Press "Enter" to skip to content

Attracting foster carers: A social marketing perspective | Melanie Randle | TEDxUWollongong


[Applause]
[Applause] [Music]
thank you everyone
thank you everyone my name is Melanie Randall and I’m from
my name is Melanie Randall and I’m from
my name is Melanie Randall and I’m from the marketing discipline at the
the marketing discipline at the
the marketing discipline at the University of Wollongong and I’d like to
University of Wollongong and I’d like to
University of Wollongong and I’d like to talk to you today about foster care at
talk to you today about foster care at
talk to you today about foster care at the moment in Australia we have around
the moment in Australia we have around
the moment in Australia we have around 18,000 children in foster care foster
18,000 children in foster care foster
18,000 children in foster care foster care it refers to a situation where a
care it refers to a situation where a
care it refers to a situation where a child is identified it but as being at
child is identified it but as being at
child is identified it but as being at risk or unsafe in their own home
risk or unsafe in their own home
risk or unsafe in their own home environment and so they’re removed from
environment and so they’re removed from
environment and so they’re removed from that environment and place in
that environment and place in
that environment and place in alternative care usually for a temporary
alternative care usually for a temporary
alternative care usually for a temporary period and often we can identify family
period and often we can identify family
period and often we can identify family or close friends that are suitable to
or close friends that are suitable to
or close friends that are suitable to take care of that child during that time
take care of that child during that time
take care of that child during that time but in many cases there is no family
but in many cases there is no family
but in many cases there is no family member or close friend to do that job
member or close friend to do that job
member or close friend to do that job and so we rely on people volunteering to
and so we rely on people volunteering to
and so we rely on people volunteering to become foster carers and give these
become foster carers and give these
become foster carers and give these children homes for as long as they need
children homes for as long as they need
children homes for as long as they need until it’s safe for them to return to
until it’s safe for them to return to
until it’s safe for them to return to their biological home so in that sense
their biological home so in that sense
their biological home so in that sense you could view foster caring as an
you could view foster caring as an
you could view foster caring as an extreme form of volunteering and it’s
extreme form of volunteering and it’s
extreme form of volunteering and it’s extreme because of the high level of
extreme because of the high level of
extreme because of the high level of commitment that’s required but also
commitment that’s required but also
commitment that’s required but also because of all the unknown factors like
because of all the unknown factors like
because of all the unknown factors like which child you might be asked to care
which child you might be asked to care
which child you might be asked to care for and how long your are asked to give
for and how long your are asked to give
for and how long your are asked to give that care and what we were finding when
that care and what we were finding when
that care and what we were finding when we started this research around 10 years
we started this research around 10 years
we started this research around 10 years ago is that the number of foster
ago is that the number of foster
ago is that the number of foster children had been steadily increasing in
children had been steadily increasing in
children had been steadily increasing in Australia over many years but at the
Australia over many years but at the
Australia over many years but at the same time the number of people
same time the number of people
same time the number of people volunteering to be foster carers had
volunteering to be foster carers had
volunteering to be foster carers had been declining and what that meant was
been declining and what that meant was
been declining and what that meant was that foster care agencies were finding
that foster care agencies were finding
that foster care agencies were finding it more and more difficult to find
it more and more difficult to find
it more and more difficult to find enough foster carers in homes to place
enough foster carers in homes to place
enough foster carers in homes to place all of the children that actually needed
all of the children that actually needed
all of the children that actually needed them and so what that meant was that if
them and so what that meant was that if
them and so what that meant was that if we can’t they couldn’t create good
we can’t they couldn’t create good
we can’t they couldn’t create good matches between the individual needs of
matches between the individual needs of
matches between the individual needs of the children needing homes and the
the children needing homes and the
the children needing homes and the specific skills and backgrounds
specific skills and backgrounds
specific skills and backgrounds backgrounds of the carers that when able
backgrounds of the carers that when able
backgrounds of the carers that when able would enable these foster placements to
would enable these foster placements to
would enable these foster placements to be stable because we know that if
be stable because we know that if
be stable because we know that if placements are stable that it creates
placements are stable that it creates
placements are stable that it creates the longer-term positive outcomes for
the longer-term positive outcomes for
the longer-term positive outcomes for foster children so what we so you might
foster children so what we so you might
foster children so what we so you might be sitting there saying well what has
be sitting there saying well what has
be sitting there saying well what has all this got to do is marketing well
all this got to do is marketing well
all this got to do is marketing well when we first started talking to our
when we first started talking to our
when we first started talking to our foster care agency partners about the
foster care agency partners about the
foster care agency partners about the challenges they were facing it occurred
challenges they were facing it occurred
challenges they were facing it occurred to us that actually so
to us that actually so
to us that actually so of the issues that we’re facing had
of the issues that we’re facing had
of the issues that we’re facing had similarities with typical marketing
similarities with typical marketing
similarities with typical marketing problems so in marketing we try to
problems so in marketing we try to
problems so in marketing we try to identify the people or the customers who
identify the people or the customers who
identify the people or the customers who are likely to be interested in the
are likely to be interested in the
are likely to be interested in the product or service that we have and in
product or service that we have and in
product or service that we have and in foster care we want to identify the
foster care we want to identify the
foster care we want to identify the types of people who are most likely to
types of people who are most likely to
types of people who are most likely to be really good in the role as foster
be really good in the role as foster
be really good in the role as foster carers in marketing we then try to
carers in marketing we then try to
carers in marketing we then try to design a product or service that suits
design a product or service that suits
design a product or service that suits the needs of that customer group really
the needs of that customer group really
the needs of that customer group really well and in foster care we try to create
well and in foster care we try to create
well and in foster care we try to create a foster caring experience that is
a foster caring experience that is
a foster caring experience that is rewarding in some way in marketing we
rewarding in some way in marketing we
rewarding in some way in marketing we develop marketing communication
develop marketing communication
develop marketing communication campaigns which often involve ads that
campaigns which often involve ads that
campaigns which often involve ads that are meaningful and motivating to the
are meaningful and motivating to the
are meaningful and motivating to the particular customer group that we’re
particular customer group that we’re
particular customer group that we’re trying to reach and in foster care we
trying to reach and in foster care we
trying to reach and in foster care we try to develop marketing communications
try to develop marketing communications
try to develop marketing communications campaigns that reach and are motivating
campaigns that reach and are motivating
campaigns that reach and are motivating for the particular types of people that
for the particular types of people that
for the particular types of people that we know are likely to be good in the
we know are likely to be good in the
we know are likely to be good in the role and finally in marketing we talk
role and finally in marketing we talk
role and finally in marketing we talk about customer loyalty which refers to
about customer loyalty which refers to
about customer loyalty which refers to customers not only purchasing our
customers not only purchasing our
customers not only purchasing our product or service once but coming back
product or service once but coming back
product or service once but coming back again and again to keep purchasing that
again and again to keep purchasing that
again and again to keep purchasing that product or service and in foster care
product or service and in foster care
product or service and in foster care it’s about not just having people
it’s about not just having people
it’s about not just having people volunteer to become foster carers but to
volunteer to become foster carers but to
volunteer to become foster carers but to actually continue in that role for as
actually continue in that role for as
actually continue in that role for as long as possible so we went around
long as possible so we went around
long as possible so we went around designing a program of research that
designing a program of research that
designing a program of research that might try to answer some of these
might try to answer some of these
might try to answer some of these questions because at the time we didn’t
questions because at the time we didn’t
questions because at the time we didn’t have answers to these questions but
have answers to these questions but
have answers to these questions but recognizing how complex the problem is
recognizing how complex the problem is
recognizing how complex the problem is we needed researchers from different
we needed researchers from different
we needed researchers from different disciplines from marketing and
disciplines from marketing and
disciplines from marketing and psychology and creative arts that came
psychology and creative arts that came
psychology and creative arts that came from different universities and we also
from different universities and we also
from different universities and we also had to partner with foster care agencies
had to partner with foster care agencies
had to partner with foster care agencies that ranged in terms of their size and
that ranged in terms of their size and
that ranged in terms of their size and geographic locations so that the
geographic locations so that the
geographic locations so that the outcomes of our research would be as
outcomes of our research would be as
outcomes of our research would be as generalizable as possible and I wanted
generalizable as possible and I wanted
generalizable as possible and I wanted to actually share some of our key
to actually share some of our key
to actually share some of our key findings with you today so first we’re
findings with you today so first we’re
findings with you today so first we’re interested in knowing what types of
interested in knowing what types of
interested in knowing what types of people make exceptional foster carers
people make exceptional foster carers
people make exceptional foster carers and it turns out that there is no
and it turns out that there is no
and it turns out that there is no distinct socio demographic profile of
distinct socio demographic profile of
distinct socio demographic profile of these people they’re not men or women
these people they’re not men or women
these people they’re not men or women they’re not old or young they’re not
they’re not old or young they’re not
they’re not old or young they’re not high or low income and they don’t come
high or low income and they don’t come
high or low income and they don’t come from particular areas what makes really
from particular areas what makes really
from particular areas what makes really good foster carers stand out is actually
good foster carers stand out is actually
good foster carers stand out is actually their psychological characteristics
their psychological characteristics
their psychological characteristics they’re particularly empathetic they’re
they’re particularly empathetic they’re
they’re particularly empathetic they’re optimistic about the future and
optimistic about the future and
optimistic about the future and importantly they see foster caring is
importantly they see foster caring is
importantly they see foster caring is something that is what they were
something that is what they were
something that is what they were want to do its who they are and it’s how
want to do its who they are and it’s how
want to do its who they are and it’s how they express who they are we also wanted
they express who they are we also wanted
they express who they are we also wanted to understand among the general
to understand among the general
to understand among the general population what is the level of interest
population what is the level of interest
population what is the level of interest and knowledge about foster caring and
and knowledge about foster caring and
and knowledge about foster caring and one of the barriers that stopped some
one of the barriers that stopped some
one of the barriers that stopped some people from volunteering to be foster
people from volunteering to be foster
people from volunteering to be foster carers encouragingly 45% of the
carers encouragingly 45% of the
carers encouragingly 45% of the population said that they are they had
population said that they are they had
population said that they are they had considered foster caring in the past or
considered foster caring in the past or
considered foster caring in the past or would do in the future and for the 55%
would do in the future and for the 55%
would do in the future and for the 55% of people who said they’d never
of people who said they’d never
of people who said they’d never considered it we asked them why and
considered it we asked them why and
considered it we asked them why and three of the top five reasons people
three of the top five reasons people
three of the top five reasons people gave were I don’t know anything about
gave were I don’t know anything about
gave were I don’t know anything about foster caring the opportunity never
foster caring the opportunity never
foster caring the opportunity never arose and no one ever asked me to and so
arose and no one ever asked me to and so
arose and no one ever asked me to and so these are not reasons that are
these are not reasons that are
these are not reasons that are particularly associated with negative
particularly associated with negative
particularly associated with negative images they have of what it’s like to be
images they have of what it’s like to be
images they have of what it’s like to be a foster carer or foster children these
a foster carer or foster children these
a foster carer or foster children these are issues about knowledge and awareness
are issues about knowledge and awareness
are issues about knowledge and awareness of foster care and also being presented
of foster care and also being presented
of foster care and also being presented with enough opportunity to become a
with enough opportunity to become a
with enough opportunity to become a foster carer we also wanted to know what
foster carer we also wanted to know what
foster carer we also wanted to know what would make the prospect of being a
would make the prospect of being a
would make the prospect of being a foster carer more attractive and what we
foster carer more attractive and what we
foster carer more attractive and what we found was that a lot of people didn’t
found was that a lot of people didn’t
found was that a lot of people didn’t realize that most agencies actually
realize that most agencies actually
realize that most agencies actually provide training and support to foster
provide training and support to foster
provide training and support to foster carers they’re not left to their own
carers they’re not left to their own
carers they’re not left to their own devices to care for a child that they
devices to care for a child that they
devices to care for a child that they don’t know and so agencies have used
don’t know and so agencies have used
don’t know and so agencies have used this to rethink about the support that
this to rethink about the support that
this to rethink about the support that they provide foster carers in terms of
they provide foster carers in terms of
they provide foster carers in terms of training before they have a child placed
training before they have a child placed
training before they have a child placed with them and also during the placement
with them and also during the placement
with them and also during the placement assistance from caseworkers and also
assistance from caseworkers and also
assistance from caseworkers and also other specialists like psychologists and
other specialists like psychologists and
other specialists like psychologists and importantly that the financial support
importantly that the financial support
importantly that the financial support they provide is enough to account for
they provide is enough to account for
they provide is enough to account for the fact that there is another person in
the fact that there is another person in
the fact that there is another person in the household and this is particularly
the household and this is particularly
the household and this is particularly important during tough Financial Times
important during tough Financial Times
important during tough Financial Times and finally we were interested in
and finally we were interested in
and finally we were interested in understanding what types of messages
understanding what types of messages
understanding what types of messages would be meaningful and motivating to
would be meaningful and motivating to
would be meaningful and motivating to the types of people who are likely to be
the types of people who are likely to be
the types of people who are likely to be good at foster caring and what we knew
good at foster caring and what we knew
good at foster caring and what we knew from previous research is for other
from previous research is for other
from previous research is for other charitable behaviors like donating money
charitable behaviors like donating money
charitable behaviors like donating money it was usually negative framing of
it was usually negative framing of
it was usually negative framing of advertisements that were more effective
advertisements that were more effective
advertisements that were more effective so negative negatively framed messages
so negative negatively framed messages
so negative negatively framed messages that create negative emotions like guilt
that create negative emotions like guilt
that create negative emotions like guilt or fear or sadness are affecting me in
or fear or sadness are affecting me in
or fear or sadness are affecting me in getting people to pick up the phone and
getting people to pick up the phone and
getting people to pick up the phone and make a donation because that alleviates
make a donation because that alleviates
make a donation because that alleviates the negative emotion that they’ve just
the negative emotion that they’ve just
the negative emotion that they’ve just been experiencing so we wanted to test
been experiencing so we wanted to test
been experiencing so we wanted to test whether this same framing effect would
whether this same framing effect would
whether this same framing effect would be applicable to foster care so we
be applicable to foster care so we
be applicable to foster care so we worked with
worked with
worked with creative arts students and colleagues
creative arts students and colleagues
creative arts students and colleagues here at the university to design some
here at the university to design some
here at the university to design some new advertising messages and I wanted to
new advertising messages and I wanted to
new advertising messages and I wanted to show you a couple of examples of
show you a couple of examples of
show you a couple of examples of negatively framed messages so other than
negatively framed messages so other than
negatively framed messages so other than the actual message in the image we tried
the actual message in the image we tried
the actual message in the image we tried to keep these advertisements similar in
to keep these advertisements similar in
to keep these advertisements similar in all other respects including a fictional
all other respects including a fictional
all other respects including a fictional foster care organization in both of
foster care organization in both of
foster care organization in both of these negatively framed advertisements
these negatively framed advertisements
these negatively framed advertisements there is a child on their own they’re
there is a child on their own they’re
there is a child on their own they’re clearly unhappy and in dire
clearly unhappy and in dire
clearly unhappy and in dire circumstances and the text is very much
circumstances and the text is very much
circumstances and the text is very much framed around what will happen if you
framed around what will happen if you
framed around what will happen if you don’t become a foster carer so on the
don’t become a foster carer so on the
don’t become a foster carer so on the left without a foster family she will
left without a foster family she will
left without a foster family she will only know sadness and despair and on the
only know sadness and despair and on the
only know sadness and despair and on the right without a foster home he has no
right without a foster home he has no
right without a foster home he has no future in contrast these two
future in contrast these two
future in contrast these two advertisements are positively framed so
advertisements are positively framed so
advertisements are positively framed so we have not just the child by themselves
we have not just the child by themselves
we have not just the child by themselves but their with a carer they’re clearly
but their with a carer they’re clearly
but their with a carer they’re clearly happy and doing something fun and the
happy and doing something fun and the
happy and doing something fun and the text is around what benefits the
text is around what benefits the
text is around what benefits the individual carer will receive from
individual carer will receive from
individual carer will receive from performing the role which is in addition
performing the role which is in addition
performing the role which is in addition to any any benefits that the child may
to any any benefits that the child may
to any any benefits that the child may gain from having a foster carer and what
gain from having a foster carer and what
gain from having a foster carer and what we found from these experiments with was
we found from these experiments with was
we found from these experiments with was that actually for decisions that involve
that actually for decisions that involve
that actually for decisions that involve a high degree of consideration and
a high degree of consideration and
a high degree of consideration and thought and require higher commitment
thought and require higher commitment
thought and require higher commitment like being a foster carer actually the
like being a foster carer actually the
like being a foster carer actually the positively framed message is the far
positively framed message is the far
positively framed message is the far more effective they generate stronger
more effective they generate stronger
more effective they generate stronger responses from the specific types of
responses from the specific types of
responses from the specific types of people that we know are likely to be
people that we know are likely to be
people that we know are likely to be good in the role so while our research
good in the role so while our research
good in the role so while our research has made contributions to the body of
has made contributions to the body of
has made contributions to the body of knowledge around foster carer
knowledge around foster carer
knowledge around foster carer recruitment the real question is has
recruitment the real question is has
recruitment the real question is has anyone used these findings to make real
anyone used these findings to make real
anyone used these findings to make real change in the real world and the answer
change in the real world and the answer
change in the real world and the answer is that we know from working with our
is that we know from working with our
is that we know from working with our foster care partners that what it’s done
foster care partners that what it’s done
foster care partners that what it’s done is created a paradigm shift in the way
is created a paradigm shift in the way
is created a paradigm shift in the way people think about foster carer
people think about foster carer
people think about foster carer recruitment marketing used to be almost
recruitment marketing used to be almost
recruitment marketing used to be almost a dirty word in the nonprofit sector and
a dirty word in the nonprofit sector and
a dirty word in the nonprofit sector and people were very skeptical about the
people were very skeptical about the
people were very skeptical about the extent to which it belongs in the
extent to which it belongs in the
extent to which it belongs in the nonprofit sector rather than just the
nonprofit sector rather than just the
nonprofit sector rather than just the commercial sector which is where it
commercial sector which is where it
commercial sector which is where it originated but now people in nonprofit
originated but now people in nonprofit
originated but now people in nonprofit organizations are actually embracing
organizations are actually embracing
organizations are actually embracing marketing concepts and realize that they
marketing concepts and realize that they
marketing concepts and realize that they can actually help to achieve social
can actually help to achieve social
can actually help to achieve social objectives and the other thing that
objectives and the other thing that
objectives and the other thing that we’ve noticed is that we’ve dispelled
we’ve noticed is that we’ve dispelled
we’ve noticed is that we’ve dispelled some of the myths around foster caring
some of the myths around foster caring
some of the myths around foster caring and the reasons why people do or don’t
and the reasons why people do or don’t
and the reasons why people do or don’t become foster
become foster
become foster Hera’s and the fact that actually as
Hera’s and the fact that actually as
Hera’s and the fact that actually as well as obviously wanting to help people
well as obviously wanting to help people
well as obviously wanting to help people who are in need foster care is actually
who are in need foster care is actually
who are in need foster care is actually get a lot of benefits themselves in
get a lot of benefits themselves in
get a lot of benefits themselves in terms of being satisfied in their role
terms of being satisfied in their role
terms of being satisfied in their role and also finding it very enjoyable
and also finding it very enjoyable
and also finding it very enjoyable we know from our partners that a number
we know from our partners that a number
we know from our partners that a number of them have significantly increased the
of them have significantly increased the
of them have significantly increased the number of foster carers that they have
number of foster carers that they have
number of foster carers that they have since we started our research almost ten
since we started our research almost ten
since we started our research almost ten years ago in some cases by over nine
years ago in some cases by over nine
years ago in some cases by over nine hundred percent and so in that respect
hundred percent and so in that respect
hundred percent and so in that respect there has been a real difference and the
there has been a real difference and the
there has been a real difference and the difference hasn’t just been here in
difference hasn’t just been here in
difference hasn’t just been here in Australia we also know that policy
Australia we also know that policy
Australia we also know that policy makers and foster care agencies in other
makers and foster care agencies in other
makers and foster care agencies in other countries like the US and the UK that
countries like the US and the UK that
countries like the US and the UK that have similar foster care systems to ours
have similar foster care systems to ours
have similar foster care systems to ours have also used our research findings
have also used our research findings
have also used our research findings importantly our research findings are
importantly our research findings are
importantly our research findings are also being taught by educators in some
also being taught by educators in some
also being taught by educators in some of the world leading universities in the
of the world leading universities in the
of the world leading universities in the UK and the u.s. particularly again and
UK and the u.s. particularly again and
UK and the u.s. particularly again and they’re educating the new cohort of so
they’re educating the new cohort of so
they’re educating the new cohort of so cohort of social workers who is
cohort of social workers who is
cohort of social workers who is graduating now to become foster care
graduating now to become foster care
graduating now to become foster care managers and they have an appreciation
managers and they have an appreciation
managers and they have an appreciation of the value of using marketing
of the value of using marketing
of the value of using marketing techniques and also how to use them in a
techniques and also how to use them in a
techniques and also how to use them in a way that makes more efficient use of the
way that makes more efficient use of the
way that makes more efficient use of the very limited marketing dollars but
very limited marketing dollars but
very limited marketing dollars but really at the end of the day the value
really at the end of the day the value
really at the end of the day the value of our research and the benefits that
of our research and the benefits that
of our research and the benefits that it’s producing are to foster children
it’s producing are to foster children
it’s producing are to foster children themselves who are often some of our
themselves who are often some of our
themselves who are often some of our most vulnerable the most vulnerable
most vulnerable the most vulnerable
most vulnerable the most vulnerable people in our population and I think
people in our population and I think
people in our population and I think that this research is a demonstration of
that this research is a demonstration of
that this research is a demonstration of what can be achieved if we’re open to
what can be achieved if we’re open to
what can be achieved if we’re open to new perspectives and we work with
new perspectives and we work with
new perspectives and we work with different disease plans to solve some of
different disease plans to solve some of
different disease plans to solve some of the really complex problems that we’re
the really complex problems that we’re
the really complex problems that we’re experiencing not just here in Australia
experiencing not just here in Australia
experiencing not just here in Australia but also in many societies around the
but also in many societies around the
but also in many societies around the world thank you
world thank you
world thank you [Applause]
Please follow and like us: