Press "Enter" to skip to content

Is a paperless, people-less court in our near future? | Hitesh Jain | TEDxSalisburyPark


well first and foremost thank you for
the guided charitable words for the
lawyers actually speaking in the
newspaper last two days it’s a pleasant
surprise that lawyers have been given
kudos and good words are coming
otherwise the common adjectives we heard
about lawyers are liars and lawyers are
devil having one of the objective was
given by my one wife that I am a liar so
it is a welcome change in last two days
particularly into the ICJ but enough of
self praise and let’s come to the real
topic then those who would have witness
in last two days about the coverage on
the case of the International Court of
Justice I was looking at the coverage
from a different perspective and I have
seen a glimpse of future in that so one
of the pointers where I can see a
glimpse of future over there is the
webcast of entire proceedings so sitting
in your drawing rooms you could actually
witness the arguments that were advanced
in the court the rulings that were
advanced in the court you could actually
see the expression of the lawyers you
could actually also see the expression
of the judges you can see the expression
of everyone who was present in the court
so there was a some sort of a glimpse
one could see on this entire webcast and
everything and what I saw is a future in
that now it is very difficult to predict
the future particularly when it comes to
the technology and I guess it is very
the technology is never an absolute it
keeps like the technology can become an
absolute in the next five days so it
will be very difficult for me to say
that I’m predicting a future or
something but I can see some point or
direction in the future at the point
which I want to make where people across
the globe the tension that is being
faced is the future of a Court which is
paperless and people less you can see a
court which will be completely without
papers and without people
and there are reasons for that and the
idea of paperless and people less has
come now and you will see lot of
attempts that will be made in this
direction now we are always used to look
at the image of the courts with hundreds
of lawyers walking into the courtroom
hundreds of clients walking into the
courtroom everybody wants to be there
personally present everybody wants to
see so in this when I’m speaking about
the use of technology to speak about
paper less people less whether it is
practicable now also last one week has
been a lot of discussions about hacking
I mean hacking so it is technology safe
enough when we are talking about
I mean court cases something decide the
fate of the individuals or the fate of
so many people and if you allow the
technology to fudge the records and
change the records it can what is the
impact it can have now let me drive home
the point for the case for a paperless
and people less future by sharing couple
of my personal experiences bit funny in
nature but I thought I mean it’s very I
mean and then you can understand how
paperless and why the case for paperless
and people less God now the example that
I’m giving is about a divorce case that
was handled by me a divorce case where a
couple got married in Bombay and the
divorce I mean within 15 days the
marriage split and the person had to
travel someone had to go to London and
the girl remained in Bombay so the idea
is that both of them ultimately decided
that they have to file a petition for
mutual consent and they should approach
the court so now to get a simple fact
simple order where the parties want to
mutually terminate the marriage is a
easier idea there is no contest over
there so why should the parties there
why should the lawyers be required to be
going and is it not possible that you
can just file a petition and the court
takes this thing so to file the petition
you have to come to the court the like
the
the boy concerned was working in London
so he had to first take a leave to come
for the filing of petition there after a
month there is a date for counselling so
he has to again come from all the way
from London for the counselling after
that you have to wait for the six months
before the actual order of termination
of marriages past so you have to come
and the scene is that both the boy and
the girl have to go in front of the
judge and they have to say that we want
a mutual termination because the court
months we heard from them personally
there was a small drama III called the
parties to the office and a day before I
thought that you know let me I mean I
sense some trouble I said okay let’s not
meet in my office we’ll meet at my home
and and I told everybody in the home
that I would like to be all alone when
I’m meeting them and and then they
realize the reason is that when we
started there was a heated exchange or
although they both of them had agreed
that they will mutually apply for their
divorce but the girl went and bang that
guy and slapped him left right so the
cases and after that they again cool
down went to the court and ultimately
the marriage was terminated now imagine
a person coming from London coming for
three dates this whole drama happening
the whole emotional drama happening so
what is the idea of paperless and people
s paperless and people s the simplest it
becomes an online dispute resolution in
an online dispute resolution it is very
simple you file the documents
electronically you respond to the
document electronically the judge can
conduct the meeting by way of video
conference you can put forth your views
before the before the judge concern who
can also look look at you by way of
webcam and this is how the matter can be
resolved so no need of coming no need of
no need of personal intervention no need
of human interface so you don’t need a
human interface what is required in the
proceeding is you cannot leave the human
out of the human interface you need the
human human touch but a human touch with
a blend of technology which can be
efficient and which can be the solution
now is this possible yes this is
possible but for this what I feel is
that we have to change your attitude
we have to change our mindset we have to
accept the challenge of the change
changes inevitable technology is giving
the solution and in my view if people
start we start embarrassing the
technology we change our attitude we
start with the online dispute resolution
process we start with with the use of
technology we start more of
virtualization this will address the
efficient this will address the issue of
efficiency and this will address the
issue of of delay I don’t know in the
audience if you are aware do you know
the magnitude of delay I mean forget
internationally but the data that is
available in India as to how many cases
are pending today can anybody make a
guess it’s close to 38 million as of now
when we are speaking so 38 million cases
if we have to try and sit and on top of
it there are so many new cases that are
getting added into that list so is it
possible and with the delay what happens
is people stop honoring the contract
people start honouring the word and that
is where the whole dispute start so
assuming the system where there is no
delay there is no errors the disputes
are getting resolved efficiently the
disputes are getting resolved in the
time bound manner what the resultant
impact is going to be dramatic it will
help people to honor the contract people
will stop taking people for granted
you’re the most important where in India
we come from the philosophy where you
know every word is honored and this
philosophy is across the globe when we
speak about ethics we speak about
morality it is about keeping the word so
from that perspective the case is for
paperless and people less now we have to
go one step further I mean speaking
about just paper less people less
technology now as for the lawyers are
concerned now lawyers are only studying
the law books
so how people who are studying with the
law books are concerned how do they go
about it I mean you are only studying
the law you don’t study the technology
you don’t study the management so a
quarry
to meet the next change what you will
see is the future of law school and the
future of the the lawyer’s office or the
ecosystem that surrounds the lawyers
it’s not going to be like what you see
like a old shady offices with books and
files and you’re trying to find out the
law schools what you will see where you
will not only study law but according to
me law school will be a combination of
law technology and management
you cannot independently if you are
saying that I am just going to study the
law and that is going to the future that
is never going to be the solution the
solution is the curriculum where we have
to create a future breed of lawyers who
will be legally sound technology Kelley
update and they will have the management
skills because ultimately also one of
the step in the queue of future is the
courts cannot be just run by the judges
alone or by the legal system you will
need the management system although you
may see the case for a CEO in the court
who will look after who will look at the
data data science is going to be
important he will start looking at the
data analytics the data analytics can
put a board he can go to the judge and
he say he can say listen you have got
100 cases you have got 300 it will
require so much of time so this is all
of the this is all about the science it
is all about putting the process use of
technology and this is where the end
according to me it’s a food great food
for thought for people who are in rnd
and people who are looking at technology
at one end we are discussing about the
h-1b visa issues and what is going to
happen but according to me technology is
going to open up a huge opportunity
there is a huge opportunity that is
lying for people I mean across the globe
people in India to come ahead to think
about how they can use the technology to
change the future to change the courts
and the research and developments can do
in terms of using the data science using
the technology for the segregation of
cases using the technology to come as to
how there can be a virtual
or like for example like you see a lot
of television debates so if the debates
can happen on the television the court
can see here the argument in form of
debate in a virtualized
set up in a web for webcast and
arguments are advanced it’s become more
efficient so in this is the future that
one is going to be and I think we have
to be prepared to be dealing with this
kind of the future because the way
things are going on the way the whole
the culture is building the if we are
not going to grow with the trend if you
are not going to change if we are not
going to embarrass the technology we are
going to paint a very sorry future I
mean every day it is very common that
you know people come people blame the
lawyers for the delays people blame the
huge cost let me also give you an
example as to how it can reduce the cost
of again the example like it’s a funny
episode where I was present in our
office in one of the law firm and I was
talking to a partner and someone just
walked in and he said he was very happy
and he told that listen there was some
client he came and he advised and the
whole before filing the proceedings he
resolved the whole matter in couple of
hours to which the answer was that how
did you resolve in if you will resolve
the matter in two hours how are we going
to earn the income and the billable
hours so the tendency is to put like
four or five lawyers on the job and
build by the hours so technology can
also give a solution to this you can
have that you can segregate so many
matters in such a manner it will make
your life simple make your life easy
high complex cases that’s fine I mean
will require some amount of human
intervention but I’m sure so many of you
will be above aware about also petty
traffic offenses where your license is
impounded or you have to go to the port
or something nowadays you can see some
change about the camera
being installed and the camera giving
you a proof as to what is happening on
the road or the camera also sending you
the messages that this is the violation
that has happened you don’t need to go
and you have to make the payment online
also so if the banks have changed for
last 15 years the banks have come with
the online banking online payment
gateway this is the case now what I
predict for the future of the court and
this presents an opportunity for
everyone to come with a case so that you
can basically come with the solution of
technology you educate yourself and then
see a different future thank you very
much [Applause]
Please follow and like us: