Press "Enter" to skip to content

Breaking Down Gender Roles in Swing Dance | Calvin Lu and Samantha Nguyen | TEDxGunnHighSchool


got to set my fingers got to rhythm in

my MA

as the elephant’s say I’m living in a

great way

[Music]

nothing but I watch it like a heart and

I’m doing okay

believe it in a great way something

oh I’m the Sun in the sky

[Music]

a million dollars as long as I gots to

set my finger got to rhythm in my bar

the devil to pay in a great way well

we’re a little out of breath but I’d

like to introduce ourselves hi everyone

I’m Sam and I’m Calvin

we’re Lindy hoppers or swing dancers

that means we do a dance called Lindy

Hop Lindy Hop is a social dance they

evolved in the 1920s and 30s alongside

the evolution of jazz music and while

this dance saw a major decline around

World War two it was brought back around

the 1980s with a huge swing dancing

revival and thinks important figures

like Frankie Manning here we are today

with the dance very much alive in fact

here in the Bay Area

you can go dancing almost any night of

the week and walk into a room full of

people all you know may be close friends

with each other

maybe strangers and they’re all dancing

together and eager to dance with you

we’re not experts at the dance

we’ve both been dancing for about four

years now but there’s one thing that’s

for sure and that’s we love this dance

we love the joy and exuberance that you

can feel dancing with someone totally in

Prague but feeling really inspired by

your partner and the best part is that

you get to share the same feeling and

sentiment over and over and over again

the entire night with a new partner and

a new dance and for this reason we love

the swing dancing community but with all

great communities there’s always room

for improvement

so today

Calvin and I want to share with you our

experience in trying to improve our

already great swing dancing community or

at least our little corner of it we want

to share with you our process for taking

and looking at our community asking

ourselves is this the ideal state that

we want it to be in and if not figuring

out ways in which we can improve on them

so Lindy Hop like most social dances has

a leader and a follower someone who

initiates movement and someone who

responds to those movements in that

dance that we just had I started as the

leader but halfway through we actually

switched so that I was following and Sam

was leading now that’s probably not

something that you see very often in

movies or in TV shows like Dancing with

the Stars it’s almost always a man

leading and a woman following but we

think that this seems to perpetuate a

very negative power dynamic one where

the man pulls and the woman Falls one

where the man asserts and the woman

reacts or one where the man makes the

decisions and the woman allows them to

happen to her what he says goes now

obviously Sam and I would love to see

you know more diversity in pop culture

media but let’s look at something a

little smaller in scale let’s look at

our swing dancing community so

historically when men left to fight in

World War two the women back home had to

learn to dance with other woman and and

sorry our pictures not showing oh here

it is and the men learned to dance with

other men and so woman leading and men

following wasn’t super

coming nowadays though at least from our

experiences we don’t see that many men

lead it dancing with other men or women

dancing with other women and we don’t

especially don’t see women leading men

we almost never see a reversal of the

power dynamic it still seems to be the

case that when one man and one woman

dance together it’s somehow more ideal

if the man is leading and the woman is

following and if you look off the social

dance floor and you look at competitions

and performances and choreographies you

know the videos that would probably end

up on YouTube that you all could watch

they seem to all be saying the same

exact thing and that’s swing dancing is

a man and a woman and the man leads and

the woman follows always but don’t get

us wrong let’s take a step back don’t

get us wrong we’re not trying to say

that we think that all men have to lead

and all women have to follow not at all

but we want to get to the real issue the

deeply rooted and in fact dangerous

issue the assumption that men must lead

and that women must follow and like with

all assumptions and values that you have

with you in a hobby such as swing

dancing they apply to the outside world

the your outside life as well so if we

don’t believe that men and women should

interact in this way in the rest of our

lives

then why is it that we’re cultivating

this idea in

side of our swing dancing community okay

so now we’ve kind of looked at our

community and we’ve seen that yes there

are things we can improve in it so now

one thing we can ask ourselves is kind

of how does this happen

kind of what forces are at work that

cause essentially all men to be leaders

and all women to be followers well let’s

start at the beginning

yeah so imagine that you’re learning to

swing dance by the way we hope this is

true after this talk that you do decide

to learn to sing dance but anyways

you’re learning to swing dance and you

go take your first class now in most

maybe not all but most Lindy Hop classes

you’ll only get to learn one roll so you

have to choose Sam and I have found that

in a lot of swing dancing classes there

are elements that kind of perpetuate a

gendered status quo you walk into the

class and all the teachers are always a

man leading and a woman following maybe

the teachers start off the class by

saying let’s have everyone get into

pairs and then everyone kind of

automatically pairs up one man one woman

maybe the teachers use gendered pronouns

like she and him when they refer to

followers and leaders even something as

simple as splitting the class

geographically maybe the teachers say

something like let’s have all the

leaders stand behind me on this side of

the room and watch my footwork and let’s

have all the followers stay on that side

of the room behind sam and watch her

footwork well that can be a little bit

of a tough situation if you don’t want

to be say the one guy standing on that

side of the room surrounded by was

otherwise all woman because maybe you

feel like that makes you stand out a

little too much or maybe because you’ll

feel awkward when someone you know and

the really helpful manner kind of taps

you on the shoulder and it’s like hey

buddy I think you’re on the wrong side

guys are on that side right it can be a

little scary already we know to learn to

dance going out there and learning to

dance that can be a little scary

and you know it’s scary enough without

having to challenge gender norms at the

same time and when you’re finished with

your classes it’s off to the social

dance floor but the social dance floor

and swing dancing is totally different

than say maybe homecoming or prom right

you don’t ask someone to be your date

for the entire night and you only dance

with that one person in swing dancing

social dancing means that you go to a

venue by yourself and then you get to

dance with lots of different people they

may be friends they may be acquaintances

but they could also be strangers so with

that in mind let’s get back to Calvin’s

scenario you’ve just finished your

classes and you’re super excited to get

to social dancing maybe a little nervous

you stand at the edge of the dance floor

waiting watching the other dancers and

hoping that someone will ask you to

dance and sure enough someone will

probably ask you to dance but it won’t

just be anyone if you’re a man women

will ask you to dance and furthermore

it’ll also assume that well you’re a man

so you must know how to lead right

and vice-versa if you’re a woman men

will ask you to dance and they’ll also

assume well you’re a woman you must know

how to follow and so

with that idea we’ve also applied that

to our experiences as well in our

experiences we found that people who

learn the role that quote unquote

doesn’t match their gender for example

if you’re a woman who learns how to lead

first you have a much harder time on the

social dance floor after all if you’re a

woman who only knows how to lead and men

keep coming up and asking you to dance

expecting you to follow well either you

get really lucky that that man also

knows how to follow or more likely and

more commonly you just you can’t dance

and so now we kind of have a coherent

explanation maybe for why when you watch

media of swing dancing you know

competitions and videos performances all

the men are leading and all the women

are following if you’re going to dance

in front of a crowd you know maybe in

front of a few cameras you probably want

to look good or you know maybe at least

look your best so you’re probably going

to dance in the role that you spend most

of your time in classes and in social

dancing doing right and well there you

have it from the classes to social

dancing – now performances and videos on

YouTube

we’ve analyzed and explained why dance

roles are so ingrained in gender so now

what well luckily we’re not the only

ones talking about this vlog city stomp

is a local event in San Francisco that

really makes it a point to be

progressive in what they do

for example they hire women in

underrepresented roles such as MCS and

DJs and musicians and they also enforce

that teachers don’t use gendered

pronouns when they’re teaching

they also help to promote a safe dance

space by having a very clear code of

conduct and even right here in Palo Alto

there’s a weekly swing dancing venue

called Wednesday night hop and it’s a

weekly venue that has classes and social

dancing every Wednesday night and

they’re also a force in which they’re

creating a progressive environment for

dancers here in the South Bay and what

about us well we are on the organizing

team of a new event called the switch

it’s a weekend long workshop being held

in San Francisco that’s focused on

breaking down gender norms we think that

this is an opportunity for us to kind of

address a lot of the you know coercive

forces and issues that we just described

for example we want to have classes in

which the teachers show that women can

be leaders and men can be followers in a

serious manner and we also want to offer

classes where people can learn both the

roles instead just one but we also want

to offer classes where people can choose

to learn one role but not have to worry

about feeling awkward about the world

that they chose chose and we also want

to have role markers these buttons that

say I know how to lead or I know how to

follow and you could even wear both at

the same time if you wanted to just so

gender isn’t the primary thing that we

use when we are trying to find someone

to dance with and we want to push the

word Amba dance trous kind of like

ambidextrous as a term that people who

dance both roles can identify with even

if they do one role better than the

other after all if a man takes one class

as a leader and you know everyone calls

him a leader then a woman who dances is

a follower for five years and then takes

one class as a leader it’s going to be

just as good a leader if not probably a

lot better and so we hope that this kind

of

helps to you know change our language

and separate and kind of decouple the

words leader from man and follower from

woman and for the switch what are we

really hoping for we’re hoping to create

a safe dance environment a safe dance

space and we want to promote these

thoughtful interactions between leaders

and followers and men and women but also

new dancers and experienced dancers and

these thoughtful interactions really are

not just about this small swing dancing

community that we have this really niche

thing that we do it’s about an attitude

that we can bring to the rest of our

lives because with the rest of our lives

it’s about all the things that we talked

about it’s about gender equality and

it’s about empowering both women and men

and it’s about shifting power dynamics

so that attitude that we can bring to

the rest of our lives is really what

we’re hoping for just in the same way

that we fight for gender equality in TV

and in film and in literature and many

other things we also fight for those

things and dance and we think it makes

the community stronger for it so

whatever community you’re part of

whether it’s a school club a workplace

maybe a group of friends we encourage

you to explore this process of

evaluating your community of kind of

looking at its flaws and understanding

why they’re there that way you can make

your little corner of the world a better

place we hope to see you on the social dance floor sometime thank you

Please follow and like us: