Press "Enter" to skip to content

Forgiveness In The Criminal Justice System | Judge Sheila D.J. Calloway | TEDxNashville


[Applause]

and I’m not singing I Will Survive today

I know I know it does avoid him can

forgiveness transform the criminal

justice system forgiveness criminal

justice I know there’s someone out there

thinking no way he broke into my house

he took all of my valuables I can’t

forgive him there’s also somebody who

might be saying but she tricked me out

of a thousand dollars it was my last

$1,000 and I was saving it up for my

rich how can I forgive that person

there’s probably also somebody thinking

he hit me he hit me and he destroyed our

family

forgiveness forgiveness in the criminal

justice system before we talk about the

concepts of forgiveness in the criminal

justice system I want each of you all to

just think about a time where somebody

hurt you think about a time maybe it was

your spouse or your may or perhaps it

was you know a parents or a sibling you

know or worse yet your best friend

someone you can fight it in someone that

you gave your all t and they betrayed

you how did that make you feel how did

that hurt make you feel and how did you

work to get through that hurt and how

did you forgive that person when we

think about forgiveness Webster’s

definition of forgiveness is to stop

feeling anger toward someone who has

done something

wrong or to stop blaming someone or to

stop feeling anger about something so

let’s go back to that time when you were

feeling hurt how did you move from that

hurt feeling to forgiveness

well that one thing that you needed to

get over this hurt was you needed that

person who hurt you to recognize truly

recognize how you were hurt and you also

wanted that person to acknowledge what

they did and how that hurt you and it

also made you feel so much better if

that person not only recognized your

hurt and what they did to cause it hurt

but also what they could do to help you

to get through that hurt true

forgiveness now when we think about the

criminal justice system just raise your

hand if you already know how the

criminal justice system kind of works

anybody has somebody now I’m not gonna

ask you how you know how the criminal

justice system works but just raise your

hand if you know a little about the

criminal justice system and so for those

who don’t let me talk to you about

criminal justice 101 say crime occurs

and the system works to find that person

who caused that crime and once that

person is identified then there’s a

system where a formal process begins

that person is usually charged could be

arrested there’s a prosecution that’s

appointed to represent or to take care

of that case and the prosecution’s job

is to represent the interest of the

state not the interest of the victim the

interest of the state and the person who

was charged with the crime will call

that person the defendant

the defendant is entitled to have an

attorney and that attorneys job is to

zealously represent his client that

attorneys job is to make sure that their

client is presumed innocent until proven

guilty throughout the entire stages of

that proceeding and they’re gonna hold

that system to that bourbon so when we

think about the criminal justice system

there really are three questions that we

focus on what laws have been broken who

did it in what do they deserve and when

we focus on those questions we don’t

really have the opportunity to think

about the harm the victim and how we

cure that harm so I’m going to spend a

few minutes talking about a few of

criminal cases that most of you probably

have heard a little about some very

famous cases one of them from my alma

mater the Vanderbilt University rape

case now this is not what we’re proud of

we’re proud of all the other many things

but the Vanderbilt University rape case

which probably many of you heard about

already now I’m not going to discuss the

case or the facts or the things that

happen but what I do want us to focus on

is the statements that were made by the

victim when she had an opportunity to

make a statement there are several

things that she stated about the

criminal justice system and about how it

made her feel one thing she said was

it’s hard for me to stand here on

display and speak to you today about the

impact this has had on my life the

thought of sharing anymore of myself

that hasn’t already been taken from me

seems unbearable and it goes against

every instinct that I have she went

further on to say

the attack on me didn’t end that day

because I relive it in every proceeding

and experienced additional tax every

time that I am in court she also stated

since the horror of that night all I

have wanted is for this to be behind me

to be left alone and it tried to live my

life in peace but the process to get to

justice has been a never-ending constant

misery that has twisted itself so into

my life that I can’t even remember what

it was like at a time when this wasn’t

happening

everything the defendant has done in

this case and the media circus

surrounding it had been a continuous

disruption repeatedly dragging me back

every step I try to take forward and she

further stated it made me angry

because I didn’t have a voice and I

couldn’t say anything and that’s also

look at the Stanford University rape

case very similar circumstances very

similar case again focusing on her

statement the victim stated I thought

there’s no way this is going to trial

there were witnesses there was dirt in

my body he ran but was caught he’s going

to settle formally apologized and we

will both move on she also said instead

of taking time to heal I was taking time

to recall the night in excruciating

detail in order to prepare for the

attorneys questions that would be

invasive aggressive and designed to

steer me off course to contradict myself

my sister phrased in ways to manipulate

my answers

she further went on to say had Brock

admitted guilt and remorse and offered

to settle early on I would have

considered a lighter sentence respecting

his honesty grateful to be able to move

our lives forward and finally she stated

I also told the probation officer that

what I truly wanted was for brought to

get it to understand and to admit his

wrongdoing it’s clear in both of these

examples that our criminal justice

system fails in many ways our criminal

justice system does not allow an

opportunity for the harms to be

discussed an opportunity for a ability

to defigurates the store ative justice

would it have made a difference

if we had a system that allows for

forgiveness so let’s talk a little about

what is restorative justice according to

how it’s there who is the king or the

the Godfather of restorative justice

here in the United States he defines

restorative justice as an approach to

achieving justice that involves to the

extent possible those who have a stake

in a specific offense or harm to

collectively identify and address the

harms needs and obligations in order to

so restorative justice moves to

conversation from who did the crime and

what they deserve and moves it to a

questions of

who has been harmed what are their needs

and whose responsibility our obligations

are those to fix that arm if I get it

it’s kind of strange sounding how does

restorative justice really work in a

system astre storeit of justice when an

incident occurs that would normally be a

criminal offense the person who

committed the offense the victim family

members and members of the community

gather together in a restorative

community conferencing and at that

conferencing they discuss the crime they

discussed the causes of the crime and

the effects of the crime and as they’re

discussing they come together with a

consensus-based

plan I plan for that person who did the

harm to cure the harm to both the victim

the families involved the community as a

whole and for themselves it’s a time for

true self-reflection it’s a time for a

firm yet structured and supportive

accountability for that person who did

the harm and a commitment for everyone

at the conferencing circle to commit to

helping that person overcome obstacles

and to learn to do what’s right it’s a

system that works in communities that

have restored with justice what they

have found is that the recidivism rate

are the rate that someone gets real that

riaf ends after they’ve gone through a

program the recidivism rate

is greatly reduced in the victim

satisfaction rate with the system is

greatly improved so let’s take Alameda

County California for instance they have

a juvenile court restorative justice

program and in that program they have a

91% satisfaction rate for the victims

and also in that program for the youth

that come back to the program the

recidivism rate for those in an 18-month

period that have gone through the

restorative justice process is less than

20% which is a stark difference from the

forty percent of those that come back

that have not gone through restorative

justice program so restorative justice

in New Zealand is the thing that they do

that’s what they do they don’t do a

regular criminal justice system they

start off with a restorative justice

program and there are several

communities in the United States that

have done it as well

for instance Alameda County San

Francisco Long Beach California and

Baltimore Maryland and all those

programs the ones here are juvenile

programs which makes me proud because

Girona courts always on the cutting edge

of doing things the right way but in

these programs the restorative justice

works and it’s defined as according to

an article called kin forgiveness be a

part of our criminal justice system

that’s in the New York Times

most modern justice systems focus on a

crime a law breaker and a punishment but

a concept called restorative justice

considers harm done and strives for

agreement from all concerned the victims

the offender and the community on making

amends and it louse the victims who

often feel shut out of the prosecutorial

process a way to be heard and

participate

now you may ask I get it I get where

restorative justice can work in a

juvenile court facility or program but

can restorative justice work as an adult

program if you read the article can

forgiveness play a role in criminal

justice the answer is yes we can do it

in the adult criminal system as well I’m

gonna tell you about one particular case

that it has been very successful in but

before I tell you about the case I need

to tell you about my mentor one of my

favorite people in the whole entire

world

her name is Sujata Baliga and Sujatha is

the director of the restorative justice

practice for impact justice in

California and they are the leading

cutting brand of doing restorative

justice

Sujatha who by herself was a child

victim of sexual assault

just had a love for two Beeson ideas and

she worked with children and women who

were victims of sexual assaults and that

work led her to law school and then her

own search for forgiveness as a victim

led her to become one of the founding

greatest people working with restorative

justice and so because of her work a

family actually two families a defendant

family and a victim’s family reached out

to her this family was in Florida and

they were struggling of a murder case it

was a domestic violence murder case as

they wanted to do restorative justice

the father the article if you’ll read it

says Ann’s face was covered in bandages

and she was incubated in unconscious but

Andy felt her say forgive him his

response was immediate no he said out

loud no way it’s impossible but Andy

kept hearing his daughter’s voice

forgive him forgive him and from Connor

the defense

after the restorative justice process

was done stated hearings of pain and

their voices and what my actions had

done really opened my eyes to what I’ve

caused in the victim’s family and

observations about them goes on to say

the gross Meyer said they didn’t forgive

Connor for his sake but for their own

everything I feel I can feel because we

forgave Connor Kate said because we

could forgive people can say her name

people can think about my daughter and

they don’t have to think owes a murdered

girl I think that when people can’t

forgive they’re stuck all they can feel

is the emotion surrounding that moment I

can be sad but I don’t have to stay

stuck in that moment where the awful

thing happened because if I do I may

never come out of it forgiveness for me

was self persuasion and finally what

they define forgiveness forgiveness

doesn’t make him any less guilty and it

doesn’t absolve him of what he did but

in refusing to become Connors enemy the

gross Myers deprived him of a certain

kind of refuge of feeling abandoned and

hated and placed the reckoning of the

crime squarely in his hands now I get it

forgiveness is hard forgiveness is a

heart they it doesn’t happen overnight

you have to work to get there

forgiveness is something that we’ve

talked about since we were little and

you know most religions talk about

forgiveness and we even sing about it

and some songs like you know y’all

remember Purple Rain from Prince I never

meant to cause you any problems never

meant to cause you any pain or we could

think about big old good Chicago song

you know the one I want to forget the

song

hold me now it’s hard for me to say I’m

sorry and that advant got famous all for

her song about apologies and being sorry

hello that’s all you get but when you

think about forgiveness we as a society

has to find a place for forgiveness in

our criminal justice system and

restorative justice will lead the way

you may not be ready yet but as sudah

always says we’ll get there we may not

be ready yet

but we’ll get there thank you and enjoy

your day [Applause]

Please follow and like us: