
[Music]
tonight we will talk to you about
school we will talk to you about
today’s school and a school
for today
we each have a foot in the middle of
national education and as you the
know in schools every day to
every moment we are confronted with
learning difficulties
where these difficulties do
that they come from children and well
when we watch the documentary film
is re become of clara blessed we see
that kids who are not who are going
not at school
after naturally and without difficulty
so if the problem does not come from
children where does he come from
some time ago we have
discovered the existence of schools
democratic in these schools the framework
is totally different from that of
traditional schools
first of all the relations between the
children and adults are not
prioritize
everyone is considered on the same footing
of equality then the management of the school
and democratic that is to say that each
day school management and the
functioning of the school is decided by
all of its members children like
adults the decisions the rules are
discussed and voted by all on the
principle following a person equals a
voice
these schools welcome children of 4
at 19 there is no 30 slice
of age everyone is together
There is also no timetable
neither program
everyone does what he wants from these
days is good in his schools the
children learn and they learn
without difficulty it would therefore seem that
which is a problem in
learning this is the program and
the and the frame in which he is
and that’s what we will develop
what is a program
it’s a body of knowledge and
know that you have to learn at an age
given and in a definite time but you
know it all as I do all children
are different and all children are
not equal before this task to be accomplished
for 2007
40% of cm2 students came out with
serious gaps plus two hundred thousand
of them have acquired acquired
fragile and more than 100,000 have not had
mastering basic skills
as the whole life of the child turns
around the school and well this failure
relative to not knowing at a time
given soon becomes a personal failure to
cause in particular all the sanctions that
that exists and the child loses confidence in
to get him into a spiral of
devaluation of demotivation or even
dropouts for the year 2010 7.80 thousand
young people have left the school system
without a diploma twice
population of Valenciennes then a
solution to this problem that is important
as einstein says to find the
solution and not an answer but the
solution to a problem it would take
maybe have another look at this
problem tells us that we have to change
the level of thinking we can not
solve a problem we can not
solve a problem with the same level
to think that whoever created it gold
the institution proposes as a solution is
many educational devices
but who says pedagogy is the
pedagogy and in all
subterfuge to make one learn
program and so you see we are
always on the same level of thinking and
what makes the devices for the
less inefficient and very expensive
so a dropout child costs at the
community 230000 euros
during his life at the jump during
his life and as to the results
well I am referring to the report of
2016 of the seine escaut committee
national system evaluation
school
who finds that the last thirty
years of educational policies for
reduce inequalities have been more than
ineffective
they were counterproductive then
where does this counter-productivity come from
well einstein can explain it is to
to say we stayed on the same level
to think ivan illitch in the years
seventy could have also given the
reply
ivan illitch is a thinker and a
critical and industrial societies
yvan niniches tells us that from the
when in a society
well this society institute ciani
zain means it happens at a moment so
in order to achieve abuse of which to solve
a problem is well this means tends to
grow to a threshold where at
that moment he becomes dysfunctional
and a nights at goal that is not sensitive
serve it gives some examples that
of the automobile so the automobile goes
harm to transport we know that
problems posed by automobiles
today is the same way in
another in another area the school
will hurt education like medicine
will hurt health
and the institution becomes
counterproductive in addition to alienating
the human being and society in his
together and this aggression I
will finally speak at the end of my talk
failure in school is not failure
of students it is only the failure of a
device that wants to make learn to
program that he can not do it and he
becomes counterproductive in the measure
is fine where he leaves a fringe of the
population he claims to have the
responsibility on the side there are
consequences at school of the program
I should say because we do not learn
no we do not learn that they savoy
learns a lot of things that are
unconscious and implicit and that he
you really need to be
this time conscious and well when
children enter the school of
program well they have to learn
this program and this acquisition
can be done only by constraint
a child who enters the school of
program must obey
to age is a duty for him and in
same time that he obeys to learn he
learns to obey and when he disobeys or
when he does not do what he is told and
well he becomes lazy or deviant
or contract diseases of the ten
something when he enters school
of the program is well the child is learning to
depend on someone else
in other words, he learns that there is
someone who thought for him who did not
do not know who did not ask him
opinion but who knows what is good for
him and proposes activities in this
meaning and so the child does learn learns
not to act for himself or by itself
even what goes against themselves
principle of autonomy autonomy which is
a primary goal in all
education knowledge is dispensed
on the same level we learn the facts
of geography history economics
as has plus one equals 2 in other words
as unquestionable truths and his
truths are all the less questionable
it allows to acquire a diploma
see a trade and they are all
less disputed that she participates in your
professional identity
we learn that the thought of others
and well can be authoritative and suddenly
you learn more to think for yourself
and by oneself and those who think by
themselves and for themselves and well in
general are qualified as marginal
not the opinion of everyone
and you need sanitary disasters
economic to realize that this
that you were told at one point and
Well, that’s not exactly the truth
I often think of it as an example to
fukushima he and the Japanese engineers
who are stuffed with diplomas they
knew many things that we were
able to put power plants
on seismic faults
the program is well serves in fact a
ideology what is this ideology is
well ideology it’s a design
classic that we have and especially for
the child in the classic design of
the child the child is an immature being
a fragile being a being incomplete to
to be born to whom we do not trust
does not give the child responsibility
must therefore obey and must submit
to acquire an education but this
design this ideology it’s
purely and simply a legacy of the
feudal society
so we saw that well the school of
program can not guarantee success
of all by its structure there are
structural effects and effects of
rather ideological causes because of
teaching the program the children
can not develop their own
potential which is the condition a
important condition for
personal fulfillment and to his
defending body
the school’s program is well developed
in individuals a thought that does not
does not promote autonomy and who does not
not to question what
is acquired and sociologists like
Bourdieu and stable is at the edge of the water
we say that in fact that’s what
allows the system to reproduce
although we are good we are
aware
that this system and malfunctions
so how to learn without a program
well that’s what men do
since the dawn of time and that’s what
develops peter gray in his book
free to learn peter gray and
psychologist and professor of psychology
at the university of boston and in the
first part of his book he we
talk about the hunters’ way of life
gatherers of nomadic tribes
in fact this way of life is modeled on
that our ancestors before the
sedentarization the development of
agriculture and that of cities and this
which is important to observe is
precisely the role that adults play
in the education of children and how
children then learn adults
hunter-gatherers have
trust in the fact that to allow
to children to do what they want
are going to allow them to do just that
to learn what they need
to learn in the world in which
they live the children are free they
do not go to school do not have a job
predefined time
they spend their time together
all ages together they do and they do
absolutely what they want from their
adults day does not run
children’s education
it is the children who educate themselves
so how was it going well
children have the freedom to observe everything
what adults do and participate
to their activity as they want
adults on their side participates in
self learning process of
children by responding to their
stresses
adults do not monitor progress
what do mine children do to congratulate them
in fact in hunter gatherers there
there is no judgment there is no
violence is a way of life and
in the children of the blow there is none
no longer and in children the activity
principal is the free game the game
without the intervention of adults and in
their game and limit the adults they
play to hunt to make tools
and to build huts to
select different varieties of
plants etc etc
and that’s how children
naturally getting ready to become
adults accomplished and adapted to their
middle
and all that is important to
emphasize one is that all this they the
do because they still want to
once nobody asks them to
to make no one fooled
children they educate themselves then
do free children learn
and well the answer is obvious
of course yes why do you think you have
today that’s wrong where then eh
well we believe that because we
have lost our freedom and our
freedom to learn naturally
freely as peter gray says
to learn is part of our genes
in other words, we can not not
learn how do you think
learned to walk or talk is what
someone blowing you words for
that you repeat them is what you are
explained that one had to put a foot
in front of the other
did we want to teach of course
that not all that you’ve learned
naturally and well as
hunter-gatherer children we have
taken naturally to become adults
accomplished and adapted to their environment
our children if we leave them the
freedom will become adults
accomplished and adapted to their environment
I will take the example of reading
writing is present everywhere in our
society
therefore it is inevitable to learn
to read and just as the children have
naturally learned to speak because
talk is a need to interact in
our world
they will learn to read to write and to
count because that too is a
need to interact in our world
we saw it we know of free children
after naturally what they need
to learn in the world in which
they live schoolchildren
democratic are free and they know
all read laura poitras has been in a
democratic school and she she learned
to read at 13 yes it did not
prevented from becoming a director and
producer of documentary films
journalists and photographers just that
and in 2015
she received the Oscar for best film
documentary for his citizen very little
does not matter the age at which the child
will learn to read
he will learn to read he will do it with
all the more easily he will do it
himself at the moment that will be his
will do it also without constraint and according to
its own methodology without manuals
school as for walking
self learning is a natural act
we could almost say it’s a
physiological act then we saw
the child needs to be made
trust and he needs freedom for
learn he also needs to play
freely without the intervention of
the adult to build himself because
to play is his job it’s his life a
child deprived of his liberty can not
to blossom a child who can not get
develop natural and who can not
to live one’s life is a child who suffers
silently or exploding children
suffer many violence the
violence of having to sit there
the violence of having to do what they are
request to do
the violence of having to succeed in doing it
they also suffer the violence of
judgments if it does not happen if they
do not want to do that or who does not
do not even understand what they are
request
and all this violence there live in
silence because they are the only ones to
to know that they are suffering violence
in the eyes of adults it’s all
normalcy for most adults
there is no violence in all this
because it’s a way of life
self education works and allows
really to the child to learn from
build and flourish school
democratic of the barrel hall was worth in
attest she is almost 50 years old
of existence and has proven itself
he is a professor emeritus and recognized
of
the prestigious university of columbia
who founded this school with a team
he made observations as he was
how as teachers and he
asked a lot of questions about
education is actually it to rethink the
educational model in these terms or a
educational model where the individual is well
develop their own representations
of what he wants to understand and
to use any means they deem
necessary for this understanding in
democratic schools
we said it in the introduction he
there are two essential pillars
ie autonomous learning
and the democratic management of the school
it’s this school at age 50 and continues
to operate what is the
reverberation of this school in europe
and well in 2008 an association saw the
day the dec which federates all the schools
democratic europe
here is the map of schools of
major democratic schools in
europe and for france is well in
2014 opened the first school
democratic to dijon these are the buses the
red which are the creations and in
purple the projects and we see
the craze for this type of school the
democratic schools brings a
alternative to a model and a model
educative
what happened to the children of the non-profit organization
ballet school could arise
question comes back over 40 years
of existence and well 80% of them have
followed higher education and had
their first college choice among
the most prestigious 20% of them
have embraced artistic careers
or craft and most of them
have learned to read at the age of more than ten
years because self education
works because the learning
stand alone make the child
responsibility of his life because the
democratic management of a school prepares
the child to become an active citizen and
responsible
and because we are the change
that we want for the world
we decided to
create a democratic school to
condé-sur-l’escaut the school of letters and
of becoming and it will open in
September 2018
[Applause]
[Music]
tonight we will talk to you about
school we will talk to you about
today’s school and a school
for today
we each have a foot in the middle of
national education and as you the
know in schools every day to
every moment we are confronted with
learning difficulties
where these difficulties do
that they come from children and well
when we watch the documentary film
is re become of clara blessed we see
that kids who are not who are going
not at school
after naturally and without difficulty
so if the problem does not come from
children where does he come from
some time ago we have
discovered the existence of schools
democratic in these schools the framework
is totally different from that of
traditional schools
first of all the relations between the
children and adults are not
prioritize
everyone is considered on the same footing
of equality then the management of the school
and democratic that is to say that each
day school management and the
functioning of the school is decided by
all of its members children like
adults the decisions the rules are
discussed and voted by all on the
principle following a person equals a
voice
these schools welcome children of 4
at 19 there is no 30 slice
of age everyone is together
There is also no timetable
neither program
everyone does what he wants from these
days is good in his schools the
children learn and they learn
without difficulty it would therefore seem that
which is a problem in
learning this is the program and
the and the frame in which he is
and that’s what we will develop
what is a program
it’s a body of knowledge and
know that you have to learn at an age
given and in a definite time but you
know it all as I do all children
are different and all children are
not equal before this task to be accomplished
for 2007
40% of cm2 students came out with
serious gaps plus two hundred thousand
of them have acquired acquired
fragile and more than 100,000 have not had
mastering basic skills
as the whole life of the child turns
around the school and well this failure
relative to not knowing at a time
given soon becomes a personal failure to
cause in particular all the sanctions that
that exists and the child loses confidence in
to get him into a spiral of
devaluation of demotivation or even
dropouts for the year 2010 7.80 thousand
young people have left the school system
without a diploma twice
population of Valenciennes then a
solution to this problem that is important
as einstein says to find the
solution and not an answer but the
solution to a problem it would take
maybe have another look at this
problem tells us that we have to change
the level of thinking we can not
solve a problem we can not
solve a problem with the same level
to think that whoever created it gold
the institution proposes as a solution is
many educational devices
but who says pedagogy is the
pedagogy and in all
subterfuge to make one learn
program and so you see we are
always on the same level of thinking and
what makes the devices for the
less inefficient and very expensive
so a dropout child costs at the
community 230000 euros
during his life at the jump during
his life and as to the results
well I am referring to the report of
2016 of the seine escaut committee
national system evaluation
school
who finds that the last thirty
years of educational policies for
reduce inequalities have been more than
ineffective
they were counterproductive then
where does this counter-productivity come from
well einstein can explain it is to
to say we stayed on the same level
to think ivan illitch in the years
seventy could have also given the
reply
ivan illitch is a thinker and a
critical and industrial societies
yvan niniches tells us that from the
when in a society
well this society institute ciani
zain means it happens at a moment so
in order to achieve abuse of which to solve
a problem is well this means tends to
grow to a threshold where at
that moment he becomes dysfunctional
and a nights at goal that is not sensitive
serve it gives some examples that
of the automobile so the automobile goes
harm to transport we know that
problems posed by automobiles
today is the same way in
another in another area the school
will hurt education like medicine
will hurt health
and the institution becomes
counterproductive in addition to alienating
the human being and society in his
together and this aggression I
will finally speak at the end of my talk
failure in school is not failure
of students it is only the failure of a
device that wants to make learn to
program that he can not do it and he
becomes counterproductive in the measure
is fine where he leaves a fringe of the
population he claims to have the
responsibility on the side there are
consequences at school of the program
I should say because we do not learn
no we do not learn that they savoy
learns a lot of things that are
unconscious and implicit and that he
you really need to be
this time conscious and well when
children enter the school of
program well they have to learn
this program and this acquisition
can be done only by constraint
a child who enters the school of
program must obey
to age is a duty for him and in
same time that he obeys to learn he
learns to obey and when he disobeys or
when he does not do what he is told and
well he becomes lazy or deviant
or contract diseases of the ten
something when he enters school
of the program is well the child is learning to
depend on someone else
in other words, he learns that there is
someone who thought for him who did not
do not know who did not ask him
opinion but who knows what is good for
him and proposes activities in this
meaning and so the child does learn learns
not to act for himself or by itself
even what goes against themselves
principle of autonomy autonomy which is
a primary goal in all
education knowledge is dispensed
on the same level we learn the facts
of geography history economics
as has plus one equals 2 in other words
as unquestionable truths and his
truths are all the less questionable
it allows to acquire a diploma
see a trade and they are all
less disputed that she participates in your
professional identity
we learn that the thought of others
and well can be authoritative and suddenly
you learn more to think for yourself
and by oneself and those who think by
themselves and for themselves and well in
general are qualified as marginal
not the opinion of everyone
and you need sanitary disasters
economic to realize that this
that you were told at one point and
Well, that’s not exactly the truth
I often think of it as an example to
fukushima he and the Japanese engineers
who are stuffed with diplomas they
knew many things that we were
able to put power plants
on seismic faults
the program is well serves in fact a
ideology what is this ideology is
well ideology it’s a design
classic that we have and especially for
the child in the classic design of
the child the child is an immature being
a fragile being a being incomplete to
to be born to whom we do not trust
does not give the child responsibility
must therefore obey and must submit
to acquire an education but this
design this ideology it’s
purely and simply a legacy of the
feudal society
so we saw that well the school of
program can not guarantee success
of all by its structure there are
structural effects and effects of
rather ideological causes because of
teaching the program the children
can not develop their own
potential which is the condition a
important condition for
personal fulfillment and to his
defending body
the school’s program is well developed
in individuals a thought that does not
does not promote autonomy and who does not
not to question what
is acquired and sociologists like
Bourdieu and stable is at the edge of the water
we say that in fact that’s what
allows the system to reproduce
although we are good we are
aware
that this system and malfunctions
so how to learn without a program
well that’s what men do
since the dawn of time and that’s what
develops peter gray in his book
free to learn peter gray and
psychologist and professor of psychology
at the university of boston and in the
first part of his book he we
talk about the hunters’ way of life
gatherers of nomadic tribes
in fact this way of life is modeled on
that our ancestors before the
sedentarization the development of
agriculture and that of cities and this
which is important to observe is
precisely the role that adults play
in the education of children and how
children then learn adults
hunter-gatherers have
trust in the fact that to allow
to children to do what they want
are going to allow them to do just that
to learn what they need
to learn in the world in which
they live the children are free they
do not go to school do not have a job
predefined time
they spend their time together
all ages together they do and they do
absolutely what they want from their
adults day does not run
children’s education
it is the children who educate themselves
so how was it going well
children have the freedom to observe everything
what adults do and participate
to their activity as they want
adults on their side participates in
self learning process of
children by responding to their
stresses
adults do not monitor progress
what do mine children do to congratulate them
in fact in hunter gatherers there
there is no judgment there is no
violence is a way of life and
in the children of the blow there is none
no longer and in children the activity
principal is the free game the game
without the intervention of adults and in
their game and limit the adults they
play to hunt to make tools
and to build huts to
select different varieties of
plants etc etc
and that’s how children
naturally getting ready to become
adults accomplished and adapted to their
middle
and all that is important to
emphasize one is that all this they the
do because they still want to
once nobody asks them to
to make no one fooled
children they educate themselves then
do free children learn
and well the answer is obvious
of course yes why do you think you have
today that’s wrong where then eh
well we believe that because we
have lost our freedom and our
freedom to learn naturally
freely as peter gray says
to learn is part of our genes
in other words, we can not not
learn how do you think
learned to walk or talk is what
someone blowing you words for
that you repeat them is what you are
explained that one had to put a foot
in front of the other
did we want to teach of course
that not all that you’ve learned
naturally and well as
hunter-gatherer children we have
taken naturally to become adults
accomplished and adapted to their environment
our children if we leave them the
freedom will become adults
accomplished and adapted to their environment
I will take the example of reading
writing is present everywhere in our
society
therefore it is inevitable to learn
to read and just as the children have
naturally learned to speak because
talk is a need to interact in
our world
they will learn to read to write and to
count because that too is a
need to interact in our world
we saw it we know of free children
after naturally what they need
to learn in the world in which
they live schoolchildren
democratic are free and they know
all read laura poitras has been in a
democratic school and she she learned
to read at 13 yes it did not
prevented from becoming a director and
producer of documentary films
journalists and photographers just that
and in 2015
she received the Oscar for best film
documentary for his citizen very little
does not matter the age at which the child
will learn to read
he will learn to read he will do it with
all the more easily he will do it
himself at the moment that will be his
will do it also without constraint and according to
its own methodology without manuals
school as for walking
self learning is a natural act
we could almost say it’s a
physiological act then we saw
the child needs to be made
trust and he needs freedom for
learn he also needs to play
freely without the intervention of
the adult to build himself because
to play is his job it’s his life a
child deprived of his liberty can not
to blossom a child who can not get
develop natural and who can not
to live one’s life is a child who suffers
silently or exploding children
suffer many violence the
violence of having to sit there
the violence of having to do what they are
request to do
the violence of having to succeed in doing it
they also suffer the violence of
judgments if it does not happen if they
do not want to do that or who does not
do not even understand what they are
request
and all this violence there live in
silence because they are the only ones to
to know that they are suffering violence
in the eyes of adults it’s all
normalcy for most adults
there is no violence in all this
because it’s a way of life
self education works and allows
really to the child to learn from
build and flourish school
democratic of the barrel hall was worth in
attest she is almost 50 years old
of existence and has proven itself
he is a professor emeritus and recognized
of
the prestigious university of columbia
who founded this school with a team
he made observations as he was
how as teachers and he
asked a lot of questions about
education is actually it to rethink the
educational model in these terms or a
educational model where the individual is well
develop their own representations
of what he wants to understand and
to use any means they deem
necessary for this understanding in
democratic schools
we said it in the introduction he
there are two essential pillars
ie autonomous learning
and the democratic management of the school
it’s this school at age 50 and continues
to operate what is the
reverberation of this school in europe
and well in 2008 an association saw the
day the dec which federates all the schools
democratic europe
here is the map of schools of
major democratic schools in
europe and for france is well in
2014 opened the first school
democratic to dijon these are the buses the
red which are the creations and in
purple the projects and we see
the craze for this type of school the
democratic schools brings a
alternative to a model and a model
educative
what happened to the children of the non-profit organization
ballet school could arise
question comes back over 40 years
of existence and well 80% of them have
followed higher education and had
their first college choice among
the most prestigious 20% of them
have embraced artistic careers
or craft and most of them
have learned to read at the age of more than ten
years because self education
works because the learning
stand alone make the child
responsibility of his life because the
democratic management of a school prepares
the child to become an active citizen and
responsible
and because we are the change
that we want for the world
we decided to
create a democratic school to
condé-sur-l’escaut the school of letters and
of becoming and it will open in
September 2018
[Applause]
[Music]
Please follow and like us: