Press "Enter" to skip to content

Dinner with a Criminal Defence Lawyer | Kathleen Heath | TEDxFulbrightPerth


I’m a criminal defense lawyer because of
that I have been called the scum of the
earth I have been lectured by police
officers for merely doing my job my own
grandfather when I told him that I had
my first real job as a criminal defense
lawyer screwed up his face and said what
do you want to represent people like
that for
I came to criminal defense thinking that
I was fighting the good fight but I was
standing up for the poor the downtrodden
the oppressed against the power of the
state but what I quickly learned is that
there is another view of a criminal
defense lawyer one that perhaps holds a
greater deal of cultural currency and
that’s a stereotype of the wily criminal
defense lawyer the one who would use
verbal tricks and scrupulous means
technical loopholes to make sure that
undeserving guilty criminals are let
back out onto our streets now even when
not outright maligned I find for at
least somewhat misunderstood when I go
to social events dinner parties and I
know my colleagues have the same
experience I often find that I’m asked a
very similar set of questions questions
that perhaps reveal to me how subtle but
pervasive some of the negative views of
criminal defense lawyers are and also
betray some of the fundamental
misconceptions that people hold about
our criminal justice system so what I
want to do tonight in the spirit of
clarification is invite you all along to
a proverbial dinner party
we’ve had our canapés with sat down for
Maine’s the wine is blowing and lucky
you all you’ve happened to be sat next
to me and what I’m gonna do over the
next few minutes is give you my answers
to the fa Q’s the most frequently asked
questions to criminal lawyers at dinner
parties so let’s start with the really
easy stuff no it’s not like CSI it’s not
like The Good Wife and much as I would
love to be the next Megan Markell it’s
nothing like suits
yes I do often have to get dressed in
those oversized black robes they are hot
they are uncomfortable and I actually
get stuck on my chair whenever I try and
stand up move on to some of the more
meaty questions and there’s a classic
the quintessential that every criminal
defense lawyer is so familiar with how
do you defend a person who you know is
guilty now there’s a range of stock
standard answers to this you’ll find it
in any first-year law textbook it
usually goes something along the lines
of this that in a democratic society
everybody has a right to a fair trial
that there is a presumption of innocence
that it is the judge and jury not for me
to decide the guilt or otherwise of my
client and if we can’t protect those
rights for everybody then we can’t
guarantee them for anyone now those are
important principles and I stand by them
in the work I do but truthfully I’m not
going to spend long on it tonight
because I think it’s a kind of boring
question criminal lawyers have been
answering that for centuries when I’m at
a dinner party when someone asks me out
question how do you defend a guilty
person what I like to do is flip the
question I say to them the real question
is this how do you defend someone who
wants to plead guilty but who you know
is innocent I can tell you now that is
far and away the more common and
pressing ethical dilemma facing criminal
lawyers in courtrooms around the country
now it may sound counterintuitive but
let’s not forget that fighting a
criminal charge is a difficult process
it can take months
it’s not years and involves complexities
that trip up even experienced criminal
lawyers now best case scenario you’re
out on bail so you’re in the community
but even then you have a charge hanging
over your head you might be subject to
ownerís bail conditions worst case
scenario you’re sitting in jail waiting
for a trial date and when that’s your
reality it becomes easy to see how
pragmatism or convenience wins the day
and add to that another ingredient that
I say only too often
in my clients hopelessness just the
other day at work we had this great
victory in court for one of my clients
effectively she was acquitted of all
charges
she had been charged with assaulting a
police officer when in fact it was she
who was unlawfully assaulted in the
first place now the difficult part of
that case wasn’t winning in court as
soon as I saw the CCTV I knew that we
had a strong defense the hard part was
convincing my client to plead not guilty
and to go to trial she was on bail for
nearly a year waiting for her day in
court but the thing that she struggled
with the most was accepting that her
voice her story
the voice of an 18 year old Aboriginal
girl would be believed against the word
of a police officer
that’s the hopelessness I’m talking
about so why do I do this why do i flip
the question in this way what’s the
point
I’m trying to make to you it’s the
criminal law is rarely about cunning
criminals conniving with their lawyers
about how to get away with murder it is
far more about real people in difficult
situations who may have made a mistake
but who find themselves being churned
through the machinery of our criminal
justice system
machinery that’s often slow
incomprehensible baffling and sometimes
just feels unjust so helping people
through that process however they decide
to plead that’s the work of a criminal
defense lawyer and that’s work that I’m
proud to do so let’s move on to the next
question and this one’s a goodie people
look at me and they have a glint in
their eye and they ask what’s it like to
sit opposite a murderer now in my career
I’ve sat opposite to people who have
committed murders and one person who is
alleged to have committed a murder my
answer for my dinner party guests is
always a disappointingly boring one it’s
a relatively ordinary experience I think
when people ask me this question what
they’re hoping for is the description of
a monster
they want to know what it’s like to look
into the eyes of evil now there may be
monsters out there there may be villains
there may be Psychopaths I’m yet to meet
one and if you thought that our jails
were full of them and you’d be sorely
mistaken what our jails are actually
full of a traumatized people desperate
people people with addictions and the
kind of backstories that make you
understand why they started abusing
substances in the first place they’re
full of the poor and the homeless
they’re full of people who face mental
health challenges or have cognitive
impairments and don’t have the support
around them to deal with those and
manage those experiences to put it
simply they’re full of people who called
to mind for me the old phrase there but
for the grace of God go I now I don’t
want to oversell it I’m not saying that
my clients are Saints I’m not saying
that they’re blameless I’m just saying
they’re not monsters they are in fact
deeply deeply human and that leads me to
the final question I want to answer
tonight sometimes people say to me but
what about the victims what about the
victims now you could be forgiven when
you walked into a courtroom for thinking
that there was a clear dividing line
between offenders and victims there’s
the body he sits on one side his lawyers
next to him and on the other side of the
room is the state the prosecutor who
most people at least think off as
representing the victims interests
visually it’s a very clear picture the
reality though is far more complex the
prosecution do not have a monopoly on
victims just the other day for work I
was reading a victim impact statement it
was written by a woman whose house had
been burgled by my 19 year old client it
was a very heartfelt statement she wrote
about the way that my clients crime not
only robbed her family of property it
robbed them of their sense of security
and safety in their own home and she
wrote this line that really stuck with
me she said that what
did her the most was her loss of faith
in humankind that she felt that her
children had been robbed of some of
their innocence and I don’t diminish or
belittle those feelings at all I fully
appreciate the sense of anxiety the
sense of invasion that comes when your
house is broken into but it didn’t make
me start to wonder when did my client
lose his faith in humanity when did he
lose his innocence or his sense of
safety or security in his own home
was it the first time he saw his dad
flogged his mum was it when his mum
started sleeping in his sister’s bedroom
with a chair jammed up under the
doorknob because she was so scared of
her husband was it when her husband
finally went to jail leaving her to
raise five children on her own and
leaving my client without a dad or was
it when his mum who was so destabilized
by her experiences of violence herself
turned to substances and followed her
husband’s footsteps into jail the
prosecution did not have a monopoly on
victims so I think it’s fair that a
judge that sentence is my client knows
about the impact that his crime had upon
that family but I also think that it’s
critical in a just society that my
client story be heard that his
background be believed that it be taken
into consideration and giving a voice to
that story that’s the work of a criminal
defense lawyer so my dinner party
companions what do I want you to take
away from all of this it’s really a very
simple message it’s the criminal law is
rarely about cunning criminals it’s
rarely about monsters it’s rarely a
simple equation with good on the one
hand and bad on the other and I hope you
do take this away because it has
consequences beyond dinner parties and
the popularity of criminal defense
lawyers
it matters because at their core those
misconceptions aren’t actually about me
or my job their misconceptions about my
clients about the worthiness of my
clients and they’re the kind of
misconceptions that conditioned us to
respond punitive ly to forego mercy
so our prison population is only
ever-growing never shrinking they’re the
kind of misconceptions that make
criminals easy fodder for politicians
and make even the most sensible law
reform proposals and unpopular cause and
they’re the kind of misconceptions that
make sure organizations like the one I
work for the aboriginal legal service
and other organizations that are
dedicated to ensuring equal access to
justice but those organizations are
chronically underfunded as to our our
social services as to our any programs
that focus on rehabilitation over
punishment at their deepest level they
are misconceptions that deprive us of
the capacity to respond with empathy and
with compassion to people who have or
are alleged to have committed crimes and
for those reasons I hope we can correct
[Applause] [Music]
Please follow and like us: