Press "Enter" to skip to content

The Bad Side of Good | Rachel Weinberger | TEDxDover


when I think of social entrepreneurship

I think of this I am currently a

graduate student at the University of

Delaware studying entrepreneurship and

design when I became interested in

entrepreneurship three years ago I

wanted to set out to be a social

entrepreneur just like this I felt

completely in love with the 141 business

model specifically TOMS shoes you buy a

pair of shoes they give a pair of shoes

to someone in need what a wonderful

concept I became obsessed with learning

all about it I wanted to base my

entrepreneurial idea exactly off of this

I went out to a tom’s cafe in austin

texas and los angeles california i

purchased and religiously red Blake

Mycoskie book I wanted to email him and

ask him if he would be my mentor a

little crazy but I thought that this was

a revolutionary business concept that

would positively impact social change

everywhere and since Blake Mycoskie TOMS

shoes model the 141 business plan has

exploded it has become a massive

industry for social entrepreneurs all

over the world but one day my

perspective changed in the midst of all

my research I stumbled upon a

documentary called poverty inc and it

completely changed how I saw things in

the world of social entrepreneurship is

there a bad side of good and how can

good become better we can argue that

good is a relative term right things can

be good on a scale there are good deeds

NGOs nonprofits charities happening and

acting all over the world and those who

have given back to people in places

struggling in poverty or doing good

there is no doubt about it however a lot

of the help that these organizations are

giving our free goods free clothing free

shoes free food the options and free

handouts are overwhelming and endless it

is good I know it comes straight from

our hearts but what I’m saying today is

the way it is done does not work we

change ideas we change the process we

try something new every 10 to 20 years

but we’re still dealing with the same

broken system Machiavelli said the

reason there will be no change is

because the people who stand to lose

from change have all the power and the

people who stand to gain from change

have none so who are the people who

stand to lose from change the NGOs the

corporations the nonprofit’s those that

have all the power these companies want

to do good they build and build and

build and they’re on a mission to give

back to a greater social good but change

requires time and effort to change the

process and the system takes work to be

a social entrepreneur takes risk but not

to change when you realize what you are

it may take more time energy financials

but to build something better than just

good can have a longer more sustainable

positive impact on the world we hear and

see words like NGO aid nonprofit every

single day and we automatically think

that is good but do we ever truly dig

deeper than that what happens after that

surplus is drop shipped what happens to

your donations what can be done that can

be better what is the good side of good

now let’s zoom all the way in who are

the people stand to gain from change

we’re in Ghana Senegal Haiti Kenya and

we’ve come in with our shipping trucks

and containers and we dispense millions

of free shoes clothing food whatever you

can think of because people are

struggling and people are in need but

let’s look over here there’s a man who

has spent his whole life trying to build

the perfect African sandal

and let’s look over here here’s a man

who has been farming and slaving in the

fields to grow pounds and pounds of rice

just for this season and who’s over here

here’s a woman who hands those

headscarves every single day just to

make a living and now here we are

dropping off all of these things for

free and what happens is the local

people lose their work they lose their

income they cannot support their

families they go even deeper into

poverty no one buys from the local

businesses because it is impossible to

compete with free so while they still

receive their free handouts this poverty

cycle continues they build themselves up

and then we tear them right back down

every single time we dispense free goods

we create a sense of dependency instead

of fostering an environment of

empowerment and potential so instead of

people who stand to lose from change and

people who stand to gain from change why

don’t we all stand together it goes back

to the all-time famous quote you give a

man a fish he eats for a day you teach a

man to fish he eats for life giving away

free goods is good especially in times

of crisis or emergency but at some point

it isn’t a crisis anymore poverty is not

a crisis it is a systemic part of

humanitarian life the founder of world

central kitchen is a man named Jose

undress and Jose has taken an entirely

new approach the idea of social

entrepreneurship he has empowered people

to be a part of the solution rather than

giving free goods what the world central

kitchen does is they create kitchens in

local schools and this has a profound

impact on the developing area with a

centered focus of creating better health

education and jobs it encourages kids it

encourages children to go and attend

school it creates a healthy safe cooking

environment it provides a sustainable

source of revenue for the school it

employs and creates

jobs for the people in the local

community it increases earnings quality

of life and it strengthens their economy

now there is an exponential difference

between this and giving away free food

so maybe you aren’t a CEO or an

entrepreneur of a major nonprofit

organization NGO or charity but in no

way does that mean that you cannot have

a significant impact on what happens in

the world every single day we are all

our own businesses you are your own

business and I want to leave you today

with three points to take away number

one be open minded to understanding both

sides of good the good side and the bad

side open up your perspective and always

dig deeper number two do your research

you have complete control of where your

money goes and you can find out exactly

what you are donating to and how it is

affecting those people if you just look

deep enough and number three change the

question instead of asking what can I

give to help let’s put more thought into

the things we think are good and

constantly ask ourselves how they can be

better thank you [Applause]

Please follow and like us: