Press "Enter" to skip to content

Sports journalists stereotype athletes by race — and we do too | Pat Ferrucci | TEDxMileHigh


Dustin Pedroia he’s quote a lot like
David Eckstein he makes the most out of
what he’s got you know David Eckstein
the guy who quote gets everything out of
his body or quote was always the first
to spring to his position think about
those statements from sports journalists
for a second if you follow baseball
you know how absurd they are they’re
comparing to second baseman who could
not be more dissimilar Pedroia at MVP a
borderline hall-of-famer someone who
according to statistics is 27 percent
better than Eckstein so why were they
compared so often well to quote the late
great blog fire Joe Morgan calm they’re
both white now I’ve been a sports fan my
entire life I’m from Boston and one of
my earliest memories yeah Boston it was
Game six of the 1986 World Series Red
Sox versus New York Mets I was seven
years old and my dad woke me up so I
could witness the Red Sox finally win a
World Series not so much I can still
vividly remember how crushed everybody
was when the Red Sox blew it as a child
and still to this day Sports represents
more than just the game for many
Americans it’s a way of life it’s
something that brings people together
it’s also a seventy billion dollar
industry now numerous historians have
argued that in terms of race sports has
always been the great equalizer in this
country but that’s not entirely accurate
sure there are examples like Jack
Johnson who won a World Championship in
1908 as a black boxer decades
before african-americans who earned
equal rights in this country but in
sports and specifically sports
journalism let’s just say things are not
always that equal I was a journalist for
nine years
and when I went back to grad school I
wanted to find out just how unequal
things were but it turned out I don’t
have to scholars had conducted dozens of
studies that look at how sports
journalists and broadcasters stereotyped
athletes by race what did they find
yes journalists and broadcasters
consistently and constantly stereotyped
athletes by race through their word
choices intelligence background
motivation physical strength effort
leadership right these are all word
choices that journalists make when
they’re talking about athletes but they
do so in a racialized manner
let’s take Cam Newton and Tom Brady as
examples now we can all agree Tom Brady
is the greatest quarterback to ever live
write ever easy yeah no doubt about it
right but when Brady succeeds do you
ever hear journalists or broadcasters
talk about his natural talent or his
athleticism for a guy to win five Super
Bowls playing eight and win an MVP after
the age of 40 you’d think he’d have to
be pretty damn naturally talented and
athletic but when Brady succeeds
journalists often talk about his
intelligence or his effort now compare
Cam Newton right guy want a national
championship in college played in a
Super Bowl won an MVP in the NFL you’d
think for a quarterback to do that he’d
have to be pretty damn smart and work
really hard but when Newton succeeds
it’s often about his physical strength
right or his natural talent and that’s
the thing with athletes and stare
riyo types if you’re white regardless of
the sport you’re often talked about in
terms of intelligence or effort or how
great of a leader you are if you’re
black it’s about physical strength
natural ability or athleticism if you’re
Latino maybe your fiery Asian
intelligent good team player trust me
now that you’re aware of this you’re
gonna see it every time you look at the
sports section those stereotypes are
good they’re positive they’re not
negative but the problem is when we
start to label people completely based
upon their race with no scientific
evidence to back it up we start to see
race which is entirely a social
construct as something that actually
matters this is what we call everyday
racism a sociological concept that
describes the subtle ways that we treat
people of divergent races differently we
see a guy in a Klan hood right we know
that guy’s racist we can say it it’s
easy to identify it’s clear everyday
racism is about the tiny sometimes not
even discernible ways that we treat
people differently based on their race
for example when we compliment a black
woman for being quote articulate or we
ask a Latino person where their quote
really from that’s everyday racism
scholars argue that everyday racism is
more insidious more harmful than overt
racism because we do it without thinking
and when we do things without thinking
we believe them more easily stereotyping
is a two part cognitive process it’s
both automatic and controlled
we know stereotypes because we see
stereotypes in the world all around us
on television in movies on the radio in
books and so on we know stereotypes
because media representations of
stereotypes are literally everywhere
around us
so when we encounter somebody from a
group that might be different than us
maybe by race maybe by gender maybe
because they look like they ride
motorcycles all the stereotypes about
that group enter our brain that’s the
automatic part right that’s not wrong
but the part that we can control is do
we apply those stereotypes essentially
do we believe them now we know sports
journalists and broadcasters stereotype
athletes but the question is do those
media representations affect our
behavior about eight years ago some
colleagues and I started to conduct some
experiments to determine whether regular
people stereotyped athletes based on
race what did we find
yes absolutely people stereotyped
athletes based on race let me give you
an example so we recruit hundreds of
people for an experiment we don’t tell
them anything about it we split them
into two groups randomly both groups
read the same stories that highlight and
accentuate specific athletic attributes
so for example both groups will read the
exact same story that talks about how
smart an anonymous athlete is but here’s
the difference above that story one
group will see a photo of an anonymous
white athlete the other group will see a
photo of an anonymous black athlete now
here’s the crux of the experiment if
people don’t stereotype the athletes
they would rate them the same in
intelligence because they read the exact
same story but that’s not what happened
our participants rated the white athlete
significantly higher in intelligence the
same thing happened when we use the
story about effort or when we swapped
out stories for ones about physical
strength or natural ability our
participants rated black athletes
significantly higher so then we thought
well maybe it’s about the race of
participant so we did another experiment
this time we over sampled black
participants and what did we find
well black participants actually
stereotyped more strongly than white
participants so for example black
participants rated white athletes as
significantly higher in intelligence
than white participants did right so
what we’re seeing essentially is that
journalists and broadcasters stereotyped
athletes and then we do too and so
probably what you’re thinking here is we
got a lot of problems in this world
right so does it really matter does it
matter that people and journalists and
broadcasters are stereotyping athletes
yes it matters it matters a lot let’s
talk about how it matters to the player
first we know that in the in sports
quarterback is considered a quote smart
position and when they’re kids
athletes both black and white play
quarterback at about the same rate but
as they move up from Pop Warner to
junior varsity to high school to college
to the pros more and more black athletes
regardless of how smart they are are
moved off those quotes smart positions
like quarterback and are moved on to
quote athletic positions like wide
receiver and white athletes regardless
of how athletic they are are moved off
athletic positions like wide receiver
and moved on to smart positions like
quarterback so let’s think of last
April’s NFL Draft right
Josh Allen is a quarterback prospect
whose numbers in college suggests he’ll
be a mediocre at best NFL player but he
was drafted 7th overall
7th and if you do a Google search for
Josh Allen I guarantee you within 2
stories you’ll find one that says Josh
Allen just looks like an NFL quarterback
right compare that to Lamar Jackson guy
won a Heisman Trophy in college his
numbers suggest there’ll be a far far
better quarterback in the pros than
Joshua Allen yet before the draft
executives from certain NFL teams asked
Jackson if he would try out as a wide
receiver even though he’d only played
quarterback in his entire life
he was drafted 32nd not seventh Josh
Allen Lamar Jackson
if you don’t know do you want to guess
which one’s white and which one’s black
now let’s see how it plays out in other
ways right in terms of a player’s career
in the NFL the average quarterback his
career lasts 18 percent longer than the
average wide receiver the average
quarterbacks annual salary is more than
double that of a wide receiver in terms
of endorsements if you’re to look back
on 2017 eight of the top ten earners in
the NFL were quarterbacks none were wide
receivers then think about the rules put
in place to protect quarterbacks
essentially a quarterback is less likely
to be seriously injured or concussed now
we know right some athletes are going to
play quarterback and some are going to
play a wide receiver their skill sets
demand it right the problem is with the
systemic decisions made from the time
these athletes are in elementary school
that implicitly affect coaches general
managers Scouts to put these players
into quote more racially appropriate
positions thus robbing them the
opportunity of potentially the longer
safer and more lucrative career
essentially giving some athletes
different opportunities than others now
you’re probably thinking well one of
those opportunities you’re talking about
is endorsements right these athletes
make a ton of money do endorsements
really matter to anybody but the
athletes yes
endorsements impact us they impact
everybody studies show that white
athletes
are far far more likely to appear in
commercials or advertisements even
though there are far more more black
professional athletes but there’s more
to it than that
white athletes are far more likely to be
represented and depicted as well-rounded
human beings think about Peyton Manning
making sandwiches or sitting around
playing music with Kenny Chesney yeah
compare that to Cam Newton we’ve seen
him sell yogurt but always in his
uniform or think about black basketball
players in commercials they’re almost
always wearing the uniform and almost
always doing something athletic right
and the problem is we don’t stereotype
individuals we stereotype groups when we
stereotype groups we see we start to see
large swaths of people as the same are
there white athletes that are super
smart yes are there black athletes that
are super athletic of course but there
are white athletes that are super
athletic and there are black athletes
that are super smart and when we start
to label people and treat groups as the
same that’s when bad things start to
happen that’s when we call the police on
a black student simply sleeping on
campus at Yale that’s when black men
waiting for a friend at Starbucks
becomes international news that’s when
more tragically police officers or
regular citizens shoot unarmed black men
because they quote look dangerous or
because the shooter quote feared for
their lives if this stuff is happening
on our sports fields do you not think is
happening everywhere else until we start
to acknowledge that we implicitly
stereotyped people based on a whole
variety of differences we’re never going
to fix these problems we’re never going
to get rid of the prejudice that is all
around us you
Please follow and like us: