Press "Enter" to skip to content

Conspiracy Theories and the Problem of Disappearing Knowledge | Quassim Cassam | TEDxWarwick


supposing that I live in a high crime

area and that when I left home this

morning I switched on the burglar alarm

as I always do and it really matters

whether it’s Richard or not

how do I know that I switched it on

well I remember switching it on my

recollection that I switched on the

burglar alarm gives me confidence that I

switched it on and this confidence is

based on a kind of trust which I’m going

to call self trust I trust myself to

know to be able to be capable of knowing

whether I switched on the alarm or not

it is not just that I am confident that

I switch it on I have the right to be

confident I have the right to be

confident as long as my memory is in

fact reliable it’s not just that I do

trust myself I have the right to trust

myself again as long as I’m generally

reliable about this kind of thing okay

now supposing that you were with me this

morning for some reason and you say to

me now look you didn’t switch it on

you’re telling me that you did but I saw

you I saw you would leave the house and

I saw that you didn’t switch it on okay

and then you might remind me of all the

previous occasions when I forgot to do

something which I thought I’d done okay

so you go on at me now if you’re

convincing enough what you might achieve

is the implanting of doubts in my mind

about whether I switched on the alarm or

not I started off pretty confident that

I did but now I’m not so sure I started

and the effect of this loss of

confidence this loss of self trust the

effect I want to suggest is loss of

knowledge I’ve gone from knowing

something that I’ve switched on the

alarm to not knowing it and I’ve gone

from knowing to not knowing as a result

of these doubts which you’ve implanted

in my mind the more I doubt the less I

know the less confident I am in myself

and in my beliefs

the less I know knowledge requires a

certain degree of confidence knowledge

requires a certain degree of trust not

just trust in other people but trust in

yourself trust in you the knower now if

that’s right then there’s a very

effective way of depriving someone else

of their knowledge if you want to

deprive someone else of their knowledge

a really effective way of doing that is

to erode their confidence and to erode

their trust in themselves and in the

burglar alarm example I want to just

make a couple of observations that I

think are quite important the first

observation is that I can lose my

knowledge in this example regardless of

whether I did or didn’t switch on the

alarm even if I did switch on the alarm

even if I’m right and you’re wrong I

could still end up not knowing whether I

switched on the alarm or not it’s not

that i no longer know because the facts

have changed the facts haven’t changed I

did switch on the alarm okay so it it

the loss of knowledge is the result of a

change in me in my psychology rather

than a change in the world that the

second thing I want to say about this

example which i think is also quite

important is that it actually doesn’t

matter whether you really believe that I

switched on the alarm or not I mean

maybe you’re just messing with me I mean

maybe you’re just making it your mission

to undermine my confidence and people do

that sometimes right I mean maybe you

just you’re just messing with my head

okay so at the point at which I finally

say well I don’t know maybe I didn’t

switch on the alarm you’ve kind of what

right and you you you’ve won you’ve

succeeded in implanting these doubts

self-doubt in me regardless of whether

you believe that I have any reason to

doubt myself okay so what I’ve just

described is how you can go from knowing

to not knowing even though there’s been

no change in the facts that’s what I’ve

just described okay and that’s what I

called the problem of disappearing

knowledge a person’s knowledge can be

made to disappear to vanish by

undermining their self-confidence and

their self trust okay what’s that got to

do with fate news and conspiracy

so what I want to suggest to you is that

one of the actual and indeed intended

effects of the proliferation of fake

news and conspiracy theories is to

undermine to erode our confidence in our

ability to know what the world around us

is like and how it works and by eroding

our confidence in our ability to know

they actually erode our ability to know

ok so just just to remind you knowing

requires a degree of confidence it

requires a degree of self Trust by

undermining that you actually undermine

knowledge and you can do that with that

without without any change in the facts

so let me give you let me give you an

example so supposing that I believe the

official account as people like to call

it the official account of what happened

on 9/11 now if I expose if I’m if I’m

exposed to lots and lots of conspiracy

theories about 9/11 the result of that

exposure may well be to make me doubt

what actually happened I might end up

thinking well I don’t know I mean maybe

okay now that effect that that

transformation of my attitude towards

9/11 was brought about by my exposure to

the tip to upper due to particular

theory exposure to conspiracy theories

and I want to suggest that that is

fundamentally the point of these

theories I mean of course sometimes

people put forward conspiracy theories

because they want to discredit somebody

or for some other or some other reason

but one of the one of the effects of

these theories is to is to instill to

implant doubts in our minds and to make

us no longer confident in our own

beliefs about the way the world works

now of course from the perspective of

the conspiracy theorist that’s exactly

the aim

I mean the thought that that someone who

wants to propose one of his theories may

have is that well you have no right to

believe the official account because the

official account is in fact false but

the point I want to make is it actually

regardless of whether the official

account is true or not

regardless of that I can still go from

my initial state of believing something

to not believing it as a result of

exposure to conspiracy theories now of

course the 9/11 example is very very

controversial and and I don’t want it to

take a stand on that for today’s

purposes so let me now give you another

example which I hope is much less

controversial so one of them one of the

the most pernicious conspiracy theories

around today is the theory that the

Holocaust is a myth many of you will

have come across this this theory now of

course one thing that it is very

striking is is how Holocaust denial in

the Internet age has become more and

more prevalent there’s more and more

evidence of people subscribing to some

version of Holocaust denial now in the

psychological literature there’s lots of

discussion of why people believe

conspiracy theories in the first place

and what are the social consequences of

belief in conspiracy theories I’m not

really interested for the moment in why

people believe them or in the social

consequences I’m just interested in the

consequences for people’s knowledge so

essentially if you start off believing

the received account of the Holocaust

but you then have prolonged exposure to

lots of Holocaust denying websites you

could end up and indeed lots of people

do end up in the position of wondering

ok so that’s another that’s another

example of of how you can go from

knowing to not knowing as a result of

having doubts implanted in your

mind by these sorts of theories okay so

this raises a kind of practical question

what’s the appropriate response then if

we want to protect our knowledge we want

to protect our knowledge for example of

the reality of the Holocaust what do we

need to do now there on the face of it

there are kind of two responses there

are two responses that you could have

one response is ignore and the other

response is rebut okay so the ignore

response says something like this the no

responses look I mean if the result of

exposure to these theories is to make

you doubt yourself or to doubt what you

have all read always taken to be the

case then maybe the right response is

just to ignore them to avoid them don’t

engage with them no good will come of it

so that’s the that’s the that’s the

ignores the response but that response

doesn’t seem to me to be satisfactory

it’s not satisfactory for a whole

variety of different reasons so one

reason is this ignoring these theories

for a start

seems like a case of intellectual

cowardice I mean the obvious thing to

think is look if you’re if you’re so

convinced that something happened and

somebody else says to you no it didn’t

then you need to be able to defend

yourself you need to be able to give

reasons in support of the claim that it

did happen it’s not enough to just bury

your head in the sand and say I’m not

listening to you however obnoxious or

repulsive the views are that are being

put to you I think there’s also a moral

obligation to stand up for the truth

there’s a moral obligation to stand up

for the facts it’s not a game I mean it

actually matters what happened in the

Second World War it actually matters

what happened on 9/11 and so on so again

it’s important it’s essential to

actually show what the facts are to

and I think it’s important also not to

be suckered into thinking that well it’s

all a matter of opinion

it isn’t all a matter of opinion it’s a

suppose you agree then that the

appropriate response in these cases is

actually to engage with the theories

that have been put to you and to show

that you’re right and they’re wrong if

they are wrong right so in the in the

case of Holocaust denial you might think

and indeed I do think that the

appropriate response is not to say I’m

going to ignore them but the appropriate

response is to actually rebut them by

looking at the facts and the evidence

and of course now we run into a real

practical problem and the practical

problem is that most of us lack the

expertise to really be able to say what

the evidence shows I mean I with regard

to 911 I’m not a structural engineer I’m

not a physicist I’m not in a position

really to determine what happened that

day in the case of the Holocaust I’m not

a historian I mean I don’t have the the

historical knowledge or the skills to

defend the official account on the basis

of documentary evidence so there’s a

kind of problem now the problem is that

on the one hand it’s very easy to lose

knowledge by having these theories put

to you and not being able to respond to

them and that problem is it is it is

made worse by the fact that actually

most of us don’t have the expertise

that’s required to respond and of course

that’s it in in many ways what these

what these theories exploit so you you

may you may think you know what’s going

on but somebody says to you yes but what

about this what about that what’s your

answer to this question what’s your

answer to that question and it’s very

easy to get to the point of saying well

I don’t know hey leave me alone I don’t

know well I think that’s it’s it’s true

that most of us don’t have the expertise

and don’t have the time to really tackle

these theories head-on

but fortunately there are people who do

have the expertise and who do have the

time and these people are called experts

it’s it whoops

sometimes tol that that well we don’t

need experts all that well you know

there’s no such thing as an expert it’s

just your opinion or it’s just my

opinion and I think that’s that’s

exactly what needs to be resisted I

think whether someone is an expert or

not for example an expert on German

history or an expert on aeronautical

engineering or that is not a matter of

opinion whether someone is competent and

qualified to pronounce on these subjects

is I think to some extent an objective

matter it’s a matter of their

qualifications their experience their

knowledge and so on their track record

these are all the these are all the

relevant factors so I think that when

faced with this loss of the threat of

the loss of knowledge the only way to

really protect our knowledge the only

way to actually say look there is a

difference between truth and falsity

there is the possibility of deciding

what happened is to draw on the work of

people who are competent to judge and I

think it’s worth it’s worth also asking

those who are propounding these various

conspiracy theories which is what worth

asking them well what’s your competence

to judge it’s all very well you saying

you don’t know what you’re talking about

or you’re not you’re not qualified to

judge are they qualified to judge some

okay so it says so that’s that that’s

the pit that’s a story I want to tell it

seems to me that all of us now are

living in a world in which there is a

tremendous amount of stuff out there

online particularly there’s a conspiracy

theory for absolutely everything and I’m

certainly not saying that all conspiracy

theories are false and I don’t really

want to get into a discussion of the

truth or falsity of particular

conspiracy theories but what I do want

to suggest you is that these theories

can have this effect of this bewildering

us of making us think

just all too complicated I just don’t

know what to think anymore

and that and the ultimate result is the

whole idea of well there’s no such thing

as truth

hence post truth politics and I think

that’s what needs to be avoided but it

can’t be avoided just by ignoring just

by ignoring this phenomenon so here’s a

kind of motto that I want to end with

when faced with all these theories that

question our beliefs about for example

Holocaust the motto should not be ignore

ignore ignore the motto should be ribbit

ribbit ribbit

thanks for listening [Applause]

Please follow and like us: