Press "Enter" to skip to content

Why it’s better to stop searching for your true self | Michael Puett | TEDxNashville


hi everyone so let’s talk about
something simple how do I live a good
life how do I live a flourishing life
how do I become a good human being now
we kind of think that’s tough to do but
at least we think we know the answers to
it and let’s just lay those out kind of
quickly um what I should do is I should
look within I should try to find myself
find my true self and once I find myself
I should try to strive to be sincere and
authentic to who I really am deciding in
my life what to do how to do things the
daily basis but what to do in a bigger
level to my future career partners etc
based on what is really me and part of
that is of course I should learn to love
myself and embrace myself for who I
really am loving myself for my good
sides of course but you’re loving myself
for my bad side so I may just be someone
who gets angry at little things I
sometimes have a bad temper but that’s
just me and I should love myself for who
I am and as long as I do that embracing
myself loving myself then I can strive
to live my life on my own terms and
luckily we have lots of things that can
help us do this right we can take
personality tests that will give us if
you answer them very carefully it’ll
give you a sense of exactly who you are
as a person and then what would be a
good career for you when what would be a
good partner for you and we help
ourselves guide in trying to do this so
if you’re applying to say college you’re
in high school and we’ll say write a
college admissions essay trying to
present who you really are how all of
your activities have really led you to
being who you are and therefore what’s
going to propel you forward when we’re
asking people about a future career same
thing we say you’ll find yourself think
about who you are and think about what
would work well for you and when we
think this we think luckily and it’s
tough to always do but luckily we can do
this
means we can live true liberated lives
and we can decide for ourselves what to
do and we often will to put to some kind
of a larger vision of the world wherein
we luckily can do these things we can
live true liberated lives being true to
ourselves because we’re modern people we
live in the modern world and this is
unlike those people sadly for them who
lived in traditional societies
traditional societies where they had to
do things like rituals for example write
rituals that would actually tell you
what to do as opposed to letting you
decide for yourself what to do rituals
that would socialize you into certain
ways of being certain assumptions about
the world instead of letting you choose
for yourself what’s best for you and
they all of these people who live before
us
stuck in these traditional societies
couldn’t do what we now can do so
luckily for us we can find ourselves so
let me just begin with an opening
question what if we’re wrong
what if we’re wrong not just empirically
about so-called traditional societies
which is we’ll see you worry a little
more complicated than we think what if
we’re wrong at a more fundamental level
– what if we’re wrong about the self
what if we have a really dangerous
restricted limited view of the self what
if we’re wrong about how we can grow as
human beings and what if some of these
ideas that we relegate to so-called
traditional societies maybe we’re onto
something that we should take seriously
that we should really allow to challenge
our fundamental assumptions what if in
other words we have rendered most of
humanity as being someone being
something from which we can learn
nothing and what if that very move is a
very dangerous one so to make this
argument let me turn to some classical
Chinese views of the self classical
China certainly as traditional according
to we think our definition of the term
is you could be but let’s talk about
their view of the self their view of
ritual their view of how we could live a
flourishing life and what it might mean
for us were we’ve to take it seriously
so let’s begin with
self this thing that we keep trying to
look within and find let me talk a bit
about classical Chinese views at the
self and I’ll forewarn you at first it’s
going to sound a little bleak but bear
with me but here’s the bleak stuff do we
have one true self that we should be
looking within and finding no know what
we are is a mess we are a mess of
different energies and dispositions and
desires and faculties and we’re all
equally messes equally messes and the
ways that we interact in the world is we
encounter other people other messes in
other words and we’re constantly
dragging out pulling out from each other
different responses so someone will
smile at me I get happy in this way of
thinking that person smiled drags out
from me the energy of happiness than
someone yells at me and it drags out
from me an energy of anger and we are
largely passive in the world endlessly
being dragged and pulled different ways
emotionally by based on things we
immediately encounter purely passively
and then it’s much bleaker because what
also happens from again a very young age
is we fall into patterns and rats in
these responses so someone smiles to be
in someone’s yells at me right but then
someone else smiles at me or doesn’t
smile at me someone does something that
reminds me emotionally at that moment
when someone smiled at me and it equally
drags out for me any motion of happiness
someone does something that emotionally
reminds me for whatever reason of
someone who yelled at me it drags out
for me an emotion of anger and what
happens from a very young age is that we
cease to even respond passively to the
world around us which is bad enough we
start responding by patterns that we
fall into patterns in which I will
simply be constantly responding to the
world that isn’t even there because it
reminds me of previous events and these
patterns in which I’m happy
sad and angry and resentful and jealous
all of these patterns become so embedded
in me that it defines how I experience
the world how I build relationships how
I even see what’s around me or more
importantly usually don’t see what’s
around me in fact these patterns become
so embedded in my entire way of being
that I begin to call them me I begin to
associate them with just my personality
my characteristics because they so
dominate how I experience the world and
putting it weakly these patterns
continue
week after week month after month decade
after decade they define us
they define us as human beings repeating
these patterns and lastly now if they’re
right and I might add scarily there are
about tons of psychological experiments
arguing that yes this vision basically
is right this is what we’re like as
human beings note immediately that if
you then say to someone you know you’re
having a tough time you just need to
find yourself and you just need to love
yourself for who you really are know
what you’re loving yourself for is a
bunch of patterns and ruts that you’ve
fallen into what you’re embracing
yourself for and what you’re defining
your life by are patterns and rats in
short if they’re right about this the
last thing you want to be doing is
loving yourself and finding this inner
self that you think is you what you want
to do and I’ll use one of their terms
attributed to a figure called Confucius
what you want to do is overcome the self
what you want to do is conquer the self
the self being understood is simply
these patterns and ruts that define us
and if that’s true how do you do it well
one of the key things you do is you
follow rituals the very thing that we
associate with these traditional worlds
the very thing we associate as
bad because it tells us what to do so
let’s look at their view of ritual why
do you do ritual assuming this notion of
the self that we’ve been discussing
here’s why you do ritual you do ritual
because rituals force you for that brief
moment to become a different person to
see the world from different perspective
to interact with those around you in a
slightly different way and the idea is
by doing that you’re not being
socialized into thinking this ritual
world is the real world you’re doing it
because it breaks you from your patterns
it breaks you from the usual way you’re
seeing the world and it opens up other
possibilities let me give you one of
their examples to give a sense of what
this means let’s talk about one of those
relationships that um I’m glad to say I
do not understand because I have a
wonderful relationship with the
equivalent of what I’m about to speak
about but let’s talk about one of those
relationships that can sometimes be a
bit problematic
fathers and sons now I have a wonderful
father and wonderful relationship so I
don’t understand this but some people
will know that sometimes some
complexities develop it’s a loving
wonderful relationship with the father
helping the Son and the son striving to
be like the father but because of the
same factors other emotions kind of set
in right all of the angers and
jealousies and resentments that can sit
in in any hierarchical relationship
where the father yes wants to send us
succeed but the son is always not
failing and always failing not quite
succeeding the sons feeling both trying
to be like the father but a little bit
rebellious and you get these very
dangerous dynamics that begin setting in
so how do you solve it do you have the
to sit down and have a nice chat well if
we’re these passive creatures that fall
into these patterns that define us at
know you can talk and talk until you’re
blue in the face you’re still going to
fall back into your patterns so here’s
what you do what you do in this case is
you enter a ritual in which each was
forced to play the role of the other one
the father has to play the son of his
own son
so he has to look at his own son as if
he were his father and the son has to
play the role of the father of his own
father looking at his own father as if
he were the son being forced over and
over again to enter this ritual space
and see the world not just from a
different perspective but from the
different perspective the perspective of
the person with whom they have the most
tensions and you forced to do it over
and over again the son learning from a
young age what it’s like to be in a
position of authority all the
responsibilities and yes potential
arrogance that can set in the father
being forced again to remember what it’s
like to be in a subservient position and
each being forced to see the world from
the opposite perspective begins a break
in their usual relationship now take the
heart example and then imagine you’re
doing these rituals all the time with
all of the complicated relationships
that define you the goal of which of
course is not to socialize you into that
way of thinking that I’ve been
socialized to stick with this example to
think of your son as your father you’re
being forced to break your patterns and
where does this take you well let me
again give one of their examples before
I get to ourselves here’s one of their
examples a figure who was seen as
someone who spent his life yes doing
these rituals in this sense of the term
his name you’ve probably heard of him
he’s already popped up once Confucius
seeing as someone who spent his life
doing this as someone who as he’s
described toward the end of his life who
could simply enter a situation since all
the patterns playing out around him
because he’s gotten so good at sensing
this and since immediately the little
things he can do gestures quotation
statements little things he can do to
break these patterns alter the situation
and open up new possibilities that’s
what he’s training himself to do and now
let’s turn to ourselves suppose they’re
onto something suppose they’re onto
something about the notion of the self
and how we could become better human
beings
note what this would mean not only are
we not loving ourselves and embracing
ourselves for who we are what we’re
really trying to do is the opposite
we’re trying to break these patterns
that we see is dominating us we’re
training ourselves to constantly create
these little breaks no we don’t have to
do rituals in the usual way that we
think of rituals you’re doing little
things all the time to create these
breaks when you get in these difficult
relationships in other words
relationships or you have difficult
family dynamics in other words a typical
family what you’re doing are these
little breaks these little shifts
something so simple as the families
fighting it’s it’s a miserable evening
everyone’s coming back from their work
in school and you simply set the dinner
in a way that creates a different
atmosphere you light the candles you
create a calm situation and people begin
talking to each other outside of the
in-person jealousies and resentments and
then you do the equivalent of that
constantly all the time and you’re
training yourself over time to be able
to sense the complexity of situations to
be able to sense yes the world is messy
that I’m not a person those around me
are not particularly are and all the
difficulties I’m in this person that has
a bad temper or this person’s friendly
it’s not them it’s patterns I’m doing
things that are creating certain
patterns and others I can change those
and I can change others and what you’re
gaining over time through your daily
mundane life is a sense that the ways we
live our daily lives we can actually
instead of falling into these patterns
train ourselves to send situations train
ourselves to do things that can create
worlds at a minimal and very high level
as well in which people around us can
begin to flourish you’re training
yourself to do that in mundane
situations at the larger level to larger
societal issues what are the larger
patterns playing out what are the
trajectories of those patterns how do I
do things that can alter those patterns
and if you’re thinking of your life this
way what it means is a constant work of
breaking these patterns sensing the
world around you
sensing
to create situations within which humans
can flourish and that is an
extraordinary vision it’s a vision in
which yes these ideas that we relegate
to the past because of our patterned way
of thinking about the traditional past
are seen as alive things from which we
can learn things that we can use to
break to use the word again our own
assumptions and from which we can learn
do that and we begin to create a truly
cosmopolitan world a world in which we
are training ourselves not to be who we
already are but in which we are training
ourselves to create worlds in which we
can flourish and become things that we
currently cannot even imagine that is an
extraordinary vision of what we
potentially could be as human beings
thank you so much [Applause]
Please follow and like us: