Press "Enter" to skip to content

Game Day Rivalry: Academics vs Athletics | Mary Willingham | TEDxUCDavisSF


[Music]

Wow well it’s a great day if you’re a

Tarheel fan because we beat Duke last

night but I wasn’t really going to start

with that but I couldn’t help myself

I was going to start with the memory a

memory that I have of being a girl

growing up in my house the house that I

grew up in on the south side of Chicago

in a small town called Beverly it was

1971 so yes this gray is for real 1971

and I was sitting on the stairs

listening to my parents talk and I

didn’t realize it at the time but they

were talking about segregation they were

talking about residential segregation

and the activism that they were doing

back in those days but what I remember

and it resonated with me all these years

what I heard them saying was that as

parents we all want the same thing for

our children we want our children to

grow up in safe neighborhoods with good

schools and that that’s something that

I’ve thought about a lot over the years

but I didn’t know you know flash-forward

35 years and I’d be arguing some of

these same basic principles and talking

about some of these issues but not in a

neighborhood but in a well a much bigger

neighborhood in college towns all across

the United States of America because of

that realization my upbringing and what

I learned from my parents when they

didn’t even probably think I was paying

attention I got into a little bit of

trouble in the town that I lived and

worked in as a grown up my husband Chuck

and I decided to raise our three now

grown children in Chapel Hill North

Carolina and you’ve probably you

probably are familiar not just by the

fact that we beat Duke last night the

Tar Heels let me mention that again but

rub that in but also you probably are

familiar with some of our notable sports

figures Michael Jordan and perhaps Mia

Hamm but the University of North

Carolina is also in

amazing research institution and it’s

one of our oldest and finest public

universities in the country and while we

were living there I changed careers from

human resource professional to an

educator and on this glorious day in

2003 I walked on to the Carolina campus

as a new employee I was so excited I had

I was pinching myself

I had actually really found my dream job

in higher education and I had intended

and then did complete another degree so

it was just fantastic and a fantastic

day but as I mentioned I hit a little

bump in that red cobblestone beautiful

pavement nine years into my higher

education career I blew the whistle and

called fall on academic and athletic

fraud the UNC case this academic fraud

case has since become known as the

largest and longest academic fraud case

in the history of college sports what on

earth was I thinking um what what

happened what followed was so

unbelievable and I really had no idea

what would follow but university leaders

tried very hard to silence me and to

scare me as has the NCAA in a recent

after going public with a local reporter

from the News & Observer Dan Kane I was

subjected to death threats hate mail and

an amazing discrediting campaign and I

believe this well of course I was

demoted and stripped of my title and

moved to the basement like all other

whistleblowers and if you’ve seen the

movie I did bring my stapler with me

god have a good stapler so but I believe

that this this all are allergic reaction

to whistleblowers stems from our own

maybe unconscious desires for secrets

and for this code of silence no one at

Carolina spoke up 22 years of academic

fraud the faculty didn’t say anything

the deans didn’t say anything

administrators students parents it’s

it’s amazing really when you think about

it that the truth of the matter is that

game days are spectacular we love we

love game days and I believe that game

days give us a snapshot of what is

fundamentally wrong with our current

culture we’re the only country in the

world to connect athletics and academics

and by doing so I believe that we have

emphasized sports and entertainment

especially in higher education but it

really trickles all the way down and

we’ve de-emphasized academics one thing

that is really striking about athletics

versus academics is that these athletes

are being told in a contract that

instead of paying money they’re going to

be given a world-class education and

this is oftentimes not true athletes in

Division one sports in particular and I

talked about what we sometimes know is

revenue sports but we’ve now called them

the profit sports Division one

basketball and football players in

particular they don’t have the same

experience that regular students have so

think about your own academic experience

and then we think about these athletes

and I worked with them for seven years

they actually don’t have access to the

same education because they can’t really

work part-time jobs or do

internships they have mandatory summer

school

they can’t take classes or labs in the

late afternoon so this is a bit of a

struggle they really are

steered to particular majors we see this

on College GameDay we actually see

athletes who have you know their we see

it on the screen that they’re all in the

same two or three majors but one thing

that you should understand about the

Carolina case that I should explain is

that the the way this athletic

eligibility system was created was that

a slate of paper classes were made a

bogus paper classes in a particular

Department and athletes were steered to

these particular classes and these

classes were a paper a prompt was given

but no work was really done this paper

was maybe copy or pasted from an

internet site or a book and so many

people on campus knew that this was

going on an investigative high high

profile investigative reporter has since

Donna reports and made public a lot of

these documents to show that this is

this is a verified system but some still

deny at Carolina that this paper class

system existed but what it did really

was it kept these athletes between 1988

and 2011 from getting what we promised

them which was a real education I

believe they were victimized by this

paper class system another good example

of how these athletes are not

necessarily students at all they’re

athletes is when we take a look at our

Bowl team that went to a bowl game the

year that I spoke out these athletes

together had I think maybe it’s back a

slide I’m not sure oh no here it is –

here it is 17 students so 17 football

players starters and regular players

together

I had a 2.3 GPA

the average at Caroline is about a 3.2

and together they had ten semesters of

academic probation so below a 2.0 there

were 29 FS and 53 DS on their unofficial

transcripts literacy is part of the

problem with all of this too and as an

educator I realized this but probably

half of these this group of players were

reading below grade level and from my

experience as a reading specialist at

least two or non-readers so literacy

really is at the core of these problems

and many of these players are

underprepared for the academic rigor of

the institutions yet we let them in the

front door and all of this stems again

from our connected silence and our

rationalizations that we are really

giving these young people a chance that

maybe they wouldn’t have otherwise

gotten but but I argue that this is such

a serious problem because then they’re

leaving the institution without anything

at all because we know that only a few

percent really do make it to the pros

and what we really need to consider here

is that race is the whale that is

swimming just below the surface because

you see black students men in particular

only make up 2.8 percent of our

undergraduate populations yet more than

half of those on our football team and

those are our basketball teams in

Division one our black males so really

this is all a charade by the NCAA and a

myth designed to make white mostly white

fan bases feel good well while our black

athletes are exploited I believe that

there’s something else that we can

connect here with college sports and

that’s our black lives matter movement

because I really truly believe that

college sports is another way that we

actually it’s another social injustice

system it’s another way that we are

keeping a group of people young men

and we really need to together break

this silence this crippling code of

silence that’s really enforced by the

NCAA and its member institutions a real

cartel we need to gather speak out and

break this silence and we need to make

sure that education and learning is a

priority so that these young people are

getting what they really deserve we need

to we need to drive home the importance

of learning and education just like we

asked our athletes to drive the ball

down the hardwood floors or across the

50-yard line we really need to make this

a public conversation so that we can

change the what just filters all the way

down through our education system and

really it’s the only way that we can say

what my parents were saying back in 1971

when I was a young girl sitting on the

stairs listening and not really knowing

enough to offer an opinion but what my

parents were seeing which is a universal

truth is that all of us as parents want

the same thing for our children and we

need to come together and make sure that

our young athletes are no longer

exploited and that by doing that I

believe that we’re going to show our

children and especially our black

children in this country that their

lives really do matter to us thank you very much

Please follow and like us: