Press "Enter" to skip to content

We Aren’t That Different | Prem Thakker | TEDxGrandForks


I’m going to say a series of statements

and if one applies you I’d really

appreciate if you’d raise your hand

you’ll either pick between option one or

option two so let’s get started

please raise your hand if you like dogs

you’re a dog person

all right hands down please raise your

hand if you prefer cats you’re more a

cat person

cat lady is no shame let’s try colors

now it’ll be between red or blue so

please raise your hand if you like the

color red all right now please raise

your hand if you like the color blue all

right all right

um let’s I want to get a bit of a gauge

of how tall we are in this room so

please raise round if you’re five foot

eight inches or shorter no shame please

raise your hand if you’re taller than

five foot eight inches all right now

let’s tweak things a little bit for

these next set of statements you can

feel free to keep your hand raised if

more than one applies to you raise your

hand if you’re from a different country

raise your hand if you or your parents

are from a different country now finally

raise your hand if you or your parents

or your grandparents are from a

different country all right a few more

almost done I promise um raise your hand

if you know someone that’s different

than you and this isn’t a trick question

so hands up

raise your hand if you know of someone

from a different country now finally

raise your hand if you’ve actually met

that person you know more about them

other than that they exist very good

alright last one now everyone hands up

put your hand on your heart and repeat

after me

Oh some of you guys long sighted hearts

here hearts here now repeat after me

loud and proud all of you all of y’all I

love you too thanks so much round of

applause for the welcome thank you thank

you that was fun but let’s move on so I

think there’s something to be said about

how similar we all are and that we’re

all so different and that’s a critical

point to understand especially when

we’re surrounded by so many different

kinds of people think about the activity

we just did think about when we raise

our hands for different things it may

sound silly but it really reminds us how

different we really are however we also

share a lot of things and an idea that I

think is worth spreading as that we as a

whole need to do a better job and

welcoming new American students into our

society by looking to the things that we

share rather than simply our differences

take school for example at school all

students come to learn grow and one day

become better versions of themselves and

to find success whether that’s for

themselves for others for their families

or even for the world we as students all

share this value in the pursuit of

success however despite this equivalency

there’s a clear divide as I walked

through the halls of high school as I

walked through high school I see this

huge divide between what we see as

normal people and different people new

American students are separated into

different classrooms not necessarily at

the fault of anyone since these students

do have to play catch-up but these

students are separated into different

classrooms where they can only interact

with people in the same situation there

rather than the huge portion of students

that they wouldn’t see outside of the in

school environment anyways these

students walk the halls together to the

same lunch tables and even use the same

corner bathroom sometimes known as

believe or not the foreigner bathroom

what does that reflect on how we truly

welcome new American students on the

flip side we do an amazing job

celebrating the differences and

uniqueness in our cultures we find ways

to highlight the beauty and value in

these cultures we hold celebrations

dances and events that truly show all

the amazing things that we have in our

differences however why can’t we do the

same thing and celebrate the things we

share why can we find a way to sit down

and to borrow from the Turk theme break

bread with different kinds of students

and identify the things we share our

passion for music our love for sports

and our lust for knowledge I’d like to

draw on a specific personal experience

that really taught me a lesson in

understanding shared values this stories

the story is fairly unique in that as

you can tell I’m not your typical

Midwestern white kid but I think that

just further goes to show that the way

in which we want welcome new American

students into our society is something

that we all can work on and that is not

just a cultural or racial issue but a

societal issue few years ago I sat down

in chemistry class eager and excited my

entire educational career has led up to

this moment after cheesy nineties lab

safety videos and hours spent in class

simply talking about once we were going

to do in the chemistry lab once we were

older I was really looking forward to

finally being able to experiment in the

lab one common component of working in

the science lab that many of you may

remember is the coveted lab partner the

person that destiny chooses for you to

work with for a year of chemical mixing

and flame testing for me this led up to

the biggest moment of my chemistry

career chemistry class career because

this would determine how the rest of the

year was going to go now let me say this

I’ve had plenty of friends that were

different than me whether that being

interests opinions or even cultures

however that day I found myself

experiencing a twinge of hesitation not

a substantial amount of hesitation but a

twinge nonetheless and that twinge led

me to realize that something was wrong

now many of you are probably scratching

ahead at this point because I just said

that I’ve had plenty of friends that

were different than me whether that be

an interest opinions or culture however

at the same time I’m saying that I was

hesitant to be paired with someone and

let me tell you who this was

this student was a new American student

who just recently came to America he was

from Vietnam and I had a twinge of

hesitation I openly admit that but the

key point I want to get out of this is

that we aren’t comfortable with our

perceived differences if you see someone

you perceive them as different there’s

and you you don’t want to admit it but

it’s there there’s a hesitation that’s

there and you don’t know what to do

about it and this confused me because my

entire life I’ve been surrounded by

different people whether that’s

different interests different cultures

yet I had this twinge of hesitation and

I was still hesitant to be paired with

his new American student moving forward

I was able to address this internal

barrier through experience as the year

went on I began to communicate more and

more with my lab partner and began to

realize there was a lot more that we

shared that I initially thought he

talked about his personal story his

personal life his job his interests his

opinions on things his favorite sports

even his idols and music I began to

realize that this hesitation was built

off of the attitudes that surrounded me

in my peers and in my education think

back to activity we just did everyone in

this room is so diverse and so different

however we’re all so similar we’re all

here we’re all talking about important

issues important things that mattered to

us we’re talking about ideas and values

that we all share why can’t we find a

way to translate that appreciation for

our differences and that openness nett

welcome this to our differences and the

acceptance that our differences are what

create parallels why can we translate

that to the classroom now I’m not here

to propose perfect solutions or

permanent fixes to the small and

inherent hesitations we have towards new

American students in our society I’m not

here to tell you all what to do or how

to do it I’m here communicating through

a candid and honest student perspective

that we need to find it within ourselves

to find new ways to welcome new American

students into our society we can always

celebrate religion and beliefs and

traditions and all the things that make

us different but where has that led us

from talking about all the things that

make us different we’ve lost the

understanding of the things that we’ve

shared I challenge you all to think in

my

personal story I challenge you all to

meet a different lab partner and to work

and to listen to that lab partner and if

life gives you a lab partner that maybe

you weren’t expecting you’d be surprised

what kind of chemistry can develop from

it thank you

it’s time to reflect on how we welcome

new American students and it’s time to

rethink how we do that as well we need

to challenge ourselves to break bread

with different kinds of people and to

break barriers externally and internally

along the way we are not that different

ladies and gentlemen and I challenge you

all to think about what I’ve said today

and I hope that you see it as an idea

worth spreading I thank you all for

listening to me – to me today sorry

bit of an accent there and I really hope

that all of you find your own lab

partner thank you very much

[Applause] you

Please follow and like us: