
you look at your clothes look at your
books look at your shoes look at your
handbags and think of where all that
material came from when you eat
chocolate do you think that you’re only
able to eat that chocolate in India
because another bossy woman somewhere
with collecting Sal seeds which makes
the oil that goes into substituting for
cocoa butter when you look at your
handbags do you think of tannin that
converts hides into leather the drugs
that you take when you’re sick Bedi
leaves I don’t know how many of you
smoke beedis but everything almost
everything that we you know look at our
paper of course tables books doors
windows of course this was before
everything became prefabricated chemical
but so much of our sense of who we are
the stage that I’m standing on has wood
comes because of the forest and who
brings that to us it doesn’t come into
the market of its own it comes because
there are people who know how to get
this stuff out of the forest people who
spend their days collecting it finding
the honey finding the right kind of
medicinal plant and bringing it to us
but where is this knowledge what is
happening to it
what are we doing about it how do we
make it part of our education that’s
something I think that we really all of
us need to think about when you for
instance see somebody at a traffic light
when you see a construction worker at a
you know building site next door
have you ever thought that this is
somebody who could actually be one of
the last few speakers of an endangered
language that this person that you see
carrying bricks is somebody who might
actually know the names of four hundred
plants you know more if I’ve lived in
Delhi all my life I can barely identify
ten trees in Delhi but I was asking some
children in bustard how many plants that
they you know how many plants they could
name and the real dove 100 names you
know without any problem different kinds
of leaves different kinds of plants
different uses and one bed in East
Godavari districts told me that he knew
the names of four hundred plants and
different uses for them so what’s
happening to that kind of knowledge we
talked about we constantly told that our
devices are need to be civilized if you
look at all the government policy
documents they’re all about how people
need to be mainstreamed now you would
have heard this word constantly we need
to mainstream our population we need to
especially when we’re talking about you
know what education means we really have
to think that we cannot have education
we cannot have something like that X we
cannot have technology innovation
without diversity and because grey
matters because gray matter is not just
in the heads of students again DTU but
in the whole in their University but
because grey matters wherever it can be
found we need to recognize that our
greatest strength in India is really
diversity and when we talk about
mainstreaming what are we thinking of
that everyone should speak English that
everyone should go to a mosque torchwood
water temple that everyone should wear
designer clothes
you know what when the means when our
own mainstream the mainstream of India
is the most incredible diverse place
that we can ever imagine
then the want to restrict it to a few
dominant languages of your dominant
religions a few dominant cultures or
ways of wearing is actually forcing us
to lose much more than we have gained in
terms of knowledge so just to give you
one little idea of I mean a few examples
of the kind of diversity that we have in
India the people of India project which
is something that was conducted by the
anthropological survey bounded above
four thousand six hundred and ninety
three communities in India the census of
India 2011 found 122 languages that were
spoken by more than by communities of
more than 10,000 speakers of which of
these 124 languages only 22 are official
languages but there are many languages
which are not official languages but
which are spoken by millions of speakers
so for instance Gandhi which is one of
the dominant Arabic languages it’s
spoken by 2.7 million speakers is not a
scheduled language Karuk again spoken by
1.7 million speakers mundari is broken
by 1 million speakers all of these are
languages with rich histories with rich
knowledge but they are not part of
artificial shells the people of India of
the linguistics peoples linguistic
Survey of India found that there was 780
languages in India and a small state
like our natural has 90 languages
nowadays when we think of our natural be
thinking of we you know we think of the
assembly and all the kind of changes
that you went on there but we don’t
think of how much you know when we talk
about politics in this country all we
talk about is the same all political
parties we don’t talk about the fact
that
you know here is a state with 90
languages that even Gujarat has 48
different languages so you think of
Gujarat is a homogenous state with one
language Gujarati but actually there are
many many people who may speak Gujarati
and their own other languages there are
66 scripts in India the National
knowledge Commission found that there
were four thousand five hundred and two
different types of agricultural
practices when we think of rice there
are 70,000 rice varieties in India even
if you think of what you are cooking on
an everyday basis on a random basis if
you count all the different kinds of
spices vegetables etc that you would use
and you know again artists cooking these
days is very restricted and if you think
of all the recipes that your
grandmother’s new people use on average
at least a hundred and fifty different
types of fruits and 150 different types
of vegetables so we have this incredible
incredible diversity in the country
which is something that we don’t seem to
care about something that we don’t seem
to preserve and we are allowing it to
disappear at a rate that is faster than
the rate of knowledge that we are
acquiring now what are the factors that
lead to the destruction of all of this
indigenous knowledge one is especially
when it comes to a diverse sees this
whole tendency to look down on them to
think that these are people who are
uncivilized I’ve seen bus conductors in
places like buzzard picking out picking
off old Adivasi men and women of the
streets now imagine of the seats making
asking them to make way for some young
official type who has a greater right to
that bus seat imagine if that happened
to your grandmother how would you feel
there is the Government of India had put
on had created an official tourism
website for bustard which said
the goons do not drink water like normal
human beings they put their work mouths
down to the stream like cattle they have
Pro fertility mentality they are always
drunk they drunk and carouse in a
drunken mood and have sex and all the
time now this is the way that the Gov if
the government is beginning to think
about its own people in this kind of way
then what hope is there that the
government is actually going to value
their knowledge treat them as anything
more than labor the second big problem
is displacement now as I said first the
FIR problem is the kind of cultural
denigration of a Debussy’s the fact that
historically across the world whenever
the government has or invading settler
colonies like in the US or Australia
they wanted to take over their land one
of the easiest ways of justifying use
using savage methods against indigenous
people is to call them savages so that
you don’t have to feel bad about your
displacement now there have been three
major waves of displacement in the last
200 years that have completely changed
the lives of millions and millions of
people in this country change the way
our environment looks changed our
ability to access knowledge now the
first big wave was forest cultivation if
you look at the photo on the left that’s
a normal bio diverse natural forest and
this is the kind of forest that the
forest department historically have
wanted to replace them with plantations
which have one species single row
because they’re easier to produce timber
from beef kinds of forests mass-produced
forest so what are we lost we have lost
this huge biodiversity this knowledge
of different types of plants different
types of species and we’ve gained the
knowledge of how to cut trees on a
commercial basis between 90 between the
17th century and the mid 20th century
about 13.5 million square kilometres of
forest were lost due to railway is due
to cultivation due to population growth
to industrialization the second big
phase of displacement in India has been
large dams and the study done by Walter
Fernandes estimated and this is a
serious underestimation that between
1950 and 2000 about 60 million people
had been displaced due to large projects
and 40% of them were adivasis
which means given that the adivasi
population is about 8.6 percent that one
in every four adivasi have been
displaced sometimes more than once
sometimes the same village will have
been displaced because of a large dam
they move into a forest area then that
polish becomes a national park when
they’re displaced again and finally they
end up in the slums of Delhi and the
third major phase of displacement since
the early part of the century is mining
and as you can see very clearly the
areas of mining or forests overlap very
clearly with the areas of Adivasi
populations and they are being widely
spaced for that the other big problem is
when we talk of formal schooling of
course everyone should be literate
everyone should be educated we want that
for ourselves you want that for our
devices we want that for Dalits we want
that for minorities but we also have to
be careful that schooling doesn’t mean
that people are made to feel inferior
they’re told that if they don’t speak
one of the dominant languages follow one
of the dominant religions that somehow
they are culturally inferior that when
they begin to speak the dominant
language somehow they will become much
that’s a huge problem given how much
knowledge we lose when vinos particular
languages the innards for example have
22 different words for white simply
because all the see around them is snow
so when you see so many different
varieties of snow there are there’s gray
snow white snore pure white snow and it
means something that those different
words exist for those different types of
practices villagers in Rajasthan have
different Anupa mishra talks about how
they have different words for different
types of raindrops patter raindrops have
a different name thin raindrops have a
different name and when we lose these
words we lose the idea the knowledge
that there are these different types of
raindrops different types of snows
different types of trees different types
of plants we’re always being told that
people need to be modern they need to
leave the forests come and live in urban
areas that they will be skilled they
will be employed but we’re really
talking about only skill employment for
about 10% which is the formal sector and
in doing that we are forgetting the
remaining 90% of our informal sector
which is really what is going to drive
our economic growth the national
knowledge Commission estimates is that
creatively tapping this informal sector
knowledge could actually lead to a
hundred million persons being employed
every year and sixty thousand crores
annually in terms of revenue so it’s not
just about citizenship it’s about good
business sense it’s about good economics
it’s about preserving our knowledge that
we should learn we look around to look
at the knowledge that people have
instead of constantly looking down and
thinking that we’re somewhere up here
thank you [Applause]