Press "Enter" to skip to content

The Women Effect | Ilyse Hogue | TEDxWUSTL


so I’m going to tell you a story that

starts in the early 90s about a group of

scientists that got together to solve a

global health problem was it curing

cancer no it wasn’t what about

malnutrition know what about

hypertension sort of it sort of was

about curing hypertension this is the

story of how viagra I came to be a group

of scientists who were studying about

how to decrease hypertension in the male

population found that a product they

were working with actually didn’t have

the intended effect but it had other

effects that they could um let’s say

leverage they applied for a patent in

1996 in 1998 viagra hit the shelves in a

few weeks later actually it was covered

by all insurance by 2012 viagra was 4.3

million billion sorry 4.3 billion on the

global marketplace so great right

everybody’s happy well sure except women

who were having a hard time sometimes

keeping up with their partners so what

about female viagra right that seems

like a reasonable answer to the solution

well not so much and here’s what we

figure it out the road to the little

pink pill has been a little rocky and

some of the answer lies strictly and how

viagra was found in the first place

there’s something called inherent bias

I’m sure all of you have heard about it

and harem bias simply means that the

rules of institutions and power reflect

the interest of those who build them

right the FDA like many governmental

structures was built by men and what we

found is that they had not only written

the rules but that in fact even products

that were designed for both genders were

disproportionately tested by Matt right

so and it was an accident that they

found viagra but the fact that the

product benefited men was no accident at

all you tend to find what you’re looking

for so that’s okay so people said okay

well we’ll get together we’ll try and

figure out

the little pink pill female viagra so

here’s what we found the FDA requires

and clinical trials a thousand four even

to apply for a patent on the marketplace

male viagra they went through three

thousand as I said they you know went in

about two years female viagra started

looking for a patent two years after

male viagra hit the shelves and didn’t

get one until 2013 after they’d gone

through 11,000 clinical trials why is

that I’ve spoken to the makers of the

product and they told me that while they

did face him overt hostility at the FDA

it wasn’t really that it was that the

way that the metrics were designed were

not taught to look at the different ways

that females process things versus males

the effects of viagra on males are well

shall we say pretty apparent for females

we’re just not wired that way there was

literally no protocol at the FDA to

gauge female sexual arousal and that’s

not it we hit another bump in the road

female viagra has side effects dizziness

drowsiness nausea unconsciousness when

mixed with alcohol oh but wait male

viagra also has dizziness drowsiness

nausea you guys have all heard the

commercials right fine to take except

for bubba baba ba-ba-ba-ba anyway but

the risks of female viagra actually held

it up and the risks of male viagra did

not my friend oh my friends hella

Greenberg at Consumer Union League says

women just like men should be allowed to

manage your own health phorus right that

was the inherent bias at the FDA men

could think about risk and make their

own decisions women could not so what

does this little story tell us inherent

bias is everywhere it’s not just at the

FDA and it’s actually not just about

gender which we know even though that is

the disproportionate focus of this time

the pay gap which should look very

familiar to you combines race and gender

let’s you know I’m sure this is all

really familiar so I’m only going to

spend a minute on it white women make

eighty-one cents on the dollar black

women make 65 cents on the dollar of

Hispanic women 57 cents on the dollar

rate women make less than men this is

obvious the question is not what but why

why are women making less than men women

are making less than men because

inherent bias women generally stay home

with the kids and men go out and earn

money combined with overt bias in some

sectors women should stay home with the

kids while men should go out and earn

money and those are very powerful social

factors to overcome when you have those

layered on top of each other so despite

the fact that we know this we haven’t

been able to overcome it and it’s not

just the what and the why but it’s the

impact of that women are significant

breadwinners and families two out of

three women with children work three out

of four women no sorry three out of four

women work two out of three women with

children are actually the primary

breadwinners in their family so you

can’t just look at that pay gap and

think oh wow that sucks women don’t make

as much as men there’s actually a

compounding effect to it women are asked

to stretch a dollar further not just for

themselves but for the families that are

dependent on them and the impact that we

get is policy that doesn’t reflect our

real lives the real needs of families

around us this should ah this should be

obvious to you guys too but when we talk

about why this stuff doesn’t change this

is just federal government we could do

it at state and local level women make

up a lot less local or a lot less

elected leadership than men right we all

know this what you may or may not know

is that this percentage puts us at 57th

in the world were on par with

Turkmenistan

just in case you want to feel proud

about that why is this women do win when

they run for office they’re just less

than half as likely to run they don’t

have the same amount of role models

they’re busier than men they’ve been

taught to stay the same course right

take less risks and even when they sort

of pursue the idea of running they get

less support they get less financial

support they get less emotional support

they get less encouragement so this is

what we end up with and the problem with

that is elected leadership that could

solve some of the problems we were just

talking about tends to vote what they

know best and they tend to vote their

own interest because after all I spent a

lot of time in DC you guys politicians

are just like all of us we all tend to

focus on our own interests right so this

is a perfect example of inherent bias

this is a credit card add from 1993 that

says marine Midland has a credit card so

safe even your wife won’t be able to use

it right what does this tell you this

tells you men go out and work really

really hard to earn money and women

cannot be trusted with it because we’re

frivolous and trivial this despite women

then as now we’re ultimately familiar

with what it meant to plan a monthly

budget make the groceries stretch over

the course of a month and in fact women

make up seventy percent of purchasing

power in this country this inherent bias

was so deep and so intense how many of

you know that when could not get a

credit card without their husband’s

permission until 1974 I see a lot of

people with their hands up that’s good

you guys are way ahead of the curve

usually people don’t know that all right

so what does this all mean you guys

asked me to talk about a renegade idea I

read on your website that that meant an

idea that goes against convention that

goes against the grain that questions

some of the things we think to be true

what if the key to actual progress and

prosperity is to turn that implicit bias

on its head and think through

women-centric lens right

k what I say what if what’s good for the

goose really really is what’s good for

the gander because one of the things

that we have to expand our thinking

about is it would be enough to fight for

gender equality just because women are

human and women have human rates it

would be enough but what if we’re not

just holding back individual women what

if we’re not just holding back millions

of women what if we’re actually holding

back all of society our entire country

because we can’t overcome our internal

bias let me tell you a story about

winter 2013 this is Washington DC it was

Snowmageddon the entire city was shut

down I live about five blocks from there

nobody was on the streets unless you run

cross-country skis or having a snowball

fight and nobody nobody could get to

work or could they this is a picture of

20 women senators who managed to make it

to work but not a single one of their

male colleagues could it’s not just

women senators but you can see in the

picture that there’s women pages there’s

women secretaries and there is one dude

there who I think was snowed in because

if it was the overnight security guard I

was told so what happened in the leaves

three days that they were the only ones

who showed up they actually moved more

legislation forward than the entire

Senate had moved in the previous two

now this is not because women are

perfect in men suck it really isn’t it

really isn’t it’s just that we have

different ways of operating and women

tend to work from a starting place of

where is our common interest and let’s

hope progress in mind it doesn’t mean

that we agree on everything it really

doesn’t but it does mean that we are

naturally inclined towards collaboration

that can work towards everyone’s best

interests because we’ve been doing it

for really long time and in fact the

same group of women during the

government shutdown much later that year

in October of that year met for weeks

behind the scenes and crafted a plan

that they could give to Harry Reid on

the Democratic side and Mitch McConnell

on the Republican side that actually

broke the government shutdown and they

let the guys take the credit but they

were the ones who wrote the plan what is

so that’s the the government sector

private sector is actually worse

representation of women in the private

sector is actually worse this is a

pretty complicated quote that talks

about the return on equity for companies

with women in more than ten percent of

key leadership positions it’s

twenty-seven percent better than those

with less than five percent what does

this mean mo women will money that’s

really what it means companies with

women and more more women in leadership

positions have that a return on the

investment but that’s not it companies

with women and key leadership positions

also have better policies on corporate

social responsibility which means

they’re not just thinking about the

bottom line they’re not just thinking

about the short term they were thinking

about environmental output working

conditions human rates and Christine

Lagarde who is the head of the

International Monetary Fund came out

with a study last year that actually

showed if we could get better

representation and women in the United

States workforce that our GDP could grow

by five percent now that may not sound

like a lot but when you look at

America’s GDP that translates into 901

billion dollars a year for India if we

could get more women in the workplace

their their GDP could grow by 27

this is what I call the women effect the

women effect is when you decide that

you’re going to invest in women and the

ROI is not just good for women it’s good

for our families it’s good for society

it’s good for our country and it’s good

for our world that’s the women effect so

you might ask what does the head of a

reproductive rights organization

standing up here are eight minutes into

her speech she hasn’t even mentioned

anything about reproductive rights oh my

goodness it’s because we can’t have an

honest conversation about how women get

engaged civically business-wise any

other way unless we start by

acknowledging that our ability to

control our own fertility and our own

reproduction controls everything else

about our lives there is no way to solve

for women’s participation for their

economic security without centralizing

the idea of reproductive rights and

reproductive freedom melinda gates knows

this some of you may have seen her

recent essay em forbes where she talked

about the Gates Foundation upping their

investment in philanthropy by hundreds

of millions of dollars globally in

contraception she’s traveled all over

the world she’s seen the fact that

contraception and family planning is the

single most determining factor and

whether young girls finish school going

to get jobs stay out of abusive

relationships and lead productive lives

she in fact says that contraception is

the first and foremost key to unlock

potential of girls and women and it’s

not just contraception right unintended

pregnancy happens it’s abortion to one

of the things that we know through a

long-term study called the turn away

study that measured women when somebody

knows it back there I’m going to tell my

friends who did it the turn away study

was was completely transformational in

the way that we think about abortion

access and abortion services because

they were able to control study and

measure one group of women who were able

to access abortion controlling for all

socioeconomic factors against another

group of women that were denied abortion

when they asked for it and what they

found is that the women were that were

denied abortion were more likely to

continue living in poverty were less

likely to finish education were more

likely to stay with abusive partners and

six and ten of them were already mothers

and they were less likely to be able to

take care of the families that they

already had this is because we are not

allowing women to have control over

their own decisions and their own lives

sometimes when we think about

reproductive rights we only think about

contraception and abortion at neighbor

all we work on the other side of the

equation because lots people like myself

and appointing to become parents right

we don’t treat women as parents very

good in this country either we make it

really really difficult I don’t know if

you guys remember but in 2013 there was

a Supreme Court case called Peggy young

versus ups this was a young woman who

was pregnant with a very wanted

pregnancy who was told by her doctor she

had to stop lifting all these really

heavy boxes that UPS required her to

lift her she might risk losing the baby

and UPS fired her they said you can’t do

your job we’re going to fire you that’s

how we treat women who want children in

this country we ranked dead last in the

industrialized world and offering

parental leave to new parents moms and

dads by the way and the studies show

that kids benefit when both have it

equal opportunity and that kids from

families who do not have the ability to

take any time off are much more likely

to live in poverty much more likely to

have health problems so you’re kind of

damned if you do and damned if you don’t

when it comes to reproductive rights

right now and some of that is inherent

bias and some of it is overt bias there

are people who really really want it to

stay that way right and that’s what

we’ve been oh sorry this is that what

they call the virtuous circle i forgot i

have this slide which says that when we

the virtuous circle is when we actually

give it women everything they need to

avoid unintended pregnancy

is plan their pregnancies allow them to

terminate unwanted pregnancies and then

support them as they’re becoming

mother’s everybody advances their

children are healthier they’re healthier

they’re more economically secure and

they can participate more in society

this is a chart of the last many many

years and it shows you how many abortion

restrictions have been introduced at the

state level you can see that they’ve

been going along for a while and kind of

took off in 2010 I don’t know if you

guys remember what happened in 2010 but

Obama had been elected there were a lot

a lot of people in this country that

didn’t like it it was the rise of the

Tea Party the Tea Party in and of itself

actually was about small government and

tax reform at the beginning and then it

converged with some pretty unsavory

characters in terms of nationalists and

in terms of the anti-choice the very

very organized anti-choice movement i

always say anti-choice because there are

individual people who have personal

beliefs that’s great we love diversity

of beliefs right the problem is when you

have an organized movement saying this

my belief so I get to sell you and you

and you went to do right and that’s what

we’re seeing here being very very very

effective this is the organized

anti-choice movement and this is the

amount of abortion restrictions that

they’ve been able to actually enact in

the last five years some of this play on

inherent bias right many of you have

seen things about waiting periods or

invasive ultrasounds that are

unnecessary right that’s basically this

inherent bias that women can’t make up

their own minds unless the government

tells them to take time out with ink

roll carefully about what they’re doing

is that women actually don’t think

really really carefully before making

these decisions some of them are totally

over bias and we’re seeing that more and

more since this last election in fact in

the last couple weeks in Oklahoma and

Arkansas there have just been bills put

out there that’s basically like a man

can sue you as a doctor if you perform

an abortion on his partner or he can

seek an injunction and stop you as a

woman from have an abortion which is not

about partnership at all right that’s

actually about control which is really

what we’re talking about when it comes

to the overt bias

but here’s the interesting thing about

the people who pursue the overt bias I

always say this they’re not really anti

abortion because if they were they would

join hands with us and fight for access

to contraception and fight for the kinds

of policies that support working moms

they don’t do any of that in fact many

of these people thought that ACA tooth

and nail which offered universal access

to contraception right the other thing

the ACA did that they tried to take down

i think it was collateral damage but

they didn’t pay attention to was that

prior to the ACA survivors of domestic

violence that was considered a

pre-existing condition your insurance

company could drop you as a survivor of

domestic violence these are really

significant advances that have been

fought by these people right so this is

what we’re up against if we want to

achieve the women effect it is really

really important to make sure that

people are aware of this dynamic if

we’re ever to unlock the full potential

of women participating in society and

how do we do that it’s pretty simple we

organize we speak out we become

renegades we call out internal bias when

we see it and we definitely question our

own things we call out external bias

when we see it and we definitely

question our own internal bias right one

of the things that’s very personal to me

that I say all the time is what’s

allowed these laws to continue to

persevere is in deep deep deep internal

bias that there are two kinds of girls

in the world they’re good girls who have

families and their bad girls who have

abortions the reality is we are the same

women at different points in our lives

making the best decisions for us so

whether you’re a goose whether you’re a

gander you can all join in the fight and

when we do we will see the return on

investment of the women effect thank you

very much you

Please follow and like us: