
it’s wonderful to be back in Rogers City
on the shores of Lake Huron which in my
estimation is the greatest of the Great
Lakes many people when they first see
Lake Huron are surprised its size and
vistas seem more fitting of an ocean or
a sea rather than a mere lake those of
you who live on the shore or who work on
the water lake huron is is like a
slightly Moody friend and I think we
take a lot of pride in knowing the lake
its moods its quirks its weather but
what if I were to tell you there is a
vast undiscovered country with broad
plains towering cliffs
majestic waterfalls that exist just
beyond your shoreline there is such a
country and I’m going to describe it to
you tonight our story begins at the very
end of the last ice age the vast
continental glaciers gouged the huron
basin out of solid rock and as the ice
gradually grudgingly withdrew those
frigid melt waters began to fill the
basin at the same time relieved of the
great weight of ice the Earth’s surface
actually began to rise in a process
known as isostatic rebound
now this interplay of filling waters and
rising earth caused the level of this
new lake to fluctuate wildly from levels
much higher than today and levels much
lower than the day that low level is
known as glacial lake Stanley and it’s
named after the geologist George Stanley
who first inferred its existence in 1936
between about eleven thousand years ago
and nine thousand years ago this Lake
existed with water levels that were more
than three hundred feet lower than
modern Lake Huron the basin was isolated
from the other Great Lakes and in fact
it can
two lakes the shallow Eastern Lake and a
deeper deeper Eastern Lake and a shallow
Western Lake and they were separated by
a formation of limestone and dolomite
known as the Alpena Amberleigh Ridge now
this Ridge had resisted the glacial ice
now
Mariners have known about this feature
for a long time it appears on your
nautical charts it’s called six fathom
bank 36 feet fortunately it’s in the
middle of the lake and away from the
main shipping channels but it formed a
continuous causeway between southern
Ontario and northern Lower Michigan
actually right up here by Presque Isle
now this time period has been very
perplexing for archaeologists despite
the long span of time
very few sites are known and those that
are known are deeply buried yet as the
lake levels begin to slowly rise we
suddenly see sites everywhere on the
lake shore what’s happening is this some
cultural phenomena is it population
growth so as an experiment dr. Ashley
Lemke of the University of Texas
Arlington plotted all the finds of dated
caribou bone in Michigan and here’s what
she found during the high-water stand
caribou fossils are common during Lake
Stanley they’re none just like the
archeological sites so clearly both the
people and the animals are someplace
else this is an aerial view of the huron
basin during Lake Stanley’s time and
this is what I call a Canadian eye view
of the world you’re north you’re looking
south everything in green is dry land
today everything that’s brown is land
that was available for occupation during
Lake Stanley this is a vast area more
than a thousand square miles the modern
lake shores are far removed from the
water no wonder we don’t find sites on
land the sites are underwater and if
we’re going to find them that’s where we
have to look for them so the starting
point is what are we looking for what
are they going to look like and here the
president gives us a lot of clues the
principal animal that these hunters
would be chasing is the caribou and the
caribou is a truly fascinating creature
and we know a lot about him
we know they existed in vast herds we
know that they preferred a periglacial
climate like would have existed during
like Stanley’s time we know that they
predictably migrated to summer pasture
and winter calving grounds and they have
one odd behavioral quirk they are
attracted and follow lines this is one
of the reasons that the caribou
migrations were so disrupted by the
original pipelines in Alaska now caribou
hunters know about this quirk too so
instead of like in the western United
States were panicked herds of bison were
stampede at over cliffs caribou hunters
create lines they make them out of rock
out of brush and it’s enough to channel
the movement of animals to predetermine
kill locations now some of these
structures still exist today in the
Arctic in fact some are still used this
is an aerial view of the edgington site
that whole long line is simply aligned
and if we look at it on the ground you
can see what it actually looks like this
line wasn’t restraining where the
animals could move it was simply guiding
them in the foreground you actually have
a recently used hunting blind again it
doesn’t take much concealment during
this period of migration so this
basically told us what we were looking
for we expect there to be caribou
migrating back and forth along the
Alpena Amberleigh Ridge we expect
hunters to be using this kind of
technology to go after them then since
stone is plentiful on the on the ridge
we expect this constructions to be made
of stone
which has a high acoustic reflectivity
which means we’ll see it with sonar we
can we can actually detect it so we now
know what we’re looking for where do we
look first problem is figuring out what
this environment looked like 9,000 years
ago now the both imagery gives you the
basic tapa
rafi and interestingly side-scan sonar
actually can tell you where there were
lakes rivers and marshes as you can see
here and you can do that because these
areas are sand and sand is lower
reflectivity so in this picture you can
actually see a small lake connected by a
river to a big lake it’s the darker
color
we’ve supplemented this with samples of
material like testate amoeba and pollen
that are very sensitive to environmental
conditions oh and yeah there are still
rooted trees it was preserved on the
bottom as well dr. Lisa Sonnenberg took
all of this data and from it constructed
a very detailed map of this nine
thousand year old environment okay we
now know what the place looked like
where are the hunting sites going to be
for this we turn to computer simulation
dr. Robert Reynolds at Wayne State
University is an expert on artificial
intelligence and learning and he
specializes in group decision-making and
his he and his students set out to
determine where the caribou would have
actually tracked along the Alpena
Amberleigh Ridge and the way they did
this is they created numerous caribou
automata and then they let these herds
loose on the ridge and they gradually
learned it as they migrated back and
forth and back and forth and as they
learned this the computer kept track of
their routes now this was a very
preliminary work that the that’s
progressed much beyond that now but
there are two important observations
that came from this initial this initial
study first of all it seems that there
are certain places that the migrating
animals always pass this is where you
want to put your hunting site it also
turned out that the path that the
animals followed in the fall was
somewhat different than that in the
spring in the fall it’s a more rambling
circuitous route in the spring it’s more
dead on let’s get there and this is
going to be significant later in the
story so now we knew what we were
looking for and we had an idea of where
to look for it as archeologists
underwater we employ a multi-tier
strategy we start out
with a large-scale survey using
side-scan and multi-beam and from this
we identify key targets we want to
identify from that we then deploy a
remote operating vehicle and ROV this
this is Jake he’s actually a celebrity
in his own right he has a Facebook page
if you want to friend him but he also
has twin video cameras
he has aligned lasers in the front which
will allow you to scale the images and
he has an acoustic pinger that lets us
know precisely where he’s located and
you need this because GPS doesn’t work
underwater
so if jake investigates it and looks
good
we then deploy scuba trained
archaeologists the archaeologists
photographed the structures they map the
features they collect environmental
samples and they also collect bulk
samples of sediment which are brought
back to the surface and screened looking
for cultural cultural material now in
the first few years of our work we were
fortunate enough to find a few of these
sites and some associated artifacts and
as we did we fed this information back
to Bob Reynolds and his team as they
updated their virtual world simulation
so scientific research really is a kind
of voyage of discovery it has odd twists
and turns and blind alleys and you often
don’t appreciate what’s really important
until afterwards and you can and you can
kind of look back the breakthrough for
our research came in the form of an
email an email from Bob Reynolds as
students that said we think we know what
season you’re hunting blinds are being
used now this would be a big deal
archaeologists typically use animal bone
and particularly teeth to work out the
season of hunting but in the Great Lakes
and really for most of northeastern
North America animal bone rarely
survives because the acid soils destroy
them so how did these kids who never had
an anthropology class never been to the
Arctic never seen the caribou how do
they know the season of these hunting
sites
well they noticed that there was a
geometry to the hunting sites and that
many of them would only work if the
animals were moving in a single
direction and they then plotted out what
these directions would be and they
aligned with the fall and the spring
migration they were right and from this
came a second observation the hunting
structures that are associated with the
spring migration were different than the
ones with the fall migration now if we
go back and think about the hunting
structures we found now and we’ve
probably identified more than 70
potential structures in the ten years
we’ve been working you can divide them
into kind of simple and complex the
simple structures like these tend to be
comprised of five rocks or arranged in
kind of a V formation they could perhaps
conceal two or three hunters they’re
typically situated in a place where the
natural features will tend to channel
the animals towards them and you often
will find several of these in a single
locality we also here find these odd
rectangular constructions and these
resemble very closely meet caches that
historic hunters used in the Arctic now
by contrast the complex sites which are
associated with the spring are much more
elaborate they often create their own
funneling structure they have multiple
hunting blinds
built into them and they also often have
outlying stations which may have been
additional hunting blinds it may have
been where hunters were positioned to
keep the animals moving towards them
these were much larger structures they
involved a lot more people to operate
but as of yet we’ve never found one of
those rectangular caches associated with
them so what we what we come away with
is in the fall we seem to have small
structures small numbers of hunters
storing meat in the spring we seem to
have large structures lots of people not
storing meat how do we how do we fit all
this together into a single into a
single picture
I think the most plausible explanation
is that we’re seeing different seasonal
poses on a single annual round that
round begins in the autumn when people
move to the ridge to basically provision
for winter in the fall the animals are
in their prime condition not just the
meat but the hide sinews and antler and
these small family groups are going out
there they’re preserving some of the
some of the meat they’ve they’ve
acquired in these stone caches now
winter on the alpena Amberleigh ridge
would be a positively miserable place a
frigid wet called rot no one in their
right mind would spend the winter out
there so we believe the people came back
West to the treeline the shelter of the
tree line in Michigan we’ve actually
looked for some of these sites on land
these terrestrial sites we found several
possible candidates but almost certainly
most of the sites are both underwater
and buried deeply beneath lake sediments
now as the winter progressed we imagine
teams setting out across that near
frozen lake to go to their caches and
retrieve meat at the end of winter with
stores exhausted we imagine hungry
hunters returning to the Alpena
Amberleigh Ridge these family groups
that have been scattered during the
winter are now converging on those key
migration points where the elaborate
structures are located and the goal is
food for immediate consumption and
there’s plenty there’s plenty to go
around and the hunters since it’s a poor
season for storing food can actually
afford to linger which is a huge luxury
for a hunter-gatherer they can renew
acquaintances they can swap stories come
summer the people dispersed again now we
don’t yet know where they go in the
summer we don’t know what they do
perhaps they hunt isolated animals maybe
like us they fished but you get this
annual cycle
the research on the alpena Amberleigh
ridge i think is important for a number
of reasons for one it has given us an
incredibly detailed picture of life in
the Great Lakes 9,000 years ago and it’s
done this in large part because the
site’s survived intact underwater it
also gives us a model from deep in the
past that is quite different from what
we see post contact in the historic era
all of the pieces are familiar and
recognizable but they fit together in a
very different and novel way the alpena
Amberleigh ridge truly is lake Hurons
undiscovered country but so too is the
past in a broader sense it’s a country
we can never hope to visit but it’s a
place we can hope to know via the
vestiges of it which linger in the
present thank you [Applause]
on the shores of Lake Huron which in my
estimation is the greatest of the Great
Lakes many people when they first see
Lake Huron are surprised its size and
vistas seem more fitting of an ocean or
a sea rather than a mere lake those of
you who live on the shore or who work on
the water lake huron is is like a
slightly Moody friend and I think we
take a lot of pride in knowing the lake
its moods its quirks its weather but
what if I were to tell you there is a
vast undiscovered country with broad
plains towering cliffs
majestic waterfalls that exist just
beyond your shoreline there is such a
country and I’m going to describe it to
you tonight our story begins at the very
end of the last ice age the vast
continental glaciers gouged the huron
basin out of solid rock and as the ice
gradually grudgingly withdrew those
frigid melt waters began to fill the
basin at the same time relieved of the
great weight of ice the Earth’s surface
actually began to rise in a process
known as isostatic rebound
now this interplay of filling waters and
rising earth caused the level of this
new lake to fluctuate wildly from levels
much higher than today and levels much
lower than the day that low level is
known as glacial lake Stanley and it’s
named after the geologist George Stanley
who first inferred its existence in 1936
between about eleven thousand years ago
and nine thousand years ago this Lake
existed with water levels that were more
than three hundred feet lower than
modern Lake Huron the basin was isolated
from the other Great Lakes and in fact
it can
two lakes the shallow Eastern Lake and a
deeper deeper Eastern Lake and a shallow
Western Lake and they were separated by
a formation of limestone and dolomite
known as the Alpena Amberleigh Ridge now
this Ridge had resisted the glacial ice
now
Mariners have known about this feature
for a long time it appears on your
nautical charts it’s called six fathom
bank 36 feet fortunately it’s in the
middle of the lake and away from the
main shipping channels but it formed a
continuous causeway between southern
Ontario and northern Lower Michigan
actually right up here by Presque Isle
now this time period has been very
perplexing for archaeologists despite
the long span of time
very few sites are known and those that
are known are deeply buried yet as the
lake levels begin to slowly rise we
suddenly see sites everywhere on the
lake shore what’s happening is this some
cultural phenomena is it population
growth so as an experiment dr. Ashley
Lemke of the University of Texas
Arlington plotted all the finds of dated
caribou bone in Michigan and here’s what
she found during the high-water stand
caribou fossils are common during Lake
Stanley they’re none just like the
archeological sites so clearly both the
people and the animals are someplace
else this is an aerial view of the huron
basin during Lake Stanley’s time and
this is what I call a Canadian eye view
of the world you’re north you’re looking
south everything in green is dry land
today everything that’s brown is land
that was available for occupation during
Lake Stanley this is a vast area more
than a thousand square miles the modern
lake shores are far removed from the
water no wonder we don’t find sites on
land the sites are underwater and if
we’re going to find them that’s where we
have to look for them so the starting
point is what are we looking for what
are they going to look like and here the
president gives us a lot of clues the
principal animal that these hunters
would be chasing is the caribou and the
caribou is a truly fascinating creature
and we know a lot about him
we know they existed in vast herds we
know that they preferred a periglacial
climate like would have existed during
like Stanley’s time we know that they
predictably migrated to summer pasture
and winter calving grounds and they have
one odd behavioral quirk they are
attracted and follow lines this is one
of the reasons that the caribou
migrations were so disrupted by the
original pipelines in Alaska now caribou
hunters know about this quirk too so
instead of like in the western United
States were panicked herds of bison were
stampede at over cliffs caribou hunters
create lines they make them out of rock
out of brush and it’s enough to channel
the movement of animals to predetermine
kill locations now some of these
structures still exist today in the
Arctic in fact some are still used this
is an aerial view of the edgington site
that whole long line is simply aligned
and if we look at it on the ground you
can see what it actually looks like this
line wasn’t restraining where the
animals could move it was simply guiding
them in the foreground you actually have
a recently used hunting blind again it
doesn’t take much concealment during
this period of migration so this
basically told us what we were looking
for we expect there to be caribou
migrating back and forth along the
Alpena Amberleigh Ridge we expect
hunters to be using this kind of
technology to go after them then since
stone is plentiful on the on the ridge
we expect this constructions to be made
of stone
which has a high acoustic reflectivity
which means we’ll see it with sonar we
can we can actually detect it so we now
know what we’re looking for where do we
look first problem is figuring out what
this environment looked like 9,000 years
ago now the both imagery gives you the
basic tapa
rafi and interestingly side-scan sonar
actually can tell you where there were
lakes rivers and marshes as you can see
here and you can do that because these
areas are sand and sand is lower
reflectivity so in this picture you can
actually see a small lake connected by a
river to a big lake it’s the darker
color
we’ve supplemented this with samples of
material like testate amoeba and pollen
that are very sensitive to environmental
conditions oh and yeah there are still
rooted trees it was preserved on the
bottom as well dr. Lisa Sonnenberg took
all of this data and from it constructed
a very detailed map of this nine
thousand year old environment okay we
now know what the place looked like
where are the hunting sites going to be
for this we turn to computer simulation
dr. Robert Reynolds at Wayne State
University is an expert on artificial
intelligence and learning and he
specializes in group decision-making and
his he and his students set out to
determine where the caribou would have
actually tracked along the Alpena
Amberleigh Ridge and the way they did
this is they created numerous caribou
automata and then they let these herds
loose on the ridge and they gradually
learned it as they migrated back and
forth and back and forth and as they
learned this the computer kept track of
their routes now this was a very
preliminary work that the that’s
progressed much beyond that now but
there are two important observations
that came from this initial this initial
study first of all it seems that there
are certain places that the migrating
animals always pass this is where you
want to put your hunting site it also
turned out that the path that the
animals followed in the fall was
somewhat different than that in the
spring in the fall it’s a more rambling
circuitous route in the spring it’s more
dead on let’s get there and this is
going to be significant later in the
story so now we knew what we were
looking for and we had an idea of where
to look for it as archeologists
underwater we employ a multi-tier
strategy we start out
with a large-scale survey using
side-scan and multi-beam and from this
we identify key targets we want to
identify from that we then deploy a
remote operating vehicle and ROV this
this is Jake he’s actually a celebrity
in his own right he has a Facebook page
if you want to friend him but he also
has twin video cameras
he has aligned lasers in the front which
will allow you to scale the images and
he has an acoustic pinger that lets us
know precisely where he’s located and
you need this because GPS doesn’t work
underwater
so if jake investigates it and looks
good
we then deploy scuba trained
archaeologists the archaeologists
photographed the structures they map the
features they collect environmental
samples and they also collect bulk
samples of sediment which are brought
back to the surface and screened looking
for cultural cultural material now in
the first few years of our work we were
fortunate enough to find a few of these
sites and some associated artifacts and
as we did we fed this information back
to Bob Reynolds and his team as they
updated their virtual world simulation
so scientific research really is a kind
of voyage of discovery it has odd twists
and turns and blind alleys and you often
don’t appreciate what’s really important
until afterwards and you can and you can
kind of look back the breakthrough for
our research came in the form of an
email an email from Bob Reynolds as
students that said we think we know what
season you’re hunting blinds are being
used now this would be a big deal
archaeologists typically use animal bone
and particularly teeth to work out the
season of hunting but in the Great Lakes
and really for most of northeastern
North America animal bone rarely
survives because the acid soils destroy
them so how did these kids who never had
an anthropology class never been to the
Arctic never seen the caribou how do
they know the season of these hunting
sites
well they noticed that there was a
geometry to the hunting sites and that
many of them would only work if the
animals were moving in a single
direction and they then plotted out what
these directions would be and they
aligned with the fall and the spring
migration they were right and from this
came a second observation the hunting
structures that are associated with the
spring migration were different than the
ones with the fall migration now if we
go back and think about the hunting
structures we found now and we’ve
probably identified more than 70
potential structures in the ten years
we’ve been working you can divide them
into kind of simple and complex the
simple structures like these tend to be
comprised of five rocks or arranged in
kind of a V formation they could perhaps
conceal two or three hunters they’re
typically situated in a place where the
natural features will tend to channel
the animals towards them and you often
will find several of these in a single
locality we also here find these odd
rectangular constructions and these
resemble very closely meet caches that
historic hunters used in the Arctic now
by contrast the complex sites which are
associated with the spring are much more
elaborate they often create their own
funneling structure they have multiple
hunting blinds
built into them and they also often have
outlying stations which may have been
additional hunting blinds it may have
been where hunters were positioned to
keep the animals moving towards them
these were much larger structures they
involved a lot more people to operate
but as of yet we’ve never found one of
those rectangular caches associated with
them so what we what we come away with
is in the fall we seem to have small
structures small numbers of hunters
storing meat in the spring we seem to
have large structures lots of people not
storing meat how do we how do we fit all
this together into a single into a
single picture
I think the most plausible explanation
is that we’re seeing different seasonal
poses on a single annual round that
round begins in the autumn when people
move to the ridge to basically provision
for winter in the fall the animals are
in their prime condition not just the
meat but the hide sinews and antler and
these small family groups are going out
there they’re preserving some of the
some of the meat they’ve they’ve
acquired in these stone caches now
winter on the alpena Amberleigh ridge
would be a positively miserable place a
frigid wet called rot no one in their
right mind would spend the winter out
there so we believe the people came back
West to the treeline the shelter of the
tree line in Michigan we’ve actually
looked for some of these sites on land
these terrestrial sites we found several
possible candidates but almost certainly
most of the sites are both underwater
and buried deeply beneath lake sediments
now as the winter progressed we imagine
teams setting out across that near
frozen lake to go to their caches and
retrieve meat at the end of winter with
stores exhausted we imagine hungry
hunters returning to the Alpena
Amberleigh Ridge these family groups
that have been scattered during the
winter are now converging on those key
migration points where the elaborate
structures are located and the goal is
food for immediate consumption and
there’s plenty there’s plenty to go
around and the hunters since it’s a poor
season for storing food can actually
afford to linger which is a huge luxury
for a hunter-gatherer they can renew
acquaintances they can swap stories come
summer the people dispersed again now we
don’t yet know where they go in the
summer we don’t know what they do
perhaps they hunt isolated animals maybe
like us they fished but you get this
annual cycle
the research on the alpena Amberleigh
ridge i think is important for a number
of reasons for one it has given us an
incredibly detailed picture of life in
the Great Lakes 9,000 years ago and it’s
done this in large part because the
site’s survived intact underwater it
also gives us a model from deep in the
past that is quite different from what
we see post contact in the historic era
all of the pieces are familiar and
recognizable but they fit together in a
very different and novel way the alpena
Amberleigh ridge truly is lake Hurons
undiscovered country but so too is the
past in a broader sense it’s a country
we can never hope to visit but it’s a
place we can hope to know via the
vestiges of it which linger in the
present thank you [Applause]
Please follow and like us: