
good afternoon who in this audience
enjoys skiing snowboarding hiking
snowshoeing Yeah right keep your hands
up if you know someone who’s been caught
in an avalanche keep your hand up if
it’s yourself yeah we have a number of
people in our audience that have been
affected by avalanches avalanches are a
really unique natural hazard in 90% of
Avalanche accidents the victim or a
member of the victims party causes the
accident and that’s really unique
compared to other natural hazards that’s
very unlike a tsunami or an earthquake
it also means that we have a role to
play it means that we can do something
about it through our choices if we look
at the Avalanche fatalities over the
last 10 years especially we see that on
average about 28 people died in
avalanches every year in the USA that’s
28 people that don’t come home to their
families there’s 28 families without a
dad a mom a brother or a sister that’s
too many we can do better when we look
at who’s involved we also know that
we’re missing something so what do we do
well teaching total avoidance is one
option but we all know that teaching
so rather than going down that track
what we want to do is teach people how
to make the right observations to pick
up the right information to understand
what the snowpack is telling them and
make the right choices we typically do
that through Avalanche education we take
students into the mountains we dig holes
in the snow and we look at the layered
structure of the snowpack and this is
absolutely critically important because
we need to understand the medium were
working on however when we go back to
our Avalanche fatalities we see that
we’re still killing 28 people per year
or so and that’s too many and when we
drill down into who those people are we
see that in many cases they are people
that had that information they knew
about the snowpack that knew about the
Avalanche terrain so what we need to ask
ourselves is what is it that we’re
missing what is it that we can provide
in future education what is it that we
as snow scientists and as researchers
need to do to try and bring that number
down what can we bring to the table on
the 5th of January 2015 I received a
phone call it’s a sort of phone call
that you really never want to get and
the phone call informed me that
unfortunately one of my snow science
students
Olivia Buchanan 23 year old
undergraduate had been killed in an
avalanche in southern Colorado
Olivia was one of those students I knew
she made sure of it she came into my
office probably on the first day at MSU
and told me who she was what she was
doing why she was there and where she
wanted to go and on top of that she was
taking Avalanche courses and building
her backcountry experience olivia was
not one of those students I was worried
about I thought of her as a precaution
well we’ll never know exactly what
happened and why exactly Olivia died
what we can see is that she probably
knew enough about the snowpack and about
the avalanche terrain and maybe it was
critical to see
point that went wrong the human factor
so her death and unfortunately others
after that really motivated me to think
about this problem a little bit more
broadly to say we need to understand the
snow we need to understand the terrain
but we also need to understand how and
where and why people make decisions in
that environment so her death was really
a big turning point in my personal
research career and I’m also hoping in
the research direction of where we as
Avalanche scientists go to better
connect the physical in the human to
bring down that fatality rate a little
bit further now I’d like to say I’m the
first person to think of that but I’m
not other people have been thinking down
this line before Ian’s McCammon about 15
years ago did a fantastic study that
looked at five hundred and four
fatalities over 30 years and identified
these key heuristics these shortcuts and
decision-making that were correlated to
Avalanche deaths while that work was
extremely important there’s only so much
we can learn by looking at potala T’s so
what’s the answer well myself and
professor Johnson from political science
at Montana State University started a
new project called the ski tracks
project and the idea behind this project
that we’ve been running now for the last
four years is to understand the
connection of where people are in the
backcountry how they move in that
terrain and what decisions they’re
making and this is what it looks like we
ask people to get out in the mountains
and they might with a GPS or with this
smartphone make a track like that and
you can see there’s two different tracks
on there and they’re under slightly
different circumstances and from that
track we can pull out some terrain
metrics we can also pull out a survey
and we can connect all of those pieces
together to understand what
decision-making they are making and
what’s influencing their decision-making
when we look at some of that data a
little bit more carefully we can see
that people under certain circumstances
making vastly different decisions not as
a function of the terrain and the
avalanche conditions but rather as a
function of who they are and what group
they’re in now if this sounds familiar
to any of you this isn’t rocket science
we often see that people in different
social circumstances make different
choices when presented with the same
physical evidence for example we see
that all male groups behave differently
than all female groups in the same
terrain with the same hazard but as a
function of their group composition we
see especially all younger male groups
using riskier terrain then say older
female groups who’s surprised by that
anyone all right so we are quantifying
the obvious okay but we’re quantifying
it in this setting we were seeing these
fatalities happen so well this work has
given us some insight about who these
people are and critically where they’re
going and maybe a little bit of insight
around their decisions that they’re
making that leaves us unsatisfied and it
leaves us unsatisfied because we don’t
understand the why and we need to
understand the why to help make better
decisions so we’ve started a new project
we just started this year and it
combines our team with a behavioral
economist from Norway a lady by the name
of Andre Amman Berg and what we’re doing
in this project is we’re taking a
behavioral economics lens to this issue
and what’s really great as a snow
scientist connecting with behavioral
economists on this is that we can use
decades of theory to look at this
problem they’ve been doing this for
years we’re just starting out thinking
about this and by taking this lens maybe
we can better understand why people make
these decisions not just where they go
some of the preliminary work that we’re
seeing already is showing that even with
education people’s foundational risk
appetite or their propensity to choose
or prefer certain terrain is
changed so what’s what that’s telling us
is that we need to dig a little bit
deeper we need to do more than just tell
people this is the snow this is the
Train but maybe we need to look a little
deeper in ourselves and into our
students to understand what truly
motivates them and what motivates their
risk-taking appetite and their desires
if we can do this successfully and we
can pull these pieces together and we
can bring this into a format that’s
teachable for future generations maybe
we can bring down the avalanche
retaliate maybe we can understand why
people are doing things and where
they’re doing things to bring in some
intervention and make sure that more
people do not die in avalanches in the
future we do that by connecting that GPS
track that view from above with those
decision-making aspects so I want to
leave you with a thought the next time
you go into the mountains and you go
snowmobiling or hiking or extreme snow
angel or maybe just skiing think about
what your track looks like from 10,000
feet up look down on your track think
about the critical decision points and
think about what that it says about your
risk tolerance and your risk behavior
and maybe by taking that 10,000 foot
view and looking down maybe you’ll make
a little bit different decision maybe
you choose a slightly different line
maybe you’ll think more carefully about
where you are on that terrain and how
that expresses your risk and your risk
tolerance and maybe by taking that view
you make it home tonight and you’ll see
your family and so will your friends
this is my take on redefining the
Avalanche problem thank you [Applause]
enjoys skiing snowboarding hiking
snowshoeing Yeah right keep your hands
up if you know someone who’s been caught
in an avalanche keep your hand up if
it’s yourself yeah we have a number of
people in our audience that have been
affected by avalanches avalanches are a
really unique natural hazard in 90% of
Avalanche accidents the victim or a
member of the victims party causes the
accident and that’s really unique
compared to other natural hazards that’s
very unlike a tsunami or an earthquake
it also means that we have a role to
play it means that we can do something
about it through our choices if we look
at the Avalanche fatalities over the
last 10 years especially we see that on
average about 28 people died in
avalanches every year in the USA that’s
28 people that don’t come home to their
families there’s 28 families without a
dad a mom a brother or a sister that’s
too many we can do better when we look
at who’s involved we also know that
we’re missing something so what do we do
well teaching total avoidance is one
option but we all know that teaching
so rather than going down that track
what we want to do is teach people how
to make the right observations to pick
up the right information to understand
what the snowpack is telling them and
make the right choices we typically do
that through Avalanche education we take
students into the mountains we dig holes
in the snow and we look at the layered
structure of the snowpack and this is
absolutely critically important because
we need to understand the medium were
working on however when we go back to
our Avalanche fatalities we see that
we’re still killing 28 people per year
or so and that’s too many and when we
drill down into who those people are we
see that in many cases they are people
that had that information they knew
about the snowpack that knew about the
Avalanche terrain so what we need to ask
ourselves is what is it that we’re
missing what is it that we can provide
in future education what is it that we
as snow scientists and as researchers
need to do to try and bring that number
down what can we bring to the table on
the 5th of January 2015 I received a
phone call it’s a sort of phone call
that you really never want to get and
the phone call informed me that
unfortunately one of my snow science
students
Olivia Buchanan 23 year old
undergraduate had been killed in an
avalanche in southern Colorado
Olivia was one of those students I knew
she made sure of it she came into my
office probably on the first day at MSU
and told me who she was what she was
doing why she was there and where she
wanted to go and on top of that she was
taking Avalanche courses and building
her backcountry experience olivia was
not one of those students I was worried
about I thought of her as a precaution
well we’ll never know exactly what
happened and why exactly Olivia died
what we can see is that she probably
knew enough about the snowpack and about
the avalanche terrain and maybe it was
critical to see
point that went wrong the human factor
so her death and unfortunately others
after that really motivated me to think
about this problem a little bit more
broadly to say we need to understand the
snow we need to understand the terrain
but we also need to understand how and
where and why people make decisions in
that environment so her death was really
a big turning point in my personal
research career and I’m also hoping in
the research direction of where we as
Avalanche scientists go to better
connect the physical in the human to
bring down that fatality rate a little
bit further now I’d like to say I’m the
first person to think of that but I’m
not other people have been thinking down
this line before Ian’s McCammon about 15
years ago did a fantastic study that
looked at five hundred and four
fatalities over 30 years and identified
these key heuristics these shortcuts and
decision-making that were correlated to
Avalanche deaths while that work was
extremely important there’s only so much
we can learn by looking at potala T’s so
what’s the answer well myself and
professor Johnson from political science
at Montana State University started a
new project called the ski tracks
project and the idea behind this project
that we’ve been running now for the last
four years is to understand the
connection of where people are in the
backcountry how they move in that
terrain and what decisions they’re
making and this is what it looks like we
ask people to get out in the mountains
and they might with a GPS or with this
smartphone make a track like that and
you can see there’s two different tracks
on there and they’re under slightly
different circumstances and from that
track we can pull out some terrain
metrics we can also pull out a survey
and we can connect all of those pieces
together to understand what
decision-making they are making and
what’s influencing their decision-making
when we look at some of that data a
little bit more carefully we can see
that people under certain circumstances
making vastly different decisions not as
a function of the terrain and the
avalanche conditions but rather as a
function of who they are and what group
they’re in now if this sounds familiar
to any of you this isn’t rocket science
we often see that people in different
social circumstances make different
choices when presented with the same
physical evidence for example we see
that all male groups behave differently
than all female groups in the same
terrain with the same hazard but as a
function of their group composition we
see especially all younger male groups
using riskier terrain then say older
female groups who’s surprised by that
anyone all right so we are quantifying
the obvious okay but we’re quantifying
it in this setting we were seeing these
fatalities happen so well this work has
given us some insight about who these
people are and critically where they’re
going and maybe a little bit of insight
around their decisions that they’re
making that leaves us unsatisfied and it
leaves us unsatisfied because we don’t
understand the why and we need to
understand the why to help make better
decisions so we’ve started a new project
we just started this year and it
combines our team with a behavioral
economist from Norway a lady by the name
of Andre Amman Berg and what we’re doing
in this project is we’re taking a
behavioral economics lens to this issue
and what’s really great as a snow
scientist connecting with behavioral
economists on this is that we can use
decades of theory to look at this
problem they’ve been doing this for
years we’re just starting out thinking
about this and by taking this lens maybe
we can better understand why people make
these decisions not just where they go
some of the preliminary work that we’re
seeing already is showing that even with
education people’s foundational risk
appetite or their propensity to choose
or prefer certain terrain is
changed so what’s what that’s telling us
is that we need to dig a little bit
deeper we need to do more than just tell
people this is the snow this is the
Train but maybe we need to look a little
deeper in ourselves and into our
students to understand what truly
motivates them and what motivates their
risk-taking appetite and their desires
if we can do this successfully and we
can pull these pieces together and we
can bring this into a format that’s
teachable for future generations maybe
we can bring down the avalanche
retaliate maybe we can understand why
people are doing things and where
they’re doing things to bring in some
intervention and make sure that more
people do not die in avalanches in the
future we do that by connecting that GPS
track that view from above with those
decision-making aspects so I want to
leave you with a thought the next time
you go into the mountains and you go
snowmobiling or hiking or extreme snow
angel or maybe just skiing think about
what your track looks like from 10,000
feet up look down on your track think
about the critical decision points and
think about what that it says about your
risk tolerance and your risk behavior
and maybe by taking that 10,000 foot
view and looking down maybe you’ll make
a little bit different decision maybe
you choose a slightly different line
maybe you’ll think more carefully about
where you are on that terrain and how
that expresses your risk and your risk
tolerance and maybe by taking that view
you make it home tonight and you’ll see
your family and so will your friends
this is my take on redefining the
Avalanche problem thank you [Applause]
Please follow and like us: