what every group I’ve
ever worked with has wanted to be seen
and heard for who we really are
to connect authentically across lines of
difference and to move together toward justice thank you
Please follow and like us: